Graham McNeill

Firstly- a bonus mention of Ferrus Manus is always appreciated. It's almost a practice in Zen to be an iron-hands fan but still- a scant 3 paragraphs or so of his deeds gladden me very much so.

Secondly- the book gives excellent characterization of both the Emperor, and Horus' lunar wolves. The Emperor (as it's implied) personally taking time out to write a letter to this smith along with having Malcador deliver it shows how important art, legacy, and cultural development was to him (which, show more if Horus was made aware of, would argue its far too much playing into his feelings of abandonment).
As for the Horus' legion- it's often said by others that their degeneration from 'normal' warriors to monsters torturing and pillaging for fun comes off as rather fast- which is something this story rectifies somewhat by showing that Horus was likely aware of this degeneration within the warrior-lodges and chose to keep it a secret (much like the chaos-spawn incident in HH1) for his 'realpolitik' purposes or just a desire to protect his sons.

The story is well written, rampant with symbolism, and was a delight to read. Have fun with it! show less

The Lightning King by Dan Abnett

“What are you afraid of? What are you really afraid of?”

This was the first Horus Heresy audio drama (possibly the first one from the Black Library?), released as a double CD: The Dark King and The Lightning Tower by Dan Abnett and Graham McNeill (2007). This was a year after the opening trilogy and the same year as The Flight of the Eisenstein, so word had literally just reached Terra or maybe Magnus had already sent his naughty message, the release order show more and timeline are wild, but the point I'm making is that it's interesting that this story jumps to Dorn preparing the Palace of Terra for the eventual siege (as well as The Dark King jumping back to pre-Heresy tensions with Curze, referenced in this story). This really marked the beginning of jumping around in time.

Dorn, Primarch of the Imperial Fists, has been recalled to Terra to prepare for the impending siege as building things up is his Special Son Skill (as knocking things down is Perturabo's). He is very sad about making the pretty palace ugly, worries about what made Horus turn and how he would fair against the Warmaster, and cringes at the memory of that time Curze nearly beat him to death. Evil Eliminster has a weird little chat with him and pokes the memory of getting curb-stomped, flashing Nighthaunter's fancy tarot deck. Symbolism!

I wrote a really scathing review on Twitter a few years ago when I attempted a re-read of the series, while going through a tenderqueer phase brought on by everything already wrong with my brain and Twitter brain rot, which I don't disagree with in spirit. I'll be folding elements of that in with this review, albeit somewhat tempered.

I enjoyed the conversation between Dorn and Malcador. There is an interesting play of their respective positions and personalities, as well as the portentous discussion of the tarot and Curze's visions (which the Emperor gaslit him about, lest we forget). This has the drama, tragedy, and mythos I want from the Horus Heresy.

The writing is great, which I have come to expect from Abnett, weird misogynistic, puritanical inner-monologues aside, but it is presenting a lot of bleak stuff as positive at face value. This is because it's Dorn's perspective, admittedly, but in this story he is cast as the honourable, if afraid and questioning, son doing his duty. There is no question of his perspective being wrong, so it's a big ask for the casual reader and those unaware of, or flatly refute, the satirical nature of the Warhammer 40K (and 30K) galaxy. It's not quite the portrayal of Guilliman and war crime apologia that we see in some later Primarch stories and the Ultramarines’ Primarch's return to 40K, but there is unquestioned veneration of brutal authoritarianism, long before it explicitly ‘justified as necessity’ (within the Imperium's lore). More satire or telehgraphing of fucked perspectives please, you know there is a depressing amount regressive and reactionary
Warhammer fans (which is funny as another huge chunk of the community is us big ole Queer transes).

Past me spitting:
So he converted the gilded palace from a shrine to opulence of feudal fascism into a brutalist shrine to the militarism of galactic fascism because of the coming siege? Like, I know which one I'd rather look at, but I'd rather tear them both down and use their valuables to help the subjugated populace.

Old me spitting, but cringe:
"It's ugly." You know what Dorn? War and fascism are ugly, and people in bright yellow ceramite houses... Oh, and so is using slave labour to build your defences. Ugly, abhorrent and evil.

The architect's slaves described as “following him...like timorous litter of young following their mother" is proper fucked though.

Dorn's fears of Horus' reasons for treachery and his fear of Kurze showing his humanity and how fallible even primarchs are highlights, though the additional details of Kurze's condition and visions that Fulgrim shared with him make his treatment of his brother even more unconscionable. In exploring these elements, introducing Malcador and showing us the Sigillite and the Praetorian's relationship, this story does a good enriching the Horus Heresy saga, despite its problems.

