Invisible republic : Bob Dylan's Basement tapes

Ate this one up. Not sure if it is just the old Romantic story-under-the-story trick, or if Bob Dylan really was onto myths so ancient that they are practically DNA -- at least in Appalachia. I got interested in this topic when Joni Mitchell called Bob a plagiarist. Of course an academic would be interested in stolen songs right out in public with his own name right on them. Outrageous. But the back story is: plenty of popular music is recycled recycled recycles. Bob just knows it and borrows freely. In fact, he takes the old song one level deeper, as Marcus shows in the book which is formally about Bob and The Band hanging out in a basement writing and recording for fun one summer. NB: Marcus is sometimes as impressionistic as Bob's show more stranger lyrics, hence the 4 stars. But if you ever read gonzo journalism, you know what s up anyway and expect as much. show less

Greil Marcus is teaching a class this fall at the New School on this book, if you're taking that class please, please help me sneak in.

That said, the book isn't so much about Bob Dylan as it is about the legacy of the "folk" song in America. Marcus's prose is beautiful and he knows how to write about music in away that makes it seem important and relevant. Like his description of Dylan's "Ballad of a Thin Man,"

Helped me belatedly understand what was at stake in the folk revival and Dylan's exit from it; and also what lies behind recenter weirdness like the Sun City Girls.

Marcus's prose is a bit fractured at times, to the point of being occasionally unintelligible (to me, anyway), but very good, if perhaps a little over Romantic, on the sources of Dylan's musical weirdness.

Seldom is it noted that springing hope can prove a real pain in the ass. I continually harbor and hope. There are always lists and plans: prerequisites for other texts clamor for attention. This vein continues however vain. I am thinking of reading all women in April, this highlighted by reading Second Sex in Serbia. There is module on slavery I was imagining for May. We shall see. Wait, I haven't really broached The Weird Old America, have I? Well that treatment is tantamount to Marcus' fleeting placement of The Basement Tapes within the text: they remain central, yet absent. It is fitting that Marcus cited Camille Paglia as that appears to be his lodestar, though he lacks her scrutiny as well as her writing panache. Marcus establishes show more The Basement Tapes as a nexus for myriad paths of American expression and legacy. Tracing these routes is intriguing but hardly conclusive. I think I prefer Nick Tosches in such free association . When considering this challenge for 2016 it was obvious that reading five books by or about Bob Dylan would be much more problematic than achieving the same with Derrida and Dickens. Marcus gives us hagiography, Dylan the mystic awakened something eternal when he went electric. One almost imagined William James, perhaps Robert Graves on Sufism . One can glean of course that the Nirvana song Polly harkens to a ballad Pretty Polly from the 17C. Again Marcus entertains without marshaling the requisite evidence. show less

I love Dylan's music to begin with, but even for me this book seems...weird. About half way through though,there's a digression on Henry Smith that's absolutely fascinating. If you don't know who he is (and I didn't), it's worth finding out.

Almost written in a stream of consciousness style itself the well-known Marcus imitates Dylan's approach to lyrics as he dissects the influential Basement Tapes.

A reference in the work recalled the answer song to Barry McGuire's, Eve of Destruction.

The Spokesmen were an American pop music trio. They scored a hit single in the U.S. in 1965 with the tune "Dawn of Correction", which was a patriotic answer record to Barry McGuire's protest song, "Eve of Destruction". The song was written by the group's members, John Medora, David White and Roy Gilmore. The tune hit #36 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LHBZ5StOiE