W.L. Idema

While tedious at times, overall this was pretty interesting. Mulan is my favorite Disney leading lady, and so I loved experiencing these real, un-Disneyfied versions of her story. Seeing the changing perspectives on and adaptations of her story has allowed me to see the far ranging implications of her character and her legend. My only major complaint about this book is the introduction. I would have benefited more from individual introductions to each of the five works than from being show more bombarded with relevant information about each version plus the appendices in the beginning. But this is just a personal preference. show less

The Butterfly Lovers, one of the great stories in Chinese tradition, is often compared to Romeo and Juliet, which this story predates by at least 700 years. The tale of Zhu Yingtai, who disguises herself as a young man in order to study, and Liang Shanbo, her "sworn brother" until he learns the truth too late, is one of the world's great tragic love stories, kept alive through the centuries in the most popular forms of Chinese traditional storytelling: ballads and operas.

This show more scholarly/literary study of the narrative begins with a fascinating survey of the various forms the story has taken, followed by four complete translations of different versions from the 13th Century onwards, followed by another five brief or incomplete versions. It's fascinating to see how many elements remain in common through the various retellings, as well as to compare embellishments. While in every version Shanbo doesn't learn the truth of Yingtai's identity until too late, the circumstances of his arrival in her village and his subsequent death from a broken heart vary from version to version. Later, when Yingtai throws herself into Shanbo's open grave, some tales have shred from her garments transform into butterflies, while in others, the butterflies emerge from the crypt. The most interesting embellishment appears in "The Account of the Peony" in Appendix 4, in which a lengthy epilogue follows the lovers through purgatory and resurrection.

This book is recommended for scholars and those like me, fascinated by the story after having seen full-length opera versions many times. The translations are clear and readable, poetic and occasionally humorous. The main disappointment for me is that all the featured versions are short, around 30 pages each, while the version with the most literary appeal, "The Account of the Peony" is a translation of only the final act. I'm still wishing for a proper translation of a full-length libretto of one of the many Chinese opera versions. show less

Fascinating look at the different retellings of the story, along with some interesting commentary on gender and the shifting themes of the story (from filial piety to proto-feminist patriotism)

Idema is a well-renowned scholar of Chinese literature, and with his fellow author Haft, presents a detailed and comprehensive overview of the state of Chinese literature, from the pre-Qin era to the modern day, including works written in Taiwan. After an introductory section discussing the concept of literature and other features of traditional Chinese society crucial to understanding its writings, the second part is broken into five major time periods and discusses the key literature found show more therein. show less