Picture of author.

Jay Lake (1964–2014)

Author of Mainspring

220+ Works 3,768 Members 194 Reviews 6 Favorited

About the Author

Jay Lake was born in Taiwan on June 6, 1964, and was raised there and in Nigeria. He graduated from the University of Texas in 1986. During his lifetime, he published over 300 short stories and nine novels including Kalimpura, Calamity of So Long a Life, and The Last Plane to Heaven. He received show more several awards including the John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer in Science Fiction in 2004. He was also the subject of a documentary called Lakeside - A Year with Jay Lake, which follows his fight against cancer, and is scheduled for release in 2014. He died from colon cancer on June 1, 2014 at the age of 49. (Bowker Author Biography) show less

Includes the names: Jay Lake, ed Jay Lake, Joseph E. Lake

Also includes: Joe Edwards (1)

Image credit: At Aussiecon IV

Series

Works by Jay Lake

Mainspring (2007) 808 copies, 35 reviews
Green (2009) 449 copies, 34 reviews
Escapement (2008) 370 copies, 10 reviews
Trial of Flowers (2006) 269 copies, 6 reviews
Other Earths (2009) — Editor — 193 copies, 5 reviews
Endurance (2011) 158 copies, 7 reviews
Pinion (2010) 158 copies, 7 reviews
Kalimpura (2013) 109 copies, 4 reviews
Rocket Science (2005) 91 copies, 5 reviews
Last Plane to Heaven: The Final Collection (2014) 87 copies, 6 reviews
Madness of Flowers (2009) 65 copies, 3 reviews
METAtropolis: Cascadia (2010) 60 copies, 3 reviews
All Star Zeppelin Adventure Stories (2004) — Editor — 60 copies, 1 review
The Sky That Wraps (2010) 54 copies, 1 review
Polyphony 1 (2002) — Editor — 33 copies, 2 reviews
Polyphony 3 (2003) — Editor — 31 copies, 1 review
Death of a Starship (2010) 30 copies, 2 reviews
Dogs in the Moonlight (2004) 29 copies, 2 reviews
The Stars Do Not Lie (2013) 27 copies, 3 reviews
Polyphony 2 (2003) — Editor — 26 copies
A Water Matter (2010) — Author — 25 copies, 4 reviews
Polyphony 4 (2004) — Editor — 25 copies
Polyphony 6 (2006) — Editor — 22 copies, 1 review
Polyphony 5 (2005) — Editor — 20 copies
METAtropolis: Green Space (2013) 20 copies, 1 review
Greetings From Lake Wu (2003) 19 copies, 1 review
Love in the Time of Metal and Flesh (2013) 18 copies, 2 reviews
The Speed of Time (2010) 17 copies, 4 reviews
The Baby Killers (2010) 16 copies, 1 review
The Starship Mechanic (2010) — Author — 14 copies, 3 reviews
Spicy Slipstream Stories (2008) — Editor — 14 copies
American Sorrows (2004) 14 copies
TEL: Stories (2005) — Editor — 12 copies, 1 review
The River Knows Its Own (2000) 11 copies
Looking for Truth in a Wild Blue Yonder (2010) — Author — 10 copies, 3 reviews
On The Human Plan 8 copies, 1 review
Footprints (2009) — Editor — 6 copies
The Big Ice 6 copies
Green Grow the Rushes-Oh (2004) 6 copies
The Goat Cutter 6 copies
Permanent Fatal ErrorsLake 3 copies, 1 review
Torquing Vacuum 3 copies, 1 review
To Raise a Mutiny Betwixt Yourselves — Author — 3 copies
Over The Walls Of Eden (2011) 3 copies
Lehr Rex (2006) 3 copies
The exquisite corpuscle (2008) 3 copies
Human Error [short fiction] 3 copies, 1 review
Chain of Fools [short fiction] 2 copies, 1 review
Hello Said the Gun 2 copies, 1 review
Mother Urban's Booke Of Dayes 2 copies, 1 review
People Of Leaf and Branch (2014) 2 copies
Jack's House (2008) 2 copies
White Boyz 2 copies
Chain Of Stars 2 copies, 1 review
Untitled 2 copies
West to east [short fiction] 2 copies, 1 review
Daddy's Caliban (2007) 2 copies
Fading Away 2 copies
Clown Eggs 2 copies
The Soul Bottles (2010) 2 copies
Grindstone [short fiction[ 1 copy, 1 review
Spendthrift [short fiction] 1 copy, 1 review
Testaments [short fiction] 1 copy, 1 review
The Git 1 copy
Two Stories 1 copy
Elf Shit 1 copy
Hitching to Aurora (2011) 1 copy
The Rose Egg 1 copy
G.o.d. 1 copy
Small Magic 1 copy
Alien Dreams 1 copy
April 1 copy
Clean 1 copy
Pax Agricola 1 copy
The Angle Of My Dreams (2002) 1 copy
Real North 1 copy
Speciation 1 copy
A Man Falls 1 copy
Fat Man 1 copy
Smoke 1 copy
Headed West 1 copy
Deka Logos 1 copy
February 1 copy
Gospel Truth 1 copy
Imago 1 copy
January 1 copy
June 1 copy
March 1 copy
May 1 copy

