There There (2018)

A good book but very confusing to follow because of all the many characters' viewpoints. ( )

Great heartbreaking story centered around Native Americans in modern day Oakland. ( )

This is one of those recent darlings of critics and book clubs, taking advantage of the shift in marketing for underserved authors and communities. Not every book that's received the new attention deserves it, but Orange's book is a good one. The shifting narrative perspective keeps the story rolling, adding a new wrinkle with every shift. The only down side to the book is that the culminating climax is somewhat anti-climactic. It was jolting to find these rich and varied characters shoved into a violent event to end the book. Certainly, the tales of Natives and poverty ridden communities are replete with violence. But Orange's grand mass shooting felt contrived, given that the violence in those communities is so oftener the day-to-day, and all the more tragic for its mundanity.

Recommended.
4 bones!!!! ( )

For a debut novel, I found the writing to be excellent and the story very important. Profoundly developed, seemingly from first hand experience. I hope Tommy writes more, as moving as this. ( )

"There is no there there," said Gertrude Stein of Oakland, California, and in the title of Tommy Orange's debut novel. This is an excellent depiction of Oakland in the twenty-first century, as well as the indigenous people that live there. The city has come to symbolize Native Americans' loss of homeland and identity throughout American history.

"We know the sound of the freeway better than rivers, the roar of distant trains better than wolf howls, we know the scent of gas and freshly wet pavement and burned rubber better than the smell of cedar or sage or even fry bread," according to the novel's prologue.

The story follows 12 Native American people who all live in Oakland, or have lived there in the past, and who all come together for a major powwow at the Oakland Coliseum. This polyphonic novel, on the other hand, is significantly more intricate and sophisticated than that short description suggests. Each character has a unique relationship with his or her Native culture.

Orange emphasizes the importance of cultural inheritance and how it contributes to the generational divide among Native Americans. Because of the ways their culture has damaged them in the past, the older characters have moved past caring about connecting with it. One of the novel's initial narrators, Opal Victoria Bear Shield, recalls a childhood spent on Alcatraz, where her mother and several other Native American families stayed during the 1969-1971 occupation. She is unable to fathom her mother's decision to relocate her and her sister to a location with diminishing food, sparse accommodations, and complete isolation as a youngster, only later realizing that it was motivated by her mother's desire to fight for her culture.

Thus certain aspects of the modern Native American experience - often the more dark ones - are told through the experiences of these twelve characters. It is a well-written exploration of the urban life of some members of the indigenous population with particular storylines that are more compelling than others. The book is helped by both its structure and the thoughtfulness of the author in planning the arc of the story. ( )