Carmenere's 2nd Cozy Corner

The Take It or Leave It Challenge: This will be directly incorporated into my 75 Books Challenge. Each month I'll pick something different that I think would be fun to read. Join me, if you'd like. Hint: Always check your TBR pile first when selecting a book!

June, 2010 TIOLI: I will read a Title w/a problem in it: An Imperfect Lens, A Sea of Troubles - Japanese author: Remains of the Day - A's have it: Animal Farm Profession in title: Death of a Salesman, Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress, Memoirs of a Geisha, The Bookseller of Kabul - Book about Africa Heart of Darkness - Author w/3 part name I'm stretching it a bit The Time Machine by H.G. Wells. I'm back again to the best book club in cyberspace (the 75 book challenge thread)! This year I have a plan. Working thru my TBR's (aka The Tipping Tower of Tomes) alphabetically (with some exceptions). In this manner I can read a selection of an author's works and compare each book easily. These books will occasionally be interspersed with books I need to get to immediately. I also plan to write my mini-reviews in a much more organized fashion (tip o' the hat to Joyce (Nickelini)
Here are my first 10 18 I will begin January 1st:
The Blind Assassin Margaret Atwood
Jude the Obscure Thomas Hardy (LT author of the month for January)
Eternal on the Water Joseph Monninger ARC
The Count of Monte Cristo Alexandre Dumas - Group Read
Wolf Hall Hilary Mantel
Mansfield Park Jane Austen
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban J.K. Rowling - Reread with son
The Last Dickens - Matthew Pearl
Old New York - Edith Wharton
The Shack - Wm. Paul Young - curiosity won out
Romancing Miss Bronte- Juliet Gael
The Simple Truth David Baldacci
Open House Elizabeth Berg
Tara Road Maeve Binchy
Scarlett Feather Maeve Binchy
Quentins Maeve Binchy
Malinche by Laura Esquivel
Mudbound by Hillary Jordan
Whitethorn Woods Maeve Binchy
The Double Bind Chris Bohjalian
Before You Know Kindness Chris Bohjalian

My rating system:
1 star - Find the nearest shredder
2 stars - Give it to someone you'll never see again
3 stars - Yard sale fodder
4 stars - Give it to someone you like
5 stars - Keep it for your personal library

Woop, I get to be the first on your new thread.

Highlight of my day :)

Welcome to the two-thread club!

I am here, too!

Glad your're all here! I'll be bringing out another tray of hot toddies and tea. Spareribs are in the slowcooker so they'll be out in about 6 to 8 hours.

I'll take the tea, thanks! (and the ribs for that matter)

What exactly is a hot toddy? Toddie?

Sure, I could google it, but asking lets me mark your thread without sounding spammy. ;)

Well Luxx, since my kitchen is rather large in my cyber cozy corner we can use some hot coffee, hot tea, hot cider or hot chocolate and add a little something, something from the equally large liquor cabinet to give it a little kick. But perhaps take the hot stuff neat until after 5pm.

Sounds good to me, although I'll make that 7pm, when the kiddies go to bed.

It's always 5pm somewhere in the world ;-)

I remembered you would rather have tea Stasia and it would make me so happy to share the ribs with you before you go off to work tonight.

That's the way I look at it, calm. Easy for me to say though, I'm a stay at home loafer.

#10

Hear hear

I'm a stay at home loafer

My dream job.

#11: I will gladly take the ribs before heading to work tonight, Lynda!

Another stay at home loafer here. The down side is that there is always something that needs to be done, although if I'm immersed in a good book, I am good at ignoring housework.

Lynda, I love your rating system. Your 2-star solution gave me my first good laugh of the day.

Continuing from your last thread...

I'm on Chapter 30 now of Mansfield Park. I think it's going to fall somewhere in the upper middle for me. I definitely like it better than Sense and Sensibility. I could like it better than Emma, depending on how the last half goes. I definitely like Pride and Prejudice better than it, so far. It's kind of neck and neck with Persuasion right now.

I'll be very interested to see what you think when you're done.

I cannot keep up with all these proliferating threads!!

Tad, everyone I know who is lukewarm about Mansfield Park has some issue with the personality of Fanny. P&P is def my favorite, followed by Sense and Sensibility and Persuasion, neck and neck. Then this and Emma, both of which have problematic heroines, in different ways.

I'm being a stay at home loafer, too. It's scary how easily I can get away with it. At least until this chunk of the book advance runs out...

Time to go and scrounge up some work, before I get too accustomed to the reading life.

>16 Donna828: Donna, it's my husband, also retired, who puts the flame under my burner. I could sit and read all day but he comes up with projects that can't seem to be done without me. We've got redecorating projects going on and March is maple tree tapping time, which actually allows for reading time while the sap cooks down. He is my reason for only read 4 books thus far in 2010 - but his projects are usually enjoyable.

>17 TadAD: & 18 Tad and Suzanne, I don't get it. I've heard that Fanny's personality is an issue to some but, so far - only chapter 10, I feel nothing but sympathy for poor, neglected Miss Price. I've come to expect a change for the worse later in the story. We'll see........

I think it's partly 20th century readers, encountering a character who, compared to those around her, seems downright prissy -- the "my morality is of a higher standard than your morality" POV that strikes us modern types as being OTT.

I'm not struck by her that way. I see her as very shy and insecure, which accounts for a lot of her behavior, but even the other stuff doesn't strike me as prissiness so much as respect for her uncle (in the issue of the play) and major crushing on Edmund combined with anger over Henry's treatment of her cousins. (OK, was that enough of a run-on sentence?)

What I like most of all about the book is the conclusion of each chapter. The last sentence always strikes me as a sly bit of humor, whether some idiocy from Mrs. Norris or Fanny making an inward observation that isn't necessarily complimentary about someone.

At this point, I feel I'm settling in on preferences that run as: Pride and Prejudice, Persuasion, Mansfield Park, Emma, Sense and Sensibility. I wonder what Northanger Abbey will bring when I try it later this year?

Hmm... I thought Northanger Abbey the weakest of 6 Austen novels. I think my list of preferences would run as: Pride and Prejudice, Sense and Sensibility, Emma, Persuasion, Mansfield Park and Northanger Abbey.

I liked Mansfield Park but I wanted Edward to be a stronger character and standing up for what he wanted, which was Fanny, instead of meekly going along with his engagement and only announcing his affection for Fanny once he was thrown over for his brother.

>21 TadAD: I will be interested in what you think about Northanger Abbey Tad. Keep in mind, that it was actually Austen's first novel and was published posthumously by her brother. Some say Austen was trying to satirize the gothic novel, but perhaps, IMO, she was just trying to find her niche. BTW thanks for the heads up on the last sentence thing, I'll begin to pay closer attention.

>20 Chatterbox: Sorry, Suzanne, I just don't see the prissiness at work yet. I wonder though if Fanny's need for exercise and her frequent bouts of fatigue indicate some kind of illness.

>22 cameling: I'll list my preference after I finish Mansfield Park Caroline, but I already know that Persuasion is dead last. Just didn't sit well with me.

Coverguess!! Bet you can't guess you has played it. Me! And I can't get enough of it! Not only has LT found another way to use up my precious reading time, they've also discovered a new way to show me more books that I just need to add to my wishlist. Urggggh.

#24: I took a look at it and (evidently) wisely decided I needed to stay away from it!

You're a wise one, Stasia ... it's got it's nasty little claws into me now... no turning back... I'm hooked! I may never read again.

#26: Uh oh.

Glad no one else is seeing the prissiness! This is something that some of my less book-addicted friends have said about Fanny on encountering her. I think her behavior is in line with what Austen's own heroines expect of themselves, as in S&S (Elinor trying to rein in Marianne's worst follies) and in P&P (Lizzie's thoughts on Lydia & ultimately on Wickham.)