Having encountered a lot more of the Sigillite, especially since smashing through the Errant Knights collection, I have a better perspective on the Bastard Blackstaff and how much of a glorious prick he's being in this. His line, "salvation in ignorance" truly shows how much the Imperium of the 41st millennium is founded on this Dogcunt Dumbledore. Of course he has the Mona Lisa in his chambers. Webb's Malcador voice puts me in mind of an old version of Hamill's Joker, which feels appropriate.

I enjoyed the glimpse of the Siege of Terra and the unimaginable scale of the battle, even if it slips away as only a simulation. But the idea of a simulator that you can just plug in the idea of Legions and Primarchs into is FASCINATING.

I really the great connection to The Dark King by Graham McNeil, especially through the tarot, which speaks to the planning and collaboration at play at the beginning of this saga. It would have been great to see more connected double audio dramas as connected as these two.

The Dark King by Graham McNeil

Part of the first Horus Heresy audio drama double feature, The Dark King is much more about tensions and divisions in the Legions before the Heresy and some wild and ridiculous action.

Told through memories and reflections, jumping around a relatively short period of time, this is the story of how the Nighthaunter and the Praetorian and the Phoenician's kinship came to an end and with it Curze's connections to his homeworld and the Imperium.

A disagreement over the execution of prisoners during a Compliance enacted by the Imperial Fists and Night Lords and a troubling secret told in confidence, betrayed, leads the brother Primarchs come to blows with brother almost killing brother, long before Isstvan, and, ultimately, the destruction of an entire planet.

I looked at a previous review I wrote of this when I was in a very strange, sensitive place that I almost entirely disagree with. I essentially railed against it as Miller and Millar edgelord Batman bolter porn, which is wildly unfair to McNeil and Curze. He's clearly edgelord Spawn. But seriously, that was a weird time when Twitter was melting my brain. I even had so little fun left in my soul that I took umbrage with the silly karate chop sound effect when Curze chops an Astartes in full plate's head off. Hey past me, things can be fun and silly and violent, as a treat.

This is a gloriously grim and entertainingly dark tale that truly encapsulates the gothic melodrama, epic tragedy, and bloody spectacle that the Dark Millennium and the times that lead to it dance between. The two-faced hypocrisy of the Imperium, represented both the two-headed eagle of the Aquila with its one head face the past and the other facing the future blind and Konrad Curze and Rogal Dorn is shown spectacularly through the Primarchs and their views of the Imperium and the Great Crusade. The betrayal that will come to define the whole of its future represented by Fulgrim betraying Curze's trust about his cursed knowledge of the coming Heresy, how apropos!

We get to see how powerful a Primarch is, as well as getting our first real glimpse on the unique abilities of the individual demigods with Nighthaunter's oneness with the shadows. This is exquisitely expressed by McNeil describing him as “a glimmering shadow of dead stars and extinction.”

The talk of prophecy and the significance of the tarot also brings that quintessential Horus Heresy mythos element and tie so perfectly to Abnett's The Lightning Tower. Seriously, how did Maleficent Merlin get hold of Curze's cards? Was he just fucking with Dorn?

While listening, I was struck with my inability to express how much I hate Dorn and sympathise with Curze, not with the murdering POWs and blowing up of planets, to be clear.

Yes, Curze is a bloody, authoritarian monster, but that is what his life and the curse in his creation by whatever fucked deals the Emperor made to create him and his brothers. But he was truly open to becoming something else and could have been more good or at least more grey like his most analogous siblings, Corax and the Lion, but his father broke him by gaslighting him the moment they met. (Gods’ arseholes does the Emperor shit me! Yes, having massive daddy issues heightens the feeling, but he truly is the worst!)

Dorn, is the yellow demigod of centrism, 'acceptable' atrocity, and the unfathomable notion that empire and authority aren't built on blood. Truly the king of the libs paving the bloody way for daddy fash claiming to not see the suffering he enables and enacts.

(In before ‘Warhammer isn't political’. Shut up. Yes it is. Always was. Grow up!)

