SandDune reads in 2018: thread 2

This is a continuation of the topic SandDune reads in 2018: thread 1.

This topic was continued by SandDune reads in 2018: thread 3.

Talk75 Books Challenge for 2018

Join LibraryThing to post.

SandDune reads in 2018: thread 2

This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.

1SandDune
Edited: Apr 1, 2018, 11:50 am

Welcome to my second thread of 2018, and to my seventh year doing the 75 Book Challenge. I'm a 57 year old accountant and, after spending most of my career in the City of London, I'm now the Finance Manager of a local charity which provides support to children and adults with learning disabilities. I live about thirty miles north of London with my husband (aka Mr SandDune), who is Assistant Principal at a local secondary school, and our 18 year old son (aka J), who attends the same school, but is currently taking some time off for personal reasons. There's also our 6 year old Staffordshire Bull Terrier, Daisy: until very recently we also had a 14 year old cat Sweep but we have had to have her put to sleep after a long illness.

I'm originally from Wales rather than England, so I do have an interest in all things Welsh (although I can't speak the language - at least only a few words) and I tend to get huffy if people call me English rather than Welsh! I read mainly literary fiction, classics, science-fiction and fantasy, but I have been trying (and enjoying) some crime recently. I tend to avoid horror, chick-lit and thrillers. I belong to a RL book group which has been going since 2000, and I also try to keep up with some of the challenges going on on LT, with varying degrees of success.

All my family are avid readers, although Mr SandDune doesn't get time to read as much as he would like. J has inherited a love of reading science-fiction and fantasy from me and a love of reading history from Mr SandDune so our books are increasingly shared. I read hardbacks, paperbacks, on kindle and listen to audio books particularly when driving or walking the dog. Apart from reading I love travelling, eating out, and going to the theatre, and over the last few years I've been gettting more and more interested in politics and environmental issues. Last year I finished my degree in English Literature with the Open University and so I've been looking for something else to occupy my spare moments: at the moment I'm considering trying to improve my French.

I like to start each thread with a famous (or not so famous) painting, and I've decided that this year's theme is the sea. This one is so here we have 'Southwold' (1937) by Stanley Spencer (1891- 1959). Southwold is one of my favourite places, and this is really evocative of a breezy day on the beach.

2SandDune
Edited: Apr 1, 2018, 11:51 am

Favourite books of 2017:

Five star reads:
1984 George Orwell
Pride and Prejudice Jane Austen
Persuasion Jane Austen
The Outrun Amy Liptrot
Lincoln in the Bardo George Saunders
Just William Richmal Crompton

Four and a half stars:
Autumn Ali Smith
His Bloody Project Graeme MacRae Burnet
When Will There be Good News Kate Atkinson
Un Lun Dun China Mieville
Through the Language Glass Guy Deutscher
Lillian Boxfish Takes a Walk Kathleen Rooney

3SandDune
Edited: Jul 26, 2018, 1:47 pm

Books read in 2018:
1. The House at the Edge of the World Julia Rochester ***1/2
2. A High Wind in Jamaica Richard Hughes ****1/2
3. The Little Red Chairs Edna O’Brien ****
4. The New York Trilogy Paul Auster ****1/2
5. The Invisible Man H.G.Wells ***
6. God Stalk P.C. Hodgell***1/2
7. The Year of Magical Thinking Joan Didion ***
8. Eleanor Oliphant is Completely fine Gail Honeyman****1/2
9. The 4 pillar plan Rangan Chatterjee ****
10. The Bookshop Penelope Fitzgerald ***1/2
11. Elmet Fiona Mozley ****
12. A Tale of Two Cities Charles Dickens ****1/2
13. A Murder in Time Julie McElwain ***
14. Tiassa Steven Brust ***1/2
15. Plainsong Kent Haruf ****1/2
16. Three things about Elsie Joanna Cannon ****
17. History of Wolves Emily Fridlund***1/2
18. An Accident of Stars Foz Meadows ***
19. The Siege Helen Dunmore ****1/2
20. The Betrayal Helen Dunmore ****
21. Educated: A Memoir Tara Westover *****
22. Bookworm: A Memoir of Childhood Reading Lucy Mangan ***1/2
23. Little Fuzzy H.Beam Piper**1/2
24. City of Bohane Kevin Barry*****
25. Earthfasts William Mayne ****
26. Cradlefasts William Mayne ***1/2
27. Candlefasts William Mayne ***1/2
28. Oryx and Crake Margaret Atwood ***
29. The Field of the Cloth of Gold Magnus Mills ***1/2
30. The Surgeon of Crowthorne Simon Winchester***
31. New Worlds, Year One: A Writer’s Guide to the Art of Worldbuilding Marie Brennan ***1/2
32. The Shape of Water Andrea Camilleri ***1/2
33. The World Without Us Mireille Juchau ***1/2
34. The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle Stuart Turton**1/2
35. The House of Names Colm Toibin ***1/2
36. The Dead House Harry Bingham****
37. The Deepest Grave Harry Bingham ****
38. The Mermaid and Mrs Hancock Imogen Hermes Gowar ***1/2
39. A Civil Contract Georgette Heyer ****
40. The Quiet Gentleman Georgette Heyer***1/2
41. Frederica Georgette Heyer*****
42. Lock In John Scalzi ****
43. A Skinful of Shadows Frances Hardinge ****1/2
44. The White Woman on the Green Bicycle Monique Roffey ***1/2
45. City of Miracles Robert Jackson Bennett ****

4SandDune
Edited: Apr 1, 2018, 12:01 pm

Reading plans for 2018:

I've decided to be more flexible about what I'm reading: I was trying to fit my reading into the various challenges and that wasn't really working for me at the moment. So the one thing I'm looking at completing are the books for my monthly RL book club:

January: no meeting
February: The New York Trilogy Paul Auster
March: Plainsong Kent Haruf
April: The Betrayal Helen Dunmore
May: Surgeon of Crowthorne Simon Winchester
June:
July:
August:
September:
October:
November:
December:

5SandDune
Edited: Apr 3, 2018, 4:53 pm

Childhood Reading:

I'm just starting to read Lucy Mangan's Bookworm: A Memoir of Childhood Reading. I was listening to something about it on a books podcast and the interviewer was suggesting that it was very unusual to remember large number of books that you read in childhood. I can certainly remember a great many books that I read (particularly if I owned a copy myself rather than reading a library book) and I would have thought many LTers were the same. So I thought I might reconstruct a list of what I did read in childhood. This will be a work in progress, and may take some time.

A Bear Called Paddington, More About Paddington, Paddington Helps Out, Paddington Abroad, Paddington at Large - Michael Bond

Winnie-the-Pooh, A House at Pooh Corner - A.A. Milne
The Wind in the Willows - Kenneth Grahame

The Tale of Peter Rabbit, The Tale of the Flopsy Bunnies, The Tale of Timmy Tiptoes, The Tale of Mrs Tiggy-winkle - Beatrix Potter

Best Word Book Ever Richard Scarry

Little Grey Rabbit's Christmas, The Country Child Alison Uttley

Orlando the Marmalade Cat Buys a Farm, Orlando the Marmalade Cat Buys a Cottage - Kathleen Hale

The Borrowers, The Borrowers Afield, The Borrowers Afloat, The Borrowers Aloft - Mary Norton

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland Alice through the Looking Glass Lewis Caroll

The Wind on the Moon - Erik Linklater

Toby the Tram Engine, Stepney the Bluebell Engine -W. Awdrey

Welsh Legends and Folk Tales Gwyn Jones
Tales of the Greek Heroes, Tales of Ancient Egypt - Roger Lancelyn Green
Grimm’s Fairy Tales Jacob Grimm Wilhelm Grimm
Anderson’s Fairy Tales Hans Christian Andersen
Tales from Shakespeare Charles Lamb

Heidi, Heidi grows up, Heidi's Children - Joanna Spyri / Charles Tritton

A Child's Garden of Verses - Robert Louis Stevenson
A Puffin Book of Verse - Eleanor Graham

One Hundred and one Dalmations - Dodie Smith

Jennings Goes to School, Jennings Follows A Clue, Jennings Little Hut, Jennings and Darbishire, Jennings' Diary - Anthony Buckeridge

Just William - Richmal Crompton

Little Women - Louisa May Alcott
What Katy Did, What Katy Did at School - Susan Coolidge
Pollyanna - Eleanor H. Porter
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer - Mark Twain

Shadow the Sheepdog, Five on a Treasure Island, The Rat-A-Tat Mystery, The Secret Island, The Second Form at Malory Towers, Last Term at Malory Towers - Enid Blyton

Jean Tours a Hospital - Doreen Swinburne
Jean Becomes a Nurse - Yvonne Trewin

Little O - Edith Unnerstad
Pippi Longstocking - Astrid Lindgren

The Children of the New Forest - Captain Frederick Marryat
Black Beauty - Anna Sewell
Moonfleet - J. Meade Faulkner
The Secret Garden Frances Hodgson Burnett

The Magician's Nephew, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, The Horse and his Boy, Prince Caspian, The Voyage of the Dawn Reader, The Silver Chair, The Last Battle - C. S. Lewis

The Weirdstone of Brisingamen, Elidor, The Owl Service - Alan Garner

The Witch's Daughter, Carrie's War - Nina Bawden
The Whispering Mountain - Joan Aiken
Earthfasts - William Mayne
The Devil in the Fog - Leon Garfield
Stig of the Dump - Clive King
Tom's Midnight Garden Phillipa Pearce

The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien

The Midnight Folk, The Box of Delights - John Masefield

The Sword in the Stone - T. H. White

Swallows and Amazons, We Didn't Mean to Go to Sea - Arthur Ransome

Tarka the Otter - Henry Williamson
Watership Down - Richard Adams

Flambards - K.M. Peyton

A Wizard of Earthsea, The Tombs of Atuan, The Farthest Shore - Ursula K. Le Guin

The Diary of A Young Girl Anne Frank

If Only they should Talk, It Shouldn't Happen to a Vet, Let Sleeping Vets Lie, Vet in Harness - James Herriot

6Caroline_McElwee
Apr 1, 2018, 12:34 pm

I've not seen that Stanley Spenser painting Rhian. I love it. I go to Cookham most years for a weekend.

>5 SandDune: this has not long landed on the mat. I'll probably pick it up later in the week. I do remember quite a few of the books I read as a child, though maybe not too many of the earliest. I look forward to seeing your list.

7SandDune
Apr 1, 2018, 1:02 pm

We are currently in Pembrokeshire for a week, so are having a much needed rest. The weather is expected to be fairly wet unfortunately, although today was dry until about 3.30pm, so I will probably get some reading done! J has stayed at home, although he may join us later in the week. He had an interview on Saturday, and has another one tomorrow and then one on Tuesday. He's very keen to get a job now.

We called into my mother's on the way here and stayed nearby Friday night, so we could see her Friday afternoon and Saturday morning. She has hurt her back, nothing major, just muscular problems it seems, and her GP has been to see her twice since she did it about 10 days ago. But she was already getting frailer with her walking and this is making the problem much worse. My sister was there the previous weekend and has bought her a walker, which was probably on the cards anyway, but she is not able to get out and about as she usually does, and she is needing to use it indoors as well. At the moment, a neighbour is popping in daily to see if she needs anything from the shops but she will need a bit more help going forward. She has got phone numbers of various people from social services and is going to try and get someone to come in daily, even if only for a half an hour or so. We will be calling in again next Saturday and if she hasn't managed to sort anything out by then I'll try and persuade her to let me sort something. She can get herself dressed and make cups of tea and prepare herself something simple to eat, and she's got plenty of food in, but she's certainly not going to be able to do any washing or housework.

When she moved into her current flat, which is in a retirement complex, my sister tried to persuade her to have a wet room type bathroom with shower, instead of a traditional bath, but she refused point blank. And that's how she injured her back apparently, twisting to get out of the bath.

8charl08
Edited: Apr 1, 2018, 4:03 pm

>5 SandDune: Interesting list!

Mangan does say in her acknowledgements that she had (adult) conversations with her friends about childhood books, reminding her of books she had enjoyed but forgotten.

I kept a notebook for about a year when I was 11 listing everything. But no idea where that is now.