This, from one blogger on Fanny: "Time and again I wanted to shout at the mousy little wisp of a thing, Fanny Price. I wanted to grab her and shake her, much as various characters wish to do no doubt at various points throughout. She is prissy, timid, moralizing, inflexible, and retiring — and we’re supposed to admire her."

ugh, checking posts 'cause I needed to take a break. Installing laminate flooring is such a pain in the ole pituti. :(

Been there, done that. Hardwood flooring also. Commiserating with you Lynda.

I'm pretty excited to be receiving an ER that I was really hoping for Romancing Miss Bronte by Juliet Gael. :)

Any kind of flooring installation is a pain in the every where ...been there, done that .. hopefully never to be suffered through again. My sympathies, Lynda.

Congratulations on snagging an ER book you wanted.

I got one I really wanted, too!! The Inheritance by Simon Tolkien.

Haha ..I snagged an ER book too ... Going, Gone by Laura Crum ... funny thing is that I don't remember requesting this. Still happy to snag it though and looking forward to receiving it.

I got one too; can't remember the name of it but it was the one book I requested.

Sounds like a bonus month for the 75 Book Challenge group! I am going to get Heartless by Anne Elisabeth Stengl.

Tad, did you request any this month? This could have been your chance!

stopping by to say I love the photos on your home page. Your cats look so pretty!

I played cover guess a few times these last few days...It is addictive.

I am supposed to be getting Wild Romance by Chloe Schama, a nonfiction book that sounds pretty good.

>36 ronincats:: I don't know. I got messages that I am both: a) receiving an ER book, b) am not receiving an ER book. I guess the postman will have to settle it for me.

I even scored one this time (first time in over a year!). I'm getting Pearl of China by Anchee Min.

Wow, it looks like a banner month for us 75ers. Congrats. Can't wait to see what you all think of your freebies.

>39 TadAD: They certainly don't make it easy for you Tad. If you are to get one, which book?

>39 TadAD:: LOL, I am (perhaps) receiving a book I don't remember even looking at...and am pretty sure I didn't request...'cause it's a bit outside the landscape of my normal reading!

I shall keep you in suspense, saying only that...should the "you will" message be correct and the "you won't" message incorrect...I shall be reviewing something whose most prominent tag so far is "Chick Lit"!

ETA: Given the book, I'm suspecting that the "you didn't manage to snag one" message is correct and the other is some kind mistake. They've happened before.

HA! Tad, that is too funny. It is always nice to nuture your softer side now and then. Seriously, I really hope you finally do get an ER soon.

Laminate flooring has been suspended due to perfect weather conditions for maple tree tapping.....

Joining this thread I was more intrigued by the maple tree tapping than your next read. We don't get to tap a lot of maple trees in Dublin. Sounds very exotic to me.

Funny, I got an ER book this month too, after not getting one for a year and a half! Which was weird, because when the program first started, I got one nearly every month... but anyway, I get one this time, so *yay* ... though for the life of me I can't remember what it's called. It has a scaly-looking eye on the front... LOL

YAY 75ers!

>44 kirsty: Sounds very exotic to me.
Kirsty, It is such a slow process cooking down the sap but it can be fun when the weather cooperates. Actually, it's not something alot of people do, so yes, it is kind of exotic.

>45 dk_phoenix: Isn't that discouraging Faith? I suppose we tend to appreciate them more when we finally do receive one. Anyway, I agree a "yay" is definately in order.

Hi, I try to read one new thread a day AND to say hello. -- I love your rating system, so clean and crisp! I like Northanger Abbey and Mansfield Park the best, in a way, maybe because they have ragged moments, boring moments, unsure moments? Emma, especially is so polished...... and P and P and S and S -- not a loose thread or crooked seam to be seen. I love them all, however, and can't help rereading them over and over! Frustrating as it is, not having time to read enough seems to be a sign of, you know, being fully engaged..... which is good thing......

Stasia, you'll have to tell me how the Schama book shapes up. It's her debut (she is daughter of Simon) and I almost requested it from Vine, but.... She's probably still in her mid/late 20s!

I haven't been asking for ER books lately because I have 2 outstanding reviews due from last summer, but the February books had several that looked really good so I went ahead and requested. To my surprise I got one even though I am so far behind on the reviews. (I have read the books and "reviewed" them on my thread last year, but I feel that somehow "real" reviews have to be better than what I put on my thread).

#49: You know, I wondered about the last name since it is not all that common. I have read a couple of Simon Schama's books.

Speaking of Simon Schama, I was able to obtain his pbs dvd regarding art. He did an incredible job. I learned quite a lot.

I highly recommend it:

http://www.pbs.org/previews/simonschama-powerofart/

Suzanne, Stasia and Linda, I am very pleased that you brought Simon Schama to my attention. I'll see what I can find on him at my library. Thanks, ladies.

>48 sibylline: Happy that you selected my thread to catch up on, Lucy. I can certainly relate to your line, Frustrating as it is, not having time to read enough seems to be a sign of, you know, being fully engaged..... which is a good thing...... I'll try this the next time my husband comes up with another brillliant project.......I'll continue reading and let him know that I'm "fully engaged" right now, I'll help you later ; )

Book #5
Mansfield Park by Jane Austen
1814
432 pgs
4.5/5 stars

Why I read it: Next alpha read from my TBR shelf. I have owned it for years.

Mini-Review:
Why is it when I'm on the train going east, everybody is going west? Why, when I am on the elevator going up, everybody else is on the elevator going down? Why is it that when so many readers seem to dislike Fanny Price and Mansfield Park, I absolutly love her as well as Mansfield Park?
Having read all of Austen's major works I sensed from the start that Mansfield Park would become my favorite. Austen's characters are richly drawn and each deciferable in their own way. Fanny is Cinderella to her well to do Aunts, Norris and Lady Bertram. I don't believe I have met a character that I dislike more than Aunt Norris. She requests that Fanny move to Mansfield from her crowded home in Portsmouth only to pawn her off on her sister's family headed by Lady and Lord Bertram. She is essentially a servant to them and is repeatedly reminded of her place within the family. Fanny is greatful to be at Mansfield and knows her place. Oh, how the family is shocked to find that a financially independendent gentleman is smitten with Fanny. Fanny's love however is with another similarly shocking young man who has his sights set on another. How will this love triangle be reduced to a duo? Will Aunt Norris ever get the comeuppance she justly deserves? Jane Austen, you tease, makes the reader dwell, hope, dream of a suitable outcome until the final chapter.
This book has suspense, shocking revelations and is much more mature in material than any other Austen I have read. I found Fanny to be an endearing creature who trusts her instincts despite what others may believe to be the best for her. You go, Fanny.

Would I recommend it: I truly recommend this novel, it is an absolute classic in my opinion.

#56: I am not sure I have ever read Mansfield Park to be honest. I will definitely have to now! Great review, Lynda.

Great review...thumbs up for your clever, insightful writing.

This book is on my shelf somewhere...oh where? Oh where? I have to find it.

>56 Carmenere:: I laughed at your review. By the time I got to the last line of the questions, I was expecting to hear, "Full story at 10:00."

Obviously, I agreed with you...what's not to like? Yet, it is different from other Austens, at least the four I've read (still have Northanger Abbey to go) and I guess it's to be expected that some won't like the change in formula.

Thanks for your kind words Stasia, Linda and Tad. I find it very easy to write a review when you become emotionally involved in a book.

Linda and Stasia, I hope you enjoy enjoy it.

OK Tad, (tapping foot, arms akimbo) I'll be waiting for your Northanger Abby review, looking forward to your thoughts on that one.

