Clue ROOTS 2016
Talk 2016 ROOT Challenge - (Read Our Own Tomes)
This group has been archived. Find out more.
Join LibraryThing to post.
1clue
ROOTS Read

1. Village School by Miss Read
2. Transatlantic by Colum McCann
3. A Walk in the Woods by Bill Bryson
4. Dissolution by C. J. Sansom
5. House Made of Dawn by N. Scott Momaday
6. My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante
7. Only In Naples by Katherine Wilson
8. A Memory of Violets by Helen Gaynor
9. The House of a Thousand Lanterns by Victoria Holt
10. The Tree by John Fowles
11. Braving It: A Father, A Daughter, And An Unforgettable Journey Into The Alaskan Wild
12. Midlife Irish: Discovering Family and Myself by Frank Gannon
13. The Peach Keeper by Sarah Addison Allen
14. Citizens Creek by Lalita Tademy
15. Tea in the Library by Annette Freeman
16. My House in Umbria by William Trevor
17. Lullabies for Little Criminals by Heather O'Neill
18. Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein
19. Late Nights On Air by Elizabeth Hay
20. Aunty Lee's Chilled Revenge by Ovidia Yu
21. Springtime in Britain by Edwin Way Teale
22. How The Light Gets In by Louise Penny
23. The Christie Curse by Victoria Abbott
24. Gillespie and I by Jane Harris
25. A Man Named Ove by Fredrik Backman
26. The Heroine's Bookshelf: Life Lessons, from Jane Austen to Laura Ingalls Wilder by Erin Blakemore
27. The Muralist by B. A. Shapiro
28. A Noble Radiance by Donna Leon
29. The Dead in Their Vaulted Arches by Alan Bradley
30. The Lost Garden by Helen Humphreys
31. Plot Boiler by Ali Brandon
32. The Girl Who Came Home by Hazel Gaynor
33. All Through The Night by Mary Higgins Clark
34. The Maiden of the Blue Willow and other Japanese Folktales by Heme Pande
35. Outlander by Diana Gabaldon

1. Village School by Miss Read
2. Transatlantic by Colum McCann
3. A Walk in the Woods by Bill Bryson
4. Dissolution by C. J. Sansom
5. House Made of Dawn by N. Scott Momaday
6. My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante
7. Only In Naples by Katherine Wilson
8. A Memory of Violets by Helen Gaynor
9. The House of a Thousand Lanterns by Victoria Holt
10. The Tree by John Fowles
11. Braving It: A Father, A Daughter, And An Unforgettable Journey Into The Alaskan Wild
12. Midlife Irish: Discovering Family and Myself by Frank Gannon
13. The Peach Keeper by Sarah Addison Allen
14. Citizens Creek by Lalita Tademy
15. Tea in the Library by Annette Freeman
16. My House in Umbria by William Trevor
17. Lullabies for Little Criminals by Heather O'Neill
18. Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein
19. Late Nights On Air by Elizabeth Hay
20. Aunty Lee's Chilled Revenge by Ovidia Yu
21. Springtime in Britain by Edwin Way Teale
22. How The Light Gets In by Louise Penny
23. The Christie Curse by Victoria Abbott
24. Gillespie and I by Jane Harris
25. A Man Named Ove by Fredrik Backman
26. The Heroine's Bookshelf: Life Lessons, from Jane Austen to Laura Ingalls Wilder by Erin Blakemore
27. The Muralist by B. A. Shapiro
28. A Noble Radiance by Donna Leon
29. The Dead in Their Vaulted Arches by Alan Bradley
30. The Lost Garden by Helen Humphreys
31. Plot Boiler by Ali Brandon
32. The Girl Who Came Home by Hazel Gaynor
33. All Through The Night by Mary Higgins Clark
34. The Maiden of the Blue Willow and other Japanese Folktales by Heme Pande
35. Outlander by Diana Gabaldon
2clue
Removed the trackers of books added...a used bookstore I've bought from for 20 years closed due to retirement. The owner contacted his regulars the last week the store was open and sold anything we wanted for $1. What could I do but help him get rid of his inventory?? Next year I'll try again to reduce books coming into the house but the future is so unpredictable!
3clue
This year I'm going to track how many books I buy just to see if it helps control the number of TBR at the end of the year. I have to laugh, every year I go to a book fair the 2nd weekend in January!
4cyderry
>3 clue: I've found that keeping track of what I buy actually does help me keep my purchases/acquisitions lower. Knowing that the number was getting too high, made me think again before I bought a book that was just going languish on the shelf.
5rabbitprincess
Welcome back and good luck! :)
7MissWatson
Welcome back and enjoy your reading!
9avanders
Happy Rooting!
As for me....... doesn't really help to track books coming in. They come in anyway. ;P
but I keep track anyway bc I'm just that kind of gal... ;)
As for me....... doesn't really help to track books coming in. They come in anyway. ;P
but I keep track anyway bc I'm just that kind of gal... ;)
10clue
>9 avanders: It may just be a ruse to play with numbers. LOL!
15clue

