Who the Devil Made It : Conversations with Legendary Film Directors

by Peter Bogdanovich

On This Page

Description

In this chronicle of Hollywood and the art of making movies, Peter Bogdanovich (director, screenwriter, actor and critic) interviews 16 directors, including: Robert Aldrich; George Cukor; Howard Hawks; Alfred Hitchcock; Fritz Lang; Sidney Lumet; Otto Preminger; and Josef von Sternberg.

Tags

Recommendations

Member Reviews

2 reviews
The book is a collection of interviews of 16 movie directors that the author knew, and, as a bonus, he discusses the scandals and tribulations of his own life and career in the book’s introduction. The interviews were done at various times between the 1960s and the 1990s; many were previously published as magazines articles. Several of the directors did work in silent films. If you have an interest in movies, the book should be broadly entertaining. Some of the directors' life stories, their revelation of how certain famous scenes were shot, their complaints about their producers and heads of studios, and their stories about actors are often both interesting and amusing.

Did you know that Lana Turner was originally cast to play the show more lead in Anatomy of a Murder, but she refused to wear a pair of slacks that the director, Otto Preminger, had selected? Preminger told her agent that if she didn’t like it, she could turn the picture down. Preminger said that she probably thought he was bluffing, but the role went to Lee Remick.

Howard Hawks, while discussing Barbary Coast (1935), commented that it was the first time he had used Walter Brennan, and told the story that a man came up to him in tears after the movie’s preview and said that he didn’t know how to thank Hawks. Hawks didn’t know who he was until Brennan took out his teeth. He had never seen him except in makeup and Brennan was playing (and often played) characters who were older than he was.

The directors interviewed are Allan Dwan, Raoul Walsh, Fritz Lang, Josef von Sternberg, Howard Hawks, Leo McCarey, George Cukor, Alfred Hitchcock, Edgar G. Ulmer, Otto Preminger, Joseph H. Lewis, Chuck Jones, Don Siegel, Frank Tashlin, Robert Aldrich, and Sidney Lumet.
show less
The book is a collection of interviews of 16 movie directors that the author knew, and, as a bonus, he discusses the scandals and tribulations of his own life and career in the book’s introduction. The interviews were done at various times between the 1960s and the 1990s; many were previously published as magazines articles. Several of the directors did work in silent films. If you have an interest in movies, the book should be broadly entertaining. Some of the directors' life stories, their revelation of how certain famous scenes were shot, their complaints about their producers and heads of studios, and their stories about actors are often both interesting and amusing.

Did you know that Lana Turner was originally cast to play the show more lead in Anatomy of a Murder, but she refused to wear a pair of slacks that the director, Otto Preminger, had selected? Preminger told her agent that if she didn’t like it, she could turn the picture down. Preminger said that she probably thought he was bluffing, but the role went to Lee Remick.

Howard Hawks, while discussing Barbary Coast (1935), commented that it was the first time he had used Walter Brennan, and told the story that a man came up to him in tears after the movie’s preview and said that he didn’t know how to thank Hawks. Hawks didn’t know who he was until Brennan took out his teeth. He had never seen him except in makeup and Brennan was playing (and often played) characters who were older than he was.

The directors interviewed are Allan Dwan, Raoul Walsh, Fritz Lang, Josef von Sternberg, Howard Hawks, Leo McCarey, George Cukor, Alfred Hitchcock, Edgar G. Ulmer, Otto Preminger, Joseph H. Lewis, Chuck Jones, Don Siegel, Frank Tashlin, Robert Aldrich, and Sidney Lumet.
show less

Members

Recently Added By

Published Reviews

ThingScore 100
Right from the jump, Bogdanovich could write about the movies with a cogency that placed him in the top flight of critics, and as an interviewer he has always been without peer. His latest book, Who the Devil Made It, is just further confirmation of a quality he seems to have had since the cradle. When it comes to movies, the master of the medium is often a buff but rarely a scholar – he show more hasn’t the time, even when he has the inclination – yet Bogdanovich somehow always managed to service his debt to the creativity of his past masters while he was busy with his own: articles and interviews, slim monographs and fat books were all done with manifest love, despite his being in a tearing hurry...

He was Hollywood’s Mr Memory even while he was its golden boy. Now that he has become the Man in the Iron Mask, he is free to cultivate the archives at his leisure. Executives who played a part in condemning him to strangle in his own beard might be in for an unpleasant surprise. What makes them pygmies is that there once were giants: it’s a cliché, but on the strength of the documentation assembled in Who the Devil Made It, Bogdanovich looks as if he might raise it to the status of an axiom.
show less
Clive James, New Yorker
added by SnootyBaronet

Lists

Film
114 works; 1 member

Author Information

Picture of author.
64+ Works 1,890 Members
Peter Bogdanovich is the author of thirteen books. His essays and reviews have appeared in the New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Esquire and the New York Observer

Awards and Honors

Common Knowledge

Canonical title
Who the Devil Made It : Conversations with Legendary Film Directors
Original title
Who the Devil Made It : Conversations with Legendary Film Directors
Original publication date
1997
People/Characters
Robert Aldrich; George Cukor; Allan Dwan; Howard Hawks; Alfred Hitchcock; Chuck Jones (show all 16); Fritz Lang; Joseph H. Lewis; Sidney Lumet; Leo McCarey; Otto Preminger; Don Siegel; Josef von Sternberg; Frank Tashlin; Edgar G. Ulmer; Raoul Walsh
Epigraph
… I liked almost anybody that made you realize who in the devil was making the picture … Because the director’s the storyteller and should have his own method of telling it.
—HOWARD HAWKS
Most of the good thi... (show all)ngs in pictures happen by accident.
—JOHN FORD
Dedication
To the memory of my brave, dear and inspiring mother, Herma Robinson Bogdanovich (1918–1979), who was a beautiful, overly selfless person and also my first director, first editor, first friend; and to the memory of my brill... (show all)iant father, the painter Borislav Bogdanovich (1899–1970), whose work and whose attitude to art influenced me more than can be expressed.
First words
Early in the summer of 1996—exactly 101 years after the first movies were exhibited—Warren Beatty and I were standing around on the lawn of Henry Jaglom’s Santa Monica home watching a bunch of young children at a birthd... (show all)ay party (two of them Warren’s, two Henry’s, one mine); we were talking about some of the big changes in the picture business since we had come into it in the late fifties and early sixties.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)Is there any advice you have for the up-and-coming?
Yeah. Slow up. One of the big things I’ve learned is not to give advice.
Disambiguation notice*
La versión original (Who the devil made it) se publicó en un único volumen. En España, en cambio, se separó en dos tomos.
*Some information comes from Common Knowledge in other languages. Click "Edit" for more information.

Classifications

Genres
Nonfiction, General Nonfiction, Biography & Memoir
DDC/MDS
791.430233Arts & recreationRecreation, sports, and performing artsMovies, TV, VideoMotion pictures, radio, television, podcastingMotion picturesStandard subdivisionsSupervisionFilm direction
LCC
PN1995.9 .P7 .W48Language and LiteratureLiterature (General)Literature (General)DramaMotion pictures
BISAC

Statistics

Members
275
Popularity
116,878
Reviews
2
Rating
½ (4.28)
Languages
6 — Catalan, English, German, Italian, Portuguese, Spanish
Media
Paper, Ebook
ISBNs
8
ASINs
2