Associated Works

Steampunk (2008) — Contributor — 875 copies, 24 reviews
The Thackery T. Lambshead Pocket Guide to Eccentric and Discredited Diseases (2003) — Contributor — 809 copies, 20 reviews
Metatropolis (2008) — Contributor — 621 copies, 31 reviews
The New Weird (2008) — Contributor — 567 copies, 13 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Third Annual Collection (2006) — Contributor — 567 copies, 5 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Fourth Annual Collection (2007) — Contributor — 458 copies, 6 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Sixth Annual Collection (2009) — Contributor — 424 copies, 2 reviews
Extraordinary Engines: The Definitive Steampunk Anthology (2008) — Contributor — 366 copies, 17 reviews
The New Space Opera 2 (2009) — Contributor — 363 copies, 13 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Eighth Annual Collection (2011) — Contributor — 329 copies, 3 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Seventh Annual Collection (2010) — Contributor — 321 copies, 6 reviews
Sympathy for the Devil (2010) — Contributor — 301 copies, 8 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Ninth Annual Collection (2012) — Contributor — 275 copies, 5 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Steampunk (2012) — Contributor — 258 copies, 5 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Thirtieth Annual Collection (2013) — Contributor — 255 copies, 3 reviews
The Solaris Book of New Science Fiction: Volume 1 (2007) — Contributor — 239 copies, 6 reviews
Paper Cities: An Anthology of Urban Fantasy (2008) — Contributor — 227 copies, 9 reviews
The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy of the Year, Volume 1 (2007) — Contributor — 217 copies, 6 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Thirty-Second Annual Collection (2015) — Contributor — 205 copies, 8 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Thirty-First Annual Collection (2014) — Contributor — 203 copies, 3 reviews
Clockwork Fairy Tales: A Collection of Steampunk Fables (2013) — Contributor — 191 copies, 5 reviews
Cthulhu’s Reign (2010) — Contributor — 165 copies, 7 reviews
Westward Weird (2012) — Contributor — 138 copies, 9 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror 15 (2004) — Contributor — 136 copies, 1 review
The Year's Best Dark Fantasy & Horror 2011 Edition (2011) — Contributor — 132 copies, 7 reviews
Logorrhea: Good Words Make Good Stories (2007) — Contributor — 131 copies, 2 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Monsters (2007) — Contributor — 128 copies, 4 reviews
The Modern Fae's Guide to Surviving Humanity (2012) — Contributor — 108 copies, 5 reviews
The Solaris Book of New Fantasy (2007) — Contributor — 98 copies
The Year's Best Science Fiction & Fantasy, 2010 Edition (2010) — Contributor — 97 copies, 2 reviews
The Best of Subterranean (2017) — Contributor — 94 copies, 8 reviews
Seeds of Change (2008) — Contributor — 91 copies, 5 reviews
Dark Faith (2010) — Contributor — 80 copies, 4 reviews
