John G. Bourke (1843–1896)

I always read what sources an author uses to develop a story and "1000 White Women" was no exception. I was surprised to read that John G. Bourke was not only a real person but truly a noted anthropologist and writer. And yes, I believe that the author created a very fair depiction of him. I don't typically enjoy reading about battles, but John Bourke writes them from such a personal level that one can almost hear the horses snorting and see their frozen breath. And scattered throughout are show more many poetic descriptions of the setting such as, "Far away to the distant horizon, the white-mantled terraces, extended in ridge upon ridge until they touched the hems of the leaden robes of clouds the sky had just doffed."
Additionally, he offers much discussion about the relationship between the men of the army and the various tribes represented by the new Indian (he calls them aboriginals) scouts. He recounts how the Shoshonee men mourned after they found in the desecrated village of their recently defeated foes, the Cheyennes, twelve severed right hands of babies. "They reasoned, and subsequent events proved they reasoned wisely, that the Cheyennes had just returned from the destruction of one of the outlying villages of their tribe, in some exposed position in the Wind River range, and that we had been listening to the savage dance which celebrated this fearful butchery."
John Bourke makes every attempt to find good in everyone he is with. There is quite a long passage in which he regales the skill of the packers and teamsters., amongst other things: "The sharp cold air of these winter mornings had the effect of intensifying the profane powers of our packers and teamsters whose language is quite often as amusing from its originality as it is shocking in its blasphemy and irreverence." There is also some humor in these notes as when the author shares how the mules consult with each other when something such as a difficult climb is before them. Later he says, "But the team has surmounted its last difficulty before reaching the camp for the night, and the voices of the mules are now upraised in a song of gladness. Much objection has been made of this chanting, as practised by mules, but the objection strikes me as frivolous and untenable. The mule's songs may be just a particle monotonous and the nasal pitch he commonly employs, somewhat harsh for cultivated ears, but the question of pitch is a question of taste, and the mule's taste may be better than our own ; or, if worse, this is the land of liberty, and the mule is free to enjoy himself as he pleases."
I had to give these quotes because there is no way I could adequately provide a description - it is truly poetic to read and provides depictions of the worst of war and yet the beauty of the surroundings.
Reading this after "1000 White Women" added so much to the fictional story while providing such context. I can just imagine John and May trying to read Shakespeare while using tribal language. show less

Reprint 1971

During his time as aide to General Crook during the Apache Wars, Bourke kept journals of his observations that were later published as On the Border with Crook. This book is considered one of the best firsthand accounts of frontier army life, as Bourke gives equal time to both the soldier and the Native American. Within it, Bourke describes the landscape, Army life on long campaigns, and his observations of the Native Americans. His passages recounts General Crook's meetings with show more Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse, and Geronimo as the General attempted to sign peace treaties and relocate tribes to reservations. Bourke provides considerable detail of towns and their citizens in the Southwest, specifically the Arizona Territory. show less

This is an interesting short tract that discusses Spanish law in the Americas. Bourke's point is not to expound at length on the subject of Spanish rule, but rather to notify his contemporaries that that they are working under some very prejudiced preconceptions, not the least of which is confusing Spanish rule with the results of rule of the newer, independent Mexican government.

Pam T for PageinHistory.com

This is a short monograph that was published in 1894 by Captain Bourke of the 3rd Cavalry. Bourke is usually a pretty entertaining writer, but in this case the paper is fairly bland, containing what is more or less a list of Spanish folk beliefs of the Rio Grand area.

I believe Bourke's intention was to show the connection between these 'new world' beliefs with those of ancient Rome and Europe but the treatment isn't vigorous enough to really drive home his point -- though he certainly sets show more the stage by giviing a few examples. In addition, he gives indication that some of the beliefs also stem from the Aztecs.

I'd give this paper a B- or C+. While the material is interesting, its just not the best Bourke is/was capable of. And overall the contents are perhaps too much like a list, and not enough like a coherent, point driven paper.

Pam T for http://pageinhistory.blogspot.com/ show less