Omega

This is my favorite McDevitt novel to date. It is a little less action driven, and a lot more thought provoking. The Goompahs are an interesting alien race, not because they are compellingly different, but because of how similar they are to humans in many ways (although with a few telling differences). I particularly enjoyed the role of the theater and the arts in Goompah society. And the role of religion in any society is given a sensitive treatment. The cast of protagonists is made up of reasonably normal, everyday people thrown into a situation where they choose to act heroically, to risk their lives for a noble cause. And in McDevitt's universe, when people take risks, there are usually prices to be paid. While some aspects of the show more climax were predictable, others were surprising. And there were smaller surprises sprinkled throughout the book. show less

The archaeological mysteries which were prevalent in the first three books are gone, replaced by a xeno-sociology/rescue mission. A new, thriving medieval civilization has been discovered on the world of Lookout. There's just one catch: an Omega cloud, those mysterious galactic phenomena that attack and destroy anything with straight lines--buildings for instance--is headed right for it.

The inhabitants have been dubbed "Goompahs" after a cartoon character whom they resemble. Images of the creatures builds sympathy for them back home and a rescue mission is conceived. One drawback, besides the lack of time, is that there must be as little contact with the natives as possible, so as to prevent, or at least, minimize "culture shock". The show more question of "How do you rescue a people without them knowing that you're there" arises.

Hutch, true to her word in Chindi, has quit her career as pilot and, as a reward for her past work, now works as a high ranking bureaucrat at the Space Academy. She organizes the rescue mission but doesn't actually go. She's regulated to a supporting character role in this book, which was a disappointment for me as McDevitt has made her a likable character. Instead, the book's main characters are Digby "Digger" Dunn and David Collingdale.

Digger, who was on the original exploratory ship, initially isn't intent on saving the Goompahs so much as he's attracted to Kellie, the pilot of the ship he's on. But an accident, taking the life of the expedition leader, forces him into the leadership role while the relief mission scrambles to get there in time. Digger develops an affection for the Goompahs and his character evolves from being lightly self-centered to self-sacrificing.

Meanwhile, Collingdale is cast as a Captain Ahab and the omega is his white whale. At first his hatred of the omegas is reasonable, but the closer he gets to Lookout, the worse he gets. Once there, his obsession takes over, alienating his crewmates (and this reader). McDevitt builds us up for final confrontation between Collingdale and the omega but just as it's climaxing, McDevitt puts the scene "off camera". It's the equivalent of showing Obi-wan about to duel with Vader but not actually showing the actual fight or hearing the dialogue, though you could infer its outcome from Luke's reaction. It left me feeling a little cheated.

McDevitt's writing style continues to be excellent and his Goompahs make for interesting aliens. His characters are real and I could easily visualize the world. This novel won the John W Campbell Award for best sci-fi novel of the year and it's been nominated for a Nebula. I can see why. McDevitt tells a good story and is able to utilize action without relying on epic battles to do so. His characters, at least in this series, use their brains to solve their problems and only use violence as a last resort. And in this novel, violence, as represented by Collingdale, achieves nothing, while Digger's personal evolution symbolizes the human race as a whole.

Perhaps it was Hutch's explanation for the Omegas themselves that did it. While the idea for them is original and intriguing, it was ultimately unsatisfying for me. It would be interesting to see McDevitt write a novel about a meeting between Earth and the Omega creators and see what happens. Could McDevitt write a novel about resolving the conflict between the two without resorting to violence? show less

I'm of two minds on this book.

It's pretty damn awesome when it comes to characters and the gentle push toward an alternate Star Trek kind of universe with almost no posturing and no overpowered gunships. The dearth of alien species is a nice touch, making it more of an archeological mystery. These future humans happen to be peaceful, too, for once, and most of their principled actions reflect those of the Federation but there's also a more realistic bending of the rules, too.

Enter this book. The Omega clouds are absolutely immense intergalactic clouds of nanotech that spike huge energies and are apparently programmed to seek out any intelligent life. Cool, right? It might explain the lack of aliens. The next world in the path of one show more of these happens to be pre-industrial LIVING aliens! Oops. And the cloud will reach them during this novel. Oops.

Enter conflict, a race to save an alien species, provide tons of commentary on general human stupidity and opportunism. Hey, look, let's grab as much as we can of their civ to sell because they're all about to become instant relics!

It sounds like a really good episode of Trek, right? Right. Well, no complaints there. I never expected total and complete originality out of these. Just a careful and methodical worldbuilding, care and devotion to characters, and a hopeful outlook despite everything. Including a very regular death toll on every single outing. (Wait... redshirts?)

So what's my problem? We get a fully developed alien culture here including PoVs from these guys, right down to a fully religious world-build and science-debates and a huge survival thing.

Well... I'll be honest. As long as we stuck with the humans I was pretty invested. The aliens? ... not so much. The whole self-aware cartoon character nod and the way we humans fell for how cute these buck-toothed aliens... well... I guess I can see it but I didn't really appreciate it.