Realms: The First Year of Clarkesworld Magazine (2008) — Contributor — 80 copies, 2 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction & Fantasy, 2013 Edition (2013) — Contributor — 78 copies, 1 review
The Mammoth Book of Best New Horror 18 (2007) — Contributor — 77 copies
The Year's Best Science Fiction & Fantasy, 2009 Edition (2010) — Contributor — 76 copies
Fantasy: The Best of 2004 (2005) — Contributor — 75 copies, 1 review
The Mammoth Book of Steampunk Adventures (2014) — Contributor — 73 copies, 4 reviews
Wizards, Inc. (2007) — Contributor — 71 copies, 2 reviews
Crime Spells (2009) — Contributor; Contributor — 68 copies, 1 review
Better Off Undead (2008) — Contributor — 62 copies, 2 reviews
Subterranean: Tales of Dark Fantasy 2 (2011) — Contributor — 61 copies, 1 review
Space Opera (2014) — Contributor — 61 copies, 2 reviews
Forbidden Planets (2006) — Contributor — 60 copies, 3 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Dieselpunk (2015) — Contributor — 59 copies, 1 review
The Mammoth Book of Angels and Demons (2013) — Contributor — 58 copies
L. Ron Hubbard Presents Writers of the Future, Volume 19 (2003) — Contributor — 56 copies, 2 reviews
Is Anybody Out There? (2010) — Contributor — 55 copies, 1 review
Visitants (2010) — Contributor — 54 copies, 10 reviews
Hex in the City (2013) — Contributor — 54 copies, 3 reviews
Leviathan 4: Cities (2005) — Contributor — 53 copies
Steampunk World (2014) — Contributor — 52 copies, 2 reviews
Time After Time (2005) — Contributor — 52 copies, 4 reviews
A Field Guide to Surreal Botany (2008) — Contributor — 50 copies, 1 review
Best New Fantasy (2006) — Contributor — 49 copies
Fantasy for Good: A Charitable Anthology (2014) — Contributor — 46 copies, 1 review
Realms 2: The Second Year of Clarkesworld Magazine (2010) — Author — 45 copies, 1 review
The Steampunk Megapack: 26 Modern and Classic Steampunk Stories (2013) — Contributor — 43 copies, 1 review
The Book of Dreams (2010) — Contributor — 43 copies, 1 review
Clarkesworld: Issue 100 (January 2015) (2015) — Contributor — 42 copies, 11 reviews
Clarkesworld: Year Three (2013) — Contributor — 41 copies, 2 reviews
Fate Fantastic (2007) — Contributor — 40 copies
Human for a Day (2011) — Contributor — 40 copies, 1 review
Love and Rockets (2010) — Contributor — 40 copies
The Stories: Five Years of Original Fiction on tor.com (2013) — Contributor — 40 copies
The Mammoth Book of Warriors and Wizardry (2014) — Contributor — 38 copies, 2 reviews
Straying From the Path (2011) — Introduction — 37 copies, 2 reviews
Album Zutique: No. 1 (2003) — Contributor — 37 copies, 1 review
Untold Adventures: A Dungeons & Dragons Anthology (2011) — Contributor — 36 copies, 1 review
Street Magicks (2016) — Contributor — 36 copies, 2 reviews
Grants Pass (2009) — Contributor — 35 copies, 3 reviews
Fantastic Companions (2005) — Contributor — 35 copies, 2 reviews
Last Drink Bird Head : A Flash Fiction Anthology for Charity (2009) — Contributor — 33 copies, 1 review
Uncanny Magazine Issue 1: November/December 2014 (2014) — Contributor — 32 copies, 2 reviews
