Author picture

Mortimer Chambers (1927–2020)

Author of The Western Experience

26+ Works 542 Members 3 Reviews

About the Author

Series

Works by Mortimer Chambers

The Western Experience (1974) 269 copies, 3 reviews
Western Experience (Vol. 1) (1974) 45 copies
The Western Experience: To the Eighteenth Century (1994) — Editor — 18 copies
Western Experience (1982) 9 copies
Ancient Greece (1973) 6 copies

Associated Works

Tagged

Common Knowledge

Birthdate
1927-01-09
Date of death
2020-12-14
Gender
male
Education
Harvard University (BA, PhD)
University of Oxford (Wadham College)
Occupations
professor emeritus
Organizations
University of California, Los Angeles
Awards and honors
Rhodes Scholar
Nationality
USA
Associated Place (for map)
USA

Members

Reviews

3 reviews
This "social history" introduction has been given steroids in its most recent iteration: The Western Experience, with Primary Source Investigator and PowerWeb by Mortimer Chambers (McGraw-Hill Humanities/Social Sciences/Languages, 2006).
I have the 1983 Third Edition.
The authors lay the foundation for Jared Diamond's GUNS GERMS & STEEL explanation of European dominance as a result of geophysical factors. The TOC fails to mention the cartographic essay by Michael Conzen which begins the show more book, and which highlights the geographical diffusions in a series of maps.
The quality, however, is extremely "iffy". For example, in presenting the paleolithic roots of the Mesopotamian [3]"People took shelter, if possible, in caves." First, there are few caves in the riparian Tigris-Euphrates-Nile regions, and virtually no evidence that people "lived" in them. The authors present many ideas which are speculative; they only partially redeem themselves by admitting "We do not know" -- [25a] In speaking of the leadership of Moses, why did Israel accept one god, "in contrast to everyone else in the ancient world"].
The work is filled with many curiously naive gems. For example, "The discovery of agriculture did not herald the evolution of some 'higher' human species, since hunting often requires greater skill, cunning, and knowledge than growing grain." [4]
"The oldest known communities are Jericho and Jarmo, while the largest known food-producing village of early times is Catal Huyuk" in Turkey. The authors fail to note that the inhabitants of Huyuk were pig-farmers subsisting largely on pork, not just barley.
Many of the recitations of fact are simply wrong. For example, [94] "...the Romans established a distinction that had no parallel in any Greek state. The patricians...the plebeians." Actually, the Greek villages had pronounced class structures, and anthropologists have not yet found a human society without this concept of an aristocracy -- compare, J.Johnson's work among the Chumash, or the materials on ISHI.
For some reason, the authors fail to present the significance of Roman Law, passing lightly over it as if it was as obscure as its origins -- the "lost" tablets -- or as simple as a struggle between the two classes [95].
show less
University textbook. Survey of Western European history from the first civilizations in Mesopotamia and the Middle East, to ancient Greece, the Roman Empire, and Western Europe as it developed from the dark ages, middle ages, renaissance and reformation, wars, the enlightenment, revolutions, napoleon, 19th and 20th century developments. Includes sociology, politics, some art essays, and many maps. A good reference, almost 20 years later.

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Statistics

Works
26
Also by
6
Members
542
Popularity
#45,992
Rating
½ 3.5
Reviews
3
ISBNs
84
Languages
1

Charts & Graphs