Ralf Georg Reuth

Rather lacking in the sense of a central thesis that takes a specific approach to Goebbels' life, despite, at the time, Reuth getting access to heretofore restricted archival material from the DDR. Instead, Reuth gives us an unending timeline, where one even never seems to outweigh another in terms of historical importance or personal development of the subject. What insight the biography gives is through implication. For example, the hesitation, paranoia, and fear that comes through show more Goebbels' writing--even though it was composed with an eye to future generations reading it as a "great man's" thoughts--actually works to distance the propaganda minister from the responsibility (and guilt) traditionally ascribed to him. At least until 1943-44, when his role as an architect of the Holocaust becomes predominant. But for earlier years, Reuth's narrative makes it seem as if Goebbels is somewhat fearful of being out of the loop and thus always on the second or even third rung of Nazi decision making. Bormann, Goering, Himmler, Hess, and even Ribbentrop, Rosenberg, and Lammers are depicted often as more powerful and influential than Goebbels. But none of this is actually stated as such by Reuth. As I say, it is done more through the implication of what the reader is made to feel and understand through the narrative Reuth constructs out of Goebbels' journals and diaries.

Another thing implied is a picture of Goebbels as a complete non-entity without Hitler. The early part of his life is undistinguished and, in fact, boring. Only when he attaches himself to the NSDAP, first through Gregor Strasser and, later, Hitler, does he become a more animated being. I am willing to buy into this notion more firmly than the relatively power dependent figure discussed above. For without Hitler, it is clear that Goebbels was nothing. The "poison dwarf" only found purpose through anger and revenge at the bourgeois representatives of capital or the reactionary aristocratic class all of whom he felt conspired against people such as himself to keep them from their proper place in society. Only the arrival of Hitler into his life allowed Goebbels to focus his disappointments and anger in a way that gave value to the Nazis.

Lastly, there is an emphasis on Goebbels' commitment to socialism and a volkisch socialist revolution. He never let that notion go. It was the mechanism through which he wanted to overthrow the old aristocratic order when he was younger. And towards the end of the war it fed his fantasies about making a separate peace with the Soviets in order to fight the Allies on one front.

The tone of this biography, meanwhile, tends towards reflecting an objective attitude. On that score Reuth is much more akin to earlier biographers of the Nazis, such as Alan Bullock, although even Bullock was much more eager to assess and place blame on the likes of Goebbels for their actions than is Reuth. show less

Chilling story of one of Hitler's most infamous followers. He had a fairly interesting life, and I picked up a lot of details from the book (his reading tastes, personality, religious faith, what drove him to follow Hitler). A bit dry in style, but still good.

Natürlich war AM nie eine Kommunistin ebenso wenig wie sie eine CDU-Frau ist. Fakt ist allerdings,
dass ihr Vater ein echter Sozialist war. Im Sinne der Bergpredigt.

Sie steht im Grunde über dem Rechts-Links-Klischee, sie moderiert aus dem Hintergrund, geschickt und mit Frauen-Hand. Ohne die unsägliche Notwendigkeit,
im Vordergrund stehen zu müssen.

Jeder sollte diese Hintergründe kennen, sie sind gut recherchiert, allerdings fehlt ihnen etwas ganz Entscheidendes: die echte, innere show more Frauen-Sicht. Die Perspektive der Autoren-Männer zielt zu sehr auf etwas zutiefst Männliches: Macht nämlich.

Alles rührt von der jungen Frau in der DDR her, die sich im Hintergrund bewegt, von dort alles beobachtet, sich um alles kümmert und heute wenig verwundert ist, dass man sie
Mutti nennt. Sie sieht es sogar als Ehrentitel.

Mutti könnte locker noch 2 Wahlperioden dran hängen, imho. Will sie aber nicht - 12 Jahre werden 2017 reichen, das sind
4 Menschenleben und man kann sie nur bewundern ob ihrer Disziplin.

Schon heute ist sie klug genug, ihre Nachfolgerin aufzubauen. Keiner der bisherigen Kanzler konnte dies. 2017 heißt unsere Bundeskanzlerin Ursula von der Leyen.

Jeder, der dies verstehen möchte, sollte dieses Buch lesen. Trotz der männlichen Sicht gut.

In jeder Gesellschaft, die mich oft auch mit CDU Freunden zusammenbringt, erziele ich verblüffte Gesichter, wenn ich aus diesem Buch erzähle. Meine Analyse, dass AM im Grunde die noch effizientere Guillaume der CDU ist, teilt nicht jeder, aber die Lacher bleiben oft im Halse stecken, wenn ich von der neuen deutschen Einheitspartei erzähle, deren Kanzlerin heute neu gewählt wurde. Nicht das Schlechteste, wenn die alten Schlachtrösser endlich lernen, die Probleme einfach anzupacken, statt sich nur aufzuplustern. show less

It is twenty yea-s since a serious biography of Goebbels was published. Ralf Georg Reuth here draws on a wealth of new source material to produce a brilliant account of Goebbels' life which will stand as the definitive biography for years to come. Some of this source material was held by the East Germans and Russians and has only been available since the fall of the Berlin wall. Goebbels was a small, spindly, highly intelligent man with a clubfoot and an inferiority complex who rose to power show more with Hitler and was, of all the Nazis, the strongest advocate of the extermination of the Jews. Reuth describes Goebbels' childhood in a strict, Catholic, lower-middle-class family; his poverty; his many affairs with women above his station; his political activity and intrigues in Berlin for Hitler; his career in the Third Reich; his wife and children; his suicide.
The use of previously unavailable archival information and diaries, and carefully excavated eyewitness accounts, makes this not only an important social document, but a fascinating and gripping study of a monster. show less