The Beatrix Potter ones - I thought I had read most of them as a kid, but went to read one to a friend's kids and was completely shocked by how violent it was - The tale of two bad mice.

Look forward to hearing what you make of the book.

9thornton37814
Apr 1, 2018, 4:54 pm

Sorry to read about your mother's back injury. I'm glad my father realized the need for something he could step in and out of years ago. When he moved to my brother's, they upgraded their master bath so it has a walk-in shower with a seat and rail to help him get up. I was thankful for that.

10Familyhistorian
Apr 2, 2018, 12:40 am

Happy new thread, Rhian. I just finished your last thread and was sorry to hear about Sweep. I was hoping that things were looking up on your new thread. Sorry to hear about your Mum's back injury. Have a relaxing time on your holiday and concentrate on the positives coming from J finding his path.

11ChelleBearss
Apr 2, 2018, 7:50 am

Sorry to hear your mother is not doing well. Is there an option to change room types and move into a shower type room instead?

12souloftherose
Apr 2, 2018, 8:55 am

Happy new thread Rhian!

>5 SandDune: I have the Lucy Mangan book on my wishlist - I think someone in the Virago group recommended it.

'the interviewer was suggesting that it was very unusual to remember large number of books that you read in childhood' Huh? I'd be surprised if that's true for most people on LT... A lot of the books on your list would be on my list too.

>7 SandDune: Sorry to hear about your Mum's back problems. I hope she can get the help she needs for daily care (and ask for the help she needs).

From your last thread also adding my condolences re Sweep :-( Has Daisy had her root canal filling now?

13SandDune
Apr 2, 2018, 9:01 am

>6 Caroline_McElwee: I had quite a happy couple of hours yesterday starting my list, although it’s nowhere near complete. I’m suprised at how visual my memory is. There’ve been a few books that I haven’t been sure of, but once I’ve managed to google a picture of the book cover that my copy had, there’s instant recognition. And books that I’d inherited from my sister (mainly plain looking hardbacks which had either never had a dust jacket or had lost it long ago) are much more difficult to remember than my own books, which were mainly more colourful paperbacks. Books I’d got from the library are also pretty much a blank - my own books I read time after time, even ones I didn’t like very much, so they managed to seat themselves into my memory pretty firmly.

>8 charl08: There’s a lot more to be added on! I haven’t got to most of favourite books yet!

We studied some Beatrix Potter stories when I was doing a module on Children’s Literature a few years ago, and they’re not anything like as twee as you might think. Even Peter Rabbit’s father is put into a pie, after all!

14karenmarie
Apr 2, 2018, 9:02 am

Hi Rhian!

I hope you're having a good holiday. Good luck to J with the job interviews. I'm glad to hear that he's keen to get a job, too.

I'll echo what Chelle asks - is there an option to change rooms for your mother?

15Crazymamie
Apr 2, 2018, 9:14 am

Happy new one, Rhian. Like Meg, I just finished catching up with the previous thread, and I am so very sorry to learn about Sweep. I was touched that the vet was able to come to you to spare Sweep the car ride - so thoughtful.

Hoping that your mother's back mends quickly.

16SandDune
Apr 2, 2018, 9:21 am

>9 thornton37814: >10 Familyhistorian: >11 ChelleBearss: >12 souloftherose: Thanks for all the good wishes for my Mum. My concern is that if she is confined to the house for any length of time it will become permanent. She is 96 so if she gets accustomed to not moving about very much it will become virtually impossible to start again. Luckily she has some supportive neighbours and two nieces living nearby who will help out if necessary - although they must be at least 80 themselves! Her younger sister has gone into a home in the last few weeks, as she has dementia, and I think that is causing some problems for my Mum’s state of mind. Over the last few years she has seen herself as providing support for her sister and being the one to encourage her to go out and now that support is no longer needed. And my aunt will be living too far away for her to visit at all regularly. I envisage that we’ll have to spend much more time in providing support, which will be difficult with J still needing support as well.

>11 ChelleBearss: Because my Mum isn’t in a care home, more a retirement complex, she actually owns her own property, so there isn’t the option to switch. I suppose she could get the bathroom redesigned, but the likelihood of her agreeing to that is very remote.

>12 souloftherose: It shouldn’t be too difficult to get someone in to provide the sort of help she needs at the moment: help with housework and errands - someone to change her library books and do a bit of shopping. My sister ordered a whole freezerful of ‘Cook’ meals for one when she was there the weekend before (and apparently the delivery man put them in the freezer for her, which was nice of him) so she has plenty of food in currently.

>12 souloftherose: Daisy is having her root canal done on Monday next week. At the moment she is on holiday with us happily chasing sticks in the sea.

17drneutron
Apr 2, 2018, 9:54 am

Happy new thread!

18FAMeulstee
Apr 2, 2018, 10:50 am

Happy new thread, Rhian!

>5 SandDune: I recognise many titltes on that list, Pippi Longstocking was one of my childhood hero's :-)

19BLBera
Apr 2, 2018, 10:59 am

Enjoy your holiday, Rhian. Good luck to J with his job hunt.

Sorry to hear about your mother, who sounds in remarkable shape for 96. Still, I imagine it will take longer for her to heal.

20SandDune
Apr 2, 2018, 2:17 pm

>6 Caroline_McElwee: I forgot to say - we used to go to Cookham for a day trip sometimes when we lived that side of London. Haven’t been there for ages though.

>15 Crazymamie: There was an extra charge for them to come to the house but I thought it was quite reasonable, and less than I was expecting. They were very nice and respectful, I thought. They sent a hand written card as well which was nice of them.

>17 drneutron: Hi Jim!

>18 FAMeulstee: Anita!

>19 BLBera: I tend to forget sometimes just how old my mother is. I had a succession of aunts who all lived into their late 90’s so it sort of seems normal, which in reality it shouldn’t... I had two aunts in particular who made it to 98 and were as bright as a button until pretty much the end of their lives. My Aunty Iris went into a home a couple of months before her death but before that she was out and about every day even though she lived alone and couldn’t walk anywhere without her Zimmer frame. She just knew all the taxi drivers by name. My Aunty Megan had lived in sheltered accommodation for some time, but with no care involved, and she was always very lively as well. (She turned down a proposal of marriage when she was around 80 as she’d been married twice and she wasn’t doing that again, thank you very much!)

My mother though, would absolutely detest it in any sort of residential home, so we need to try and keep her out of one as long as possible. And for that reason it wouldn’t work to move her closer to us as she would have to go somewhere with more care provided if she moved now.

21SandDune
Edited: Apr 2, 2018, 4:08 pm

Here’s a rather misty (and wet) St David’s Cathedral, where we went this afternoon. St David’s is the smallest city in the U.K., with a population of just under 2,000. In medieval times it was a big place of pilgrimage with two trips to St David’s equalling one to Rome, while three trips equalled one to Jerusalem. But it didn’t really recover from the Reformation. The Cathedral is also unusual in being in a hollow. I was always led to believe that it was because St David’s original monastery (supposed to have been built on the same location) had to be out of sight of passing Viking marauders.



This is the ford through the stream that runs between the Cathedral and the Bishop’s Palace. I think the stream had ideas above its station today, and we definitely weren’t driving through it!


22thornton37814
Apr 2, 2018, 4:13 pm

>21 SandDune: Rather lovely.

23PaulCranswick
Apr 2, 2018, 9:17 pm

Happy new thread, Rhian.

>22 thornton37814: It is, isn't it?

24Caroline_McElwee
Apr 2, 2018, 9:35 pm

>20 SandDune: my brother-in-law is a John Lewis Retiree, and they have an estate there that staff use. He is involved with their am-dram show there every year, so we pitch up to support him and enjoy some time in Wind in the Willows land, and always visit the Spencer gallery for its exhibitions.

Sorry to hear about your mum.

25SandDune
Edited: Apr 19, 2018, 12:42 pm

19. The Siege Helen Dunmore ****1/2



We've had several Helen Dunmore's on the shelf for some time, mainly belonging to Mr SandDune, who has always rated her very highly. After reading The Siege it's a mystery to me why I've never read any of them before, as she is a magnificent writer.

Anna is the daughter of an out of favour writer in the Leningrad of the Second World War. Her father, once highly regarded, is now somewhat suspect, and none of his writing has been published for years: he scrapes a living with occasional translation work, though even that has become more and more intermittent. Anna herself has had to abandon her study of art to become a nursery assistant, a job that she can combine with the care of her much younger brother Kolya, their mother having died shortly after his birth. Despite their fall from favour the family has managed to retain their small country dacha, where Anna can grow the stores that will keep the family going through the winter. For even as a city at peace, there are constant food shortages in Leningrad, and keeping a family fed requires constant queuing: vegetables stored for the winter can make all the difference.

But with the breakdown of the Nazi-Soviet, Leningrad rapidly finds itself surrounded. After the bombing of the city's food reserves, the citizens of Leningrad are left with virtually nothing to fall back on. As the winter deepens its grip on the city, rations are cut to two slices of adulterated bread each day ...

This is a beautifully written book, as befits an author who is also a poet. The depiction of food is almost sensuous, right from the beginning when Anna is contemplating her growing vegetables:

'Anna pictured the seeds beginning to stir. Plump nubs of green feeling their way up through the earth, unfolding, fattening, changing hydrogen and oxygen and all the rest of it into solid, succulent food.'


I loved Helen Dunmore's ability to create memorable scenes which brought home the horror of the situation in which Leningraders find themselves.

'The streets are almost empty. She passes the hump of a body frozen into a doorway, covered with drifted snow. It looks like a bag of rubbish, but Anna knows it's a body because she saw it before the snow hid it. It's an old woman. Maybe she stopped to rest on the way back from fetching her ration. Anna doesn't like going past the park anymore. There are people sitting on benches, swathed in snow, planted like bulbs to wait for spring. They stay there day after day. No one comes to take them away.'


Highly recommended!

26Crazymamie
Apr 4, 2018, 4:49 pm

>25 SandDune: That is a very well written review, Rhian. I'll add my thumb if you posted that. I have it in the stacks and your review is making me want to get to it.

27SandDune
Apr 4, 2018, 5:45 pm

Found a very dog-friendly pub this lunchtime. Dog beds provided as well as dog treats and bowls of water. Apparently there was usually doggy ice cream as well, but they had run out...



Human stuff was pretty good too!

28jnwelch
Apr 4, 2018, 6:08 pm

Happy New Thread, Rhian.

I really like those photos of St. David's and the stream. Looks like the kind of place we'd enjoy.

We've yet to get to any part of Wales. I hope to change that in the next few years.

I liked The Siege a lot, too. That was a vivid reading experience.

29lauralkeet
Apr 5, 2018, 7:34 am

I loved The Siege, it was so gripping. It was my first Helen Dunmore, and I am reminded that I read it on the strength of @rebeccanyc's recommendation. She was such an influence here on LT.

I love the dog-friendly pub!!

30rosalita
Apr 5, 2018, 10:07 am

Oh, The Siege sounds amazing, Rhian. Off I go to the library requests list ...

31SandDune
Edited: Apr 5, 2018, 4:00 pm

J made it down to Pembrokeshire yesterday after all. The arrangement was that we would pick him up from Haverfordwest Station at 4.05pm. We arrived at the station a few minutes late and the train from Swansea that he was on had been and gone, but no J, and Haverfordwest station isn’t the sort of place where you can exactly miss someone. The next train wasn’t for two hours and when we tried to call J he had, as usual, got his phone switched off. We were just debating whether we should come back in two hours when we did get a phone call from J, who apparently was in Milford Haven. Apparently, he ‘hadn’t been concentrating’ when the train went through Haverfordwest and had ended up at the end of the line! Luckily, the end of the line was only fifteen minutes away.

We’ve had a lovely walk today, and the sun was out all day! We walked along the cliff tops to one beautiful beach, and then over another headland to another beautiful beach, and back inland to where we started from via a series of lakes (Stackpole Quay to Barafundle Bay and then Broad Haven beach and back via Bosherton Lily Ponds, if anyone knows the area.) Daisy was in her element. The second beach had a large stream/ small river which she was in and out of. She found a very high sandbank next to the river which she could slide down into a deep stretch where the current was running quite quickly, get swept downstream for twenty feet or so until it got shallow again and she could climb out. She did that over and over again: it was clearly great fun.