Clarkesworld: Year Four (2013) — Contributor — 32 copies, 1 review
Rode Hard, Put Away Wet: Lesbian Cowboy Erotica (2005) — Contributor — 31 copies, 1 review
Dark Terrors 6 (2002) — Contributor — 29 copies
The Magic Toy Box (2006) — Contributor — 29 copies, 2 reviews
Boondocks Fantasy (2011) — Contributor — 26 copies
The Lone Star Stories Reader (2008) — Contributor — 23 copies
Japanese Dreams: Fantasies, Fictions & Fairytales (2009) — Contributor — 22 copies, 1 review
Dark Faith: Invocations (2012) — Contributor — 22 copies, 5 reviews
Tales for Canterbury: Survival, Hope, Future (2011) — Contributor — 20 copies, 4 reviews
When the Hero Comes Home (2011) — Contributor — 19 copies, 1 review
Agog! Ripping Reads (2006) — Contributor — 17 copies
Postscripts Magazine, Issue 1 (2004) — Contributor — 17 copies
Coins of Chaos (2013) — Contributor — 15 copies
When the Villain Comes Home (2012) — Contributor — 15 copies
Postscripts Magazine, Issue 15: Worldcon 2008 Special (2008) — Contributor, some editions — 15 copies
Text: Ur (2007) — Contributor — 14 copies
Clarkesworld: Year Nine, Volume One (2018) — Contributor — 13 copies
Shanghai Steam (2013) — Introduction — 13 copies
River (2011) — Contributor — 12 copies
Visual Journeys: A Tribute to Space Artists (2007) — Contributor — 12 copies, 1 review
The Feathered Edge (2012) — Contributor — 10 copies
The Best of Talebones (2010) — Contributor — 9 copies
Beyond the Last Star: Stories from the Next Beginning (2002) — Contributor — 9 copies
Like Water for Quarks (2011) — Contributor — 8 copies
The Best of Abyss & Apex: Volume One (2009) — Contributor — 8 copies
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 77 • October 2016 (2016) — Contributor — 8 copies
Apex Magazine 12 (May 2010) (2010) 8 copies, 1 review
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 67 • December 2015 (2015) — Contributor — 7 copies
Lady Churchill's Rosebud Wristlet No. 14 (2004) — Contributor — 7 copies
The Best of Strange Horizons: Year Two (2004) — Contributor — 6 copies
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 98 • July 2018 (2018) — Contributor — 6 copies, 1 review
Metastasis: An Anthology to Support Cancer Research (2013) — Contributor — 6 copies, 2 reviews
Clarkesworld: Issue 005 (February 2007) — Contributor — 6 copies
Blood & Devotion: Tales of Epic Fantasy (2010) — Contributor — 6 copies
Tales From The Fathomless Abyss (2011) — Contributor — 5 copies
Fabulous Whitby (2008) — Contributor — 5 copies
Jigsaw Nation (2006) — Contributor — 4 copies, 1 review
The Year's Top Ten Tales of Science Fiction 2 (2010) — Author — 4 copies
Fantasy Bundle (2017) — Contributor — 3 copies, 1 review
From the Trenches (2006) — Contributor — 2 copies
Subterranean Magazine Summer 2010 — Contributor — 2 copies
Clarkesworld: Issue 018 (March 2008) — Author — 2 copies
Daily Science Fiction: February 2011 (2011) — Contributor — 1 copy, 1 review
Daily Science Fiction: January 2017 (2017) — Contributor — 1 copy, 1 review
Subterranean Magazine, Issue #3 (Winter 2006) (2006) — Contributor — 1 copy