>60 Carmenere:: LOL. I downloaded an audio copy for my commute. It's next up after I finish O'Brian's The Ionian Mission...so some time next month.

I had already decided to say "OK, you've convinced me....I must get over being NOT ABOUT AUSTEN and try this one" when I saw Tad's post at #60. If it's in audio, I'll definitely give it a try. You all make it sound like I'm truly missing something, and who on earth wants to go to her grave with a tombstone saying "Here lies Tina....she never read Jane Austen"?

BTW TAD--- which audio do you have? There are two different versions showing my library's catalog, one read by Flo Gibson, one by Wanda McCaddon? Any preferences?

>62 tututhefirst:: Just in case it wasn't clear, Lynda and I were talking about Northanger Abbey at that point, not Mansfield Park. The NA is read by Donata Peters...it's what my library had.

I listened to Pride and Prejudice by Flo Gibson and really enjoyed her reading. Long afterwards, when discussing readers here on LT, some people have said something along the lines of, "Oh, people either love her or dislike her, she's so unique." I haven't the faintest idea what they were talking about...but, then, it's been a couple years since I listened. All I can say was, at the time, nothing seemed especially "unique" about her and I enjoyed her presentation of the story.

I've never heard anything by Wanda McCaddon.

Of the two, I'd personally go with Flo Gibson because she's a known quantity to me. However, maybe you're in the "dislike her" group. :-D

Loved your review Lynda. I'm afraid if I don't get a move on I will beat Tina to that tombstone carving. Jane Austen will be read before July! There; it's in writing and now I have to get to it. No more procrastinationg.

Oh yeah I thumbed your review, too.

>61 TadAD: Sounds like a great way to begin and end your workday, Tad. Enjoy!

>62 tututhefirst: Tina, you are one funny lady! Whether you decide to listen to it or read it, I hope you like it as much as I.

>64 brenzi: A thousand thank you's Bonnie. I'll check back with you in July, (scratch, scratch, scratch) I've just penciled it in on my calendar. Don't you and Tina go thinking about epitaphs 'cause hopefully, we all will be reading the books we didn't get to this go round on a cloud on the other side :)

I am just so tickled pink and I thank all of the LTer's who have given my review of Mansfield Park a thumbs up. I've been included in Hot Reviews all weekend, the longest for me, ever.

>56 Carmenere:: A well-deserved hot review. I, too, am a fan of Fanny. I also liked Emma as an Austen character (and book). I read all of Austen several years ago and discovered I liked the quirky characters better than the "good" (but kinda boring) girls.

Happy Almost Birthday! I may be out of town on the 22nd, so I wanted to be sure to take a minute and wish you all the best! I hope the day is as special as you are!

Ya know Donna, it makes sense that you would like Fanny too. We both share a great taste in many of the same books and now heroines. If you like pickle sandwiches as much as I, I'd say we were probably separated at birth :O

Love those balloons, Linda :)

Pickle sandwiches...

My favorite sandwich is bologna with miracle whip and sweet pickles...

Guess I'm heading to the store tomorrow to obtain these items...

>71 Whisper1:: This sounds only one step above pickles with ice cream! Ack!

:-D

>71 Whisper1:: Oh my... now I feel a bit queasy... o_O ...haha *urp*

>69 Carmenere:: I like pickles, and lots of 'em, on my sandwiches, but I draw the line at a sandwich with only pickles!

Please may I have permission to go and throw up after reading this? Thank you

Oh, come on people! It's really not all that bad, especially if Bread and Butter pickles are used, my favorite. If anyone gets the nerve to try it, I recommend toasting the bread simply because untoasted bread gets too soggy. OK, it's not gourmet but when you're reading and you need a quick snack, it can't be beat. : }

You people are sick. I am with Jenny.

OK, OK! That's the last time I'll be sharing recipes from my private collection of savory dishes.,,,,,Just wait, Rachel Ray will be calling me any day now, you'll see, uh huh. :>)

These NCAA brackets are making my head spin. What upsets! :o

Wait... let me get this straight..........there are only pickles on the sandwich?? Nothing else?? I'm usually a pretty adventurous gustatory experimenter but just pickles?? Yikes!

#78: I am with you all the way, Darryl! Of course, I have a husband who eats Miracle Whip on saltines. I cannot even be in the same room with him when he does that. Ick.

These NCAA brackets are making my head spin. What upsets! :o

My two brackets for my group's pool just went down in flames, after Kansas and Villanova both lost today. The previous losses by the Big East teams (Georgetown, Notre Dame, Louisville and Marquette) caused moderate damage, but those two games today were probably fatal blows, since I had 'Nova in the Final Four and KU as the winner in both brackets. Maybe next year...

>80 brenzi: Yes, just pickles Bonnie :o)

>81 alcottacre: Mmmmm, not! But perhaps he'll be getting a call from Rachel too.

>82 kidzdoc: I'm still alive Daryl in that I've chosen Pitt for National Champion, however with the losses to Gtown and Kansas my midwest is trashed.

Surprisingly enough, my second bracket is in first place in the work pool bracket. However, that bracket has KU and 'Nova playing in the championship game. So, I'll get passed by whomever didn't pick Kansas, Villanova or Georgetown to make the Elite Eight or Final Four, unless there is a Final Four from Bizarro World (Northern Iowa, Saint Mary's, Washington, Gonzaga). My East region is perfect so far (including the U-Dub beatdown of UNM), and only one of my teams from the West bracket has been eliminated (Murray State, although I correctly picked them to beat Vanderbilt). My Midwest bracket is a complete disaster, and my Mideast bracket is nearly so, although I can salvage points if Cal keeps winning (I have them going to the Elite Eight).

My first bracket has Pitt and WVU making the Final Four. Unfortunately I still have KU and 'Nova in the championship game.

According to ESPN's Tournament Challenge, only 0.3% of the brackets have Northern Iowa in the Sweet 16, and over 42% picked Kansas to win it all. Oops.

#81: Stasia, that concoction (which I refuse to name) should be illegal.

My brackets are in flames. With Xavier's defeat of Pittsburgh it's all over for me.
Bring on the baseball season, then again, Wall Street Journal gave the Indians a 0% chance of reaching the postseason. I guess I'll get a lot of reading done this spring and summer. : oP

Today was a complete disaster for my brackets. My second bracket slipped from first to 18th, and my first bracket is now 28th. Even worse, with today's losses by Cal, Pitt, Wisconsin and Missouri, my chances to make up any ground have evaporated. I'll still follow the tournament, and hope that one or both of the remaining Big East teams can win out.

I can't find the WSJ article you're referring to, but I did find an article on Fox News about a NJIT (New Jersey Institute of Technology) professor who predicts that the Indians will finish in last place in the AL Central, with 67 wins. He has the Phillies winning the NL East, with 90 wins.

I hope you have a wonderful birthday (despite the flaming brackets), Lynda!

The thing that bothers me most Daryl is, having been burnt in the past, I decided to dismiss Ohio State. Now that Kansas has been eliminated it makes the road to the Final Four wide open to OSU. Shame on me :(

The prediction in WSJ was only a side bar to their sports section. Their source was predictionmachine.com

Thanks Stasia, flaming brackets won't hold me back it's all flaming candles that concern me (fire extinguisher at the ready) :o)

Happy Birthday to yooouuuu....

Have a wonderful birthday today, Lynda. I hope you get to sneak in a pickle sandwich as a special treat. ;)

glitter-graphics.com

Haaaappy Birthday!!! Hope you get to eat lots of (non-pickle) treats! ;)

Happy birthday!

Sher, Donna, Bonnie, Faith and Doc, Thanks so much for your good wishes. You are all so nice - now I'm off to the store to pick up a few things.....yes, even bread and butter pickles!