She had less fun when we were walking back via the ponds, as she managed to fall off a narrow pedestrian bridge when we walking across it. None of us saw her do it, so we assume she must have slipped, as she’s always very careful not to go into water she can’t get out of. We managed to encourage her to swim to shore, which was clearly quite a long swim for her, but she made it OK. Otherwise, Mr SandDune would have had to be going in to rescue her ...

32lauralkeet
Apr 5, 2018, 5:34 pm

Such holiday adventures! I'm glad J didn't end up to far afield. Daisy seems to be having fun although that slip into the pond must have been a bit scary for all involved.

33CDVicarage
Apr 5, 2018, 5:51 pm

>31 SandDune: The Chalet School had a trip to Bosherton Lily Ponds and one girl fell in! She was rescued by a passing handsome doctor and his dog, which led to a romance for one of the accompanying teachers. Mr SandDune is already committed so I'm glad he didn't have to make a rescue or who knows what it might have led to!

34SandDune
Edited: Apr 9, 2018, 3:32 pm

>32 lauralkeet: Here are the Bosherton Lily Ponds, although a lot less greenery (and a lot less sun) this time of year. Daisy fell off the bridge somewhere in the middle - so a long swim for a little staffie. She is pretty good at swimming, but it does require a lot of effort, so she can’t keep it up for too long.



>33 CDVicarage: They were pretty deep - it would be possible for someone to drown. The only way to have got her out without her swimming would have been for someone to climb down into the water. It would have been possible for someone to have got a foothold on the bridge supports and heaved her up, but not without getting soaked to the skin, so we were very glad she made it in her own.

35SandDune
Apr 9, 2018, 3:38 pm

We are back from holiday now, and called back in to see my mother on the way home. There was some definite improvement from last week. She is still using the walker but is clearly getting up from her chair a lot more easily and quickly. Rather than just sitting down as she had done the week before she was up and down to supervise the chores that we were doing, and making sure that we were putting all her recycling in the right colour recycling bag. She had arranged for a cleaner to come in once a week starting this week, and she was amenable to getting some more support a couple of times a week going forward.

My sister spoke to her yesterday and apparently she is now thinking of going out for twenty minutes to sit on the Prom, if the weather improves, so that’s another step in the right direction as well.

36SandDune
Edited: Apr 19, 2018, 12:41 pm

20.The Betrayal Helen Dunmore ***1/2



The sequel to The Siege. It's ten years since the events of the earlier book: Andrei and Anna are now married, and Andrei is a qualified paediatrician. One day a child is brought into the hospital with a suspicious growth on his leg, and Andrei's colleague is very anxious that Andrei should take charge of the case. It soon becomes apparent why: the boy is the son of a notorious senior official in the Secret Service, and with the outlook for the child poor, no one wants to become involved in a case which is likely to bring down the anger of such a dangerous man ...

I didn't like this one as much as The Siege. While it's a sequel, I think it's meant to be read as a stand-alone novel as well, and rather too much time was spent on going over the events of the previous novel. What I was interested in was the effect of living in a totalitarian regime, where a wrong comment at work or an dispute with a neighbour can lead to disaster. The Siege had been so evocative in creating a picture of Leningrad under siege, that I had expected The Betrayal to create a similar picture of the last year's of Stalin's regime. It achieves this to a certain extent but nowhere near as successfully. Additionally, whereas in The Siege the characters were very nuanced, the characters in The Betrayal are rather more one dimensional.

Overall, it's still a good read, but it doesn't compare to The Siege which is exceptional.

37lauralkeet
Apr 9, 2018, 6:27 pm

>36 SandDune: I completely agree with your last sentence.

I'm glad your mum is showing improvement.

38souloftherose
Apr 10, 2018, 7:16 am

>25 SandDune: I've had that one in the TBR pile for ages - so glad to see such a positive review and hopefully that will help me pick it up and read it!

>35 SandDune: Glad to hear your Mum's doing better.

39SandDune
Apr 10, 2018, 1:57 pm

>37 lauralkeet: >38 souloftherose: Interestingly, Mr SandDune read The Betrayal first (it's our next book club book) and then read The Siege. He found the explanations useful for the back story, whereas I felt that she should have written a completely separate book.

>37 lauralkeet: >38 souloftherose: I was very pleased to see her improvement. I was worried about whether she was going to go downhill after we saw her last week.

40SandDune
Apr 10, 2018, 2:02 pm

Daisy went into have her root canal filling for her canine tooth yesterday. She was a little quiet when she got home but she's fine now. She was very reluctant to have her stretchy bandage taken off her foot though. Every time we tried she just tucked her foot under the rest of her and refused to budge. We eventually got it off this evening.

41vancouverdeb
Apr 10, 2018, 8:35 pm

Sorry to hear about your mum, Rhian . One of my grandma's just would not consider any sort of residential care , or sheltered accommodation, despite the fact that she had a ileostomy at the age of 89 or 90 , and she returned to her seniors apartment that offered no more than fellow pensioners for help, and they did offer a couple of group meals per week, but my grandma was not the sort to attend a group meal. She lived until the age of 96 and remained on her own.

I really enjoyed both The Seige and The Betrayal.

So interesting about your cousin being a Karen from Thailand. I had not even heard of the Karen's until I read Miss Burma. You might enjoy the read.

I'm glad to read that your mum is improving.

42rosalita
Apr 11, 2018, 10:11 am

>40 SandDune: Well done, Daisy! Glad she came through the root canal with no hiccups. I wonder why she wanted to keep her bandage? Dogs can be mysteriously silly sometimes.

43SandDune
Apr 12, 2018, 2:53 pm

>41 vancouverdeb: My mother would detest any form of residential care - i really think it would be the end if she was forced into it.

>41 vancouverdeb: I believe that the Karen are related vaguely to Tibetans and they live across the border of Thailand and Myanmar. My niece's husband is from quite a remote village in northern Thailand. My great nephew and niece are growing up trilingual: English, Thai, and the Karen language that their grandparents speak.

>42 rosalita: I think Daisy was just very suspicious of anybody wanting to mess around with her further!

44SandDune
Apr 13, 2018, 12:11 pm

Anybody read Educated: a memoir? This is such a roller-coaster of a book. I don’t usually swear, but with this book I lurch between wanting to scream at the parents “What the f*** did you think you where doing! Are you completely out of your minds” and coming to the conclusion that it’s just too awful and alien to actually be true. I am listening to it on audio, and am truly shocked about every 10 minutes.

45SandDune
Apr 13, 2018, 12:24 pm

I’ve been contemplating my childhood reading list. (>5 SandDune: above). I’ve noticed that virtually no books that I remember reading as a child could in any way be said to be relevant to my life growing up in 1960s & 1970s South Wales. Not a single one, really. I suppose I may have read some books set in the contemporary period that didn’t involve magic, time travel or talking animals, but if I did I certainly can’t remember them.

Another question, Earthfasts by William Mayne is one which I remembered well, and enjoyed, and I discovered when compiling my list that it was part of a trilogy. I would like to read the other two. My moral question for the day is this: in 2004 William Mayne was convicted of child abuse and imprisoned for two years. He is now dead. Am I justified in reading the books? If he was alive I would not read them, as the author would then benefit from my reading them. But he is not alive and will clearly not benefit in the slightest. What do people think about this one?

46lauralkeet
Apr 13, 2018, 9:54 pm

>44 SandDune: I haven't read it yet, but it's certainly getting a lot of media attention. I'm appalled that someone would raise children under those circumstances, so appalled that I admit to some skepticism about the memoir itself. Does it strike you as genuine?

47ronincats
Apr 13, 2018, 10:50 pm

>45 SandDune: I haven't heard of William Mayne's books, but they sound like classic British children's fantasy. I wouldn't think that the personal crimes of the author should prevent your reading them, especially since it is quite likely the crimes occurred long after the books were written and indeed, he will not benefit in any way.

48CDVicarage
Edited: Apr 14, 2018, 2:28 pm

>45 SandDune: I, too, have some William Mayne to read and have wondered whether I should. I have decided that I will but not after any reasoned thought. I realise that I am inconsistent about the links I make between author or artist and their work Some individuals are so revolting (to me) that I will not touch their work with a barge pole and some that I know led/lead dreadful lives I can totally separate life from work and I have no idea how I make the decision.

49BLBera
Apr 14, 2018, 12:03 pm

Hi Rhian. >21 SandDune: Lovely photos.

I loved The Siege as well and should read The Betrayal, but maybe to refresh my memory, I should reread The Siege first?

I've heard about Educated and have been debating whether I want to pick it up... Maybe not, or at a time I am feeling very mellow.

50SandDune
Edited: Apr 16, 2018, 4:45 pm

>46 lauralkeet: >49 BLBera: Finished Educated. A fairly traumatic read, to say the least. In the end, my view is that it probably is true, at least in its essentials. Several other readers have said that the last portion of the book lost energy - personally I breathed a sigh of relief when she arrived in Cambridge to study a PhD. I didn’t think I could take much more trauma. We were in Cambridge in Saturday to buy J shoes, and I viewed it in a completely new light as a place of exceptional peace and security! I have to say, if i’d been Tara Westover I’d never have gone within 2,000 miles of Idaho ever again if I could possibly have helped it.

51lauralkeet
Apr 16, 2018, 7:08 am

>50 SandDune: Very interesting, Rhian, especially your reaction to the last section of the book. It's good to have your endorsement for it, too. I have it on a sort of mental "read this someday" list.

52Caroline_McElwee
Apr 16, 2018, 7:56 am

>50 SandDune: hmm, your link takes us to a Terry Pratchet book Rhian.

53BLBera
Apr 16, 2018, 3:38 pm

I do want to read Educated, Rhian. Your comments are enlightening. I know my library has a copy. I'll see how long the reserve list is.

54SandDune
Apr 17, 2018, 4:22 pm

>49 BLBera: I wouldn't bother rereading The Siege before The Betrayal unless you have a burning desire to. Mr SandDune read them the wrong way around and didn't have any trouble at all

>49 BLBera: >51 lauralkeet: >52 Caroline_McElwee: >53 BLBera: Well I will get around to writing a proper review in due course but at the moment all I can say I see that Educated: A Memoir is highly recommended.

>47 ronincats: >48 CDVicarage: >49 BLBera: I've decided to get second hand copies of the Earthfasts trilogy from Abe books. I saw this old article from the Guardian on the subject which is relevant:

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2004/may/27/childprotection.uk

One of the points she makes which I rather disagreed with though was this: 'Mayne's stories seem to be blameless even if one of their particular attractions for a child - the regular escapes from the harsh, adult-run world, often into a different place altogether - cannot but echo, for an adult reader, Mayne's real efforts to establish private complicities and relations with children behind the backs of their families' For me, it doesn't echo that at all: it's a normal device used by a whole sub-genre of children's books. The children have to be removed from their parents so that the story can start.

55SandDune
Edited: Apr 17, 2018, 4:35 pm

I've decided to make more use of my library, as it's clear that we can't go on buying new books exponentially! And the library has a new App for audio books and ebooks which seems a lot easier to use than the previous one. Anyway, I was looking at the audiobooks and thinking that they didn't have very many and picked up City of Bohane to try. (I later realised that it was only showing me books that were not currently checked out so there were a lot more than I had thought at first.) I managed 10 minutes of City of Bohane before deciding it was far too difficult to listen to as an audiobook: very strong Irish accent & dialect, including quite a few expressions which I assume have been invented for the purpose of the book. But I couldn't change to anything else whilst driving to work, and by the time I had got there I'd started to get my ear in. Now I'm loving it and could listen to the language all day! Anyone else read it? It's a sort of futuristic low-tech Irish gang war - with some very fancy clothes thrown in.

56quondame
Apr 17, 2018, 4:40 pm

>55 SandDune: City of Bohane does sound interesting - I'd have to read rather than listen, but like the idea of fancy clothes. So many SF stories ignore or get clothing wrong.

57katiekrug
Apr 17, 2018, 4:46 pm

>55 SandDune: - I haven't read it, Rhian, but I own a paperback copy of it....

