Julia Boyd

Providing food for thought and giving pause at the same time, Boyd's mosaic of traveler's tales from post-1918 Germany has as its main theme the sense of confusion that nation tended to leave visitors with. Yes, those who were easily convinced found what they wanted to find; either the Germany of their school days, or hope for a bulwark against the Soviet menace. Even those who were skeptical, to downright hostile, could find themselves suffering from cognitive dissonance, seeing the show more supposed virtues of the Nazi regime on one hand, in conjunction with rising menace on the other; until with "Kristallnacht" there could be no more doubt. A story that is more relevant than ever. show less

More from my Odyssey into the Third Reich.

A bunch of firsthand accounts of what was happening in Germany from the 30s right up to the war.

Also highlights how much Hitler was admired by the British Establishment both low and high born. In fact by almost all Establishments.

I got a palpable sense of what gripped Germany and how it gave new life to broken nation. What they did with that is something else. It is amazing how all those proponents of Hitler developed amnesia after the war both low show more and high born. You’d think that he alone was the culprit and that he succeeded as far as he did in spite of the towering opposition he faced.

The truth is he had wide support from all sides and it was only the Russians that stopped him.

If it wasn't for Stalin we'd all be speaking German and me and my entire family would have been cleansed into non-existence.

One of the points made strongly in this book is how visitors to Germany were taken in by his propaganda machine or simply refused to see what was right in front of their eyes.

I think it also opens up the idea that many people shared his ideas about the Jews. Something borne out in David Cesarani’s definite book, Final Solution: The Fate of the Jews 1933–1949. In fact anyone interested in this period should read David Cesarani’s book to get over the misinformation from all sides about where they all stood both at this point in history and later.

Informative without being preachy. show less

Honestly, I don't have much to say about 'Travellers in the Third Reich'. I was given it for Christmas in 2018 and hadn't read it before now as I correctly predicted it would be a downer. The writing style is very engaging and readable, not at all dry or academic. It collects diary entries, letters, and other similar accounts from foreigners who visited Germany during the 1930s. The subtitle, 'The rise of fascism through the eyes of everyday people' says it all, really. The main messages are show more that a few visitors were actual Nazi converts, but far more were antisemitic enough not to care and/or willing to ignore all the warning signs for the sake of a cheap package holiday. Surprising numbers of British parents continued packing children off to a rapidly re-arming and politically aggressive totalitarian state because the exchange rate was good. Boyd suggests that many tourists focused on a nostalgic vision of pre-WWI Germany, looking past all the swastikas in favour of historic architecture and pretty countryside. There's a running theme of German cultural Anglophilia, which meant UK tourists specifically may have felt more welcome and perhaps receptive to Nazi propaganda. I was mostly depressed by how much wilful naivety was on display, among academics, students, diplomats, writers, and tourists alike. Perhaps the most clear-eyed commentator quoted is an unfortunate Chinese PhD student who got stuck in Germany throughout WWII.

A particularly notable detail is that Thomas Cook was still advertising package holidays to lovely Germany in 1939, right up until the outbreak of war. This reminded me of seeing an ad from the same company last week, hawking international package holidays during a global pandemic. Seventy years later, their marketing is still strikingly irresponsible. Boyd synthesises a wide range of material into a chronological narrative very effectively, employing only loose themes. There are lots of little details that remind you of the seemingly mundane normality that can coexist with a brutal fascist regime. In these times of resurgent neo-fascism, it all felt a little too close to home. A well-written book, but not one I could really appreciate. show less

Myopia of the Moment

Time and the critical eye of historians brings perspective often lacking at the time events occur. That is one of the takeaways from Julia Boyd’s intriguing exploration of the rise and fall of Nazi Germany through the eyes of visitors from 1919 to 1945. These visitors included British and American citizens, as well as one Chinese graduate student. Visitors were vacation goers who loved the landscape and culture of Germany, as well as the value it represented right up to show more the start of WWII. For the most part, though, visitors were politicians, intellectuals, and students, individuals you would hope to have been more acute observers, people attuned to the politics of a country, and thus able to tell when they are being seduced and hoodwinked. Not so in most cases, especially prior to at least 1938, when Hitler’s and Germany’s march to war became more apparent, and the persecution of the Jews outright and undisguised.

If you’ve read the history of the period and of Germany in particular, you understand how Hitler used the anger of Germans over WWI and its aftermath, as well as Germany’s long volkish history that included a very strong current of antisemitism, to beguile them with visions of greatness to surpass that of the past. (Readers might like to try George Mosse’s The Crisis of German Ideology: Intellectual Origins of the Third Reich, one of the best studies of the subject.) These resentments come through loud and clear in the conversations related by travelers. Too, the level of antisemitism might startle some modern types, especially that expressed by the travelers, politicians, intellectuals, and students alike.

That observers quoted in this volume could not see German military intent even before 1936 will strike readers as surprising, especially when you read about a population in uniform, people, young and older, marching here, there, and everywhere, while singing patriotic songs. You would have to ask yourself: what were they practicing for, what would this uniformity of behavior lead to? Often, you’ll read accounts of young people holidaying in the mountains encountering troops of Hitler youth groups practicing military techniques, including stealth assault employing camouflage.

While this book has garnered a large international readership, here in the U.S. it appears little read. Yet, it should be better known to Americans, because it’s loaded with information on the power of propaganda, the myopia of observation in the moment, how quickly people can fall prey to totalitarians who promise to restore the past, and make the future even better, and how readily the dominant populace can succumb to scapegoating. Even casual readers will find themselves drawing parallels to our own current situation.

Recommended to all readers, and as a welcome addition to the bookshelves of readers of German history and the Nazi era. show less