March birthdays are wonderful. I hope you have a happy one!

The pickle sandwich (with bread and butter pickles) sounds fine to me!

Happy Birthday! Hope it's a great day.

Happy Birthday to you!

Happy Birthday Lynda!!

Happy Birthday, Lynda! Try pickles on a grilled cheese sandwich. I use dill, but I'll bet bread & butter would be good too! My mother makes a batch of bread & butter pickles once a year. I'll have to remember to try it...

Happy Birthday! I love pickle sandwiches. I use those large garlic pickles that come in a barrel. I've never tried it with bread and butter pickles. Hmm.
Back to lurking...

Happy Pickle Day Birthday!

Wow, I am overwhelmed and overjoyed by your good wishes. Thanks to:
>96 London_StJ: Hey Luxx, *fist bump*
>97 ronincats: Roni! Finally, someone who appreciates the finer things in life :)
>98 Whisper1: Linda, one of my first LT friends! :0)
>99 FAMeulstee: Anita, Thanks for the very far away greetings!
>100 tloeffler: Oh, I have, I have Terri and it is so very, very good. We tried growing pickling cucumbers last summer and they shriveled :}
>101 cameling: Caroline, as busy as you are travelling, thanks for taking the time to stop by.
>102 VioletBramble: Kelly, I see you, too, have developed a palate for exquisite concoctions!
>103 kidzdoc: Last but not least Daryl, thanks for the picklicious greeting.

I'm leaving this thread and refusing to come back until all pickles are gone. You lot are just too strange, even for me and that's saying something!!

You lot are just too strange,

Thanks lc, I appreciate the compliment :0) Unique is a good alternative to strange too.

Belated Happy Birthday. Hope you had a great day!

Happy birthday Lynda!

I don't know if dill pickles are gherkins, or if bread and butter pickles are gherkins, but where I come from there are just gherkins and I love them! (But #100 Terri - pickle and cheese is just too strange... a bit like peanut butter and jelly if you're not American).

>108 cushlareads: Cushla,

Is that a suggestion that peanut butter and jelly is odd, unusual, weird, not eaten in other parts of the world? How odd, unusual, weird out of the ordinary ;-)

> 109: Yes! But we have other odd, unusual and weird (eating) habits :-)

And I do like pickles/gherkins or whatever you call those, but not on bread...

>108 cushlareads: Thanks Cushla! Those cute little gherkins are terrific but I'm with Anita on this one, I like them beside a sandwich, not on it.

Happy birthday! (Only a day late)

>112 _Zoe_: You're not a day late at all Zoe. I celebrate all week long.

O.K enough of this tomfoolery it's time to get back to work.

Book #6 Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban by J.K. Rowling
1999
435 pgs
5/5 stars

Why I read it: A reread with my son.

Mini-Review: It's all been said before and I can not add anything new for review. But I will say that personally I feel that Ms. Rowling's imagination is in peak form for this novel, #3 in the series. The dementors are such frightful creatures. Imagine, they have the ability to suck out a persons very soul with The Kiss.....eeek. Little ones need not be all that frightend for brave Harry Potter, with the help of friends in high places, fend off these prison guards with a little...what else.....magic.

Would I recommend it: Of course I would. Harry Potter takes the reader to a world full of fantastical events and unique characters while bringing back old friends and foes to round out a thrilling plot.

> 114: Lynda
I am so glad I read the Harry Potter books recently, now I can really appriciate the conversations about the books!

Happy (somewhat) belated birthday! Sorry I can't do dancing pickles, or make your brackets come back to life, but happy year anyway... :-)

I adore Harry Potter. He combines all the best elements of the English school story (midnight feasts and sports matches and outwitting the bullies) with some cool fantasy stuff, like dementors. Oh, and those matches are quidditch instead of field hockey or lacrosse! Love it....

#114: I just re-read that one recently too. It remains my favorite in the series.

#7
The Last Dickens Matthew Pearl
2009
386 pages
3.5/5 stars

Why I read it: March TIOLI challenge: LT author

Mini-Review:
Is it at all possible that opium, murder, Bookeneers and greedy publishers played a significant part in Charles Dickens' last and perhaps unfinished novel, The Mystery of Edwin Drood? Author Matthew Pearl seems to think so in his novel, The Last Dickens and weaves an intricate storyline which is nicely presented in a period style six installments.
The reader travels with Dicken's during his last tour of the U.S., then on to India where the opium trade is integral to many countries and of course England where Dickens died. Where are the last installments of Edwin Drood? Who has them? Were they in fact written, if not, who will complete them? A lot of money rests on the answers and some cutthroat publishers will stop at nothing to find them.

In The Last Dickens, Matthew Pearl attributes this quote to Charles Dickens, "The books do pretend...But that is not all. Novels are filled with lies, but squeezed in between is even more that is true - without what you may call the lies, the pages would be too light for the truth, you see? The writer of books always puts himself in, his real self, but you must be careful of not taking him for his next door neighbor." It is appropriate because Pearl does a fabulous job walking in Dickens' footsteps. Fact melds with ficton and one can hardly see where one ends and the other begins.

Would I recommend it:
The novel is rather slow at times and for that I would rate it a three but a four star conclusion brings it to 3 1/2 stars

One thing that suprised me while reading The Last Dickens was the way people reacted to Dickens as he travelled thru Boston, New York etc. It was comparable to the way celebraties are treated today ie. droves of people waiting for tickets, groupies, ducking the masses, making today's paparazzi nothing new at all.

I need to read Dickens book about his American visit. I have not read it yet. Have you, Lynda?

#120 Nope, not yet. Is there one?

Yes, it is called American Notes.

Ooooo, thanks again Stasia. I never would have known about this one and by Dickens himself, none the less. I requested the book from my library's ILL.

No problem. I am going to try and pick up a copy of it when I am at the library today. We can compare notes :)

I was just looking at Drood at the bookstore this weekend, and it sounds like Simmons and Pearl have similar goals. Very interesting.

My wonderful neighborhood library's booksale did not disappoint. 29 books for $13. Many of the books I found were recommended to me by many of you.
Some real catches: Child 44
The Book Thief
gods behaving badly
The Known World
The Hummingbirds Daughter
Into Thin Air
Into the Wild
84, Charing Cross Road

I could go on and on but hey.....I've got some reading to do :0)

29 books=$13

Now that is a deal!

Woot! What a haul!!

> 126 Gosh, were you ever lucky!!! What great finds! I am envious but happy for you all the same.

What, what a nicer haul. You're going to have a great time reading those book. Congratulations! I guess we won't need to ask what you'll be doing this fine weekend... ;-)

Nice...

#8
The Simple Truth David Baldacci
1998
470 pgs
2.5 stars/5

Why I read it: Next book in alpha order on TBR shelf - picked it up on vacation on the book exchange shelf

Mini-Review A mystery/thriller in the same vein as Grisham and Patterson. Seemingly intelligent people doing stupid things - The formulaic characters and storyline left me emotionless.

Would I recommend it:I don't think so.

>132 Carmenere:: Somehow, Baldacci has never wowed me. Some of his books reach the "mildly recommended" category, but never much beyond that. The only exception is The Christmas Train...but here I freely admit I'm a sucker for Christmas stories at Christmas time and they always get unfair treatment from me.

I enjoyed The Christmas Train as well, Tad. I enjoy train travel so if an author adds the ambiance of snow & Christmas to that it adds up to a winner for me. That's probably why I can't get enough of The Polar Express, book and movie.

#132: Skipping that one! I hope you enjoy your next book more, Lynda.

