Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... Illness as Metaphor & AIDS and Its Metaphors (1989)by Susan Sontag
Metaphors, etc. (13) Loading...
Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. No current Talk conversations about this book. Reading Sontag is an experience of extraordinary clarity and lucidity, which are themselves powerful enough that it is easy to imagine that Sontag is declaring an unimpeachable, gospel-like Truth, and not simply a person sharing her opinions as best she can, because she believes they will be helpful. ( ) Le pongo cuatro porque el primer ensayo me parece excelso y el segundo muy desigual. Se nota la distancia en tiempo entre uno y otro, se nota que en el primero Sontag se estaba enfrentando a las metáforas del cáncer, mientras que el segundo viene a raíz de una enfermedad que en ese entonces aún era desconocida y que no es a la que se tienen que enfrentar la autora. Además después de la distancia una vez más en tiempo, las metáforas del primer ensayo siguen siendo cercanas y tristemente vigentes, mientras que la segunda ya está desfasada y rebasada. “Modern disease metaphors specify an ideal of society’s wellbeing, analogised to physical health, that is frequently anti-political as it is a call for a new political order.” Illness as Metaphor & AIDS and Its Metaphors is an eloquently incisive dissection of how diseases used as metaphors limit, twist, and bring forth several other meanings that can jeopardise and vaporise their medical definition. This, in turn, can have a strange, harmful effect to people who have these diseases and the people within their “communities.” More than that the usage of metaphors not only in a literary sense but also to the advantage of any political agenda (to alienate/isolate a minority, incite ridiculous fear to the public, et cetera), the romanticisation/stigmatisation of these diseases along their accompanied demise are fascinatingly magnificent additions to their history of metaphors throughout the years. Sontag, although perhaps a bit repetitive here and there, is seamless: from tuberculosis as a fashion trend, a standard beauty in all its pale and sallow, gaunt glory, cancer as an overused metaphor (ex., as “unqualifiedly and unredeemably wicked”) which mentally affects patients with cancer and its further association to a type of extremism that causes displacement and discrimination (ex. “Islam is spreading like cancer”) to the AIDS epidemic in ‘80s US where it's labelled as the “gay plague” and how this perpetuated, exacerbated the already ingrained hatred and prejudice on top of the government’s intentional inaction. This painfully claimed a lot of lives. Sadly, bigoted beliefs still exist today in those who choose to be ignorant and stupid. And similar to what’s currently happening, there is a pattern of justified discrimination, this time of a racial kind, with the initial identification of COVID19 in Hubei, China. Asians—Chinese and people mistaken as Chinese (because of people’s narrow idea of what Asians look like and the lack of geographical knowledge)—are subjected to verbal abuse even physical violence across the globe. And this doesn’t stop there, people of colour also receive worse, little to no medical attention because of the implicit social hierarchy established particularly in western countries. This slim book does not end here, it inspects countless of metaphors I'm afraid to blabber about. By the end, Sontag's polemic is unforgettably powerful and strikingly remains frighteningly relevant during this pandemic we are all in. It is despairing that she predicts these metaphors will be obsolete in the future, maybe it's indeed better, but it seems to me they only pile up like clothes in an otherwise already full closet, metaphors we use at our disposal without critically thinking of their lasting impact. Illness as Metaphor is highly polemical, and as such, is a suburb piece of polemic. Sontag, herself diagnosed with breast cancer at the time of the writing (a fact she does not disclose in the initial essay itself) compares eighteenth and early nineteenth century discourse about tuberculosis to present day language about cancer. Of course, "present day" for Sontag is 1977. This fact alone makes the book a compelling read -- simply considering how much the approach of Western medicine to cancer has changed in 30 years. Doubtlessly this essay itself has been a large contributor to this shift in thinking. In a nutshell: Sontag argues that the word "cancer" has become little more than a metaphor for everything that is wrong and evil in the world, and this systemic demonizing of this illness in particular makes it all the more complicated for its patients, and fosters a range of stigmas that are virtually invisible to anyone not dealing with cancer themselves. Reading the counterpoints and rebuttals to Sontag's thesis is compelling secondary reading as well. All together, a thorough inquiry into Sontag's propositions yields a much broader awareness of the "cancerous" language and metaphors we still use rather flippantly today." no reviews | add a review
Belongs to Publisher Series
In 1978 Susan Sontag wroteIllness as Metaphor, a classic work described byNewsweek as "one of the most liberating books of its time." A cancer patient herself when she was writing the book, Sontag shows how the metaphors and myths surrounding certain illnesses, especially cancer, add greatly to the suffering of patients and often inhibit them from seeking proper treatment. By demystifying the fantasies surrounding cancer, Sontag shows cancer for what it is--just a disease. Cancer, she argues, is not a curse, not a punishment, certainly not an embarrassment and, it is highly curable, if good treatment is followed. Almost a decade later, with the outbreak of a new, stigmatized disease replete with mystifications and punitive metaphors, Sontag wrote a sequel toIllnessas Metaphor, extending the argument of the earlier book to the AIDS pandemic. These two essays now published together,Illnessas MetaphorandAIDS and Its Metaphors, have been translated into many languages and continue to have an enormous influence on the thinking of medical professionals and, above all, on the lives of many thousands of patients and caregivers. No library descriptions found. |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)306.461Social sciences Social Sciences; Sociology and anthropology Culture and Institutions Specific aspects of culture Technology Medicine and healthLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Penguin AustraliaAn edition of this book was published by Penguin Australia. |