HomeGroupsTalkMoreZeitgeist
Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Loading...

Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy: Four Women Undercover in the Civil War (2014)

by Karen Abbott

Other authors: See the other authors section.

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
8425219,691 (3.82)62
"The never-before-told story of four real-life women who risked everything to take on a life of espionage during the Civil War"--Provided by publisher.
  1. 10
    Capital Dames: The Civil War and the Women of Washington, 1848-1868 by Cokie Roberts (norabelle414)
    norabelle414: Non-fictional accounts of women's roles in the American Civil War
Loading...

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 62 mentions

Showing 1-5 of 52 (next | show all)
Review of: Liar Temptress Soldier Spy: Four Women Undercover in the Civil War,
by Karen Abbott
by Stan Prager (12-31-20)

Women are conspicuously absent in most Civil War chronicles. With a few notable exceptions—Clara Barton, Harriet Tubman, Mary Todd Lincoln—female figures largely appear in the literature as bit players, if they make an appearance at all. Author Karen Abbott seeks a welcome redress to this neglect with Liar Temptress Soldier Spy: Four Women Undercover in the Civil War, an exciting and extremely well-written, if deeply flawed account of some ladies who made a significant contribution to the war effort, north and south.
The concept is sound enough. Abbott focuses on four very different women and relates their respective stories in alternating chapters. There is Belle Boyd, a teenage seductress with a lethal temper who serves as rebel spy and courier; Emma Edmonds, who puts on trousers to masquerade as Frank Thompson and joins the Union army; Rose O’Neal Greenhow, an attractive widow who romances northern politicians to obtain intel for the south; and, Elizabeth Van Lew, a prominent Richmond abolitionist who maintains a sophisticated espionage ring that infiltrates the inner circles of the Confederate government. Each of these is worthy of book-length treatment, but weaving their exploits together is an effective technique that makes for a readable and compelling narrative.
I had never heard of Karen Abbott—the pen name for Abbott Kahler—a journalist and highly acclaimed best-selling author dubbed the “pioneer of sizzle history” by USA Today. She is certainly a gifted writer, and unlike all too many works of history, her prose is fast-moving and engaging. I was swept along by her colorful recounting of the 1861 Battle of Bull Run, with flourishes such as: “Union troops fumbled backward and the Confederates rammed forward, a brutal and uneven dance, with soldiers felled like rotting trees.” I got so carried away I almost made it through the following passage without stumbling:
Some Northern soldiers claimed that every angle, every viewpoint, offered a fresh horror. The rebels slashed throats from ear to ear. They sliced off heads and dropkicked them across the field. They carved off noses and ears and testicles and kept them as souvenirs. They propped the limp bodies of wounded soldiers against trees and practiced aiming for the heart. They wrested muskets and swords from the clenched hands of corpses. They plunged bayonets deep into the backsides of the maimed and the dead. They burned the bodies, collecting “Yankee shin-bones” to whittle into drumsticks, and skulls to use as steins. [p34]
Almost. But I have a master’s degree in history and have spent a lifetime studying the American Civil War, and I have never heard this account of such barbarism at Bull Run. So I paused and flipped to Abbott’s notes for the corresponding page at the back of the book, where with a whiff of insouciance she admits that: “Throughout the war both the North and the South exaggerated the atrocities committed by the enemy, and it’s difficult to determine which incidents were real and which were apocryphal.” [p442] Which is another way of saying that her account is highly sensationalized, if not outright fabrication.
To my mind, Abbott commits an unpardonable sin here. A little research reveals that there were in fact a handful of allegations of brutality in the course of the battle, including the mutilation of corpses, but much of it anecdotal. There were several episodes of Confederate savagery later in the war, principally inflicted upon black soldiers in blue uniforms, but that is another story. How many readers of a popular history would without question take her at her word about what transpired at Bull Run? How many when confronted with stories of testicles taken as souvenirs would think to consult her citations? Lively paragraphs like this may certainly make for “sizzle”—but where’s the history? Historical novels have their place—The Killer Angels, by Michael Shaara, and Gore Vidal’s Lincoln, are among my favorites—but that is not the same thing as history, which must abide by a strict allegiance to fact-based reporting, informed analysis, and documentation. Apparently, this author demonstrates little loyalty to such constraints.
I read on, but with far more skepticism. Abbott’s style is seductive, so it’s easy to keep going. But sins do continue to accumulate. I have a passing familiarity with three of the four main characters, but fact-checking remained essential. Certainly the best known and most consequential was Van Lew, a heroic figure who aided the escape of prisoners of war and provided key intelligence to Union forces in the field. Greenhow is often cited as her counterpart working for the southern cause. Belle Boyd, on the other hand, has become a creature of legend who turns up more frequently in fiction or film than in history texts. I had never heard of Emma Edmonds, but I came to find her story the most fascinating of them all.
It seems that the more documented the subject—such as Van Lew, for example—the closer Abbott’s portrait comes to reliable biography. Beyond that, the imaginative seems to intrude, indeed dominate. The astonishing tale of Emma Edmonds has her not only impersonating a male Union soldier, but also variously posing as an Irish peddler and in blackface disguised as a contraband, engaged in thrilling espionage missions behind enemy lines! It rang of the stuff that Thomas Berger’s Little Big Man was made of. I was suitably sucked in, but also wary. And rightly so: Abbott’s version of Emma Edmonds’ life is based almost entirely on Edmonds’ own memoir, with little that corroborates it, but the author doesn’t bother to reveal that in the narrative. That Edmonds pretended to be a man in order to enlist seems plausible; her spy missions perhaps only fantasy. We simply just don’t know; a true historian would help us draw conclusions. Abbott seems content to let it play out as so much drama to tickle her audience.
But the worst of all is when the time comes to reveal the fate of luckless Confederate spy Greenhow, who drowns when her lifeboat capsizes with Union vessels bearing down on the steamer she abandoned, the moment where the superlative talent of Abbott’s pen collides with her concomitant disloyalty to scholarship:
She was sideways, upside down, somersaulting inside the wet darkness. She screamed noiselessly, the water rushing in. She tried to hold her breath—thirty seconds, sixty, ninety—before her mouth gave way and water filled it again. Tiny streams of bubbles escaped from her nostrils. A burning scythed through her chest. That bag of gold yanked like a noose around her neck. Her hair unspooled and leeched to her skin, twining around her neck. She tried to aim her arms up and her legs down, to push and pull, but every direction seemed the same. No moonlight skimmed along the surface, showing her the way; there was no light at all. [p389]
Entertaining, right? Outstanding writing, correct? Solid history—of course not! Imagining Greenhow’s final agonizing moments of life with a literary flourish may very well enrich the pages of a work of fiction, but it is nothing less than an outrage to a work of history.
This book was a fun read. Were it a novel I would likely give it high marks. But that is not how it is packaged. Emma Edmonds pretended to be a man to save the Union. Karen Abbott pretends to be a historian to sell books. Both make for great stories. But don’t confuse either with reliable history.
Review of: “Liar Temptress Soldier Spy: Four Women Undercover in the Civil War,” by Karen Abbott https://regarp.com/2020/12/31/review-of-liar-temptress-soldier-spy-four-women-un... ( )
  Garp83 | Dec 31, 2020 |
Extraordinary compilation of historical documentation! Karen Abbott's extensive research in combination with an articulate and eloquent writing style provides a fascinating portrayal of four women that valiantly gave service to their country during the Civil War. There are almost limitless examples of their networking with persistence and without hesitation in their actions to utilize their strengths to push forward their hopes of the outcome of the war.