>134 Carmenere:: I enjoy train travel

One of my greatest disappointments is that train travel in the United States is so poor. I live on the NE Corridor, so trips to Washington or Boston are great. Anything beyond that is painful. The schedules are erratic because freight trains take precedence; equipment is uncomfortable and ill-maintained. The family took a trip down to Myrtle Beach once on the train. As far as Virginia it was fine. Then, bathrooms became disgusting, food unpalatable in the extreme.

We were in England last year and, listening to folks complaining about the trains, all we could think was, "If only you knew!!"

I understand that the economics just aren't there for the distances in America, but I wish it were otherwise.

I wonder what it's like in Canada? I've always wanted to take the Toronto to Vancouver route ever since reading Dick Francis' The Edge but, given how expensive it is, I'll have to do some research first to make sure it's really a pleasant trip and not another Myrtle Beach hold-your-nose-when-you-pee type of thing.

I wonder what it's like in Canada? I've always wanted to take the Toronto to Vancouver route

Oh, wouldn't that be a beautiful trip.

To clarify, my only experiences with traveling by train occured through scenic routes. Grand Canyon Railway in Arizona. What locals call the Heber Creeper in Utah etc.

Have not yet used Amtrak because it is so unnatural to board at 2 AM out of Cleveland.

I did that trip, from Vancouver to Toronto, and it was amazing. That was back in the summer of 1980, when I was 18. My parents had just moved to Tokyo, flying out of Vancouver, and I traveled back to Toronto solo for my second year of university. It was three nights and four days, and it took me more than a week before I no longer felt that I was sleeping in a train! That was when they still had what I call "real" trains on that route, not just tourist trains or really bad local services. I'm not sure it's an experience I could replicate today. I had what they called a "roomette", with a large seat that was pulled out to make a bed at night. First overnight was in the Rockies; second in the prairies and third in Northern Ontario. There were those observation cars, where you could go up a flight of stairs and be in an area that was all windows, and get a panoramic view. I particularly remember sunset on the prairies -- all sky, and the colors were astonishing.

I've travelled on the Coast Starlight from Seattle to Portland and from Los Angeles to San Francisco, and from New York to Toronto, Toronto to Montreal, Montreal to NYC. The only sleeper train we did was Toronto to Montreal, and it was a fun experience. I'd love to do a longer US train journey.

The trains aren't frequent enough, not very fast and the schedules are at weird times, but the seating is quite comfortable with lots of space compared to a lot of UK trains.

#9
Old New York Edith Wharton
1924
315 pgs.
4/5 stars

Why I read it TIOLI short story challenge, tbr shelf, April-readathon

Mini-ReviewI do not particularly care for short stories. I am always looking for the connect, the constant that holds the stories together. Now, I realize, that is not and should not always be the case but when a selection of stories comes together that happens to offer a cohesive string I become completely satiated. I found Old New York by Edith Wharton quenches this appetite of mine and left me satisfied.
The four novellas taking place in the mid to late 1800's offers a glimpse of a young New York City. To read Old New York one would think that it is populated by well to do aristocrats and their help. Their society has strict traditions or rules if you will. One should behave in a proper manner, suitable for their class. However, we are introduced to 4 individuals who think outside the box, non-conformists. They are so, sometimes by chance, sometimes by nature, sometimes by both. As Wharton relates in her story New Year's Day, "But such daring spirits were few in old New York, their appearances infrequent and somewhat furtive." Their decisions touched the lives of friends and family alike and cemented them in their place in society.
This selection of stories is somewhat like a study in sociology and can certainly relate to the tradtional quirks of any era.

Would I recommend itSure, if you are looking for a good selection of short stories covering an era lost to history.

Just taking my little corner of cyberspace to give a shout out the the Cavs. Go Cavs! Perhaps Cleveland's first championship in some forty years is finally within reach. :0)

#141: Since I have no interest in basketball whatsoever, I will cheer along side you for the Cavs. Forty years is an awfully long time with no championship.

That's the funkiest basketball I've ever seen, Stasia! But the sentiment is much appreciated :0)

Lynda, I'm way behind on reading the posts. I'm catching up on your thread today.

Going back to the pickle posts...message 103....
I'm going to drive Darryl bonkers by saying I love pickles and miracle whip on a sandwich!!!

Post 133...I'm adding the Christmas Train to the pile. It sounds delightful.

I've never read Wharton but I have Age of Innocence on my shelf. Your review of the novellas has piqued my interest Lynda. Thumb!

I'm going to drive Darryl bonkers by saying I love pickles and miracle whip on a sandwich!!!

Ack! Not as bad as Miracle Whip on Saltine crackers, though...

I love Edith Wharton -- the 'sleeper' -- the one nobody reads that I think is the most amazing of all is called Summer. She was very ahead of her time. I also love a late novel called The Children.

sibyx...Thanks for recommending these Edith Wharton books.

Sibyx--I read The Children a couple of years ago and also thought it was very good. It wasn't written that much earlier than Lolita, but what a very different treatment of some similar themes.

>149 arubabookwoman: I need to think about that -- it is in my 'revisit' pile! We're moving and I've been packing like a madwoman, and I pulled it out as a book I had really enjoyed but couldn't remember well enough other than some scattered images and a strong positive reaction..... often about thirty pages (or less) in the whole thing just unfolds in my head again. Strange indeed that process.

I have Ethan Frome and The Age of Innocence on the Tipping Tower of Tomes but I had not heard of the others you mentioned. So, naturally, on to the wish list they go.

Lynda...
I'll be very interested in learning your thoughts/feelings regarding Ethan Frome

>152 Whisper1: Get comfortable, Linda. It is going to be a long while............unless a challenge of some sorts comes up that fits.

#10
The Shack Wm. Paul Young
2007
250 pgs.
2/5 stars

Why I read it It was recently gifted to me and put on the Tipping Tower of Tomes for later reading until the comments of fellow LTer's (and you know who you are) peaked my curiosity.

Mini-Review Because some people have found this book to be life changing and enlightening I'm going to try to tread lightly as I review this novel.
This fictional account of Mack Phillips' troubled life takes an unusual turn after he receives a note in his mailbox, signed by God, inviting him to return to the dilapidated old shack where his six year old daughter was murdered three years ago. Is this some kind of joke? Is the murderer setting him up for further terror or could this actually be from....God? Mack apprehensively obliges and in so doing has quite an experience.
I found this story to be at times humorous, slightly entertaining, cautiously amusing and absolutely, definately..... predictable.

Would I recommend it No. If someone desires to know God better, develop a relationship with him, with Jesus and the Holy Spirit, I would first suggest a study Bible and a knowledgeable group to discuss your reading.

ETA: because LT cut me off in mid review.

"Treading lightly..." is a good idea with this book. When I saw the emotional response it had on some people in my group, I knew I had to keep an open mind (and a closed mouth!) about it. I think it will lead some people to that deeper relationship with God. In those cases, the book was a success. Nice tiptoeing!

nice tiptoeing indeed.

Oh...yeah..tiptoeing...ok...I get it.

Hi, just dropped in to read your thread. Great reviews. I know I'm late to the party but I love Mansfield Park! I think I will read that again soon!

I started Ethan Fromme years ago with a book club but never finished it. I'll be interested to read your perceptions.

>155 Donna828: Yes, I agree with you Donna. I felt that if this book is what it takes for a person to be drawn to God, become more curious about Him, then so be it.

>158 PetHairMagnet: Thanks for dropping in PHM. Please do so again.

#11
Open House Elizabeth Berg
2000
241 pages
3.5/5

Why I read it Purchased from a booksale, it has been fermenting on the Tower of Tomes for a while & next up in alpha order.

