Carl F. H. Henry (1913–2003)

Summary: Henry's classic manifesto challenging the heirs of the fundamentalist movement to a recovery of a social and intellectual engagement while maintaining gospel integrity.

In a recent conversation about people leaving evangelicalism because of the "rootedness" of those in traditions like Catholicism, I wondered aloud whether many who are repudiating evangelicalism have much knowledge of what they are repudiating, other than the uncomfortable experiences they likely have had personally. show more In my experience, most evangelicals are sadly out of touch with even their own history, let alone the great history of the church over the past two millenia.

The Uneasy Conscience of Modern Fundamentalism is one of the keystone works in the rise of the twentieth century evangelical movement. In it Carl Henry decries the regrettable loss of a social conscience in fundamentalism's retreat from a vibrantly engaged evangelicalism of the nineteenth century. He writes:

"In a company of more than one hundred representative evangelical pastors, the writer proposed the following question: 'How many of you, during the past six months, have preached a sermon devoted in large part to a condemnation of such social evils as aggressive warfare, racial hatred and intolerance, the liquor traffic, exploitation of labor or management or the like--a sermon containing not merely an incidental or illustrative reference, but directed mainly against such evils and proposing the framework in which you think a solution is possible?' Not a single hand was raised in response."

He attributes this in part to the retrenchment from theological liberalism and its associated "social gospel." But he also lays part of the blame on an eschatology that is indifferent to all efforts to address social and physical needs since "it is all going to perish" and what must be done is simply to rescue lost people. He argues that the exclusive focus on the "not yet" of the kingdom to the exclusion of the "already" that heralds the work of Christ leads to a great imbalance in preaching. He writes this as one who embraces rather than denies premillenial theology.

Furthermore, he calls for an intellectual recovery of a Christian mind and social ethic that roots a vigorous engagement in the realms of higher education as well as societal needs in theological orthodoxy. He proposes protest that roots advocacy in evangelical belief while also recognizing that ameliorating social needs without spiritual regeneration through Christ is inadequate.

Carl Henry represented a vanguard of evangelical leaders who created journals like Christianity Today and began to assert a socially engaged and intellectually rigorous Christianity that remained rooted in fundamental beliefs. It was a movement that advocated for a "both-and" approach when everyone else had assumed an "either-or" approach to Christian faith--either socially engaged or doctrinally orthodox. Henry argued for both and believed this reflected gospel integrity.

While there were things Henry and others no doubt didn't get right, many more don't even know he existed or that his manifesto anticipated the socially engaged evangelicalism of Sojourners, the intellectual and doctrinal rigor of the neo-Reformed folk, and the movement toward a recovery of a Christian mind in the world of higher education.

This slim volume "stirred many pots." It is worth a read in our day, both for the vibrant vision it articulates and for the glimpse it gives us of the beginnings of twentieth century evangelicalism after World War Two. show less

Unapologetically technical in categorizations and analysis, Carl F.H. Henry's critique of the Modern Fundamentalist in the 1940s is a cautionary tale to consider the implications of an American Christianity that critiques efforts of societal change from afar yet pats itself on the back for remaining "faithful". Henry challenges this form of fundamentalism as inherently subverting its own message. He argues that historical orthodoxy has never remained on the sidelines but led in engaging the show more needs of society from a robust theological foundation that lead to sound practical application.

This is not an easy read for those without a background in theology(a foundation in theological studies is almost a prerequisite before attempting to engage with Henry's thoughts), but an important one. Reflecting on Henry's assertions will continue to remain timeless for the lived Christianity that we imagine; and how it asks us to pursue our conscience to love God and neighbor. show less

I first read this book several years ago in college. I remembered finding a few valuable insights, but being largely unimpressed. Having just finished the second reading, I realize that I missed the brilliance and clarity of Henry's overall vision for evangelicalism's cultural engagement. Even though it was originally published in 1947, The Uneasy Conscience addresses issues that are still relevant to modern Christians.

While I'm not sure I agree with every single point of Henry's view, this show more book is certainly valuable, an essential read for anyone wrestling with the Church's relationship with the broader society. show less

Quando 263 respeitados eruditos evangélicos internacionais escrevem significativos ensaios sobre diferentes aspectos da ética cristã, o resultado é um dicionário de valor incomum. Centenas de tópicos muito importantes são aqui discutidos com autoridade: aborto, inseminação artificial, crime, família, delinqüência juvenil, racismo, tolerância e riqueza, juntamente com muitos outros tópicos de grande interesse para a fé cristã. Esta valiosa obra de referência será de grande show more ajuda para pastores, professores e crentes em geral interessados em dar à vida a orientação que glorifica a Deus. A ampla, mas ainda completa abordagem dos temas, servirá de apoio para os que desejam aplicar a verdade da Escritura aos problemas éticos de nossos dias. Esta edição foi traduzida da edição americana de 1973, mas contém atualizações de abordagens e de temas, a partir das enormes mudanças ocorridas nos últimos trinta anos. Desse modo o seu conteúdo será ainda mais útil para os que vierem consultá-lo. show less