Big news! LibraryThing is now free to all! Read the blog post and discuss the change on Talk.
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.


Star Wars on Trial: Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Debate the Most…

by David Brin (Editor), Matthew Woodring Stover (Editor)

Other authors: Lou Anders (Contributor), Bruce Bethke (Contributor), Jenne Cavelos (Contributor), Don DeBrandt (Contributor), Keith R.A. DeCandido (Contributor)13 more, Richard Garfinkle (Contributor), John G Hemry (Contributor), Tanya Huff (Contributor), Scott Lynch (Contributor), Nick Mamatas (Contributor), Robert A Metzger (Contributor), Laura Resnick (Contributor), Adam Roberts (Contributor), Kristine Kathryn Rusch (Collaborator), Bill Spangler (Contributor), Karen Traviss (Contributor), Ken Wharton (Contributor), John C Wright (Contributor)

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
1542128,684 (3.71)1
Debates on the authenticity of the Star Wars franchise and the hero-or-villain status of George Lucas are at the heart of these essays by bestselling science-fiction authors. The incredible popularity of the movies has led to the formation of strong emotions within the science fiction community on the strengths and flaws of the films, exemplified here by David Brin's attacks and Matthew Woodring Stover's defense of the movies. This intense examination of the epic works addresses a broad range of issues--from politics, religion, and the saga's overall logic to the impact of the series on bookshelf space as well as science-fiction film. The question Is George Lucas a hero for bringing science fiction to a mass audience or a villain who doesn't understand the genre he's working for? is discussed before a final "Judge's Verdict" on the greatness--or weakness--of the franchise is reached.… (more)



Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 1 mention

Showing 2 of 2
Thanks to Netgalley!

I'm not normally a reader of non-fiction unless I'm in a hardcore research mode, but I wanted this solely because I'm a fan of both David Brin and Matthew Woodring Stover. It really had nothing at all to do with the arguments one can fling at the SW universe, whether to attack or defend.

To do so is a very deep rabbit hole, indeed.

Fortunately, it turned out to be rather amusing to hear Stover intimate that Brin was a Sith Lord in disguise and to show that Stover is an unabashed apologist because he got paid for the novelization of Ep 6. (As well as a number of EU novels.)

But that isn't all! I genuinely enjoyed most of the coherent arguments and definitely enjoyed the incoherent ones. I think I'll always enjoy the reading of the movies as the revelation that we live in a real holographic universe and Lucas is just trying to show us the path, and that the Jedi are just exploiting the bugs in the software universe to hack and exploit it. Bingo! I can't enjoy the movies more than THAT interpretation. :)

But really, seeing the movies as a comedy in the old sense, that we enjoy them because it evokes a real sense of JOY? That resonates with me, too.

I couldn't care less that the movies are monsters of science inaccuracy. Even if I understand science, and I do, it doesn't always make for stories that resonate, and often put too much burden on any tale to make anyone want to read it, let alone watch a movie about it. Did anyone see Gravity? Did anyone see anything other than a bunch of action sequences and silence? Yeah, that's because it was scientifically accurate, and to bring anyone's attention to that fact would kill the tension. :)

But when it comes to the argument that women are consistently stripped of agency through the story arcs, I have to agree. Simply. Easily. Leia was treated poorly as a character, but Amadala's treatment was deplorable.

Fortunately for the rest of us who have actually seen the new movie, I rejoice in the new direction, and pray that Rey continues to be badass throughout the next two movies. Prove that the valid complaint had taken root and will grow into something truly marvellous. :)

This book came out right after Ep 6, and was given only a minor update *before* the release of Ep 7, so don't expect an cogent and relevant arguments either way that includes the new movie.

I would have LOVED that, but timing is everything, and this was aimed primarily at the fanboys and fangirls who love to think about the franchise, and the best time to capitalize on that is in the tension before the film.

Of course, now that the new movie is such a success, I hope to see more. :)

( )
  bradleyhorner | Jun 1, 2020 |
Not as funny as it thinks it is especially Stover. Although there is a need for soem humour, otherwise it would be just acollection of po-faced writers poking holes in a film, when everybody already knows that books are always better.

David brin leads the prosecution with a series of charges that amount to - SW was the best film, and that Lucas could have done a much better job than he did, especially with the rest of them. The Defense basically amounts to stop being so stuffy they are fun films that inspired generations of people. Neither of these sides are sufficeint to fill 395 pages of waffle. Stovers intended to be comic interuptions don't work, and the Droid Judge is equally dull.

Various other authors (18 of them, ranging from the just about famous like Tanya Huff, and Scott Lynch to the obscure) offer evidence one way or the other for the various charges, with more or less persuaive voices. None of them rise above the summary presented above. Noe of the short essays was sufficiently inpsiring for me to seek out more of their work or even remember what they said. Likewise none was that badly written that I made a note to avoid their work.

I'm not really siure who the target audience was concieved to be for this book. Die hard fans won't agree witht eh Defense's reasoning, and can't support hte prosecution, noone else will really care or be inspired to pick up the book. I thought it might be funny, but there was no corss examination, no rebuttal, just assertions. The prosecution cases don't include any evidence that Lucas could have done things a different way - all the suggested changes wuld cost more, make already long films even longer or more complicated.

Readable if you're doing a project on the Star Wars universe (or seeking inspiration as a spin-off writer), but no-one else should bother. ( )
  reading_fox | Apr 13, 2013 |
Showing 2 of 2
no reviews | add a review

» Add other authors

Author nameRoleType of authorWork?Status
Brin, DavidEditorprimary authorall editionsconfirmed
Stover, Matthew WoodringEditormain authorall editionsconfirmed
Anders, LouContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Bethke, BruceContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Cavelos, JenneContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
DeBrandt, DonContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
DeCandido, Keith R.A.Contributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Garfinkle, RichardContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Hemry, John GContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Huff, TanyaContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Lynch, ScottContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Mamatas, NickContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Metzger, Robert AContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Resnick, LauraContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Roberts, AdamContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Rusch, Kristine KathrynCollaboratorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Spangler, BillContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Traviss, KarenContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Wharton, KenContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Wright, John CContributorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed

Belongs to Publisher Series

You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
First words
Well, it's done.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Publisher series
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (2)

No library descriptions found.

Book description
Haiku summary

LibraryThing Author

David Brin is a LibraryThing Author, an author who lists their personal library on LibraryThing.

profile page | author page

Quick Links

Popular covers


Average: (3.71)
2 2
3 8
3.5 1
4 10
5 5


About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 149,179,083 books! | Top bar: Always visible