The Crime of Olga Arbyelina

Not many a writer can pull it off - a plot so off-putting and odd, the emotions so raw. To a great extent, Makine managed to do it, though, mainly thanks to his inimitable writing style - lyrical, as usual, only here it's so much darker. And inherent to him, these very skillful repetitions throughout the book, going to the same event in the past again and again - but from a different perspective - not easy to do without boring the reader, but always done uniquely in this writer's case.

There is never any doubt in my mind when I pick up Makine's book - it will never disappoint. (The same I can only say about one more writer, Boris Akunin)... I love Makine's style. As far as his writing, this book didn't disappoint either, and probably if show more one gets into the character of the protagonist more intimately, one can actually get what's going on inside and be less judgmental. I am not at that stage yet. show less

This would have been my last of the Makine novels that are available in English translation, had it not been for [b:Lieutenant Schreiber's Country|40125197|Lieutenant Schreiber's Country The Story of a Forgotten Hero|Andreï Makine|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1526382760l/40125197._SY75_.jpg|40004228], which is a rather expensive recent hardback.

This is one of the books that most stands out from his ouevre as different - not least because it is a long way from Makine's personal experience and it is mostly set in a Russian emigre community in France just after the Second World War.

The heroine Olga Arbyelina (a princess by a now failed marriage) works as a librarian in the "Caravanserai", an old show more brewery which is now part old people's home and part cheap flats populated by Russian emigres, situated in a small town a short train trip from Paris. She lives with her son, a haemophiliac. At the start of the book she is suspected of murder after a suspicious death, but most of the book takes place in the previous year and explores the reasons for her involvement.

Much of the plot cannot be described without spoilers - it concerns an incestuous sexual relationship through her son, initiated by him after he has laced her tea with sedatives, but continuing with her growing complicity and eventually leading to her relationship to the victim of the murder/accident. The shadow of haemophilia is never far from the surface, and the morality of the story is very complicated.

As always Makine's writing is very enjoyable to read, if a little more convoluted than in most of his books, perhaps because of the complexity of the plotting. show less

The time is 1947. Olga Arbyelina is a Russian emigre living in a small town outside of Paris. She is reputed to be of royal blood, a rumor supported by the fact that her son is hemopheliac.

Makine's prose is characteristically lyrical--dreamy and repetitious--it reminds me of Debussey's music. But in this case, the lush language is not supported and complemented by the plot and characters. The crux of the novel is Olga's relationship with her son, and her great love for him. However, Olga comes across as passive, apathetic, and unthinking. She and her son are rarely in the same room together (unless one of them is asleep). The disturbing acts of her son and Olga's reaction (or perhaps her nonresponse) to them are unrealistic and show more unbelievable.

2 stars show less

Haunting detail, but a bit lurid, and somewhat of a disappointment after Dreams of My Russian Summers.

Un frío domingo del año 1947, un crimen estremecedor conmociona al pequeño pueblo de Villiers-la-Fôret, próximo a París: un hombre agoniza a la orilla del río con el cráneo aplastado, y junto a él, aún aturdida y medio desnuda, se encuentra Olga Arbélina, una antigua aristócrata rusa que tuvo que huir de su país durante la Revolución bolchevique. La comunidad de rusos emigrados establecidos en Villiers apenas alcanza a entender qué ha podido conducir a Olga, la apacible bibliotecaria, a una situación tan extraña y comprometida. La investigación que se inicia remueve un doloroso pasado: la precipitada huida de su país, el dolor del exilio, el abandono por parte de un marido mezquino y el nacimiento de un hijo show more hemofílico, que, llegado a la adolescencia, parece reencarnar el destino trágico de los Romanov. Pero la vida de Olga Arbélina todavía oculta un secreto terrible, quién sabe si un segundo «crimen». show less