Picture of author.

Sean Longden

Author of Dunkirk: The Men They Left Behind

5 Works 213 Members 4 Reviews

Works by Sean Longden

Dunkirk: The Men They Left Behind (2008) 84 copies, 1 review
To the Victor the Spoils (2004) 27 copies
Hitler's British Slaves (2005) 18 copies

Tagged

Common Knowledge

There is no Common Knowledge data for this author yet. You can help.

Members

Reviews

4 reviews
This book is not quite what the title suggests, though no doubt that final subtitle was chosen to sell more copies.

It is a studied and human view of the man and operations of a rather unconventional British force. This force was rapidly formsd and trained, then employed equally rapidly to secure German military and then industrial sites, secrets and personnel in the last few months of World War 2. The process continued in a different way in post-war Germany.

I use the word human, because show more there is considerable focus on the men themselves, and this book is not exactly military history. It does however attempt to re-cast certain aspects of military history regarding Hamburg. Hours before the end the end of world war 2 in Europe, a mad chase ensued in which competing units (including Fleming's predictably 'colourful' unit) drove at top speed to Hamburg in contradiction of 'hold fast' orders which formed part of the ceasefire and surrender agreement with German forces. It is suggested their actions were neither officially sanctioned, nor completely discouraged, in the hope of denying Germany's main port and route to the sea to Russian forces.

T-force itself was quite different from the swashbuckling force created by Ian Fleming in Naval Intelligence for covert operations. It was by contrast a disparately-staffed unit of both veterans and rookies, often with little desire for military confrontation or firefight - they were not front-line troops. However, their objectives were often just behind or slightly ahead of the military advance.

These men found themselves in an increasingly complex, politically-charged, and sometimes even distasteful position as war progressed to peace. Originally tasked to secure military-industrial resources in the name of 'the war effort', they found their role substantially changed in the race to control vital parts of Germany before the war ended and before the Russian army pre-empted them.

Also, once the situation was relatively stable post-war, motive for their activities became less clear. Certain parts of British industry seemed to have official backing to plunder Germany of its industrial secrets, other intellectual and industrial property and staff. This ultimately proved distateful for some of these men, as the 'war effort' motive was now completely transformed. The British aid given to regenerate Volkswagen, for example, was perhaps the exception rather than the rule.

Some men stayed long-term post-war, but for many the desire was to get home as soon as possible. They didn't see the need to deny a nation of the means to recover. Arguably, the need to start afresh ultimately served to rejuvenate the German economy, while the British economy rested on its sometimes borrowed laurels and failed to adapt to peace and the utterly changed new world order.
show less
½
Beginning with the swift formation of the elite unit toward the end of WWII, 'T-Force' details the evolution of this force and some related units as they attempt to rapidly and safely secure German industrial and military secrets, locations and people (everyone from workers to cutting-edge research scientists).

Well researched and packed with wondrous stories, I learnt a lot about what it meant to be involved in the military toward the end of the war. This is definitely a history book, but in show more many places it reads like a novel.

To hear what's great about this book, read the 5-star reviews on Amazon: they are correct and I will not repeat them. Here's what I thought could have been improved…

The personal stories make this a great read, but the technical information is slightly limited and I would have loved it if Longden had gone into greater detail when describing what became of a number of the findings and what technologies they helped bring to existence in the post-war world.

Overall the book could have done with some tighter editing, too: a number of points were often repeated, almost verbatim. It was slightly confusing at times when an entire paragraph was almost identical to one I had read the previous day. Not a showstopper in terms of reading and enjoying this book, but it would have been nice if my 'flow' hadn't been disturbed by these anomalies.
show less
½
Interesting account of children's contributions to World War II. The decision to keep a strong chronological structure has made it a tad long, but it is good and interesting.

Lists

You May Also Like

Statistics

Works
5
Members
213
Popularity
#104,443
Rating
4.0
Reviews
4
ISBNs
15

Charts & Graphs