Tagged

2008 (87) 2008s (84) 2009 (28) alternate history (72) anthology (106) C (108) clockpunk (31) collection (36) ebook (155) fantasy (479) fiction (353) free sf reader (105) goodreads (28) Kindle (23) library (28) not free sf reader (34) read (49) religion (25) science fiction (352) sf (217) sff (50) short fiction (47) short stories (227) short story (23) signed (62) speculative fiction (63) steampunk (203) to-read (277) unread (55) wishlist (26)

Common Knowledge

Canonical name
Lake, Jay
Legal name
Lake, Joseph, Edward, Jr.
Other names
Lake, Joseph E., Jr.
Edwards, Joe (pseudonym)
Birthdate
1964-06-06
Date of death
2014-06-01
Gender
male
Education
University of Texas, Austin (BA ∙ Plan II)
Occupations
marketer
business writer
product manager
Organizations
Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America
Awards and honors
John W. Campbell Award (2004)
Agent
Jennifer Jackson (DMLA)
Cause of death
colon cancer
Nationality
USA
Birthplace
Taiwan
Places of residence
Portland, Oregon, USA
Place of death
Portland, Oregon, USA
Associated Place (for map)
Portland, Oregon, USA

Members

Reviews

355 reviews
Surprisingly, given the nature of a number of the reviews I've seen for this book, I really enjoyed it.

Let me rephrase. I opened it up briefly to peek at it and see what the writing was like, and ended up carting the book up and down the stairs with me while I got ready for work, reading over breakfast, reading the moment I got home, and reading well past my bedtime to find out what happened. I loved this book.

I think the author did very well communicating the depths of Green's lack of show more understanding about the world around her; I think he did well following her journey to understanding about her own nature; I think the journey itself had mythic qualities that not only follow the quintessential hero's journey, but the tales of folklore.

I also loved the writing style. For some reason, I found it almost lyrical and meditative.
show less
Rating: 4* of five

The Publisher Says: "Within our tale, gentle reader, you will see writ before you a palimpsest of low living and high misdemeanor, and the curious redresses that are visited as a result thereof . . ."

In The Baby Killers, Jay Lake restages mankind's Fall from Grace as an alternate-history steampunk fable. Written in a style of rambunctious Victoriana-that-never-was, this novella is set in Philadelphia in 1907, when that city serves as the seat of the British Dominion of the show more Americas, and as a Pandora's Box of sin and vice. The Governor-General has a taste for violating innocents, while the good Dr. Scholes uses them to fashion his mechanized agents of Justice. The Gollinoster, a feminine incarnation of angry retribution, wanders beneath the city streets - and an undying creature of ancient destruction is rushing to meet her. Villains and heroes (categories that overlap significantly) battle in a story of debauchery, degradation, radical experimentation, mad metaphysics . . . and a farting Frenchman.

Both popular culture and actual history are mined here to create a tale in which the use of idealized technology meets our darkest desires . . . and the result is positively electric.

My Review: Never let it be said or implied or even thought that Jay Lake is anything other than adventurous. This is an exuberant trip into a sick, weird vision of a sick, weird culture.

Much like our own.

Don't believe me?
{She} stood sobbing in front of her house. She, who had not cried since age ten when her brother took her virginity in the upstairs maid's room. ... There had probably been six people in the house when {the girl} exploded into flames. Two were girls from her list, valuable members of her stock book.

If this doesn't remind you of the response of the owners to the Bangladeshi clothing-factory collapse, and the BP America president's response to the Deepwater Horizon disaster, you're not paying attention.

The Baby Killer of the title isn't what you think it is. Well, it sort-of is; but not really because it's so much worse than what you think it is: Dr. Scholes uses the living brains of babies to power his retribution machines, his Robocops of steam, which of course means the babies qua babies are dead, though their "lives" are continuing and are augmented by Countess Lovelace's punchtape difference engines.

Drone-using teenaged soldiers, anyone?

So that's the book's level of success. It's a dark and bitter look at the endless and boundless vileness of humanity, and it's a cautionary tale told too late about the price extracted from us all for the sin of hubris, and it's darkly funny as well as starkly moral. It's compact, at 68pp, and so it's impossible to overdose on the grims. It's got a farting Frenchman as its Angel of Justice. It's, well, it's surreal and it's weird and I can think of no good reason for you not to buy and read it.

So go already. Amazon doesn't run on air.


