SilverFin (2005)

School Library Journal
Gr 6-9-Meet Bond-James Bond-at 14, before he became the suave, lady-killing international spy. An orphan, he attends Eton and lives with his Aunt Charmian during school breaks. While the premise for this prequel sounds intriguing, it fails to deliver. Action, adventure, and mystery are not a part of the plot until the end. While visiting his dying Uncle Max in Scotland, James discovers that his enemy at Eton, George Hellebore, is visiting his father, Lord Randolph, who owns the castle in the same town. On the train to Scotland, James met Red Kelly and learned that Red's cousin Alphie is missing. Rumor has it he disappeared near Loch Silverfin, which is part of the Hellebore estate. It doesn't take long for James and Red to determine that Alphie's disappearance is connected to the castle. Red Kelly, Meatpacker, Wilder Lawless, and her horse, Martini, are interesting and quirky characters while James is positively dull. He is merely a part of the plot instead of a driving force. The book may appeal to serious Bond fans, but for students who are looking for mystery and adventure, Anthony Horowitz's "Alex Rider" books (Philomel) are a better choice.- ( )

awesome book ! huge fan of bond ( )

Very exciting and fun book to read, definately reccomend to read it. ( )

A page turning book that starts out slow, but pays to read to the end. Story that you will want to buy the next one the day you start reading it. ( )

Malcolm and I were on one of our book buying escapades and feeling slightly experimental (books are so much cheaper in England than Australia - until you start buying in bulk...). Malcolm pointed out the (then) new novel that introduced James Bond as a boy and I was instantly intrigued by the idea. I've never been much of a James Bond fan, although I have no problem watching Sean Connery as a rule - it's all too gruesome for me. So I've never read any Ian Fleming. But when Malcolm pointed out Silverfin I knew he was interested, and I was in the mood to be impulsive and just "try it out." I didn't really expect to enjoy it that much but I thought that Malcolm would read it anyway, so the money wouldn't be wasted. That's how reckless we were with our book spending back then. Sigh.

As it happens, several years have passed and I am still the first of us to pick it up (I guess that now that we can't buy books so madly, we're finally having to catch up with our old purchases!). I have no way to compare it with the original Bond novels. But I don't care. It's a great book. For the first two thirds, apart from a few dark hints, it doesn't even seem like Bond to me. It's a fascinating, and not particularly fast-paced story, about a boy's first half at Eton. I enjoyed every minute of the development of James' character and his life at Eton. It has the same satisfying feeling that entering Hogwarts has - there is enough space devoted to "normal" life to really appreciate and enjoy it, unlike the tantalising glimpses one is afforded of some fictional universes. I felt I was able to walk around and get to know James' Eton without ever being bored.

I was also startled by the essential thread of "Britishness" that runs as a connector between the characters of Arthur Ransome, Enid Blyton and Ian Fleming / Charlie Higson. At points James might very well be a member of the Famous Five, setting up camp and trying to solve the mystery of the castle. At other times, he and his friends display the kind of practical know-how that typify the Swallows, Amazons and Death or Glories. James Bond could so easily be a grown up Julian with added toughness.

The more gruesome elements are left to the final third of the novel and the vivid and imaginative portrayal wouldn't disgrace a Bond movie. But by the time I reached this section I was hooked on the characters and had to continue. Interestingly, there were even moments that reminded me of John Marsden's Tomorrow series. James' combination of experience and inexperience is very reminiscent of Ellie and her companions. But I'm just glad that books were sufficiently cheap in England that I was tempted to feel reckless one day... ( )