Thanks to everyone for the good wishes, my ROOTING has officially started. Last night we had to scuttle New Year's Eve plans even though we had reservations at a nice restaurant because the streets around it were closed due to flooding. I was very tired as were others in the group so rather than try to crowd in somewhere else we decided to postpone our fun night together until the restaurant is open again since we think the only problem is that we couldn't get to it and not that it has water inside. I was so happy relaxing in my reading chair and I chose a gentle read to kick off my challenges. I had read a couple of Miss Read's Fairacre books but never the first one so I began and have finished Village School, a lovely little book. It was the right book for the time and now I'm going to begin When Books Went to War along with Transatlantic by Colm McCann.
Happy ROOTNG!
17MissWatson
Happy New Year and congrats on digging in early!
18Tess_W
Due to surgery we did not go out (which we never do on New Year's Eve) or invite people over to celebrate with us. I also spent New Year's Eve with a book and some classical music and it was delightful!
19avanders
>18 Tess_W: sounds delightful! :)
20clue

Transatlantic by Colum McCann is written in 3 sections. Each revolves around the Irish and/or American experience in some way. There are historical characters intermingled with fictional characters that run through the maternal line of a family for 5 generations. The first of the women is a housemaid in the home where Frederic Douglas stays during his 1845 visit to Ireland. Inspired by Douglas she takes passage to America hoping for a better life. From there history is told through the present by the lives of each succeeding generation. I think McCann is one of the best writers of our generation and this will be one of my favorite books of the year.
21clue

Completed A Walk in the Woods by Bill Bryson and I'm glad I finally read it so I can see the movie! This is Bryson's account of his attempt to walk the 2100 mile Appalachian Trail with his childhood friend Stehen Katz. The pair "only" completed 875 miles over 2 summers though they made a sincere attempt. Some of the stories Bryson tells about the adventure are very funny but others, particularly those about the environmental changes to the woods, are serious and rather sad. It's been more than 15 years since their attempt and I can't help but think about how much more damage has been made since the book was written.
22Soupdragon
It's very brave of you to record your book buys on a ticker. I don't think I dare!
I was pleased to see you enjoyed Transatlantic so much. I have it on my TBR but a few people seemed to have been disappointed with it recently, which had dimmed my enthusiasm to make a start on it.
I was pleased to see you enjoyed Transatlantic so much. I have it on my TBR but a few people seemed to have been disappointed with it recently, which had dimmed my enthusiasm to make a start on it.
23connie53
>22 Soupdragon: I have the buying ticker too. just to scare me!
24Jackie_K
I did a ticker for my acquisitions last year, for the first time, and whilst it was a bit gulp-inducing I think that actively monitoring what was coming in as well as what was being read was a really good thing for me to do, and strengthened my resolve to not acquire so much this year.
25clue
After I decided to include the books bought on a ticker, I decided to have 2 tickers so I could see how many books I buy vs how many I'm given. I go to a couple of book fairs a year, one was in January, where I get books free. I don't usually have any choice in what I get, they are just handed out. That's why I show 6 free this one month. Some of those I don't think I'll read and when I decide for sure I'll remove them from the free ticker. I know a good portion of my TBRs were not bought by me.
26avanders
>21 clue: me too! I mean, I want to read it so I can see the movie ;) Sounds great.. I'll get to one of those Brysons on my shelves one of these days....
>22 Soupdragon: lol it can be rather shocking...
>25 clue: good plan!
>22 Soupdragon: lol it can be rather shocking...
>25 clue: good plan!
27clue