58SandDune
Edited: Apr 19, 2018, 12:40 pm

21. Educated: A Memoir Tara Westover*****



Tara Westover was born to a strict Mormon family in Idaho, was home-schooled but ended up studying at Cambridge and Harvard. That's what I knew about Educated: A Memoir before I started: I was imagining an interesting story about different cultural mores. What I found was a roller-coaster of a read that was traumatic enough in the reading: God only knows what it would be like to live it. For Tara's family is not just strict, it is dominated by a father who is clearly mentally ill, who has created a world view that his family must believe in that is the product of his own paranoia. Time after time I was so shocked by this book, only to be shocked again by something even worse ten minutes later.

Time after time, illnesses and injuries are dealt with herbs and essential oils only. Third degree burns over face and hands? A few drops of rescue remedy will sort it out. Falling headfirst onto concrete from twelve feet? Just sit down for twenty minutes and you'll be fine to go back to work. And there are so many injuries, due in large part to the complete lack of care shown by the father in his scrapping and building business. An accident waiting to happen, you'd say, and the accidents happen on a very regular basis. I couldn't help wondering if there aren't any health and safety regulations in Idaho, because it certainly didn't seem like it. And then as Tara becomes a teenager, things get worse, the paranoia of her father and the complete abnegation of any sort of support from her mother is supplemented by actual physical abuse from another family member.

What I found most disturbing in this book, actually, was that everything seemed to be going on in the sight of the community at large. When Tara is aged 11, the local community seems very accepting of the fact that Tara is getting no education at all (the home-schooling having died a death much earlier) and is happy to make use of her free time to obtain cheap labour.

Once, Tara has made it to BYU in Utah I heaved a sigh of relief, but it takes a long time for the ties of family to be broken. I was expecting some positives as well as negatives to appear from Tara's childhood: a simpler life maybe, or perhaps being part of a wide network of a close knit family. As it was, I couldn't see any. I just wanted her to run kicking and screaming out of Idaho at the earliest opportunity and never go back. Possibly a few thousand miles might have been a safe distance...

Anyway, it's highly recommended but a cheerful read it is not

59BLBera
Apr 18, 2018, 8:27 pm

>58 SandDune: I'm reading The Glass Castle with my class now, and this one sounds a lot like Educated, Rhian. It is very disturbing that no one spoke up for Tara. I'm no. 30 on the library wait list, so it will be awhile.

60SandDune
Apr 19, 2018, 2:10 am

<57 >59 BLBera: Books like Educated aren’t usually your sort of thing. I was never into ‘misery memoirs’ particularly (well maybe Angela’s Ashes.) I’d actually picked it up as I was interested in the cultural differences. I’d realized Tara’s childhood was different, I hadn’t realized it was so unmitigatingly awful.

>56 quondame: Although it’s set around the year 2050 i’d hesitate to describe City of Bohane as SF. It just doesn’t have the feel of SF somehow, although I suppose strictly speaking it is.

61lauralkeet
Apr 19, 2018, 7:08 am

>58 SandDune: excellent review, Rhian. Based on your earlier comments I added my name to the looooong hold list at my library. My name will come up someday, or I'll cave and buy it.

62SandDune
Edited: Apr 19, 2018, 4:28 pm

22. Bookworm: A Memoir of Childhood Reading Lucy Mangan ***1/2



In which the Guardian columnist Lucy Mangan revisits her childhood reading. From The Very Hungry Caterpillar to Enid Blyton to Judy Blume she charts the books that she loved (as well as a few of those she hated). I found it quite surprising that we didn't have more overlap (she's younger than me, but only by ten years or so), a lot of the same books would have been around. Perhaps her attitude to fantasy, as well as an aversion to talking animals, explains much of the difference:

English children's literature is consider d a treasure trove of high fantasy, but Narnia was as far as I wanted to go. I liked - still like - my flights of fancy firmly rooted in reality. I needed to be able to get back through the wardrobe,or out from under the floorboards. The Borrowers were welcome to share my world but I did not want to be a visitor stranded in someone else's universe entirely.

'I had an early, strict and enduring rule against books in which animals -especially talking animals - were the predominant feature. Thus to the oblivion to which I had already consigned Beatrix Potter, Winnie the Pooh, the inhabitants of Brambly Hedge, Rabbits Peter and Brer and Tales of Farthing Wood I now added, with an equal lack of compunction, the likes of the Just So Stories and The Wind in the Willows. What an idiot'

In my opinion, you probably couldn't get too much fantasy, or talking animals, preferably both in the same book!

Another major difference is her childhood love of Enid Blyton. I remember reading some Enid Blyton (six to be precise) but half of those were inherited from my sister, and none of were anywhere near the top of my favourite books list. At the age when I would have been reading them, there was definite disapproval of Enid Blyton in certain circles, and as both my major sources of books were firmly in the disapproving camp (namely my now grown-up sister and the local library) , then I might have found it a difficult passion to indulge in anyway, even if I'd been minded to.

There were some books which we'd both loved, and it was enjoyable being reminded of them: Stig of the Dump, Tom's Midnight Garden , and of course the Narnia books are the ones that come to mind. And there were plenty more that I hadn't actually read as a child myself, but I'd read with J when he was growing up, and it was nice being reminded of those too. So altogether a fun read (especially for those of the right age), although the author does try a little bit too hard to be funny at times. But if you're only going to read one memoir about childhood reading, then I'm afraid this one doesn't stand up to Francis Spufford's The Child that Books Built which I would highly recommend.

63charl08
Apr 19, 2018, 3:48 pm

Oh, I think I liked the Mangan more than you did Rhian! I did think it was a fun trip down memory lane. I don't remember being particularly fussy about talking animals though I did like Mrs Frisby and the Rats of Nimh,

64SandDune
Apr 19, 2018, 3:57 pm

>63 charl08: I did enjoy it! But there wasn’t anything like as much crossover of books as I had expected. I actually had come across more of the books by reading them to J, as reading them myself, which I found a little strange as she is much nearer my own age. I think that basically We had very different tastes in books as children. She mentions somewhere about feeling relieved when she comes across books set very firmly in the real world of her normal day to day existence. That was always the sort of book I tried to avoid as a child!

65rosalita
Apr 19, 2018, 4:19 pm

>62 SandDune: Many of the books mentioned here are not ones I'm familiar with over here on the other side the bathtub, but I adored the Borrowers beyond all reason. I only ever read The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe from the Narnia series, but I've got all the books now and am going to try to read them all in order to see what I missed. I must say I don't understand an aversion to talking animals in children's books — to me, those were some of the best books!

P.S. Your review seems to have some repeating bits in it — perhaps some copy-paste woes? I've done it many a time myself!

66SandDune
Apr 19, 2018, 4:35 pm

>65 rosalita: My reading was equally biased to authors from this side of the pond! I'd read a few 'classic' type American authors (Little Women, What Katy Did, Pollyanna - that sort of thing) but nothing really after the first years of the twentieth century

The Narnia books were some of my all time favourites. I remember having a dream once, when I was about 9 or 10, that there was another Narnia book which I hadn't yet read, and then being so disappointed when I woke up and realised that it wasn't true.

67rosalita
Apr 19, 2018, 4:47 pm

Oh gosh! What a terrible dream to have. I often find myself dreaming that there is some vital information written on a piece of paper in my hand but I can never manage to read it. Sometimes it's because I get interrupted, or the paper is sealed shut and I can't open it, or whatever. I guess my imagination is fertile enough to think up the basic scenario but isn't good at plot details like what notes say!

68SandDune
Apr 19, 2018, 4:49 pm

It's now gone from being extremely cold and wet less than two weeks ago, to extremely hot now. It was over 29 degrees C in London today - apparently the warmest April day since the 1940s. I can't take all these sudden changes ...

69quondame
Apr 19, 2018, 5:40 pm

>62 SandDune: >65 rosalita: >66 SandDune: Because of dyslexia I didn't read much as a young child, and almost as soon as it was relieved at puberty I was mostly reading either adult swashbucklers and mysteries or whatever was in my Jr. High library. Edward Eager, Frances Hodgson Burnett, lots of shoes books - Noel Streatfeild, Tales of a books, colored fairy books, and tales of Roman boys stolen but somehow returning to there senatorial families. The Narnia books were never favorites and singling out Susan for lipstick as if Peter couldn't have been teenaged guy involved with his own physicality was just weird.

70karenmarie
Apr 20, 2018, 8:32 am

Hi Rhian!

>66 SandDune: another Narnia book which I hadn't yet read, and then being so disappointed when I woke up and realised that it wasn't true. A friend gave me the Narnia books as a college graduation present in 1975. I still have them, and have only read 3 of them. When I told her that, sometime in the 1990s, she said she was envious that I still had them to look forward to.

71ChelleBearss
Apr 20, 2018, 8:46 am

Wow, 29 in April! It's been overly cool here still

72jnwelch
Apr 20, 2018, 4:18 pm

Hi, Rhian.

I loved the Narnia books, too, when I was a kid. What a dream! Wouldn't that be something, to have another one appear.

73PaulCranswick
Apr 21, 2018, 9:13 am

I don't think I would appreciate the sudden climate changes in the UK at the moment either, Rhian.

Try to stay cool and have a lovely weekend.

74SandDune
Edited: Apr 21, 2018, 10:35 am

24. City of Bohane Kevin Barry*****



It's the year 2053 and Logan Hartnett has controlled the City of Bohane, on the west coast of Ireland, for 25 years. His Hartnett Fancy control the bars and the drugs and the prostitutes, all of which Bohane has in abundance. But change might be in the air: rumours swirl through the backstreets of Bohane that Gant Broderick has returned across the Big Nothing waste. And as the Gant was the previous ruler of the Fancy and the previous lover of Logan's wife Macu, that can only spell trouble. And the families of the notorious Northside Rises, incensed by the stabbing of one of their own, are ready to descend the 98 steps down to the Bohane Trace to take control themselves. Is the fifty year old Logan, old by Bohane reckoning, still up to the job ...

You would not want to meet any of the characters of this novel on a dark night, or even on a well-lit one, come to that. The ambitious Wolfie Stanners, Logan's lieutenant, pursues the love of his life, the murderous Jenni Ching, proprietor of the Ho Pee Ching Oh-Kay Koffee Shoppe, while his henchman, Fucker Burke devotes himself to his equally violent Alsatian Angelina. Logan's 89 year old mother, Girly, exerts a Machiavellian control over events from her bed in the honeymoon suite of the Bohane Arms hotel. Ol' Man Mannion moves from camp to camp striking deals and keeping on the right side of everyone ...

The City of Bohane might be set in Ireland, but this isn't any Ireland that we're familiar with. It's a gang-ruled, almost tribal, Ireland where people walk rather than drive, murders are by knife not by gun, and electricity is only patchily available. A place where nostalgia for the Bohane 'lost time' is endemic, and where even the most murderous of Logan's henchman spend their time studying the fashion magazines in the Café Aliados. You've got to be well dressed to be a Fancy boy.

What I loved about this book was the language. After struggling for the first thirty minutes or so with the audio (the dialect of mid twenty-first century Irish gangs doesn't make this an easy listen) I eventually got to the point where I could listen to this all day. It's not an easy listen. Probably not a particularly easy read, but it's really, really worth it. Here's one of the easier passages:

'He cut off from the dockside and walked on into the Back Trace, the infamous Bohane Trace, a most evil labyrinth, an unknowable web of streets. He had that Back Trace look to him: a dapper buck in a natty-boy Crombie, the Crombie draped all casual-like over the shoulders of a pale grey Eyetie suit, mohair. Mouth of teeth on him like a vandalised graveyard but we all have our crosses. It was a pair of hand-stitched Portuguese boots that slapped his footfall, and the stress that fell, the emphasis, was money.

Hard-got the riches –oh the stories that we told out in Bohane about Logan Hartnett.

Dank little squares of the Trace opened out suddenly, like gasps, and Logan passed through. All sorts of quarehawks lingered Trace-deep in the small hours. They looked down as he passed, they examined their toes and their sacks of tawny wine –you wouldn’t make eye contact with the Long Fella if you could help it. Strange, but we had a fear of him and a pride in him, both. He had a fine hold of himself, as we say in Bohane. He was graceful and erect and he looked neither left nor right but straight out ahead always, with the shoulders thrown back, like a general. He walked the Arab tangle of alleyways and wynds that make up the Trace and there was the slap, the lift, the slap, the lift of Portuguese leather on the backstreet stones.