"Karen Abbott examines the role of four women during the Civil War who risk their lives for their beliefs. Each chapter shifts in focus, alternating between Union and Confederate sympathizers...Drawing from original source material, Abbott makes these women and their histories come alive, illuminating the women’s war and how these unsung heroines influenced the course of history...Belle Boyd and Rose O’Neal Greenhow are two women whose allegiances lay with the Confederacy...Two other women Abbott highlights, Emma Edmonds and Elizabeth Van Lew, assist the Union in different ways." ~from BookMark: "Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy" By Karen Abbott. Article by Adison Godfrey • March 10, 2016. ( )
  FerneMysteryReader | Dec 4, 2020 |
Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy: Four Women Undercover in the Civil War by Karen Abbott is a fascinating story about four women, patriots to their own beliefs, who took a stand during the Civil War. Two were loyal Confederates and two were for the North. By using diaries, eyewitness accounts, contemporary news articles and official records the story of these four women gives us a glimpse of how women overcame the rigid roles there cast into and managed to influence the War in many ways.

I admit to having a favourite among these women. Canadian Emma Edmondson, disguised herself as a man and calling herself Frank Thompson joined the Union Army as a private for Company F, 2nd Michigan Infantry. Frank eventually found herself donning disguises and crossing military lines to spy on the Confederates. All of these women, Emma (Frank), Belle, Elizabeth and Rose, sacrificed something of themselves in order to serve their respective countries and this up-close and personal look at them made for an engrossing read.

Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy is a portrait of four strong women who became ground-breakers and helped to pave the way for others to appreciate women’s abilities. The book is well researched and gives the reader a good overview of both the political and military viewpoints of the day. ( )
  DeltaQueen50 | Oct 3, 2020 |
This book was interesting. Really nice to hear about some of the women that "fought" in the civil war. ( )
  expatb | Jul 16, 2020 |
I liked this book more in concept than I did in execution. At a certain point, it felt like being inundated with who did what: I felt like I had only the barest of connections with the material. I know that it is nonfiction and therefore, not a lot of room for internal dialogue, but the four women began to blur into one another. I wanted to like it, but I just couldn't quite manage it. ( )
  slmr4242 | Oct 16, 2019 |
Showing 1-5 of 52 (next | show all)
no reviews | add a review

» Add other authors

Author nameRoleType of authorWork?Status
Karen Abbottprimary authorall editionscalculated
Barose, NickAuthor photosecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Bozic, MilanCover designersecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Buckley, LynnCover designersecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Davies, VictoriaCover photo of womansecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
ShutterstockCover photo of flags & patternsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Turner, PatriciaCover photo of troopssecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
White, KarenNarratorsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
Information from the Russian Common Knowledge. Edit to localize it to your language.
Epigraph
Dedication
For Chuck, from his unequal half
First words
In the town of Martinsburg on the lower tip of the Valley, a seventeen-year-old rebel named Belle Boyd sat by the windows of her wood-frame home, waiting for the war to come to her.
Quotations
Their gender allowed them with both a psychological and physical disguise; while hiding behind social mores about women's proper roles, they could hide evidence of their treason on their very person, tucked beneath hoop skirts or tied up in their hair. Women, it seems, were capable not only of significant acts of treason but executing them more deftly than men.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS
Canonical LCC

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (1)

"The never-before-told story of four real-life women who risked everything to take on a life of espionage during the Civil War"--Provided by publisher.

No library descriptions found.

Book description
Haiku summary

Popular covers

Quick Links

Rating

Average: (3.82)
0.5
1
1.5
2 11
2.5 1
3 30
3.5 10
4 60
4.5 10
5 27

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.

 

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 162,174,060 books! | Top bar: Always visible