Dissolution by C. J. Sansom is a mystery set in 1537, a year after the death of Anne Boleyn. Under the orders of Thomas Cromwell a team of commissioners is investigating monasteries and preparing for their dissolution. Mathew Shardlake, a lawyer and Reformist, is sent to the monastery at Scarsea to investigate the murder of one of those commissioners. What he learns and all that he must question leads him down dangerous paths and ends in surprising discoveries not just within the monastery but also of his own beliefs. A fine historical mystery.
28Caramellunacy
>27 clue:, I really liked Dissolution (reminded me of a somewhat more accessible Name of the Rose). But what I liked best about the Shardlake mysteries is how each of them seem to be a slightly different approach to historical mysteries (this one is almost a 'locked room' style mystery, Dark Fire is more adventure/puzzle-thriller, Sovereign is quite political and Revelation is a historical twist on a serial killer novel).
29clue
>28 Caramellunacy: I'm looking forward to reading them all! I had actually read Dissolution in 2009. I decided I wanted to read more in the series but thought I needed to reread Dissolution first and I'm glad I did.
30Soupdragon
I've read Dissolution and Dark Fire and have most of the others on my shelves to read. I enjoyed the two I read but remember Dark Fire mostly as being long, which puts me off continuing a little. Not that I mind long books, just that noticing and remembering seems a bad sign!
31connie53
>30 Soupdragon: If you remember it as long it could have been 50 pages shorter! That's what I always think. To much wandering trough the woods or reminiscing about old things happened.
32Soupdragon
>31 connie53: You're probably right!
33Caramellunacy
>30 Soupdragon: That's interesting, I really enjoyed Dark Fire as being more "action"-y but thought the third (Sovereign) dragged a bit. But I suppose one's preference informs tolerance levels for that sort of thing!
34Soupdragon
>33 Caramellunacy: Actually, I remember Dark Fire as quite actiony too and I'm usually pretty tolerant of wanderings and meanderings anyway, so I'm not sure what it was. Maybe I was just impatient to start my next read!
35clue

House Made of Dawn by N. Scott Momaday received the Pulitzer Prize in 1969. It tells the story of a young Indian man beginning when he returns from WWII and follows his struggle adjusting to living in mainstream society. The book isn't written in linear format, there are flashbacks and flash-forwards along with Kiowa myth interspersed. House Made of Dawn has been credited with being the impetus to move Native American literature into the mainstream.
36avanders
Wow you're kicking ROOT butt! Congrats! :)
>27 clue: >28 Caramellunacy: et al. Feeling an addition to the wish-list.. is there a best place to start? Dissolution?
>27 clue: >28 Caramellunacy: et al. Feeling an addition to the wish-list.. is there a best place to start? Dissolution?
37Caramellunacy
>36 avanders:,
I think the solution to Dissolution (I did not see what I did there until now, but am letting it stand) turns up as a source of some angst in later books - so probably best to start there.
I think the solution to Dissolution (I did not see what I did there until now, but am letting it stand) turns up as a source of some angst in later books - so probably best to start there.
38clue
>36 avanders: I've only read the first one but I plan to read them in order.
Yep, I've read 5 ROOTS against a goal of 30 so that's pretty good. This month will be slower, I have 2 library books and then I'll get back to ROOTS, hope to get at least 2 more this month. I forgot that I had The Lake House by Kate Morton on reserve on the library's e-book system, it just became available a couple of days ago and I had placed a reserve request in mid November! No wonder I forgot.
Yep, I've read 5 ROOTS against a goal of 30 so that's pretty good. This month will be slower, I have 2 library books and then I'll get back to ROOTS, hope to get at least 2 more this month. I forgot that I had The Lake House by Kate Morton on reserve on the library's e-book system, it just became available a couple of days ago and I had placed a reserve request in mid November! No wonder I forgot.
41clue
My first ROOT for February...My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante. I have another about half read but now must switch to a library book for my book club selection for the month.
This isn't right, I finished a book on the 1st of Feb that I thought I finished in Jan so I have completed 2 this month. That makes me feel better! Tickers have been updated.
This isn't right, I finished a book on the 1st of Feb that I thought I finished in Jan so I have completed 2 this month. That makes me feel better! Tickers have been updated.
42clue

