Becky Garrison

A very personal yet penetrating analysis into the claims of "New Atheism" and its three main promoters-- Harris, Dennett, and Hawkins.

The author does not go into a deep scientific analysis of their views but shows familiarity with the writings of others against them. She does well at showing the inconsistencies and fallacies of their arguments and their perspective. It is evident that they are "high" on science and not nearly as well-educated about theology and are as prone to show more mischaracterization and puerile arguments as those whom they repudiate.

One also learns the author's story-- the loss of her parents, the trials of her faith that she has encountered-- and therefore the book also represents a very visceral investigation into what it means to have faith, be a Christian, and work for good in modern American society. show less

With a dry wit and an eye for hypocrisy, Garrison highlights the misbehaviors of prominent individuals and organizations alike, while espousing a return to the basic principles of the gospels. Abortion, homosexuality, policitcs: all the hot areas are covered and neither side escapes condemnation. Garrison succeeds in raising important questions and forcing others to consider their stances, but the first person tone reduces the impact of the argument somewhat. Humor is effectively embedded show more within the text, though those who do not follow religious news will not full appreciate the nuances. For readers who are discouraged by churches that focus on politic topics rather than personal faith and universal issues. show less

I really enjoyed this book. Garrison travels the country interviewing folks (both clergy and lay) who have been involved in the formation of new Christian communities. Most of the ministries in this book are from the Episcopal tradition.

I appreciate this book because it doesn't feel gimmicky to me. These are folks that aren't trying to save or grow churches but are simply trying to meet the needs they feel in themselves and in their communities. They aren't trying to tap into the "next big show more thing" but are instead trying to live out their calling in a faithful way that reaches the deepest parts of their hearts. show less

She raises very insightful points and seems on the right track, but she almost isn't hard hitting ENOUGH when it comes to Christians and political agendas.