Eg's Roots 25

Talk2025 ROOT Challenge

Join LibraryThing to post.

Eg's Roots 25

1EGBERTINA
Jan 19, 2025, 1:36 am

Okay- I think I accidentally figured this out.

I'm on my new "adventure" - in which I am struggling with memory and maintaining skills. I have been reading less and enjoying it less; for now, I strive to continue.

With this new "cross" in mind, I had planned to propose a total of 10 books. However, "a funny thing happened on the way to the forum". I got lost and separated. meanwhile, I managed to read 15 books this month. (at least 5 were Caldecott possibles) I will add 10 to the 15 and propose a total of 25. If I suddenly disappear somewhere along the way- you will probably guess why.

Let me know if this thread is in the wrong place and I wii add the ticker to the ticker thread in a few days.

Happy New Reading

2MissWatson
Jan 19, 2025, 5:31 am

Welcome back, Egbertina. Sorry to hear about your "cross", I hope keeping this thread is proving helpful.

3EGBERTINA
Jan 19, 2025, 1:19 pm

>2 MissWatson: thank u so much

4connie53
Jan 20, 2025, 5:43 am

Hallo Egbertina, so sorry to hear about your problems. I hope you will have some fun with ROOTing.

5EGBERTINA
Jan 20, 2025, 5:59 pm

>4 connie53: Thank u Connie. It is always lovely to see your photos. I think I am inspired to attempt putting up one of my youngest grandson.

6connie53
Jan 21, 2025, 5:26 am

Please do, Eg.

8EGBERTINA
Jan 21, 2025, 11:52 pm

9EGBERTINA
Jan 22, 2025, 12:30 am

I'm Eg. When I first joined LT, I had hoped to catch up on the ancient classics. I was, however, in the middle of completing all the Newbery/Caldecotts. I've been feeling the ol' noggin decline for a number of years, but last year was the worst. I now recognise that I shan't be completing the ancient writers or even the Victorians. Regrettably, I waited too long. It really hit home that you cannot walk back into a historic mind-set, once you've lost it. I watched my mother go through a similar process. Every week, I went to the library and borrowed 15-ish books. Literally, one day she stopped opening them. There had been authors that she loved and suddenly, they were too overwhelming for her. I recall her touching a book at her bedside sort of mindlessly wondering why it was there. I went about two weeks, in December, without opening a book and it was simultaneously alarming and of no consequence. So, I am attempting to maintain smaller forays into reading; focussing on one chapter at a time. These are my goals for the year.

1. any book on shelf
2. any book on e-book shelf
3. any book on a list that I follow
4. any ancient classic (she laughs)
5. primarily, suppose that I will focus on children's works that dont feel too dull; hoping to kindle some spark of interest, somewhere.

10connie53
Jan 22, 2025, 9:03 am

I really feel sorry for you and the way you feel now. I hope the spark will come back. And for being so open about what is happening to you. That is very courageous.

11Cecilturtle
Jan 22, 2025, 4:15 pm

>9 EGBERTINA: Wonderful determination! I wish you the best, Eg.

12EGBERTINA
Jan 22, 2025, 5:14 pm

thanks guys. not certain any determination involved.

13EGBERTINA
Jan 23, 2025, 2:28 pm

Girl, Woman, Other

Sadly this was a DNF, for me- I just couldn't follow the conversation. I wont add to my ticker. Hard enough when you can't remember books a week after reading them- but, to feel so lost while reading.....

14EGBERTINA
Edited: Jan 25, 2025, 9:32 pm

Unbroken
Martian Chronicles

Sadly, I just couldn't find my spark- but I did finish them

My Friend Flicka

Another DNF. As far as stories go, it had its place and time. I couldn't relate to the MC and the autocratic verbally-abusive Dad just was too much. If I had stuck it out the MC was going to develop a sense of purpose and responsibility, but this is not a time in my life when I need to endure abusing males berating their sons and wondering why the kid is rejecting adulthood. Good thing a horse was going to come along and be a proper mentor for the kid.

Elsie Dinsmore

This an example of a book that should have been read in childhood. Elsie was, originally, written c 1837. It was published in a children's magazine one chapter at a time across the years. 1837 was when Queen Victoria came to the throne, though, this is an American book. So, the historic backdrop is pre-Civil War. I'd never heard of this book, prior to the 1980's when a friend of mine told me that she and her children loved the Elsie books and they had read all of them. It is quite likely that I would have been able to garner a greater appreciation for Elsie in the 80's; though, I'm not certain I could ever have, fully, loved it.

Elsie appears in about the same year as Little Women - a book that i read in the fifth grade, still fully able to place myself into that style of writing and the time-period. The writing style and the expectations of readers is much gentler in Little Women, likely, due to the Transcendental influence.