A memoir that begins when the author finishes college and goes to Italy to live for 6 months. An average read.
43Caramellunacy
>42 clue:, a shame you didn't much care for it. I have a bit of a fondness for ex-pats abroad/study abroad memoirs - being an expat myself, and I always love to see other cultures and people connecting with them.
44clue
>43 Caramellunacy: I usually like this sort of book too. My problem with this one is that the author featured her relationship with one family and didn't write much about Naples or any other people she met. The book covers one year and at the end she is in love with the son of the family and will eventually marry him . It just wasn't very engaging.
45clue

A light book about the flower girls of London who are poor, often orphaned and disabled in some way. Although it's a serious topic it lacks depth but is good for a break from more weighty reads.
46clue

The House of a Thousand Lanterns was published in 1974 by the very popular writer Victoria Holt. A gothic romance, the pace is rather slow compared to fiction written today but it was an enjoyable read. This is my last ROOT of the month which brings me to 9 complete against a goal of 30.
48clue

I have completed my first ROOT for April, The Tree by John Fowles, an argument by one of the best 20th century novelists on the connection between nature and creativity.
49avanders
>48 clue: well, that touchstone takes you to Return of the King ;P But sounds interesting!
50clue
>49 avanders: Thanks, I took them both out since it's pretty confusing.
I thought the essay was interesting, it's been a long time since I've read anything by him, and would never have guessed he was so interested in nature. I've added rereading The French Lieutenant's Wife to my to read list, I read it long years ago and want to see what I think of it now.
I thought the essay was interesting, it's been a long time since I've read anything by him, and would never have guessed he was so interested in nature. I've added rereading The French Lieutenant's Wife to my to read list, I read it long years ago and want to see what I think of it now.
51clue

I've read my second ROOT for the month, Braving It: A Father, A Daughter, And An Unforgettable Journey Into The Alaskan Wild. This was an ER and by my rules a ROOT.
A terrific book by a well known outdoors-man and nature writer, about his trip to far Northern Alaska with his 15 year old daughter. It was a working trip where they helped Campbell's cousin build a home in one of the most remote places in the world.
52clue

I completed my first ROOT for May, The Peach Keeper by Sarah Addison Phillips. Maybe not my favorite of hers, but it was still good. She writes about friendship, loyalty and love and uses just a sprinkle of magical realism that makes her books fun to read.
53clue
I have read two more this month:
Citizens Creek by Lalita Tademy a historical novel based on the life of a black man who was a slave of a Creek chief and who eventually became a chief in the tribe himself.
Tea in the Library by Annette Freeman, a memoir of sorts about Freeman's experience planning and opening a restaurant and bookstore that closed after 18 months in business.
Citizens Creek by Lalita Tademy a historical novel based on the life of a black man who was a slave of a Creek chief and who eventually became a chief in the tribe himself.
Tea in the Library by Annette Freeman, a memoir of sorts about Freeman's experience planning and opening a restaurant and bookstore that closed after 18 months in business.
54clue

