The War of the Buttons

A French classic of children's literature that can also has much to offer to adult readers, The War of the Buttons chronicles the war-like conflict between the boys of two rival villages, in rural France at the beginning of the 20th century. It's a war fought with sticks and stones, and when a boy is unfortunate enough to be captured by the enemy, among other indignities all the buttons from his clothes are removed and stolen which, in poor communities such as those, will ensure that he receives further punishment at home.

It's one of those stories told exclusively from the point of view of the children, alien to the adult way of thinking but, at the same time, not so different from adults as they may at first seem. It's a homage to the show more freedom and imagination of childhood, but also a reminder that children are not innocent angels themselves. In some ways it reminded me of Lord of the Flies, in its depictions of the cruelty of children, and to the William Brown series by Richmal Crompton and the Little Nicholas series by René Goscinny and Jean-Jacques Sempé, in its use of the children's point of view and rejection and criticism of adult society.

It also has some very funny moments, like the fight between the adults of the two towns when both of them organized religious parades, one town asking for more rain and the other asking for less rain.

Highly recommended. show less

em>La Guerre des boutons (The War of the Buttons) is the story of two rival gangs of children, from villages separated by a river. The victors tear the buttons from the losers' clothing so that they get into trouble with their mothers. This classic French story was first made into a film in 1937, then again in 1962, in 1994, and (inexplicably) twice in 2011, one directed by Christophe Barratier, and the other, the version I saw, was directed by Yann Samuell.

The original novel was first published in France in 1912. Pergaud warns in the preface, that despite its title, it's not a story for children, because it's an assertion that such savagery could be heroic.

Louis Pergaud was born in 1882 and died in August 1915 aged only 33. Following show more in his father's footsteps, he had become a schoolteacher by profession, and was appointed to the village of Durnes (Doubs), in 1901. In 1903 after the death of both his parents in 1900, he married Marthe Caffot, who was also a teacher at a neighbouring village.

Pergaud had published his first poems in 1904. The following year he was transferred from his school because of religious issues when the Third French Republic enacted separation of Church and State, and this was the catalyst for him to move to Paris in 1907 where he worked first as a clerk, and then as a schoolmaster while also pursuing his passion for writing.

He was serving as a second lieutenant in the infantry on the Western Front when he became trapped in barbed wire behind German lines and was killed by French fire. Some of his work was published posthumously.

La Guerre des boutons begins in the melancholy of autumn, the children returning to school after working on the harvest in the fields. Father Simon at the door of the school is surprised at the punctual entrance of two boys who are usually late: he is not to know that there is an urgent meeting to deal with an insult from the boys of the neighbouring school. Lebrac quickly establishes himself as the leader who will restore their dignity!

As in Enid Blyton's stories decades later, the local policeman is a figure of fun and easily outwitted. However, it is harder to deal with the suspicions of their parents and teacher.

There is an innocence about this tale that charmed me. While the conflict between the gangs is really about nothing other than some insulting words, they fight with rotten apples, marbles, pieces of vine and branches, and the threat of a mother's rage at the state of their clothes. They have no access to any serious weaponry and the cruelty of social media is a long way off. But there is still jealousy and treachery culminating in Bacaillé's act of betrayal. (The brutality of their vengeance isn't a feature of the film, BTW, and there's no mushy boy-girl romance with La Crique and Lebrac either).

To read the rest of my review please visit https://anzlitlovers.com/2020/12/30/la-guerre-des-boutons-by-louis-pergaud/ show less

Adolescents, playing in woods and meadows, realise the usenessless of war

Skvělá kniha, o níž si v rozporu ze všeobecným míněním (alespoň zdejším) troufám tvrdit, že se ji ve třiceti nebo čtyřiceti člověk užije ještě o poznání víc než ve dvanácti. On to totiž rozhodně není jen popis bojů dvou klukovských part, ale dá se to velmi úspěšně číst i jako pacifistický román (sice není vůbec jasné, proč se válčí, ale vální se nemilosrdně a krutě, nepřátelé jsou nejen cizí, ale i "zlí, podlí a proradní", vítězové svým vítězství reálně nic nezískávají, agresí se pouze stupňuje agrese protivníka), jako sociální sonda do tehdejší francouzské vesnice (i v lépe situovaných rodinách dosti citelná bída) i jako sžíravá kritika tehdejších show more výchovných metod (nesmyslně trestající učitel, naprosto nechápaví rodiče, kteří si vůbec nejsou vědomi toho, co děti celé dny dělají a prožívají). Pokud jde o film, kniha je opět rozhodně o poznání lepší. Mnohé tam chybí nebo je potlačena o překvapivě jiný je i závěr filmu. Celkový dojem: 90% show less

Mientras el mundo se ve sacudido por los terribles sucesos de la Segunda Guerra Mundial, otra contienda se libra en un pequeño rincón de Francia entre niños de Longeverne y Velrans, dos pueblos vecinos que siempre se han odiado. En una de esas batallas, a uno de ellos se le ocurre la brillante idea de arrancar los botones de sus enemigos para que vuelvan a casa vencidos y humillados.

Humouristique et tendre; regard bienvillant sur l'enfance

Il commença par la blouse, il arracha les agrafes métalliques du col, coupa les boutons des manches ainsi que ceux qui fermaient le devant de la blouse, puis il fendit entièrement les boutonnières, ensuite de quoi Camus fit sauter ce vêtement inutile ; les boutons du tricot et les boutonnières subirent un sort pareil ; les bretelles n'échappèrent point, on fit sauter le tricot. Ce fut ensuite le tour de la chemise : du col au plastron et aux manches, pas un bouton ni une boutonnière n'échappa...
- T'as pas de « caneçon » ? Non ! reprit Lebrac, en vérifiant l'intérieur de la culotte qui dégringolait sur les jarrets.
- Eh bien, maintenant, fous le camp !