It might just be me. The commentary was fairly clever but the way it was pulled off? I don't think McDevitt went far enough. Or the amount he did go was a bit too far for the pacing and investment I was supposed to have in saving these guys.

Too much of the novel was slightly meh. Not a lot of meh. Just slightly. The rest was engaging and interesting. :) Hence the four stars. But this is pretty much on the same level as the second Academy novel for me. show less

McDevitt, Jack. Omega. Academy No. 4. Ace, 2003.
Jack McDevitt has had a long career of writing very good science fiction. He creates nuanced and believable characters and puts them in a credible far future space-faring society. The Academy is a government-funded organization of scientists and spaceship crews that make first contact with alien species and explore astrophysical anomalies. Most of the books in the series deal with Fermi’s paradox as the Academy works to find out why technological societies are so rare. Omega offers a partial explanation, the eponymous Omega Cloud, a cloud of gas and nanoparticles thousands of kilometers long. It homes in on star systems with technological societies, destroying artificial structures. No show more one knows why. Now a newly discovered pre-industrial society is threatened, and an expedition is launched to warn the aliens and try some tricks to deflect the cloud. It is the sort of situation one might find in a Star Trek plot, complete with its own version of the Prime Directive, but McDevitt handles it more realistically than the usual Trek story. For one thing, space travel is expensive, starships are in short supply and the central characters of the series are aging. His early protagonist, Priscilla “Hutch” Hutchinson, is now an administrator struggling with funding and public relations. The expedition has trouble learning the alien language without violating its non-interference mandate. No Babel Fish or universal translators here. In sum, Omega is a well-told story with intriguing ideas, adequate action, and engaging characters. 4 stars. show less

Typical McDevitt. On the one hand, life on Earth in the 23rd century seems identical to about 1990. I'm surprised characters don't read the morning paper and open mail. On the other hand, interstellar travel! Flight with little concern for fuel! Invisibility via lightbenders! You have to read McDevitt for the adventure story and the sympathetic if not very deep characters.

This novel features the planet-blasting Omega clouds introduced earlier in the series. They are attracted to and wipe out artificial structures like cities. Now one is bearing down on a planet with a just discovered race of aliens named Goompahs after a popular kids TV show. Wait. Did I say 1990s above. I meant 1960s. The Federation --I mean, Academy -- Protocol says show more to not interfere but the Goompahs are too popular so ships are sent to either destroy or distract the Omega cloud or convince the Goompahs to abandon their cities.

There's the unforgivable use of the old trope where someone says "I have an idea what those clouds are but let me work on it and get back to you in two days" and you know what happens next. Otherwise the book proceeds smoothly if slowly through various successes and failures in the rescue attempt. Though this is part of the Priscilla Hutchins series, at this point she is primarily an administrator who sets up the missions. She also gets to propose a solution to what the clouds are but you won't like it so don't read this for that.

Recommended for McDevitt fans. If you've not read him, start earlier in the series, like The Engines of God or Deepsix when Hutchins is more front and center. show less

"Omega," a mid-series entry in the Priscilla Hutchins group of novels, is a slightly off-beat, unusual work for Jack McDevitt, but serves to prove that "unusual" can certainly be a good thing.

The omega clouds are back, and one is headed for a populated world whose low-technology inhabitants have no idea what is on the way. Public opinion on Earth is split: do we intervene, or let nature take its course? When footage of the awkward- but friendly-looking aliens is released to the public, many people decide that they must be saved. Thus begins the great race of creativity versus destruction. After all: how does one stop a malignant cloud?

Drawing upon lessons learned in previous encounters - and of the artifacts of the famous monument show more makers themselves - a team of specialists sets out to protect the hapless aliens from certain destruction.

This novel is definitely a departure from the McDevitt norm. Gone are the sweeping, galaxy-hopping adventures following cosmic bread crumbs in the effort to unravel an age-old mystery. No, Omega is about something much smaller, but with much more emotional impact. Readers will find themselves rooting for the survival of a technologically inferior - but ethical and intelligent - species that has never, and can never, know that we were there. Other reviewers have made this a much-maligned book for its focus on what they see as an unremarkable set of circumstances. However, fans of the McDevitt novels will see this for what it is: a change in perspective. Rather than looking at a huge stage with an infinite set of circumstances, McDevitt has instead focused on one particular place, with one very serious problem and, rather than trying to solve some esoteric mystery buried in the stars, seeks to examine something much closer to home - are we ourselves civilized enough to save another civilization?

This is definitely a McDevitt to read, and re-read, with great relish.

-BrowncoatLibrarian show less

I did not enjoy this as much as the first book in the series, The Engines of God. I felt there were too many ships, too many characters, and not enough action. However, I did really enjoy the alien race that gets dubbed "the Goompahs." I particularly appreciate how McDevitt insinuates that a culture with a low-key religion, and no promise of an afterlife, ends up being more peaceful than Earth. Another factor contributing to this is the females' control over when they get pregnant. Three cheers for that!