The protagonist of My House in Umbria by William Trevor is Mrs. Delahunty. Mrs. Delahunty is English but owns a property in Umbria where she takes in lodgers when the hotels are full. While she is on a train returning from a trip to Milan there is an explosion attributed to terrorists though that is never proven. Several passengers are killed but Mrs. Delahunty receives injuries that aren't fatal. Two adults and a child from her car are also hospitalized. The three are a young German man, a retired English General, and a young American girl. The families and traveling companions of the three are all killed. Once they are released from the hospital all need a place to go and Mrs. Delahunty invites them to stay at her home until they are ready to travel. The girl is suffering from psychological rather than physical injuries and a search for a relative is launched because her parents and brother are among the dead.
From the beginning Mrs. Delahunty admits to a shadowy past: " It is not easy to introduce myself. Gloria Grey, Janine Ann Johns, Cora Lamore: there is a choice, and there have been other names as well". We learn she previously lived in Africa where she owned a bordello. Quinty, who runs her house in Umbria, came with her from there. Three other people, the child's estranged uncle, the Dr. that treats her and a maid who is also Quinty's love interest complete the cast of characters.
The book has many layers and the reader can think them over or take the book at it's most basic level. Over the months the characters reside in Mrs. Delahunty's house she gathers tidbits of their histories. Even then, all is not clearly uncovered and the reader is left to wonder.
55avanders
Congrats on passing the halfway point!
Looks like you're finding books that you're enjoying... so motivating when ROOTing! :)
Looks like you're finding books that you're enjoying... so motivating when ROOTing! :)
57connie53
Congrats on reaching and passing the halfway point, Luanne
>54 clue: Sounds very interesting but I can't find a translation. Pity. Or perhaps a blessing, dodging this BB. What I can't buy I can't read ;-))
>54 clue: Sounds very interesting but I can't find a translation. Pity. Or perhaps a blessing, dodging this BB. What I can't buy I can't read ;-))
58clue

Late Nights on Air by Elizabeth Hay takes place in 1975 in Northern Canada and revolves around people who work at a radio station with very few listeners. The characters are primarily station employees. They include the beautiful, seductive and talented Dido, shy Gwen who drove 3000 miles through remote Canada alone looking for a job, and Eleanor who has been in Yellowknife the longest and is realizing it's time to move on.
The employees think the first television station coming to Yellowknife will change their lives. Before that can happen, a canoe trip taken by four of the employees becomes a fateful turning point.
I was impatient with the book at first but stayed with it and I'm glad I did. The characters are quirky and the ending unexpected. I like those things.
3.5 stars
60clue

The first ROOT for August is How The Light Gets In by Louise Penny. This is the ninth in the Chief Inspector Gamache series and is one of my favorites. This series stays fresh and I always look forward to the next one.
61clue

The second ROOT for August is The Christie Curse by Victoria Abbott. This is the first in the Book Collector Mystery series.
64clue

Completed A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman this morning. As so many have said, it's a great book.
67clue
>65 Tess_W: I got a slow start but once I got into it I was hooked!
68clue

A Noble Radiance is the 7th title in the Commissario Guido Brunetti series by Donna Leon. The series is set in Venice where Leon, an American, has lived for 30 years. Like others in the series, corruption and aristocratic Venice play a large part in the plot.
69clue

The sixth in the Flavia de Luce series and one of my favorites. I love this character, an "almost twelve" chemistry enthusiast with plans to become a detective. Fun reading.
71MissWatson
Congratulations on finishing your challenge!
74clue
Thanks to all, I think I'll raise my goal for next year. As I wrote in the first post, a long running used bookstore closed due to retirement this year and the owner was kind to his regulars....and I brought more books into the house this year than I read! And then there's part 2 to the story. A couple reopened the store and tbeir college age son ran it all summer. Of course I had to help them get a good start! More books into the house!

This isn't a mystery as I expected, but a cozy Christmas story that revolves around a child that was left on a church doorstep one cold Christmas night. A chalice was stolen that same night so the question was, could the thief also have taken the baby?

This isn't a mystery as I expected, but a cozy Christmas story that revolves around a child that was left on a church doorstep one cold Christmas night. A chalice was stolen that same night so the question was, could the thief also have taken the baby?
75rabbitprincess
>74 clue: Great story! I am glad to hear the bookstore reopened and hope it does well. Also glad to hear you are there to help them out ;)
76avanders
>74 clue: lol well that's a great part 2! And I agree, of course you had to help them get started... ;)
oh! Good to know re that book! I also thought it was a mystery & have it shelved in my "mysteries" section :)
cozy Christmas story sounds lovely!
oh! Good to know re that book! I also thought it was a mystery & have it shelved in my "mysteries" section :)
cozy Christmas story sounds lovely!
79clue
, 
The last two for the year for me are: The Maiden of the Blue Willow and Other Japanese Folktales by Hema Pande and Outlander by Diana Gabaldon
It's been a good year, read some good books and finished at 35/30.
Thanks to everyone for good wishes and for being good reading friends! Hope to "see you" in 2017.