This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
show less
Rating: 4.25* of five

The Publisher Says: The City Imperishable's secret master and heir to the long-vacant throne has vanished from a locked room, as politics have turned deadly in a bid to revive the city's long-vanished empire.

The city's dwarfs, stunted from spending their childhoods in confining boxes, are restive. Bijaz the Dwarf, leader of the Sewn faction among the dwarfs, fights their persecution. Jason the Factor, friend and apprentice to the missing master, works to maintain show more stability in the absence of a guiding hand. Imago of Lockwood struggles to revive the office of Lord Mayor in a bid to turn the City Imperishable away from the path of destruction.

These three must contend with one another as they race to resolve the threats to the city.

My Review: What a trip. The back cover copy calls it an "urban fantasy," which to my mind doesn't conjure images of Perdido Street Station (which this book reminds me of) so much as it does Dead Until Dark et. seq. But the key factor here is to be found in the word "fantasy."

I read a fantasy novel.

There, I said it.

I not only read it, I enjoyed it. BUT DON'T FOR GAWD'S SAKE TELL ANYONE. I will swear an oath that you're lying and that you must be the one who hacked my account and wrote a glowing heap of praise for a book with dwarves, an ancient city declining under an empty throne, a reluctant hero...well, you see my predicament. I can't admit out loud that I liked this kind of guff. "The city is," runs the motto Lake gives the City Imperishable. Yeeesh, really? Portentous much?

But seriously, who wouldn't like a book with this in it:
There was nothing left of himself that he wanted, save the vague glimmer of peace that he found somewhere inside the violet smoke. Finally he understood the place to which his wife had long since retreated.
Sometimes, when the snow was not so deep and he'd managed a little soup or coffee, {he} thought about making his way {home} and apologizing to his wife. He wasn't sure she'd understand him though--the crap dust had begun to rot his teeth, getting in all too quickly through the breaks, and his tongue was always dry as leather and twice too big.

The abjection of a powerful character, the absolute fall, the hitting bottom with a resounding *crunch* is unsettlingly well-limned.

And some regulars among you might recall my utterances on the subject of majgicqk. They have been uniformly derisory and occasionally cachinnatory. But here again Lake subverts and alters my wall of defense against balderdash:
"Everything carries the seeds of its own opposition, in equal measure. Have you ever toppled a wall? ... You must press as much as it takes to move the stones. They react as they are pushed. What people care to call magic works the same way. No one calls lightning from the summer sky without burning a hole in something, somewhere."

When you put it that way....

The City Imperishable is, like all places and cultures, built on a bargain. The bargain has costs and it has benefits. Those who pay the costs aren't always the ones who reap the benefits. Each main character, Bijaz the dwarf, Imago the Lord Mayor, and Jason the fector, pays dearly for the City Imperishable to derive the final benefit: Remaining alive. But each of these men, in their turn, finds a greater benefit in his sacrifice. They become whole in their brokenness, and anneal the metal of their character, and in the testing of their different mettles, bring life raging anew through the City Imperishable.

The city is.
show less
½
Rating: 4.75* of five

The Publisher Says: Jay Lake's first trade novel is an astounding work of creation. Lake has envisioned a clockwork solar system, where the planets move in a vast system of gears around the lamp of the Sun. It is a universe where the hand of the Creator is visible to anyone who simply looks up into the sky, and sees the track of the heavens, the wheels of the Moon, and the great Equatorial gears of the Earth itself.

Mainspring is the story of a young clockmaker's show more apprentice, who is visited by the Archangel Gabriel. He is told that he must take the Key Perilous and rewind the Mainspring of the Earth. It is running down, and disaster to the planet will ensue if it's not rewound. From innocence and ignorance to power and self-knowledge, the young man will make the long and perilous journey to the South Polar Axis, to fulfill the commandment of his God.

My Review: Several things militate against my discovery of pleasure in this book, such as a Low Tolerance for Capitalization Errors, a complete and oft-expressed disdain for the kind of god present in this book, and its celebration of the Love that Should Shut The Hell Up Already, aka heterosexuality.