One incredible nerd pedant thing that is on display here and throughout Horus Heresy and Warhammer 40K tales that I actually love and find very funny is the inconsistency with which humans are able to use bolters is hilarious. I don't know where it was, but I remember one story talking about how a human firing the machine gun rocket launcher would be killed by the recoil. It's standard that Inquisitors, their retinue, high ranking Astra Militarum officers have special repulsors to allow them to heft and handle the recoil. Honestly, it would have been an incredible moment highlighting the inhuman strength of Astartes for the prisoner to attempt to shoot Curze in the back and be bludgeoned to death by the attempt.

I truly feel for Curze & Angron, both warped & abused by their lives on their home worlds, & then simply used as tools with no care or aid by the Emperor. He did them both so wrong, particularly in this instance Curze, who's visions plagued him all his life, before the Emperor gaslit him about them. Devastating to see Fulgrim snithcing to Dorn who just comes to berate him about them, like a kind & thoughtful brother. (I'm not entirely sure of the timeline here, so this could have been a purpose traitor move, either way it's brutal).

This truly is an absolutely cracking audio drama that crams a ludicrous amount into its mere 25 minutes without ever feeling rushed or unsatisfying, which is an unbelievable feat!

Goodness me I had a good time with this and a serious cringe at reading back my old review (long before I joined Goodreads)! I am so happy for Nighthaunter and myself to be free and doing better, I'm sure the future only holds wonderful good times for the both of us! show less

Magnus was always a tragic character for me - Primarch that fired the very opening salvo in Horus Heresy while trying to prevent that very carnage from taking place. Everything that takes place from there on, destruction of Prospero, flight to the Warp to the sorcerers planet and witnessing the new mutations of his Legion, everything seemed to be a punishment for something Magnus did by accident, gigantic tragedy born out of misunderstanding. But in truth all of that was was caused by show more Magnus' vainglory, his view of himself as the only one with sufficient knowledge to control the Warp and guide the humanity to bright future (this even comes to the surface in his discussion with Ahriman on how he sees post-Heresy events unfolding).

Story confronts Magnus with Malcadore and later with the Emperor. In all these conversations it is visible that Magnus has fallen way lower than he ever thought was the case. When offered only way out and rejoining the Emperor's forces, Magnus refuses it, but while it might seem to be out of love for his sons for me it looks like decision born out of inability to admit that he (Magnus) failed and literally opened the gates of Hell to consume entire universe. And through this refusal he loses the very last traces of humanity and finally fully joins the Horus' team.

Very interesting book, highly recommended to all fans of Horus Heresy and W40K in general. show less

I've previously read a couple of Arkham Horror novels by game-developer-cum-novelist Graham McNeill, and I wasn't profoundly impressed by them. But I'm glad I took a chance on this book of his, set in his original fictive stomping grounds of the Warhammer 40,000 milieu. It was probably the best WH40K book I've read, with a huge variety of characters and the introduction of several alien races and Imperial cultural aspects that had been at most merely mentioned in my other reading.

Priests of show more Mars is the first of three volumes in the series "Adeptus Mechanicus," and the titles of the book and the series alike refer to the retro-technical cyborg hierarchy concerned with retrieving, deploying, and maintaining the sort of ancient human technologies that the now-decadent Imperium is no longer capable of devising for itself. In addition to the Martian magi, though, this book incorporates Black Templar space marines, a rogue trader, elite Imperial Guards of the Cadian 71st, mech titans of Legio Sirius, and -- perhaps most interestingly -- starship bondsmen conscripted from the space docks on the world of Joura.

Other WH40K literature I've read has referred to the bonded and subjugated classes of the Imperium, but has never set any of them up as characters of interest or explored their experiences, and by doing so, McNeill radically expands the perspectives available to him in telling the story of events on the Speranza, an enormous Ark Mechanicus starship that is the flag of the fleet gathered to explore the Halo Scar in the footsteps of a long-lost Archmagos of the Mechanicus priesthood.

The central plot is centered on the exploration of the "Halo Scar," which is an anomalous and dangerous zone of space more than a little reminiscent of the "Kefahuchi Tract" in the recent space opera novels of M. John Harrison. Having said that, the Adeptus Mechanicus books couldn't be more stylistically dissimilar to Harrison's polished gems of surreal enigma. They are straightforward far-future adventure with a heavy emphasis throughout on monstrosity, militarism, and machinery.

While this book clearly completes a segment of the overall plot arc, it doesn't supply any settled conclusion to the course of events that it begins to chart. It is nevertheless a fast read despite its 400+ pages, and I've already acquired the next volume in the series. show less