I should say, this isn't going to be for everyone. If you object to large amounts of swearing, or are easily offended, then this book is not for you. There is also some graphic violence, although infrequently enough that I could cope with it: the threat of violence is pervasive however. But if a mixture of The Wire combined with The Sopranos appeals, with a dash of Bladerunner thrown in and all given a very Irish makeover, then this might be the book for you. I'm just going to go out and buy everything else that Kevin Barry has written. My favourite book of the year so far.

75SandDune
Apr 21, 2018, 2:43 pm

>69 quondame: I didn't worry so much about Lewis's comments about Susan, probably mainly because Susan was always my least favourite of the siblings, but maybe because that doesn't appear until The Last Battle, which is definitely the most overtly Christian book. I always took it to mean that she didn't reappear in Narnia just because she work lipstick, but because she denied the existence of Narnia as a childish game ... or something like that anyway.

>69 quondame: >70 karenmarie: >72 jnwelch: Oh the Narnia books were definitely my favourites for a long stretch of my childhood, beaten only by The Weirdstone of Brisingamen. Funnily enough it wasn't The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe that I liked best - that was either probably The Magician's Nephew or The Voyage of the Dawn Treader.

76SandDune
Apr 21, 2018, 2:45 pm

>71 ChelleBearss: >73 PaulCranswick: It's been incredibly hot here. I mean, the high twenties is hot for the middle of the summer, not just April. And considering that it was snowing over much of the country at Easter it's a bit of a shock to the system!

77kidzdoc
Edited: Apr 24, 2018, 7:42 am

Great review of City of Bohane, Rhian!

High twenties in the UK?! I don't think it's been that warm in Atlanta for more than one or two days. We'll only get to 20 C today, and gradually warm to 25 C by Sunday.

78SandDune
Apr 24, 2018, 5:23 pm

>77 kidzdoc: It has returned to more normal temperatures now (12-14 C maximum). But last week we had the hottest April day since the 1940s!

79SandDune
Apr 24, 2018, 5:30 pm

Some sad news tonight - my mother phoned to say that my only remaining aunt had passed away last night. She had gone into a residential home a few weeks ago, as she was not able to live alone any more. My cousin (who lives in the States) was flying home today to see her, as seemingly she had very much given up and was refusing to eat, but she passed away last night.

That was my last remaining aunt: my mother is now the only one left of that generation in my family.

80Caroline_McElwee
Apr 24, 2018, 5:49 pm

Sorry for your loss Rhian. It's also strange when a generation draws to an end in a family. We are down to one uncle in my dad's generation now.

81quondame
Apr 24, 2018, 6:49 pm

>79 SandDune: So sorry to hear about your aunt.

82ronincats
Apr 24, 2018, 10:59 pm

My sympathy to you and your family about your aunt, Rhian. I am down to two remaining aunts out of five and no uncles; one aunt is in a nursing home with dementia, not recognizing family, and the other, the youngest except for my mom, is failing noticeably. My mom is still going strong at 87, thankfully.

83lauralkeet
Apr 25, 2018, 7:20 am

I'm sorry to hear about your aunt, Rhian. How is your mother holding up?

84FAMeulstee
Apr 25, 2018, 3:22 pm

Sorry for your and your mothers loss, Rhian.

85charl08
Apr 26, 2018, 2:40 am

Sending my sympathy Rhian - how sad that your cousin just missed her.

86kidzdoc
Apr 26, 2018, 5:34 am

I'm very sorry to hear about your aunt's death, Rhian.

87jnwelch
Apr 26, 2018, 4:55 pm

My condolences over the loss of your aunt, Rhian. It has to be hard to see that generation go. I'm glad your mom is still with you.

88SandDune
Apr 26, 2018, 5:23 pm

>80 Caroline_McElwee: >81 quondame: >82 ronincats: >83 lauralkeet: >84 FAMeulstee: >85 charl08: >86 kidzdoc: >87 jnwelch: Thankyou for the condolences everyone. I think my aunt had given up quite some time ago, and moving into a residential home was the final straw. My sister is finding out about the funeral arrangements: there is to be a cremation in Norfolk and a memorial service in South Wales where she she lived her whole life. I’m not sure which one family are expected to attend at the moment.

I am by far the youngest of my generation in my family, as the youngest child of a youngest child. My oldest uncle was born in 1906 and the youngest one in 1925, and only my mother, born in 1921 is left.

89karenmarie
Apr 26, 2018, 6:56 pm

My condolences, Rhian, to you and your mother.

I'm sad for your cousin - I, too, was flying home to see my mother in Dec 2016 but she passed before I could get there.

90lauralkeet
Apr 28, 2018, 7:00 am

>89 karenmarie: I had a similar experience in Nov. 2016. I was in a shuttle from airport parking to the terminal when my brother called to say my mom had just passed. I remember going through check-in and security in a bit of a fog.

91SandDune
Edited: Apr 28, 2018, 9:48 am

25. Earthfasts William Mayne ****



It’s the Yorkshire Dales in the 1960’s and two friends are investigating a strange noise that seems to be coming from underground, from a newly formed mound in a field. Keith thought that the noise was badgers underground and David though that it might be an underground stream, but neither of them expected that it was the sound of a drum being played underground, and getting closer and closer to the surface. And neither did they expect that that drum was being played by a drummer boy of the eighteenth century, who had entered the tunnel under the local castle over two hundred years before, looking for the legendary treasure of King Arthur that was supposed to be buried underneath, and had not been heard of since. But Nellie Jack John, as he introduces himself, will not believe the time that has passed while he was underground, as to him it seems he was walking for less than half an hour, and is certainly ill equipped to deal with the twentieth century.

This is a reread of a book I had as I child, and I was surprised to find that while I remembered certain elements of it very well, I had forgotten other equally vivid elements. But Nellie Jack John’s appearance isn’t the only strange thing that happens. Standing stones start to move, (if they are actually standing stones at all), candles burn cold, and time itself seems to becoming more fluid. This is a very well written children’s book, a lot more literary perhaps than most, and it holds up well rereading it as an adult.

92SandDune
Edited: Apr 28, 2018, 3:54 pm

26. Cradlefasts William Mayne ***1/2



David is still damaged by the death of his mother and baby sister seven years’ previously. He doesn’t like to discuss it even with his best friend Keith. But then Clare appears, who says she is his sister: she’s the same age, and has the same birthday and knows things about him that only his sister would know. Surely, she must be wrong ...

As a sequel to Earthfasts this is quite a strange book. Whereas in the first book the supernatural elements came thick and fast, this is much more contemplative. The supernatural elements in the first book are still there, but much more normalised. Until nearer the end, it’s more about a boy coming to terms with the traumatic events that have happened in his life. Earthfasts was written and clearly set in the 1960’s, and in a small town in Yorkshire at that (swinging London it is not), while Cradlefasts was written thirty years later (1995) and is clearly set in that time period. In the internal chronology of the book only eighteen months has passed, which makes for some slightly strange juxtapositions. Some characters seem to belong rather more in the earlier time period, and don’t quite work in the updated one.

But all in all it’s still a decent read, but one that needs to be read in sequence.

93SandDune
Edited: Apr 29, 2018, 2:32 pm

27. Candlefasts William Mayne ***1/2



Set in the years after the conclusion of Cradlefasts, when David and Keith and Nellie Jack John must work out the meaning of what exactly happened on the moor all those years ago. Whatever it was must come to a conclusion, and David’s young sister Liddy is at the heart of it ...

This isn’t a particularly easy read, and you finish it having to think about what exactly had had happened. It’s difficult to say too much, without spoilers for the earlier books, but it’s a compelling conclusion to the trilogy.

Edited to add: discovered from reading this book that the word ’attercob’ was an old word for spider. Was racking my brains to think where I had heard this before: it’s how Bilbo teases the giant spiders in Mirkwood in The Hobbit.

94SandDune
Apr 29, 2018, 4:19 am

>89 karenmarie: >90 lauralkeet: I’m sorry that you both had a similar experience. In the case of my cousin, at least he had been over pretty recently when they were making the decision to move her to a residential home.

I think my other cousin (the one who lives in the UK), would have been happy toward to have my aunt live with them in theory, but it wasn’t practical. They have recently downsized to quite a small house to allow them to purchase a property for their son. He has some learning and behavioural issues almost certainly caused by having a brain tumour as a young child which left him with some permanent problems, and he can be difficult. Apparently, having my aunt and him together was a very explosive mixture on both sides (she would berate him about his lack of ability to hold down a job, for instance, and then he would react badly), and this caused my cousin a great deal of stress. And even though he has his own home he is with them very frequently.

95SandDune
Apr 29, 2018, 6:57 am

After our heatwave the week before last, the local weather forecast is now saying it might snow tomorrow. Very strange weather indeed this year so far.

96BLBera
Apr 30, 2018, 10:59 am

Hi Rhian - My condolences to you and your mother on the death of your aunt. How is your mom doing? It must be hard for her.

I will definitely search for the Mayne books.

As I read your review, I thought City of Bohane is not for me, but when you said it's the best you've read this year, I paused. I might have to give it a try.

I added The Child that Books Built to the list. I love memoirs about books.

97ChelleBearss
May 1, 2018, 9:29 am

So sorry to hear of your aunt's passing. Hope you are doing ok!

98SandDune
May 2, 2018, 3:01 pm

>96 BLBera: >97 ChelleBearss: Thank you both. It has been decided that both myself and my sister will go to the funeral, as the memorial service has some fairly vague date at the moment and we may be on holiday. So my sister is flying back from Cyprus on Tuesday night, staying with us overnight, and we are going to the funeral together on Wednesday.

>96 BLBera: My mother was struggling a little, even before my aunt died, and she is now the last of her generation. Funnily enough, when they were younger my Mum and her sister rarely saw each other, they were pretty different people with not a huge amount in common. But they’d grown much closer together over the last twenty years.

99SandDune
Edited: May 4, 2018, 3:32 pm

29. The Field of the Cloth of Gold Magnus Mills ***1/2



Well this is a strange book. An unnamed narrator arrives in a field in early spring , and puts up his tent. Where he comes from is never explained, but he has great expectations of his new home ....

The Great Field, as it was properly known, lay in the bend of a broad, meandering river. Irregular in shape, it was bounded in the east, south and west by water, and in the north it dwindled gradually into wilderness. As far as I knew it had never been cultivated: it was grassland pure and simple. To many eyes the field probably looked insignificant; after all there was nothing to distinguish it from the countless neighbouring fields. For a select few, however, it was the chosen field: the place where momentous events would unfold and come to fruition.


The narrator is not the first in the field: Hen has arrived before him and settled in the west. Gradually, over the course of a summer, more people arrive, firstly in ones and twos, and then in larger numbers. Some stay for good, others leave after a short time. There are arguments: about bugles, milk pudding, copper baths and ditches. There are quite a few conversations about tents ... and about biscuits.

It very soon becomes clear that the field is an allegorical representation of Britain, and the various happenings are allegorical representations of events in early British history. At least some quite clearly are, others I’m not so sure about and may be just weird events for all I know!

As I said, a strange book, but an enjoyable one (if you like this sort of thing). I’ll be looking out for more by Magnus Mills.

100Whisper1
May 4, 2018, 4:03 pm

>31 SandDune: This must have been very scary. I'm glad that your dog was fine and there was a happy ending.

I'm sorry for the loss of your Aunt. Sadly, all my Aunts have passed away. My father's oldest sister outlived all her siblings. I received word from my cousin that she passed away at 94.

All good wishes to you.

101SandDune
May 4, 2018, 5:11 pm

We have discovered that Daisy has a bowl phobia. Last few evenings she has seemed reluctant to eat her food. She didn’t seem off her food generally (she was more than happy to eat any biscuits or other snacks that were going begging), just didn’t want to eat her own food. I thought maybe it was a bit stale or she was bored of it for some reason. This evening I was saying this to Mr SandDune, and he was saying that she was fine when he feeds her in the morning. He gets up first and always puts her food in her puzzle feeder (she has to twist things around to get at it). So we tipped the food from the bowl into her puzzle feeder and low and behold she ate it straight away! Who knows what goes through Daisy’s mind ...