Elsie introduces a much more severe supposition of Christianity; tenets such as not playing secular tunes on the Sabbath. Further, Elsie lives her creed. Though she is a girl of 8, she has been instructed by her "governess" and has chosen to follow God's laws over those of her family, including her father. Modern readers are likely to find this unlikely, but, I disagree. Children comprehended their spiritual lives and expectations to a much greater degree during that time period. I fully relate to 8 year old awareness of similar expectations. Children were often considered spiritually, adult by twelve, making communal commitments at that age. In that they were much less exposed to numerous religious sentiments, children were often surrounded only by their local prevailing religious attitudes. Most of my ancestors were strongly devoted to a single church and its mind-set, with little intermarriage permissible prior to the Depression.

While Elsie is, clearly, a subset of literature that indoctrinates young readers, I do not find it out of touch for those times. Even, her good behaviour is not that unrealistic. The popularity of this book suggests that young readers found her both believable and inspirational. My pre-Civil War family brought their steadfast and inflexible attitudes down to the Depression. It isn't until the Turn-of-the-Century, that authors begin promoting the concept of wiggly, boisterous, distracted children. Were they more accurate in their portrayals, or, simply, promoting a vogue trend?

However, as an adult, I could not love this book, unreservedly. It was neither the religion nor stiff morality; it was the outdated paternalistic and controlling attitudes of the father. Probably, immensely realistic for some even if also uber-dramatic, in-keeping-with the period. There are other outdated representations of the time.

There is a foreshadowing of an older man who is fond of this 8 year old child (all pretty innocent). I have to suppose, though, that he is going to become her husband- and this just creeps me out, no-end. Sure, I get it; it was a thing. Women were "protected" by these powerful older men. It is just that the adult me can no longer un-know the realities of all this patriarchal protection. Also, given Elsie's absolute religious passivity to meekness, humility, and submission.... no... no...no...

Little Women, Anne of Green Gables, Pollyanna avoided this aspect of the Protestant Ethos of their time, by omitting the paternal figures, either entirely, or mostly. The heroines blossomed in their freedom. Elsie only "blossoms" into subservience. Just fine for literature, but most of us know how this appears in real- life. I cannot view this as a healthy spiritual relationship, because all the submission to principles benefit the men, while Elsie is being groomed and ignorant of this reality.

If you are going to read this for maximum enjoyment, better read it before the age of 12.

15EGBERTINA
Edited: Feb 21, 2025, 6:23 pm

Getting Ready For February:

This year's Newbery/Caldecotts were named, today.

Anticipating reading the following:

The First State of Being - GOLD
2025

Across So Many Seas - Honor
2025
read last year

Magnolia Wu Unfolds It All
2025

One Big Open SkyDNF
2025

The Wrong Way Home
2025

Chooch Helped
Home In a Lunchbox
My Daddy Is a Cowboy
Noodles on a Bicycle
Up, Up, Ever Up!
and

Life After Whale - Robert F Siebert

16EGBERTINA
Edited: Mar 21, 2025, 6:53 pm

18EGBERTINA
Edited: Feb 2, 2025, 2:11 am

JANUARY STATS:

TOTAL - 24
ROOTS - 22
PICTURE BOOKS - 8
RE-READS - 3
JUVENILE/YA - 6
VARIOUS - 5
DNF - 2

19EGBERTINA
Feb 4, 2025, 12:29 am

Old Western Culture The Greeks The Histories DVD 3

So, I watched the DVD portion of this series, this evening. Perhaps, it will inspire me to read the book portion, too. I listened to an audiobook of Herodotus, last year; but audiobooks seldom are retained by the sieve on my shoulders. As far as the information part, - it's all knowledge, previously, acquired. Still, an enjoyable refresh.

20ritacate
Edited: Feb 20, 2025, 8:53 pm

>14 EGBERTINA: I can relate to your comments on Elsie Dinmore. Reading books of another era (or writing them) presents the challenge of understanding them in their cultural context and being able to separate that from our current expectations. It's the difference of frustration over an era that didn't recognize women's abilities versus getting angry that the author wrote from that view without acknowledging that was the norm in which he/she lived. I also struggle with the flip side when characters in historical novels express extremely modern viewpoints.

21EGBERTINA
Edited: Feb 21, 2025, 12:33 am

>20 ritacate: The heck of it is, that I, and I imagine, my generation were able to read Little Women; Kidnapped; and other older literature and have a decent grasp of the times. Partly, I suppose because much of the mindset of the world was still intact. My grandchildren will never be able to read Little Women as the distance has become too great. I loved that they played at Pilgrim's Progress. My grands could never identify with that - it is a moment, too far in time.