But there's an exception to every rule, and this is one.

I confess that the thoroughly requited love story elicited weary, disgusted sighs, and I did a bit of flippity-flip to get past the bits that made me most annoyed, but there's not a whole helluva lot of it, thank goodness. And working for the couple is the fact that she's a different species, sort of.

But the central joke of the book, the mainspring (!) of the humor, the drama, and the action, is the brass track in the sky that the Earth runs on. The Universe IS the clockwork that the famously disproved watchmaker-parable proof of god's existence posits! (If one finds a watch, that is proof there is, somewhere, a watchmaker...the rest is just as silly, so no need to go into it here.)

This I love. This alone gets five whole gold stars with an oak-leaf cluster. This is a new Universe, not just a warmed-over Operation-Sealion-worked yawnfest of an alternative history. (Side note to writers: WWII? Done, done, done, done, done. Aliens even. DONE. Pick something else! ANYthing else!) (Except the American Civil War, also DONE.)

Also because of this complete re-imagining of the laws of physics (good one, Mr. Lake!), I put aside my abiding mistrust of majgicqk as deus ex machina. After all, there's a giant brass track in the sky that emits a mechanical rumble forming the backdrop of all life, the gears of the track must be navigated to go from Northern to Southern Hemisphere, and there are airships! In for a penny, in for a pound. Majgicqk it is.

But it's like all the other tropes that annoy me in fiction (indeed in life), it's *used* in Lake's novel. It's not a Get-Out-Of-Jail-Free card. It's a necessary component of the kind of world this clockmaker god would create. It makes sense. And it happens to be made of desperate needs, which is more like the way the world works anyway.

Hethor, like all heroes, suffers on his quest to save the world, and loses his sense of himself outside his quest. He defines himself as his quest, and is forced to confront the inevitable end of such a self-definition: Complete and utter aloneness and alienation. Because Lake is on the Hero's Journey, the Hero must lose it all.

But Lake is on the Hero's Journey. So, in losing it all, Hethor is rewarded with his heart's desire, and it is not the one he started the quest desiring. That, in my well-read opinion, is how a writer of great gifts ends a Hero's Journey: Wishes granted; now what will those be?

A quarter star off for a villain who isn't a villain but a collection of nasty until far too late in the story to matter. His villainy, as finally expressed, would've launched me into six-star orbit had it been explicit earlier in the narrative.

Whipping back through Mainspring convinces me that a thoroughgoing re-read cannot come amiss. It's that good. It's that rich and dense and satisfying. Just wonderful, and thank you for it, Jay Lake.
show less
½