102lauralkeet
May 4, 2018, 10:09 pm

>101 SandDune: I'm going to keep this in mind. Occasionally our silly terrier Alys seems reluctant to eat her food. We have a couple of other bowls we could use and I'll have to remember to give that a try.

103SandDune
May 5, 2018, 3:16 am

>102 lauralkeet: It’s weird what goes through their heads sometimes, isn’t it. She was eating her food eventually, and didn’t seem ill, so I wan’t too worried, I was just going to get her some different food this weekend.

104SandDune
Edited: May 5, 2018, 3:42 pm

30. The Surgeon of Crowthorne Simon Winchester ***



When the idea of the Oxford English Dictionary was first proposed it was very clear that it was a mammoth undertaking: every word that existed (or had ever existed) in the English language was to be documented, with quotations illustrating each nuanced meaning that the word might have, and in particular illustrating when the word had first appears in English. It was clear to the newly appointed editor, James Murray, that this task could not be done by paid staff alone: volunteers were sought from all corners of the English speaking world to read the required books and send in quotations. One of those that answers the call was Dr W.C.Minor, an American army surgeon who gave his address only as Broadmoor, Crowthorne, Berkshire. These days, at least for a British reader, the name Broadmoor immediately conjures up images of the most notorious criminals, as it’s the best known of the high security psychiatric hospitals in the U.K. In the second half of the nineteenth century, it was the newly built Broadmoor Criminal Lunatic Asylum, and presumably not as well known, as James Murray and Dr W.C. Minor were in correspondence for some years before Murray realised that Minor was not the retired doctor with time on his hands that he had always supposed. The truth was that Minor had been committed to Broadmoor after shooting a man in London: in a celebrated trial he had been found not guilty on grounds of insanity (although everyone including himself had been quite clear that he had carried out the shooting), but had been detained ‘at her majesty’s pleasure’ as a danger to the public.

The book outlines Minor’s history and speculates on what had brought him to his reduced state, and also what had brought Murray to his rather more exalted one. To be honest, I could have done with a little more of Murray’s story. As the son of a Scottish draper he certainly wouldn’t have been expected to have ended up as Sir James Murray, and the most famous editor of what proved to be one of the most monumental accomplishments in the English language. It’s an interesting story, but I wasn’t overly enamoured of Simon Winchester’s telling of it, although I did find the mechanics of the compilation of the dictionary fascinating. He’s very much of the school of writing that thinks if one sentence is good, five sentences will be better. It’s not what you call concise. And male readers should be warned, there’s a bit in the middle that you might find a little bit upsetting ...

105PaulCranswick
May 6, 2018, 8:45 am

Dropping by to wish you and Mr SandDune and J a peaceful Sunday.

106rosalita
May 6, 2018, 7:38 pm

>104 SandDune: Very nice review, Rhian. I read The Professor and the Madman year's ago and found it an interesting story, but I'm not sure I feel the need to read another version, but nice to know it's out there. And you've piqued my curiosity about the bits that men might not like ...

107charl08
May 7, 2018, 11:21 am

>104 SandDune: What Julia said.
What a great tidbit about a contributor from the OED being in Broadmoor!

108SandDune
May 7, 2018, 12:04 pm

>106 rosalita: I think that’s the same book, it’s got a different title in the US to the U.K. The bits that men might not like referred to his self-mutilation of a certain part of his anatomy. Or maybe it’s just that i’ve got a squeamish husband ...

109nittnut
May 8, 2018, 9:44 am

De-lurking to say hello, and wonder why books get such different titles sometimes?

110karenmarie
May 8, 2018, 3:22 pm

Hi Rhian!

>104 SandDune: Excellent review. I found this book fascinating. It's the first book by Simon Winchester that I read. I've since read several others and have a few more on my shelves just waiting for the right time.

111rosalita
May 8, 2018, 3:57 pm

>108 SandDune: Oh! It is the same book. That makes a lot more sense as it seemed odd that there would be two on such a narrow subject. (I also don't remember the grisly bit but then I'm not a man. Ha!)

Now that I know I read the same book you read, I concur about Winchester's windiness. I also read his The Men Who United the States and felt the same way — interesting topic but less than scintillating writing.

112SandDune
May 8, 2018, 5:38 pm

>107 charl08: >109 nittnut: >110 karenmarie: >111 rosalita: We’ve just had our RL book club meeting (which is why I read The Surgeon of Crowthorne. The general consensus was rather more favourable than my view. Everyone else gave it 8/10 I rated it 6.5/10.

113SandDune
May 10, 2018, 4:00 pm

We went to my aunt’s funeral yesterday. There were not many people there, as the funeral was so far from where she had lived all of her life, but it was a respectable turn-out. They are expecting more people at the memorial service in July. I think all-in-all my aunt had a decent life, but with elements of sadness too. She married when she was quite young in the Second World War, but her first husband died when he was only in his mid forties. They had gone on holiday to Switzerland in the mid 1960s (quite a big thing then) and he had a heart attack when he dived into the swimming pool. Turned out that the family was genetically predisposed to have extremely high cholesterol levels, which of course they didn’t know about then. So she had to fly home alone with the body, never having flown before. She did marry again, but she would never go back to Switzerland. My other cousin moved to the United States years and years ago, and while my aunt was happy to visit him there, she would not visit when he spent a year in Switzerland on a sabbatical.

114lauralkeet
May 10, 2018, 8:50 pm

>113 SandDune: that's a sad and touching story. I can see why it would be difficult for her to return to Switzerland.

115vancouverdeb
May 11, 2018, 2:39 am

Bowl phobia. I think I have heard of that. I'm glad you found a solution. I've heard that some dog's don't care for metallic bowls , as perhaps they don't like seeing a reflection, not understanding what it is. I know our dog does't like to small of a bowl. I think she fears it is too small for her muzzle?

Sorry for the loss of your aunt. A sad story, losing her first husband so early in life.

116lyzard
May 11, 2018, 5:53 am

Sorry for your difficult times, Rhian.

Interesting about Daisy: I know that cats sometimes object to bowls because of whisker-touches, but I've never known a dog who wouldn't eat anything anywhere. :)

117SandDune
May 11, 2018, 3:12 pm

>115 vancouverdeb: >116 lyzard: Well, the bowl phobia seems to be over, thank goodness. She’s had the same bowl for quite some time, and it was plastic not metallic, so goodness knows what caused it ...

>114 lauralkeet: It is sad, isn’t it? I can only just about remember my uncle, but my sister can remember him well, and said he was a very nice man.

118SandDune
Edited: May 11, 2018, 3:53 pm

31. New Worlds, Year One: A Writer’s Guide to the Art of Worldbuilding Marie Brennan ***1/2



When I requested this book from Early Reviewers, I missed the second part of the title, the part that says that this is a writer’s guide. And as I am not a writer, nor have any intention of becoming one, I was initially thinking that I had made a bad choice. But actually, I found this book quite interesting and readable. Marie Brennan takes aspects of fantasy worldbuilding and considers what makes a world work, and what doesn’t. So there are chapters entitled ‘Rivers’, ‘Mountains’ and ‘Deserts’ dealing with the physical environment, ‘Where does the Food Come From’ and ‘Dining Customs’ dealing with the edible, and ‘Your Money’s Worth’ dealing with the financial, as well as a whole lot more. Next time I read a fantasy book I’ll have a much better idea of how the author has constructed their world, and why it works (or why it doesn’t).

119PaulCranswick
May 11, 2018, 10:42 pm

>113 SandDune: That is quite a sad little update, Rhian. At least you were there to commemorate your aunt.

120BLBera
May 12, 2018, 10:41 am

>118 SandDune: That does sound interesting, Rhian.

121drneutron
May 12, 2018, 6:19 pm

>118 SandDune:, >120 BLBera: Yeah, I agree. Plus, Brennan is really good at world building!

122SandDune
Edited: May 13, 2018, 2:34 pm

I needed to buy a cheap kindle version of a classic book yesterday, and in doing so came across the most awful cover that I have come across in a long time. Any ideas as to which famous nineteenth century novel this is supposed to represent:

123rosalita
May 14, 2018, 2:01 pm

>122 SandDune: I'm so afraid it's going to be A Christmas Carol. I hope I'm wrong.

124SandDune
May 15, 2018, 5:18 pm

>123 rosalita: I’m afraid that it is Middlemarch. How you can put a car and a tram and telegraph poles on the cover of a book that is supposed to be set in 1830 is something of a mystery! Oh and they seem to have moved it across the Atlantic as well, with the sign for drugs!

I had signed up for a day’s study day on Middlemarch at Topping’s book shop in Ely (one of my favourite book shops by the way), but I could not find my paper copy, hence my need for a quick kindle version. A really good day, so i’ve signed up for an Ursula K Le Guin weekend as well in September.

125SandDune
May 16, 2018, 5:02 pm

I’m going to whisper this very quietly. I am actually sick to death of the royal wedding...

126nittnut
Edited: May 16, 2018, 5:13 pm

>122 SandDune: That is a truly awful cover.

>125 SandDune: *quietly- rah-rah!* The media are certainly squeaking every last ounce out of it, aren't they? I especially love all the fuss about what it's going to be like to have an American Princess. *Shrug* If what everyone here says about her is true, probably a lot like any other kind of spoiled princess. Lol And won't the media love it?

127charl08
May 16, 2018, 5:15 pm

>125 SandDune: Ha! Maybe there's a support group?

128rosalita
May 16, 2018, 5:36 pm

>124 SandDune: Oh dear, I would never have guessed Middlemarch in a hundred years! That is dreadful. On the other hand, Middlemarch is actually quite good, so I hope you enjoy the book shop event.

129lauralkeet
May 16, 2018, 8:48 pm

>122 SandDune:, >124 SandDune: I was thinking maybe Trollope. That cover doesn't fit Middlemarch at all!

>125 SandDune: Previews of US television coverage show American presenters doing really, truly awful British accents and wearing really, truly awful hats. I doubt I'll be able to watch the wedding because it's the morning of Julia's graduation. But if I were going to watch it, I would seek out a more authentic source. I enjoy the pomp and circumstance -- it's done so well over there -- but I agree all the hubbub is a bit much.

130karenmarie
May 17, 2018, 8:08 am

Hi Rhian!

I'm sorry to hear about your aunt. Such a tragedy about your uncle dying young on vacation.

I don't watch TV news and haven't been overwhelmed by the royal wedding stuff. I just hope they're happy.

131Familyhistorian
May 19, 2018, 7:14 pm

Sorry to hear about your aunt, Rhian. It feels odd when the generation before your's goes. It has been that way for my family for a few years now.

132ronincats
May 20, 2018, 6:14 pm

>122 SandDune: I was thinking Meet Me in St. Louis, the movie, which doesn't meet any of your criteria except it fits the cover!

The wedding is over! I didn't get up for it but watched some of the reprise coverage later in the day, which was plenty for me. Loved the cellist! And the gospel choir.

133souloftherose
May 22, 2018, 1:19 pm

>124 SandDune: Oh, the Ursula Le Guin weekend sounds really interesting. Sadly a bit far from me and not good dates - I hope you enjoy it!

134Caroline_McElwee
May 25, 2018, 12:05 pm

>122 SandDune: what on Earth has that got to do with Middlemarch Rhian, I'd agree with Ronicats.

135SandDune
May 28, 2018, 1:42 pm

Well, I’ve been missing in action for the last couple of weeks, so apologies. My work life has been taken up with GDPR (and if anyone does not know what GDPR means then all I can say is that you are very lucky). Actually, it’s the General Data Protection Regulation, and it’s the new data protection legislation being introduced by the EU. (Which we are retaining once we leave the EU, as not to do so would put us beyond the pale, data wise). Combining the requirements of the GDPR with social care, where regulations require that we retain data for 80 years in some cases, (or is it 85, anyway it’s a long, long time) is challenging, to say the least!

>126 nittnut: >128 rosalita: >129 lauralkeet: >132 ronincats: >134 Caroline_McElwee: It is a truly awful cover isn’t it? I can sort of see that the artist might not have read the book (although you would hope so), but surely the editor or the publisher or at least someone connected with the book has read it and should realise that that is not appropriate at all!