Mini-Review
Open House is the story of Samantha Morrow's pathetic attempt to keep her husband from divorcing her and continue living as she and their son, Travis had come to expect. Although their marriage appeared stable to her, David, her husband, believes they have nothing in common. At the onset I must admit I despised "Sam". Totally dependant upon her husband she comes across as needy, prejudicial, impetuous and insecure. I found her unsuccessful attempts to draw her husband back into her life and their home were absolutely pathetc. Author, Elizabeth Berg, has me believing that a long, hot contemplative bath will somehow cleanse Sam of her sorry self and take control of ther situation - alas, it does not.
Perhaps it is Travis' request to live with his father that is the catalyst that moves her to let go of the past. His request was heartbreaking and was the moment when I finally sympathized with Sam and began liking her just a little bit.
Could it be that what she wants in life is what her mother, Veronica had once known and boarder, Lydia has just regained? Undying, eternal love? Perhaps it is not so distant nor unattainable as she believes.
By story's end, I had grown to like Samvery much and had hope that she had found her way. Berg is such a talented writer, she can make the reader gasp and laugh in the same paragraph. She subtly turns Sam from a distressed, no talent, domestic princess into a stronger more empowered woman who can see life does not end when a marriage ends.
If this is an example of Berg's work I most certainly wish to read more.... and soon.

Would I recommend itYes, whether you have gone through a divorce or not you will find it to be a quick and entertaining read.

I liked Berg's Dream When You're Feeling Blue when I read it a couple years ago. You might give that one a try, Lynda.

Thanks for your recommendation Stasia. I will keep my eyes open for Dream When you're feeling Blue.

I hope you enjoy it!

I enjoy Berg too -- another author who writes a bit similarly who I like even better is Sarah Lewis -- especially --The Answer is Yes. I haven't tracked down what she's written lately, keep meaning to. Entertaining and sensible stuff indeed.

>164 sibylline: Thanks for the recommendation, Lucy. I will certainly add Ms. Lewis to my wishlist.

I can not believe it myself, but I only spend $4.50, well actually $9.50, I had to renew my FotL membership to get in, at my library's booksale. What a dud but I did walk off with The Things They Carried which is really hot here in LTworld, A sea of troubles by Donna Leon (thanks tutu), The Infinite Plan by Isable Allende and Malinche by Laura Esquivel. I purchased Empire Falls for the second time (the first one still sits on my shelf, obviously forgotten)...and I think my husband already has my other purchase The Discoverers. But the four which I really wanted made it all worth it. That's it for booksales till autumn now I just need to read like crazy and clear off some shelf space. :}

Good reason to eat out tonight!

Gotta love those library book sales!

>167 Carmenere:: We stayed in and made tacos!

Hey Faith, My husband and I took our mom's out for lunch (Polish restaurant) yesterday and we had way to much to eat so we really weren't too hungry for dinner. So tonight we will celebrate Seis de Mayo!

I so intended to finish Quentins last night when a huge storm rolled thru my neighborhood, bringing with it hail, lightening, rain and high winds - then the power went out. So went to bed and the dawn showed us the disaster that struck. Trees uprooted, tree limbs scattered everywhere, leaves plastered to the house and windows. We learned that a small tornado formed over the little lake in our development and ripped thru a stretch that included our yard. Spent all day cleaning up, so my hopes are to finish Quentins tonight with review tomorrow....unless I fall asleep early.

Oh boy Lynda, we've had 50 mph winds here but no damage to speak of and no tornado as far as I know. Good luck getting everything restored (or as close to restoration as possible).

Lynda
My daughter called last night to tell me of a tornado warning in Beavercreek/Dayton Ohio. As I type, the winds here are 40-50 mph and the huge tree in my neighbors yards snapped and crashed into the yard.

Wow! I hope everyone is OK!

Thanks for your comments ladies. Our neighbor put it all into perspective with his comments regarding Katrina and the mess they had to face. So after that, all the neighbors worked together to saw, stack, chip and rake everything back to order. Only the leaves which were tossed onto the house and roof by natures food processor remain.

I hope you have a Happy Mother's Day in spite of the circumstances, Lynda!

#12
Quentins by Maeve Binchy
2002
359 pages
2/5 stars

Why I read it: TIOLI one word title challenge for May. Somewhat next on the TBR shelf in alpha order.

Mini-Review
Quentins is obviously the third in a series of novels written by Maeve Binchy. Although the other stories are referenced in this book it is not necessary to have read them in order to understand the connections. In this respect Ms. Binchy does an admirable job. However, there is little else to her writing style that makes me enthusiastic to read the other books, of which I own three.
The pace of the story flows so quickly, as if watching a movie in fast forward mode. Ella meets Don at a party – poof, they’re in bed – poof, they’re in love – poof, there are problems – poof, Ella finds a diversion – poof, Ella and her friends will make a documentary of Quentins, the go to restaurant which will suit any occasion – poof…..no wait – the flow of the story comes to a screeching halt as the reader reads the stories of several life changing events which took place at Quentins and made it such a special place. That done, poof, Ella’s story continues in the same fast paced fashion till all is happily rectified at the novels conclusion.
No sweetener required in my coffee this morning, I have already had way too much sugar.

Would I recommend it?
If you enjoy soft corn. A quick summer read that does not take much thought nor concentration.

#176 thanks Stasia and to you as well. Hopefully a nice day of reading for all moms.

#177: I had that one in the Black Hole. I think I will just take it right back out again. I hope you enjoy your next read more!

I've read two of Binchy's novels, Quentins and Scarlet Feather, and I find her formula pretty much as you describe. Some people have told me that her earlier books are a little different but, even though I own a copy of Light a Penny Candle, I don't have any real motivation to pick it up.

I do have motivation, Tad! Read them quickly, tie them together and sell them as a set at my next yard sale in September. The sooner I can move on to the next "B" author on my shelves the better.

I think you've pretty much explained why I've never read Binchy although I've been tempted. Nice review Lynda.

Circle of Friends is one of her earlier works and it is not too sweet or syrup filled. It was made into a movie and I liked this as well.

Echoing Linda's comments in Msg. 183. Binchy's earlier works were better than the latest drivel. They may be in the "soft corn" category (love that phrase, Lynda), but at least the earlier stories made sense and were good for whiling away an afternoon with a cuppa tea. I couldn't finish Quentins.

Unfortunately, Circle of Friends is not one of the Binchy's wich remain on my shelf. And silly me, I had the gaul to pick up another one at the latest booksale I found myself drawn to. Now, the title is even making me cringe Firefly Summer. I feel obligated, to at least, try to speed read thru them.

I thought Quentins was ok but she's written much better books. I preferred the earlier ones but even some of the more recent ones were better than Quentins - the last I read was set on a Greek island. My memory is that I quite enjoyed Firefly Summer. They are light reading.

First of all, the Cavs once again proved why it is so very, very difficult to be a fan of Cleveland sports teams. Build us up only to let us down. :(

>186 elkiedee: That is good news to me, elkiedee. I'll be approaching Firefly Summer with a little less trepidation.

Malinche by Laura Esquivel
2006
186 pages
2.5 stars

Why I read it TIOLI Latin American Author - Rev me up for my forthcoming vacation to Mexico

Mini-ReviewMalinche is best described as a novel of historical fiction. The title character, Malinalli also known as Malinche or Dona Marina was actually very real and played an integral part in Cortes’s conquest of Tenochtitlan, the capital of the Aztec Empire.
Malinalli was purchased by Cortes to be his translator and to interpret the many dialects he would encounter during his trek towards Tenochtitlan especially important were the words of Montezuma whose city of gold Cortes so desired. Malinalli knew she was in a very precarious situation, one in which she held much power in her words but in translation brought death and destruction to a powerful and proud group of people whose blood she shared.
For any fan of Laura Esquivel who expects lyrical prose, magical realism and vivid depictions of love and nature, I must warn you, you will not find it between these pages. The supposed love affair between Cortes and Malinche comes off more like a lust affair on the part of Senor Cortes. Other than Malinalli’s vivid dreams of the four elements of nature and images of her gods there is little else in this novel that resembles Like Water for Chocolate or The Law of Love. Granted the conquest of Mexico is a very serious and complicated subject but it seems Esquivel’s style of writing does not do it justice. Trying to include historical, cultural and personal information only produced a disjointed and incohesive product.

