Ciel

First of all, I'm a cisgender, white woman and can only review this book from this perspective :) I read a lot of books that contain diverse characters because I love the Queer world and diverse characters appeal to me. That being said, I can't speak to the "authenticity" of the "Trans" experience... because I'm not trans. What I can do... is read a book like this by an own-voices author and speak to what I learned... or what appealed to me about it. I hope that makes sense.

Ciel is beginning a new year at High School. Ciel identifies as trans and also non-binary. At home, Ciel's father is great about allowing Ciel to wear what they want and be however they want. I loved the way this relationship was described in the book. My hope is show more that more children will begin to grow up in homes in which they are allowed to express themselves however they want.... just be who they are.

When Ciel returns to school it's with their best friend Stephie at their side. They are adorable friends, always supportive and sweet. The one thing that is different for these two is that Stephie doesn't want people to know that she is trans while Ciel is very public. Ciel even has a youtube channel on which they post videos about being trans and non-binary. I thought this was a great choice by the author for demonstrating that people are different in terms of how they want to express themselves and their gender identities.

There are some lovely scenes in this book when Ciel explains things to their friends/ classmates. There is a brave discussion at an LGBTQIA group at school during which Ciel points out that all those in attendance should give their name and pronouns. Not everyone is aware that there are more pronoun choices than "he" and "she" and Ciel takes the time to explain.

Ciel is also dealing with a long-distance relationship with their boyfriend Eirikurl. He used to live in Montreal but he has returned to Iceland with his family. Ciel is finding that Eirikur doesn't contact them as much as they had hoped. It's a learning experience for Ciel.

In my mind, the First year of high school is fifteen or sixteen years old. The characters in this book read as younger than that to me. I just wouldn't want anyone to pick this up thinking it was a "young adult" book.

This is a great book for young folks who may be exploring their own gender identity, or those who just want to learn about it. There are some great explanations in the book.

My review will be posted on my blog on August 15, 2020 show less

First of all, I'm a cisgender, white woman and can only review this book from this perspective :) I read a lot of books that contain diverse characters because I love the Queer world and diverse characters appeal to me. That being said, I can't speak to the "authenticity" of the "Trans" experience... because I'm not trans. What I can do... is read a book like this by an own-voices author and speak to what I learned... or what appealed to me about it. I hope that makes sense.

Ciel is beginning a new year at High School. Ciel identifies as trans and also non-binary. At home, Ciel's father is great about allowing Ciel to wear what they want and be however they want. I loved the way this relationship was described in the book. My hope is show more that more children will begin to grow up in homes in which they are allowed to express themselves however they want.... just be who they are.

When Ciel returns to school it's with their best friend Stephie at their side. They are adorable friends, always supportive and sweet. The one thing that is different for these two is that Stephie doesn't want people to know that she is trans while Ciel is very public. Ciel even has a youtube channel on which they post videos about being trans and non-binary. I thought this was a great choice by the author for demonstrating that people are different in terms of how they want to express themselves and their gender identities.

There are some lovely scenes in this book when Ciel explains things to their friends/ classmates. There is a brave discussion at an LGBTQIA group at school during which Ciel points out that all those in attendance should give their name and pronouns. Not everyone is aware that there are more pronoun choices than "he" and "she" and Ciel takes the time to explain.

Ciel is also dealing with a long-distance relationship with their boyfriend Eirikurl. He used to live in Montreal but he has returned to Iceland with his family. Ciel is finding that Eirikur doesn't contact them as much as they had hoped. It's a learning experience for Ciel.

In my mind, the First year of high school is fifteen or sixteen years old. The characters in this book read as younger than that to me. I just wouldn't want anyone to pick this up thinking it was a "young adult" book.

This is a great book for young folks who may be exploring their own gender identity, or those who just want to learn about it. There are some great explanations in the book.

My review will be posted on my blog on August 15, 2020 show less

Nonbinary teen Ciel deals with friendship, romance, and internet drama in their first year of high school.

Ciel’s gender confuses the teachers, all the bathrooms are gendered, and even the Gender and Sexuality Alliance isn’t the safe space it should be, but Ciel remains optimistic. They are saving to buy a camera and take their YouTube channel to the next level. But as their channel gains popularity, it also gains attention from trolls who disparage nonbinary identities and say Brazilian Canadian Ciel should “go back to [their] country.” Meanwhile, the Montréal teen and their best friend, Stephie, seem to be growing apart, and their long-distance boyfriend Eiríkur (he lives in Iceland) takes weeks to respond to their emails. show more Refreshingly, Ciel is not the only trans character in their story; both friends and foes are trans or queer. The most vicious attacks on Ciel’s gender come from a believable trans character, not a transphobic straw man. Ciel doesn’t win a victory for trans rights but simply triumphs over personal hurdles. Though accessible and filled with likable characters, the book suffers from a meandering plot, dangling threads, and language choices that weaken the authenticity of Ciel’s voice. In particular, Ciel sounds like a technological dinosaur with their reliance on email communication. The translation from the French seems to commit only halfway to recasting the story into an English-speaking setting, landing on a confusing middle ground. However, Ciel’s heart shines through the stylistic issues.

This charming novel depicts a realistic slice of life as a nonbinary teen. (Fiction. 9-14)

-Kirkus Review show less