>119 PaulCranswick: >130 karenmarie: >131 Familyhistorian: Thank you! I can’t help feeling that i’m a little young to have no aunts and uncles left (I’m 57) especially as I started out with a fair few. But the generations are a little odd in my family and the birth dates of my aunts and uncles ranged between 1906 and 1926, so while most of them lived to a ripe old age, into their nineties, they are all gone now. My oldest first cousin was born about 1930 and the youngest is 10 years older than me ...

136SandDune
May 28, 2018, 2:08 pm

>126 nittnut: >127 charl08: >129 lauralkeet: >130 karenmarie: >132 ronincats: Well, I didn’t watch the wedding in the end (although of course I saw snippets on the news) but I might just as well have done. We went to a reunion of my ante-natal group in the evening, and the only thing that the women were talking about for at least the first hour was the Royal wedding. So it was nice to see everyone but I did feel a little left out ...

137SandDune
May 28, 2018, 3:38 pm

It’s been a three day weekend here so: we’ve not been doing anything massive, but the weather is lovely and it’s nice to have an extra day off work and not be running around. Yesterday we went out for breakfast, which Mr SandDune likes to do. I’m not so enthused about eating breakfast out - in my book going out is something you do after you’ve had breakfast - but it was nice. And then we went and had a little wander around town and I bought three summer dresses and a cardigan, which I was very pleased with. I always find that I do my best shopping when I’m not really shopping! Today we went out for a walk to the north-east of Cambridge, and it was a lovely day for it. Managed to keep Daisy out of any very smelly water, which can be a problem when it is hot. She likes water, and doesn’t seem to mind at all how smelly it is.

138SandDune
May 30, 2018, 3:16 pm

Anyone else watching A Very English Scandal? It’s a fictionalised account of the Jeremy Thorpe affair, with Hugh Grant playing Jeremy Thorpe (in a very un-Hugh Grantish role, it has to be said) and he’s excellent in it. For those people who’ve never heard of Jeremy Thorpe, he was the leader of the British Liberal party in the 1960’s and 1970’s. In the early sixties he had an affair with a young man called Norman Scott (this was when homosexuality was still illegal in the U.K. remember) and over the following years became more and more concerned that his career would be ruined by Norman Scott’s increasing attempts to tell the world all about it. After all attempts to silence Scott failed, he was eventually accosted by a somewhat unsuccessful ‘hitman’ on Exmoor, who failed to injure Scott at all, but did succeed in killing his dog. The scandal grew, and Jeremy Thorpe and three associates ended up being tried for conspiracy to murder at the Old Bailey...

I remembered the basics of the case, but not the details, and it’s a pretty amazing story. Well worth watching.

139SandDune
Edited: May 30, 2018, 4:23 pm

32. The Shape of Water Andrea Camilleri ***1/2



The first of the many Inspector Montalbano books. Two rubbish collectors are clearing up the Pasture, the stretch of waste ground on the outskirts of town where the drug dealers and prostitutes hang out, when they come across the body of Silvio Luparello, a prominent local politician. Luparello has seemingly died of natural causes, but something about the case doesn’t seem to add up to Inspector Montalbano, the investigating officer. Why wasn’t Luparello’s close colleague, the lawyer Rizzo, more shocked when he first discovered that his close friend was dead, and had been found dead in a very compromising position at that. And who exactly was in the car with Luparello at the time of his demise?

This was an enjoyable book although the plot was a little convouted at times. It had a great feel of a real, rather than a showcase, Italy. One unfortunate consequence of reading the book though, is that I now have a great desire to eat octopus. I gave up eating octopus in 2007 after a holiday day trip run by a marine biologist who spent most of his time extolling the beauty and intelligence of octopuses, and I’ve avoided eating them ever since. But the octopus dish that they have to eat in The Shape of Water just sounds wonderful...

Several reviews of The Shape of Water have mentioned its focus on food and drink and that has got me thinking about something else. Not why this one talks about food so much, but why don’t other novels talk about it more? It suddenly occurred to me that I have far, far more conversations about food in real life than occur in the average novel. Does my family talk about food an abnormal amount (quite possibly) or do novelists on average not find this an interesting topic? Who knows!

140Caroline_McElwee
May 30, 2018, 4:22 pm

I read that in Sicily Rhian, but I just couldn't get past the misogyny. None of the female roles portrayed women in a good light I felt. I'm not sure I will read another, though I bought a job lot of ten.

141SandDune
May 30, 2018, 4:36 pm

>139 SandDune:None of the female roles portrayed women in a good light I felt To be honest it didn’t worry me particularly, as I’m not sure that many of the male roles did either! And it was written originally in 94 and in Sicily, so a different time and place. I spent nine months in Italy in 1982/83, so a lot closer to the time frame that the book was written than today, and the feel of it seemed right, somehow.

142lauralkeet
May 31, 2018, 1:15 am

>138 SandDune: that sounds like an interesting program, Rhian. I wasn't aware of the scandal at all, but it sounds like excellent material for a television program. I'll have to look out for it over here.

143charl08
May 31, 2018, 2:50 am

>138 SandDune: I read the book it has been based on Rhian, but haven't watched the series. Amazing how much of the book felt like fiction, but was based on letters / interviews with the protagonists.

144lauralkeet
Jun 1, 2018, 3:30 am

>142 lauralkeet: I just read something in the NYTimes about new crime programmes coming in June and hooray, this is one of them. It will be available to stream on Amazon US towards the end of the month.

145ChelleBearss
Jun 2, 2018, 8:43 am

Hope work slows down for you!

>139 SandDune: Glad to see you enjoyed Montalbano! Every book talks about food but thankfully, for me, I am not one for trying unique things so the foods he talks about don't always appeal to me. The books, however, do appeal to me and I've read them all :)

146SandDune
Jun 2, 2018, 3:35 pm

I’ve had two very different days in yesterday and today: yesterday was incredibly stressful and today was much much nicer.

First, yesterday. You know when you see a car broken down at the side of the road and you thank your lucky stars that you didn’t break down there? Well, I was the person in that car yesterday. I drive through Hertford on my way home from work: it’s a bottleneck at the best of times but all last week it was even worse as they are doing roadworks and a normal two-lane dual carriageway has been reduced to one lane. Well, on Friday we finish work at three and I was very much looking forward to getting home before the real rush started. So I get as far as Hertford, start queuing before the roadworks, ‘not too bad I think, I’ll be through here in 10 minutes’ and then the car breaks down. My car has a start-stop option that switches the engine off when it’s in neutral - the engine had only been off for twenty seconds or so, but when I tried to move again nothing worked. Nothing at all. Every single warning light seemed to come on at once but apart from that nothing. So I was stationary in the outside lane of the dual carriageway starting to cause a major hold-up. I phoned up the breakdown people, they said they would send someone urgently, so all I could do was sit on the crash barrier and wait for someone to turn up. First a police car came, he phoned the breakdown people again to see how long they would really be, they said an hour and a half. Well, he wasn’t too keen on that as I was single handedly causing a major traffic obstruction, and the design of the road at that point meant that the car couldn’t be pushed off the road. So they sent off for another police car with a battery pack to see if that would help. (If it wouldn’t, I was going to have to have the police recovery people which was going to cost £150, as they certainly didn’t want me there for an hour and a half.) In the meantime they tried to push start the car but that didn’t work. By the end I’d collected three police cars and they did get it started, but they weren’t confident that it would stay started. So I drove to the nearest car park, and as predicted once it was stopped it wouldn’t start again (I couldn’t even open the doors without manually using the key). So I waited another hour or so for the repair guy, who wasn’t much more informative than the police to be honest: he could start the car but didn’t think it would stay started and decided it would need a tow truck. By this time Mr SandDune has come to offer moral support, so we went for a pizza while waiting for the truck. I eventually got home at 8.30pm, so five and a half hours to travel a grand total of 22 miles! We’ve now got the car sitting in the drive and will need to get it repaired next week. If the tow truck had come earlier they could have taken it straight to a local garage and Mr SandDune could have taken me home from there, but it was too late by the time it arrived. So I got home very tired, very stressed and not happy about the car situation at all!

147SandDune
Jun 2, 2018, 4:10 pm

Today has been much better. I’ve been to Ely to have my degree ceremony for my BA in English Literature. The ceremony was in the cathedral, which is always lovely, and the rain kept off (it had been threatening to rain) so a more relaxing time was had by all. We had a nice lunch, and then a visit to Toppings, my favourite bookshop ...

Here I am after the ceremony:



And here are me and Mr SandDune before the ceremony:



148SandDune
Jun 2, 2018, 4:19 pm

>143 charl08: >144 lauralkeet: It was on the news today that they are reopening the police case into the events:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-44336859

>145 ChelleBearss: I’m exactly the opposite - I do enjoy trying new things to eat. And I particularly enjoy Italian cooking, so I doubt that there’s much that they would cook in Sicily that I wouldn’t be prepared to try.

149lauralkeet
Jun 2, 2018, 6:58 pm

Congratulations on your degree, Rhian! That's quite an accomplishment. I'm very sorry you had to go through such hell with your car, though.

150quondame
Jun 3, 2018, 12:08 am

>147 SandDune: Congratulations! Great that the weather co-operated.

151charl08
Jun 3, 2018, 12:26 am

Congratulations! And what a lovely setting for it.

Hope the garage can sort out the car sharpish.

Thank you for posting the Thorpe link: fascinating stuff, I'll have a look at the documentary I think.

152Caroline_McElwee
Jun 3, 2018, 7:42 am

>147 SandDune: Congratulations Rhian, I'm glad it was a special day for you. And I know how much effort goes into doing a degree when you are working. You should be very proud of yourself.

>146 SandDune: grr re the car incident. Very frustrating. I hope your car gets fixed soon, and the lack of it doesn't make the week ahead too difficult.

153karenmarie
Jun 3, 2018, 12:15 pm

Congratulations, Rhian, and thank you for sharing the photos!

I'm sorry to hear about the car problems and stressful time.

154BLBera
Jun 3, 2018, 2:12 pm

>147 SandDune: Congratulations on your degree, Rhian.

I hope your car problems are sorted soon. What a frustrating afternoon.

155SandDune
Edited: Jun 3, 2018, 2:41 pm

33. The World Without Us Mireille Juchau ***



I’ve been meaning to read this for some time, but I was under an misapprehension as to what it was about. I had expected some sort of environmental apocalypse, and while the environment features strongly, and there are concerns about the survival of the bee hives that provide a living for the main characters, it is by no means apocalyptic.

Stefan and Evangeline Müller attempt to make a living by making honey in a moutaineous region of New South Wales. But the family is collapsing: the youngest daughter Pip has died of leukaemia and the family struggles to come to terms with her death. The eldest daughter Tess refuses to speak at all, Evangeline walks the roads around their farm from morning till night, while Stefan himself drinks to excess. And the bees on which their livelihoods depend seem to be disappearing.

When a derelict car is found on a remote corner of their property, containing an unidentified body, more distant memories are brought to the surface for Evangeline, who was brought up in an commune called The Hive further up on the mountain. When the commune burnt down when Evangeline was a teenager, she herself was badly burnt, and lost her memories of the events that led to the fire. But events are conspiring to bring everything to the surface.

I found The World Without Us to be very evocative of the location - small town Australia really came alive for me - and the environmental issues facing the locality were interesting. The plot was weaker though, and the motivations of some of the characters were a little hazy, to say the least. So overall this was a reasonable book, but I’m not sure I’ll be rushing out to buy anything by the same author.

156SandDune
Jun 3, 2018, 2:53 pm

>149 lauralkeet: >150 quondame: >151 charl08: >152 Caroline_McElwee: >153 karenmarie: >154 BLBera: Thanks for the congratulations. We all had a lovely day! I was sitting in the first row of graduates, immediately behind those people who had got an MA or MSc and I couldn’t help thinking that getting one of those would be nice ...

I will have to be taking Mr SandDune’s car to work this week I think. He can walk to work, whereas I can’t travel to work by public transport. Hopefully, it won’t be too expensive.

157FAMeulstee
Jun 3, 2018, 6:00 pm

>147 SandDune: Congratulations, Rhian, nice picture of you and Mr Sanddune!

Sorry about the trouble with the car, I hope it can be repaired at reasonable cost.

158ChelleBearss
Jun 4, 2018, 8:12 am

Congrats!! I hope that great day made up for the yucky car day!