Lists

Awards

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Ken Scholes Contributor, Author
Carol Emshwiller Contributor
Pamela Sargent Contributor
Ruth Nestvold Contributor, Author
Jeff VanderMeer Contributor
Forrest Aguirre Contributor
Nick Mamatas Contributor
Lucius Shepard Contributor
Theodora Goss Contributor
Carrie Vaughn Contributor
Ekaterina Sedia Contributor
Bruce Holland Rogers Contributor, Author
Greg Van Eekhout Contributor
Ray Vukcevich Contributor, Author
Benjamin Rosenbaum Contributor
Elizabeth Bear Contributor
Robert Freeman Wexler Contributor, Author
Leslie What Contributor
Tim Pratt Contributor
Tobias S. Buckell Contributor
James Van Pelt Contributor
Michael Bishop Contributor, Author
Kit Reed Contributor, Author
Jack Dann Contributor, Author
Sally Carteret Contributor, Author
Lawrence M. Schoen Contributor
Eric Marin Contributor
Stephen Baxter Contributor
Liz Williams Contributor
Alastair Reynolds Contributor
Paul Park Contributor
Gene Wolfe Contributor
Mikal Trimm Contributor
Jeremiah Tolbert Contributor
Howard Waldrop Contributor
Karl Schroeder Contributor
Vandana Singh Contributor, Author
Don Webb Contributor, Author
Nina Kiriki Hoffman Author, Contributor
Heather Shaw Author, Contributor
M. K. Hobson Contributor
Timalyne Frazier Contributor
Brendan Connell Contributor
Lee Battersby Contributor
David Brin Contributor
Jed Hartman Contributor
Richard A. Lupoff Contributor
James L. Cambias Contributor
David D. Levine Contributor
Paul Berger Contributor
Michael Manis Contributor
Tobias Buckell Contributor
Mike Philbin Contributor
Maureen McHugh Contributor
Douglas Lain Contributor
Andy Duncan Contributor
Eliot Fintushel Contributor
Lisa Goldstein Contributor
Steven Mohan Jr. Contributor
Beth Bernobich Contributor
Stepan Chapman Contributor
Brendan Day Contributor
Piper Selden Contributor
Gavin J. Grant Contributor
Honna Swenson Contributor
Dianna Rodgers Contributor
Diana Sherman Contributor
Jerry Oltion Contributor
Jenn Reese Contributor
Ken Liu Contributor
Eric M. Witchey Contributor
Holly Arrow Contributor
David Moles Contributor
Richard Wadholm Contributor
Darin C. Bradley Contributor
Ben Peek Contributor
Josh Rountree Contributor
Hannah Wolf Bowen Contributor
Paul M. Berger Contributor
Anna Tambour Contributor
Esther M. Friesner Contributor
Laura Anne Gilman Contributor
Barry N. Malzberg Contributor
Robert Reed Contributor
Steven Utley Contributor
D. G. K. Goldberg Contributor
Alexander Lamb Contributor
Brian Richard Wade Contributor
Scott Thomas Contributor
Blake Hutchins Contributor
Rick Waldholm Contributor
Jay Caselberg Contributor
John Aegard Contributor
Seanan McGuire Contributor
Bob Urell Contributor
Aynjel Kaye Contributor
Rob Vagle Contributor
Paul O. Miles Contributor
Robin Catesby Contributor
Michael Jasper Contributor
Nancy Jane Moore Contributor
Iain Rowan Contributor
Joy Marchand Contributor
Eric Schaller Contributor
Sarah Totton Contributor
Frank Wu Illustrator
Lori Selke Contributor
Richard Becker Contributor
John Bowker Contributor
Lisa Mantchev Contributor
Lynne Jamneck Contributor
Joe Murphy Contributor
A.H. Jennings Contributor
Angeline Hawkes Contributor
Dean Wesley Smith Contributor
Steve Carper Contributor
Greg Beatty Contributor
Leah Bobet Contributor
Gregory Feeley Contributor
Sonya Taaffe Contributor
Ian Creasey Contributor
Paul Woodlin Contributor
Charles Tuomi Contributor
Greer Gilman Contributor
Jetse de Vries Contributor
Th. Metzger Contributor
Anil Menon Contributor
C.E. Grayson Contributor
Nathaniel Williams Contributor
Kate Kelly Contributor
Heather McDougal Contributor
Cliff Winnig Contributor
Jody Sherry Contributor
AD Guzman Contributor
J. Michael Shell Contributor
Mark Onspaugh Contributor
Christine Lucas Contributor
Alastair Mayer Contributor
Gene Stewart Contributor
Gerri Leen Contributor
David L. Clements Contributor
G. D. Falksen Contributor
Erin Cashier Contributor
Brenda Cooper Contributor
Eric Choi Contributor
Stephan Martiniere Cover artist, Illustrator
Daniel Dos Santos Cover artist, Illustrator
Edward Miller Cover artist
LeVar Burton Narrator
Kate Mulgrew Narrator
Wil Wheaton Narrator
Robin Miles Narrator
Mark Boyett Narrator
Scott Brick Narrator
Dion Graham Narrator
Michael Hogan Narrator

Statistics

Works
220
Also by
126
Members
3,768
Popularity
#6,725
Rating
½ 3.5
Reviews
194
ISBNs
88
Languages
6
Favorited
6

Charts & Graphs