Would I recommend it It is alright for an introduction into the conquest of Mexico however I am positive that there must be other books both fiction and non fiction that will do a better job. IOW I wouldn't really recommend it.

#188: OK, I will pass on that one even though I did enjoy her Like Water for Chocolate several years ago.

I loved Like Water for Chocolate so this is disappointing but I'm not sure too many writers have more than one five star book in them.

Here I thought I was done with booksales until November but my development put on a booksale I could not refuse - proceeds go to the upkeep of landscaping. Only a few caught my attention but I am completely satisfied. Numero UNO!!!! Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet, (I was hoping for The Help too but no luck, not quite as great but two that I would have gotten around to eventually, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo and The Girl who played with Fire and lastly a roadtrip read Open Road:A celebration of the American Highway

Nice haul!

#14 Romancing Miss Bronte by Juliet Gael
2010
414 pages
4.5 stars

Why I read it May TIOLI Challange - Early Reader selection

Mini-ReviewFor the life of me I cannot understand why I was so hesitant to read this novel in the historical fiction genre. Perhaps I was expecting more fiction than fact, more fluff than substance. What a pleasant surprise to discover that Romancing Miss Bronte was nothing like that at all.
Ms. Gael's prose is somewhat Austenesque although her subject matter is nowhere near Ms. Austen's well to do, charming, close-knit family with suitors stumbling over each other. This is the story of the family Bronte headed by a patriarch who is curate of the little Yorkshire town of Haworth and perhaps living through his own grief he pays little attention to his lonely, tragic brood who resort to creating their own imaginary worlds through stories and poetry. Though their brother, Branwell struggles with his own demons, the girls, Emily, Anne and Charlotte devise a plan to publish their works under pseudonyms. The rest is literary history which Ms. Gael relates with a well researched eye. Many a reader is sure to see the love that Ms. Gael holds for her subjects as it comes through in a tender and almost sorrowful and sympathetic manner while still being truthful.
I struggle giving this novel 4.5 stars when I know I should give 5, yet that would place it in the realm of Wolf Hall and perhaps it is not quite there, but so very, very close – as close as Charlotte was to a life of happiness and contentment.

Would I recommend it Yes, I certainly do!

Lynda

Romancing Miss Bronte sounds delightful!

It does indeed!

Yessiree! Onto the pile.

#194: Well, I thought I had that one in the BlackHole already, but discovered I did not, so now I do! Thanks for the review and recommendation, Lynda.

Now that LOST has seen its conclusion perhaps I'll have more time to read books instead of blogs. It was a great run none the less and thanks to the LTer's who brought me to LOST thru its literary connections.

>199 Carmenere: I'm crushed that it's over. Did you like the finale?

I actually enjoyed the finale very much, LL23 (that's Jack's number). I never had any expectations of having all the mysteries answered so I wasn't let down. The storyline, characters, acting and of course the book references, although those were few and far between towards the end have been sooooo different from anything else on tv and I welcomed it.

I also liked the ending, Lynda. It would seem pointless to answer all the little things that weren't explained. Life just doesn't wrap up so neatly as that! I'm wondering how "Lost" will affect future television programs, although I'm very much in favor of less TV and more reading!

> 194 Romancing Miss Bronte sounds great! Great comments! Onto the list it shall go.

# 202 I'm wondering how "Lost" will affect future television programs,

I fear, very little but I'm hoping for the best.

#203 I think you'll enjoy it .

# 15 Mudbound - Hillary Jordan
2008
328 pages
3.5 stars

Why I read it: My local library's book club

Mini Review: To paraphrase an episode of Lost -There are two sides, one is light the other is dark – These forces are very recognizable in Hillary Jordan’s novel, Mudbound. It is a well written story told in the voices and perspectives of six narrators, two of which are young men returning from their tours of duty in WWII. During the war, they fought for the same side against a common enemy, back home in Mississippi the war still rages. This war, by all accounts, would certainly divide these two soldiers yet their common bonds of the terrors seen in that foreign conflict draws them together to face another battle on home soil. You see, one is white, the other is black. One is Jamie, the brother of the owner of the farm, Mudbound, the other, Ronsel, the son of the farms share tenant. Ronsel found that color barriers in Europe were virtually non-existent and upon his return to Mississippi he mistakenly believed that the people whose freedoms he fought for would treat him as more of an equal, possibly with a little more respect, but some things and some people are just not ready for change in the Mississippi Delta. It is the ignorance and hatred that Pappy and his cronies live and breathe that sets the tone for conflict, oppression and bigotry. Is racism the only conflict in Mudbound? No, there are other struggles but they are more subtle, the not so in your face struggles but the internal conflicts that one must find the courage and grace to face off and ultimately they will either break you or make you.

Would I recommend it: Absolutely, especially on this Memorial Day weekend as a reminder to thank a vet.

#205: I already have that one in the BlackHole. I guess I better bump it up some!

I hope you do, Stasia.

Oh Lynda, that one made my Top 10 last year so I think I liked it more than you did. I could not believe it was a debut novel. Her writing was pitch perfect to me; loved it :)

>208 brenzi: I was very moved by the novel, Bonnie. In fact, like Ronsel, my dad served under Patton and many of Ronsel's memories reflected my dad's, especially those at Dachau. Only the relationship between Jamie and Laura held me back from giving this novel four stars. I found it just a bit predictable. But you are correct, as a debut novel it is quite an achievement.

I read Mudbound a few years ago. Your review captures the book wonderfully.

Thank you, Linda. When I borrowed it from the library I had not realized that it has been out for awhile. Seems like I'm so wrapped up in my TBR shelves that I don't get the newer stuff 'til it's old.

Lynda -Nice review of Mudbound. I loved it when I read it. Did you know it won the Bellwether Prize, an award that goes to an unpublished novel that addresses issues of social justice? Barbara Kingsolver is the founder of the prize. The Girl Who Fell from the Sky, which was released earlier this year, won the award too. I haven't read that one yet.

#212: I have The Girl Who Fell from the Sky home from the library now. I hope I like it - I do not do very well with prize winners unfortunately.

Thanks porch_reader. Yes I learned of the award on the book flap. Well deserving of it too. On your mention, I've added The Girl who fell from the Sky to my wishlist to see what another Bellwether winner looks like.

Stasia, better luck with those prize winners!

Death of a Salesman
Arthur Miller
1949
139 pages
5/5

Why I read it:June TIOLI - A title which includes a profession - from TBR shelf

Mini-Review:In Arthur Millers play Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman is portrayed as a pathetic braggart, transparent, insecure, delusional, lying philanderer who believes that to get ahead in life one only needs to be “well-liked”. He drives all along the Eastern corridor of the United States selling his product to buyers who he believes like him but only seem to tolerate him. It is the 1940’s yet he has not had any professional achievements since his great sales record of 1928. He is no longer on salary, only commission. He is painfully in debt and he and his wife Linda live paycheck to paycheck. Yet he continues on with his false belief that he’s achieved his American Dream or ….is it a nightmare?
It appears that either through genetics or learned behavior his sons, Hap and Biff, have become……..nothing! Perhaps it is because their father/son relationship resembles more frat house brothers misbehaving rather than a father teaching his sons the truth about life, about honesty and sincerity. But these boys…er…men in their mid-thirties, are adrift with no direction and no idea what they want from life. Biff knows he wants to work out west but the payback is small, Hap is making a decent living but he is unfulfilled and lonely.
Mr. Miller does a splendid job creating conflict and tension. His Willy Loman may play your heartstrings or he may repulse you as he did me. Miller also invites discussion as to what is of utmost importance in one’s own American Dream. I see why so many young adults read this in high school, it asks the big questions and introduces thoughts for reflection. No need to hard sell me on this one.

