Soup

I read some concerning reviews so I’ll be reading this myself before I decide if it stays.

Example:
A story from a bygone era...
Reviewed in the United States on August 15, 2015
Fair warning upfront: this book was written about a time that was not politically correct whatsoever. There are parts with bullies at school, fist fights, children getting spanked / whacked by teachers and parents, and an episode of anti-Semitism. Yet overall, these small stories (each chapter is a stand alone tale) are interesting and engaging memories of our narrator Robert and his childhood best friend, named Soup. If you can read these books without a judgmental 2015 eye, you're sure to enjoy them as well.”

This is a fairly nostalgic look at the author's childhood, well-written and funny... kinda like The Great Brain series, but set in a later decade.

The chapters are self-contained stories, which makes it possible to skip over any you find problematic. There's one chapter where the kids make acorn pipes and smoke cornsilk - they get incredibly sick, and it's highly unlikely that any child will decide to emulate them.

There's another one where the children get it into their head that they MUST see the double feature movie, and since they don't have the money they decide to trade in their foil for cash. Lacking enough foil, they decide to cheat the man who owns it, because one of them was told that it's okay to cheat Jews. It's pretty clear show more from the discussion (how this man is nice and always jokes with them) and from the aftermath (they get paid full price, but there are no smiles and the stone they wrapped the foil over is given back to them, so they know they got caught and aren't being punished, a shameful thing) that they feel guilty and that, in fact, it's not okay to go around cheating anybody... but it's not stated outright and either way, understandably, many parents and especially teachers aren't going to want to bring this issue up at all. I strongly suggest that you read this book before you buy it. show less

These fall under the "reading whatever is lying around" category. My little sister was into them, and I was way too advanced for them, so I do not have good opinions of them. I might have liked them at a younger age.

3010936

SLJ starred review!

Lexile: 740
Reading Recovery: 24
DRA: 40
Fountas Pinnel Guided Reading: R