I feel a sense of loss over this, both in myself for no longer being able to fully relate to these older works; and that they can no longer speak to the next generations. Are we going to be the last generation to comprehend Dickens, without being forced to read him? Already, there are books that defy comprehension as the backdrops no longer make sense. So many cultural comprehensions, beyond mere vocabulary words.

Even my own children could not fully grasp the notion that mothers stayed home; (separate diatribe) because their teachers pounded the concept of career and make lots of money.

...

anyhow, thank u for your thoughts. I'd forgotten that I had accidentally posted that there. I'm so far behind on posting my random comments.

22EGBERTINA
Edited: Mar 1, 2025, 6:13 pm

FEBRUARY STATS:

TICKER TOTAL - 61
ROOTS - 32
PICTURE BOOKS - 14
RE-READS - 2
JUVENILE/YA - 11
VARIOUS - 8
CD - 1
DNF - 3

24EGBERTINA
Edited: Apr 29, 2025, 7:09 pm

25EGBERTINA
Edited: Apr 29, 2025, 7:04 pm

APRIL:

I have several teaching books that I am reading as I tutor. They will have been read several times by the time I enter them.

EDUCATION:
Junior Book - Carden Reading Method
Questions For Developing Comprehension And Building A Speaking Vocabulary
Complete Manual For Spelling Book 3
Carden Method Spelling Workbook 3
Carden Method Spelling Workbook 4
Carden Method Spelling Book 4
Carden Composition Forms 3

JUVENILE:
Blaze And The Mountain Lion
The Little Red Hen
Another Shore
The Chimneys Of Green Knowe
The River At Green Know

An Unexpected Peril
The quantum thief
A Thousand Pieces Of You

Longevity Paradox
Undoctored
Aging with Agency - Building

26EGBERTINA
Mar 30, 2025, 11:21 pm

I completely forgot that I listened to an audio book of
War and Peace

I had to listen to some chapters over and over again. Nothing much was sticking in my brain. I cant claim that it was a fun or meaningful read. Perhaps, I will try again in book form another year.

27EGBERTINA
Apr 29, 2025, 7:09 pm

29connie53
May 26, 2025, 6:49 am

Hi Eg, Reading a lot, I see.

30EGBERTINA
May 26, 2025, 2:09 pm

>29 connie53: oh hello. actually, so much less than i used to read. but i am grateful that i am getting more read than i thought possible. i used to read at least one a day regardless of size. I've been enjoying seeing your books, though. i keep trying to write about my books, but its not easy. also, I've been reading many scientific articles, but i can no longer find the energy to catalogue them.

31EGBERTINA
Edited: May 31, 2025, 9:20 pm

33EGBERTINA
Edited: Jul 30, 2025, 2:38 pm

JULY:

Mr. Arctic, an Account of Vilhjalmur Stefansson
Dinosaurs, dinosaurs

Why We Get Fat And What To Do About It

The Case for Keto
The Ageless Brain - How to Sharpen and Protect Your Mind for a Lifetime

MAGAZINE ARTCLES:
We’re Entering a New Age of Meatless Meat Today - But We’ve Been Here Before - At the turn of the 20th century, the first mock meat craze swept the nation
A Brief History of Peanut Butter - The bizarre sanitarium staple that became a spreadable obsession
The Secret Ingredient in Kellogg’s Corn Flakes Is Seventh-Day Adventism

34connie53
Jul 12, 2025, 12:40 pm

Hi, Eg. Good for you to do get some reading done and even more than you expected. Thanks for visiting my thread too and enjoying it.

35EGBERTINA
Edited: Jul 13, 2025, 7:39 am

>34 connie53: I always enjoy your reviews- because you get to read books less well known than those offered in my country (usa)

37EGBERTINA
Aug 31, 2025, 12:16 pm

41connie53
Dec 1, 2025, 6:57 am

>37 EGBERTINA: I'm in awe about the amount of books you have read. Do you ever sleep?

42EGBERTINA
Dec 4, 2025, 11:35 am

>41 connie53: Thank you. I'm mostly trying.

43EGBERTINA
Dec 26, 2025, 8:55 pm

I have added to my final ticker- but now I've lost the group post again.

If I don't end up at the new one in January- maybe someone can tell me where it is- ...

I' have contemplated not trying to keep next year, but, perhaps, if I just keep them low again, I won't get too lost.

44connie53
Dec 27, 2025, 11:05 am

>43 EGBERTINA: I will try to remember to give you a shout when the thread for 2026 is up, Eg.

Happy Days for you and your family!

45EGBERTINA
Dec 27, 2025, 1:44 pm

>44 connie53: oh thank you