159SandDune
Jun 4, 2018, 3:08 pm

>157 FAMeulstee: >158 ChelleBearss: The breakdown people are picking the car up tomorrow at 8.00am to take it to be repaired, so I’m just hoping there isn't too much wrong with it. I’ve had it since new (it’s coming up to 4 years old now) and I’ve not had any problems before.

160rosalita
Jun 5, 2018, 8:07 pm

Congratulations on getting yourself graduated, Rhian! And boo for car trouble. Breaking down in the midst of heavy traffic with no way to pull out of the way is a nightmare of mine that so far (knock on wood) hasn't come true. I hope the car repairs aren't too expensive.

161SandDune
Jun 17, 2018, 2:41 pm

Oh dear, I am hopelessly behind (again). The last couple of weeks have been a little traumatic. I managed to get into quite an argument with my boss, who I thought was behaving completely unreasonably, to the extent that I came seriously close to resigning. And I probably would have resigned if we hadn’t managed to patch things up last week and I got something approaching an apology. But it was all quite stressful while it lasted.

One thing that came out of it was we spent the weekend reviewing our financial position, and we’ve realised that if we do want to retire when we’re 60, we can do it. We’ve always assumed that we will retire when we’re 62, by which time J will have finished at Uni, but it’s nice to have the options. Not that I’m really feeling ready to retire as yet, to be honest, but don’t know what i’ll feel like in three years time.

J went back to school a couple of weeks ago and so far seems to be doing well. He seems to be making some friends in his new year and coping with the work side of things, so it’s all quite promising.

My car turned out to be nothing more serious than needing a completely new battery. Apparently cars with stop-start technology get through the battery quite quickly, and the hours spend queuing the week before had just been the final straw. But by the time that they’d also replaced two tyres (I knew one of them needed replacing) and fixed the worn windscreen wiper it came to pretty much £500.

In other news, Daisy has been to have a tooth removed (she wasn’t keen on that) and I have been to have my complicated root canal fixed (I wasn’t too keen on that either).

162BLBera
Jun 17, 2018, 3:04 pm

Your life has been busy, Rhian. Glad the work was sorted. It is nice to have options, though.

I'm happy that J is doing well.

My car goes in to be serviced tomorrow. Fingers crossed.

Are you done with the dentist now?

163Caroline_McElwee
Edited: Jun 17, 2018, 3:26 pm

Oh dear Rhian. Few of us like to argue with colleagues, but I'm glad you got an apology of sorts. I hope things improve going forward.

It is good having choices though, and knowing if things don't settle down you are going to be able to cope is a good thing. It takes some pressure off. I know I can't stop work at 60, I'm a year older than you, but I've pretty much decided to go down to four days a week next year. I can afford to do that, and suspect it will make a big difference (my average daily commute is three hours, tiring). I may be able to work from home one day a week too.

Ouch re the car, but glad it wasn't anything more serious. They are good at not telling you the side-effects of some new technological 'advancement'!

Sorry about both lots of teeth!

164SandDune
Jun 17, 2018, 3:26 pm

Quick book catch-up

34. The Seven Deaths of Evelyn HardcastleStuart Turton **1/2

I thought I’d love this one - sort of Groundhog Day meets Agatha Christie - but I really didn’t. I stuck with it to the end to see what was going on, and then wished I hadn’t bothered. Lots of people seem to love it though.



35. House of Names Colm Toibin

A retelling of the story of Agamemnon and Clytemnestra. Made me want to read more Greek myth.



165Caroline_McElwee
Jun 17, 2018, 3:28 pm

I have the Tóibín on the shelf, might nudge that up soon.

166SandDune
Jun 17, 2018, 5:01 pm

36. The Dead House Harry Bingham ****



37. The Deepest Grave Harry Bingham ****




I’ve enjoyed these crime novels more and more as the series has progressed. The plots are very far-fetched, but I really like the characters. And they do remind me of home ...

167SandDune
Edited: Jun 17, 2018, 5:06 pm

>162 BLBera: The root canal has been finished, but I do have to have the tooth crowned. I was going to get that done before going on holiday, but I’ve had enough of being poked about for one month, so I’m going to wait until we come back and get it done in August. The crown should be straightforward, unlike the root canal: the root of that particular tooth is very curvy apparently. Daisy has to go back to have an x-ray of her newly filled tooth, again when we come back from holiday.

168ronincats
Jun 17, 2018, 11:42 pm

A belated congratulations on your degree, Rhian! Well-deserved after all the work you put into it. Hope your tooth is well during your holidays; crowns are much more straight-forward as you say--I have multiples.

169charl08
Jun 18, 2018, 7:58 am

Oh no - just reading about your dental works makes me feel nervous about my (overdue) next visit to the dentist. Yuk.

Really glad to hear J is settling into his new year at school, sending good wishes that it continues to go well.

I tried to start The Seven Deaths and got nowhere, so thanks for the vindication. I thought perhaps I was missing something!

A friend of mine has just started the English lit course at the OU and I am quite tempted. I did a module years ago with them and really liked the approach. I'm not sure I would be so successful at combining it with work though.

170BLBera
Jun 18, 2018, 11:28 am

My dental check-up is tomorrow. I'm hoping for no surprises.

I think you've probably mentioned it, but I forgot. Where are you going on holiday? Yours always sound so interesting.

171SandDune
Jun 18, 2018, 1:59 pm

>168 ronincats: >169 charl08: The most annoying thing about my tooth is that it has cost a lot of money. I usually have an NHS dentist, but it was quite specialist work that needed doing which he was not able to do himself. So he said he could either refer me to a dental hospital in London (which would still be on the NHS) or a specialist private practice in Cambridge which I would have to pay for. So I asked him to do both, on the grounds that I would go with the private practice if I had heard nothing from the NHS in the meantime. It took quite a long time for the private practice to fit me in, but by the time of my appointment I had heard nothing from the NHS so decided to pay privately. I then had my NHS appointment letter come through the day after I had the first appointment. Very irritating!

>169 charl08: I felt The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was far too long and really needed a good editor. And I hated the writing style. The strange thing is that it was recommended for people who liked The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August by Clare North which I actually enjoyed a lot.

172SandDune
Jun 18, 2018, 2:16 pm

>170 BLBera: Best of luck at the dentist! We are gong to Latvia and Estonia - does that count as interesting? We are flying to Riga in Latvia, immediately driving to Tartu in Estonia (an old university town), then Tallinn, then Saaremaa (an island off the coat of Estonia), then back to Riga. I’m really looking forward to it. J’s just announced that he’s going to Copenhagen for a week or so in the summer to visit a friend, so that will be nice for him as well.

173SandDune
Jun 19, 2018, 4:48 pm

I’m dipping into Lingo: A Language spotters Guide to Europe at the moment and particularly like the chapter on the complexities of Welsh...

Suppose you read the word ‘nghymoedd’. . You will search in vain in the dictionary. Naturally, because it’s a plural and plurals don’t have separate entries in the dictionary. The last letters, -oedd, are a fairly common plural marker in Welsh, but in this case the plural form is created not by adding a suffix to the singular form - the vowel, too, is different. In the singular, the vowel is not y, but w, pronounced as oo....

Right: putting the suffix -oedd aside and replacing the y with w we get nghwm. But that seems not to be in the dictionary either. Because the right place to look for ‘nghwm’ is under ‘cwm’ (coombe or valley) a word that shares just one letter with ‘nghymoedd’...

What is typically Welsh though, or rather typically Celtic - are the changing consonants at the beginning of words. ... But it’s not an easy system. ‘Cwm’ in the singular has three ‘mutations’ (the technical term):the soft form gwm; the nasal form nghwm; and the aspirated form chwm. ...Some other words have only two mutations, still others only one and some have none. It all depends on the initial sound.


To be honest I think that coming across a word that looks like ‘nghymoedd’ is probably enough to make most non-Welsh speakers close whatever they are reading pretty quickly but never mind that. It really took me back to Welsh lessons at school when I learnt very quickly that you couldn’t just look up words in the dictionary under the letters which they did start with, you had to work out what other letters they might possibly start with as well ...

174rosalita
Jun 19, 2018, 5:54 pm

>173 SandDune: And here I thought the biggest problem with Welsh was not being able to pronounce any of the words! Turns out I can't look them up in the dictionary, either. :-)

175BLBera
Jun 21, 2018, 9:15 am

>172 SandDune: :( I need a crown revision, Rhian. Not the news I wanted to hear. I'm putting it off until the end of the year.

Yes, your holiday plans sound wonderful.

>173 SandDune: That is fascinating. I love language stuff.

176jnwelch
Jun 21, 2018, 11:44 am

Hi, Rhian.

Your take on The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle fits for me; I've been on the fence, but I'll give it a pass.

I'm glad you're enjoying the Fiona Griffiths series; that's one of my favorites now.

177Familyhistorian
Jun 30, 2018, 1:18 am

Belated congratulations on your graduation, Rhian. It's nice when they give you something for all the hard work you put in. Latvia and Estonia sound very interesting especially to us in North America where it takes so much travel time to get to anywhere else.

178nittnut
Jul 1, 2018, 9:40 pm

Just getting caught up - Huge congratulations on the degree! That's a very good day.

Ugh to dental work.

Hooray to Latvia and Estonia. I've heard they are wonderful places to visit.

179The_Hibernator
Jul 2, 2018, 7:56 am

Congrats on your graduation!!! Big news!

180SandDune
Jul 2, 2018, 5:14 pm

>175 BLBera: >177 Familyhistorian: >178 nittnut: The Baltic States are really easy to visit for us. We live very near to Stansted airport which is the best airport in the U.K. for cheap city breaks within Europe. The weather is looking good too. We’re having a heatwave here at the moment, and the weather in Riga is a bit cooler, but still 22-23 degrees which will be fine for sight-seeing. Tallinn is a degree or so cooler. I’m hoping it will be warm enough for us to do some swimming. I think the Baltic should be considerably warmer than the sea off the coast of Portugal where we were last year! When we went to the north of Denmark a few years ago the sea was a surprisingly pleasant temperature. And they have lake swimming - I do like swimming in a lake - for some reason in Britain the idea of swimming in a lake is treated with deep suspicion only to be carried out by people with a death wish.

181lauralkeet
Edited: Jul 2, 2018, 9:39 pm

Rhian, I'm just stopping by to thank you for recommending A Very English Scandal. It was released on Amazon US last week, and we just finished watching tonight. What an excellent program. That was such an atypical role for Hugh Grant. I really enjoyed his portrayal. And Ben Whishaw is just wonderful. Thank you!!

182SandDune
Jul 3, 2018, 2:20 am

>181 lauralkeet: It’s great isn’t it? Hugh Grant was so convincing I thought. I saw an interview with David Steel, who succeeded Jeremy Thorpe as leader of the Liberal Party, where he said it was a pretty accurate portrayal.

>176 jnwelch: I do like the portrayal of South Wales in the books. Makes me feel quite homesick at times!

183AMQS
Edited: Jul 14, 2018, 10:58 pm

Dear Rhian, are you on your Baltic vacation right now? Hope it's wonderful, and hope to see pictures! I am embarrassed to realize (and even more so to admit) that I was so far behind that I hadn't even visited this thread! Yikes. I'm caught up now. You've been through a lot. I am so sorry about Sweep, and very, very sorry to hear about your aunt. I wish the very best for your mother - it is so hard as parents age, isn't it? I hope everything goes well for J., and I'm sorry he's had troubles with school. A visit to friends inDenmark sounds lovely.

Also - thanks for posting photos of your Pembrokeshire visit, and THANK YOU for your recommendations!! Marina and I had such a wonderful time in Wales. We truly loved every minute of it, and enjoyed spectacular weather. We found the Welsh people to be so very welcoming and friendly. Most assumed we were on a grand UK tour, and were very pleased to hear that we were there to visit Wales only. The countryside was stunning, the beaches lovely, the food delicious, the wine & beer very inexpensive (Marina did not care one way or the other but I was very pleased), the roads way too narrow, and I desperately want to go back. Thank you so much for your insight and advice.

184Ameise1
Jul 15, 2018, 4:21 am

Belated congratulations on your degree, Rhian. Enjoy your holiday at tha Baltic.
This topic was continued by SandDune reads in 2018: thread 3.