Beneath the Underdog: His World as Composed by Mingus

Wow! Straffen toebak. Geen droge bio of een boek vol opsommingen en feitjes, maar een anekdotische vlot geschreven rollercoaster doorheen het leven en vooral het brein en gemoed van Mingus.
Je staat met je neus op de dagelijkse strijd van Mingus met zichzelf, zijn gevecht om erkenning als zwarte muzikant en als zwarte tout court. Heftig, waanzinnig, hilarisch, indrukwekkend.

I loved this book. I read a lot of jazz biographies, and i have an interest in jazz behind the iron curtain - and this book has enough drugs, prostitution, crime, bigotry, religion, and insanity to justify banning jazz music in half a dozen countries. Mingus's voice is as clear as the voice of his muse, who takes turns narrating the story and interviewing the musician. Fifty years of the backdrop to the jazz scenes of New York, California, and the south - the way it was for a half-black half-mad genius.
If there's a downside, there isn't much about jazz. Great musicians wander through the tale, but the tunes, gigs, and venues are incidental to the girls and the troubles of a crazy pimp and artist trying to make his way through an show more impossible life. Occasionally the number of albums he's recorded comes up in conversation, but not a single session is mentioned. If you want more of that, read a biography - you might also find out how true the stories are. I don't care, it's his reality and they are his stories and i loved them. show less

Like, apparently, every woman mentioned in these pages, I finished Mingus with equal parts amusement and dissatisfaction. It's sometimes charming, and sometimes annoying - just like the repetitive tales of a good man brought low by his times.

Many memoirs are nothing but vehicles for ego-stroking and self-aggrandizement - Beneath the Underdog certainly qualifies - but it is so just plain bizarre that I found it more entertaining than offensive.

For such a storied artist, Mingus doesn't seem to have a lot of experiences. There are two stories in this memoir, repeated ad infinitum. A) Mingus is seduced by some woman, struggles with his morals, but decides to cave into sex, and then feels badly about it. All women are sex-crazed fiends who show more can't get enough of him and insist on dragging the poor man down! (We have a few mentions of prostitutes, who don't apparently count as women for this purpose.)This shows, I think he thinks, that he is a better man than anyone else, no matter what his behavior would otherwise indicate.

B) Occasionally, he pops up with a strong stance on musical purity, diatribing at his father or friends, but this bad world and his bad friends are too cynical to let that stand, and he always finds himself having to compromise. This shows, I think he thinks, that he is a better man than anyone else, no matter what his behavior would otherwise indicate. Sound familiar?

ETA: a friend points out I'm being unfair - there is also substantial name-dropping of other musicians. Not much about them except to mention they loved the Mingus, but Famous Names of Jazz are strewn throughout. Noted!

Throughout, Mingus narrates his own life in a third-person voice, an omniscient narrator voice - you're not sure if it's meant to be some heavenly or diabolical intervention until late in the book, where he says that as a consequence of being dropped on his head as a child, he's always existed outside himself, in the third person.

I can't in good conscience recommend this one - if you want a memoir that tells you nothing, really, about the person in question, but is quirky, I'd recommend The Last Holiday instead. But if you do pick it up, you might find moments of enjoyment, despite yourself, as I did. show less

It's difficult to describe Charles Mingus' story. It's improvisational, stream-of-consciousness, full of dialogue, philosophy and sexual escapades. He addresses and hates the racism inherent in the music business and the world in general. The story wanders often but is never, ever boring.

One of the most interesting and unusual Jazz autobiographies. Mingus was a fascinating artist who was angry about jazz music's lack of dignity in the american mainstream culture of his era. His prose is unencumbered by literary style yet thoughtful, even philosophical. his choice of subject matter skews heavily towards two subjects: his sexual relationships and his unhappiness about the music business.

The historical veracity of his narrative is, at many points, questionable. Certain scenes and events do not correlate with established timelines. However, poetic license can be given since there is honesty and conviction in his presentation. The real life characters he writes about, his contemporaries, seem to be truthully portrayed up to show more a point. If you are familliar with Jazz music history, you should be able to seperate the fact from the fiction. For the less knowledgable reader: I recommend careful fact checking.

As an unflinching psychological self portrait and a love letter to the artform of jazz, it is excellent. show less

The first 80 to 100 pages had me intrigued but the stream of consciousness writing style was tedious by the end. I read this book because I dig Mingus’s music. Too bad he spent more time writing about fucking instead of music. It’s like reading a pimp’s bio who writes about music.

Spirited, raunchy read but if you're trying to find factual information about Mingus's life, Mingus isn't the one to ask. This book is his own personal mythology. It tells you how he wanted to be perceived, not what he actually did.