Would I recomment it:Yes! As I asked myself, what's taken you so long!

>215 Carmenere:: I've never read it. I've seen Fredric March so many times that, when I look at the book, all I can think is, "Been there." I don't know why I can't force myself beyond that...it's rather odd.

#215: I have never read it either and am not a great fan of reading plays - I think they need to be watched, but I may give that one a try.

Great review, Lynda!

I like how you talk about why you read a book. I might start doing that, too. Thanks for the idea!!

#216 I see your point Tad. If you feel that way about a book you might as well use your time with something new to you. There are soooo many books and soooo little time.

#217 Plays are definately not my typical fare either Stasia but I've heard so many references to Willy Loman that I wanted to see what he was all about.

#218 Why thank you linda. I liked the idea when I saw it in Nickelini's thread (Joyce) and she let me steal it.

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire – J.K. Rowling
2002
733 pages
4.5/5

Why I read it:This was a reread for me - much more enjoyable this time reading it with my son who earns 37 AR points for completing the book.

Mini-ReviewHere is another enjoyable read by J.K. Rowling. As her readers have grown and matured since they first began their Harry Potter journey with HP and the Sorcerer’s Stone, so have her characters. Harry, Ron and Hermione begin to deal with their first date, their first feelings of interest in the opposite sex and the death of a very close and well liked student. It is a lot for young readers to wrap their heads around but when reading it with your child it is a great opportunity for questions and thoughts to be shared.
I found Goblet of Fire to be the most intriguing story thus far in the series. Although Harry is not eligible for the Tri-Wizard Tournament, someone or something has entered him by placing his name in the Goblet of Fire. The Three Tasks which are the challenges that the contestants must complete are so dangerous that many accomplished wizards have died from competing in them. To the reader they provide edge of your seat suspense and excitement.
The novel comes to a conclusion which leaves many details unresolved and offers a great setup for HP and the Order of the Phoenix.

Would I recommend itYes, as long as you're over 10 and/or mature enough to handle the sad parts.

Death of a Salesman is one I've avoided thanks to the butcher-method of my primary education, but your review has me rethinking my prejudice. I may just have to give it a look now that I've distanced myself a bit!

It's a quick read, Luxx. You just may find some merit in it.

#18 Heart of Darkness
Joseph Conrad
74 pages
1/5

Why I read it From TBR shelf - June TIOLI challenge: A book about Africa

Mini-ReviewQuick, someone, lend me a flashlight. I have just finished reading Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness and I can’t see for the density of Conrad’s prose. Let me explain.
Marlow is a seaman. His current ship, The Nellie, is stranded on the Thames due to the tide and absence of wind. He takes this opportunity to tell his story of his search for the mysterious Mr. Kurtz in the Congo region of Africa to those fortunate enough to be onboard with him. He is appointed to take charge of a steamboat on the Congo. For reasons unclear to me, he traverses the river in search of Mr. Kurtz and while doing so meets with atrocity’s to mankind and multiple ineptitudes on the part of the English attempting to colonize the region.
In some respects I found the story similar to A Passage to India but without the three dimensional characters. I have no sympathy for Marlow nor Kurtz, there is no anchor at all to cleave me to the story.
If Conrad has a story here, and indeed I believe he does, it would have been better related to the reader in another fashion. The Heart is not just Dark in this novella, it is absolutely absent.

Would I recommend it Blah

ETA: As I was in a hurry I neglected to review in my usual format, now corrected.

Wow 1/5. It doesn't get much worse than that.

Conrad gets a point for bringing the injustices to light.

Lynda

Finally a book that I don't have to add when visiting your thread.

Better luck with your next book.

Hi Lynda - thanks, you've just reinforced my "never read Conrad" thoughts. I do not want to put myself through that!

Lynda, I hope you enjoy your next read more!

#226 Happy to give you a well deserved break, Linda.

#227 I wish I had those thoughts too, calm - any other "nevr read" thoughts you wish to impart.

#228 Well as you know Stasia, my next read is Animal Farm for which I have high hopes.

Ack! Compared my '09 challenge thread to '10 and I have only read 1 more book than I did last year......so much for reading more in retirement.

Sure Lynda, Not every book is for everyone and I think it would take a lot for me to even attempt certain books. Henry James and William Faulkner are also on the never read list - from what I've heard about their books they wouldn't suit my tastes. Can't remember any others offhand.

Animal Farm is a good one, enjoy!

#230 I've yet to read anything by James or Faulkner although I do have them on my Tipping Tower of Tomes. I think I purchased them at a library booksale quite awhile ago. In no hurry to get to them but when I do, I'll keep your comments in mind.

#19 Animal Farm
George Orwell
1946
139 pages
5/5

Why I read it: June TIOLI Challenge - The A's have it, from TBR shelf, a Stasia recommendation

Mini-Review: Animal Farm is an absolutely moo-valous tale. Pigs, cows, horses and sheep are incited my Major, a Middle White Boar, seriously,to overthrow Mr. Jones, the owner of Manor Farm, and run the farm themselves. Their rebellion starts out smoothly enough until a certain swinish character takes charge – facts are spun, accusations fly, lies are told, gossip is rampant and fear reigns supreme.
Although this little story was written 64 years ago it is still very relevant in 2010. Many a character will seem familiar to you – many a situation will seem typical of the human condition today. I really can not see any reason not to give this engaging book five stars. It’s timeless.

Would I recommend it: No doubt about it!

#232: I am glad you liked that one! I was very surprised at how relevant it still is even today.

I've just started A Sea of Troubles and was surprised to learn that Venice is actually an island. Duh! Is this something that everyone already knew?

I did not realize it. I never really sat down and thought about it. I thought it was just a city with canals.

Exactly, so did I! Ahhhh, another door opened to this bookworm.

I Googled Earth Venice and the pictures are amazing. I understand more clearly now why St. Mark is known to flood occasionaly. Must add Venice to bucket list.

Just sitting here, biding my time till I need to leave for my son's 5th grade graduation picnic - then to the beach for friends, fun and of course food.

I hope you have a lovely time today!

Thanks, Linda. It's an outstanding day here, the rain has decided to take a break for a few days.

5th grade graduation---sweet. Hope it was fun.

Definately a good time, Bonnie. A great opportunity to rehash the year just completed and pick brains for tips on preparing for middle school. Eeeeeeeeeeeeek!
Schoolday begins one hour earlier in middle school and that alone is going to be a HUGE adjustment, for the little guy and me!

Thought I'd go ahead and set up a new thread before I head off for vacation,

http://www.librarything.com/topic/92978

I read Heart of Darkness and Nostromo for a university English literature course - didn't like HoD much. There's an interesting piece about by Chinua Achebe in his recent essay collection The Education of a British-Protected Child - he's very critical of what he describes as a very racist portrait of Africa and its people. I own a copy now which was a newspaper freebie - I probably didn't keep the previous copy - but don't have much desire to reread it.

Heart of Darkness appears to be a very polarizing read, Elkie. It was included with a selection of additional stories by Conrad which I am in no hurry to read at the moment.

By the way, my new thread is over here, http://www.librarything.com/topic/92978