In the Shadow of the Banyan

This is a feat of writing. In spite of the child’s-eye viewpoint, the author conveys the complexity and depth that are really essential to telling such a difficult story. Only in retrospect did I realize how closely I had followed Raami’s journey, and how much I learned from her even in moments where I “knew” more about what was happening than she did.

Set during the horror of the Khmer Rouge, a young girl and her family are forcibly moved from Phnom Penh to a rural district where they can be re-educated among the peasant class. Raami has lived in a wealthy household, surrounded by an extended family, including members of the royal family. Her father, a poet and intellectual, initially supports the Revolution, but their status puts their lives at risk as the Khmer Rouge rise to power. Raami’s innocence is shattered by the brutality of the civil war, but in the midst of almost unbearable sorrow, she is lifted up by the poetry of her father, the stories of her heritage, and by the love of those who surround her.

Please read this book! It will break your heart, but the writing is show more positively luminous and the persistence of the human spirit will inspire you. I can’t wait to read Vaddey Ratner’s second book, Music of the Ghosts. show less

Ratner tells us in her author's note that "Raami's story is in essence my own." This is a novel about love and survival and the power of stories. Raami is just seven-years-old when the novel begins, when the Khmer Rouge comes to power. The murderous regime over the course of four years was responsible for as many as two million deaths, wiping out about a third of the Cambodian population in their attempts to establish a communist utopia.

The story is described in blurbs as "lyrical." I thought at first too lyrical, bordering on purple, as Ratner paints an idyllic life among mangoes and butterflies and jasmine and the banyan tree, poetry and legends. It wasn't long before I was pulled in though; it occurs to me all that lush imagery show more isn't without its purpose--and not the one I thought at first. It's not so much that the golden world of her childhood is presented as a contrast to the horrors to come, as that it's a vision that sustains Raami through it. Raami's parents are especially strong characters. And the warmth lingers through much of the novel.

I couldn't help comparing this in my mind to Wiesel's Night, the memoir of his time in Auschwitz when barely in his teens. That wasn't cloaked as this story is in fiction. But the main difference is that this story somehow escapes its bleakness, despite the at times graphic brutality. Hope and faith even to the end shines through. It's not as powerful as Night, and the voice did strike me as a bit too sophisticated for such a young child, but this is still a moving story and very evocative of time and place with characters to care about. show less

In the Shadow of the Banyan is a fictionalized work that parallels author Vaddey Ratner's personal history: a (minor) royal family of privilege and education is driven from Phnom Penh during the Khmer Rouge revolution. Told from the perspective of seven-year-old Raami, the novel follows her family through years of toil and labor in the countryside of Cambodia, through monsoons, sickness, and famine. Banyan is suffused with myth and poetry, both of which play a large role in Raami's family. The storytelling is lyrical and rich and it transports the reader to the jungles, riverbanks and rice paddies of Cambodia. Ratner does an amazing job of illustrating both the horror of the genocide and the power of hope.

As beautifully written as the show more book is, I didn't love it. My personal preference is for stories that are driven by plot or dialog. This book is much more introspective and descriptive. I found myself skipping paragraphs, too anxious to find out what would happen next. (For comparative purposes: I had the same problem with Snow Falling on Cedars.)

Final verdict: Beautiful, but not the right book for me. I don't have the right reading temperament for Ratner's slow and deliberate style. show less

Moving and tragic story of Raami, a seven-year-old girl, and her family, as they, along with the rest of the population, are forced by the Khmer Rouge to evacuate Phnom Penh. They are relocated a number of times, and endure violence, oppression, physical deprivations, mental anguish, separation, and deaths of loved ones. In the Shadow of the Banyan is based on the author’s experience as a small child in Cambodia. She wrote it to honor the lives of the estimated two million people, including some of her family members, who suffered and died in the Cambodian genocide of 1975-1979.

Ratner shows the brutality of the Khmer Rouge regime, referred to as the “Organization,” but at the same time points out the small bits of beauty that show more remain in the wake of destruction. The author adds fragments of poetry, Cambodian folk tales and legends, and examples of human kindness. These seem particularly appropriate to a young and innocent narrator who wants to be protected from harm and uses the stories as a form of escape. The child narrator is also the only drawback: she often exhibits wisdom and language beyond her years.

Themes include the power of storytelling, family relationships, memories, guilt, grief, and love. Vaddey Ratner’s writing style is simply beautiful. Heart-wrenching but ultimately hopeful, this story illustrates the desire to live even in the most horrific conditions. show less

In the Shadow of the Banyan is a heartbreaking story of a minor royal Cambodian family caught up the disastrous social engineering of the Khmer Rogue in the mid 1970's. Based partially on the experiences of Ratner, herself being only five years old at the time when the Khmer Rogue came to power, this fictionalized account of the aristocracies and utter devastation of the Cambodian people have suffered through is beyond understanding. Ratner has done a wonderful job of breathing life into a period of Cambodia's darkest period. Chronicled from the perspective of a seven year old girl, whose family is violently uprooted from their city home and forced to work in the country as part of the idealized agrarian society the regime believes will show more return Cambodia back onto the right path, she gives first hand account of the struggle to adapt to ever changing whims of “Organization,” the lose of a beloved father, the separation of families, starvation, forced labor, and what it's like living knowing that one step out of line the Organization's ever changing rules results in torture in death. The tension knowing that at any moment the life you have built and rebuilt could be destroyed because you are today's enemy must have been overwhelming. And for much of the story there isn't a way out for this girl's family dark corrupt reality where death is all around them, but the overwhelming will to survive for her and her mother, if not for themselves than for all that they lost, gives them a chance a to triumph over extreme adversity and make their escape.

Ratner uses lines of poetry and flowery prose to create a serene atmosphere that is completely counter to devastation of the events taking place in the story. This gives the story a real sense of Buddhism; a peacefulness that's hard to describe concerting the topic. It can be surreal at times. Another thing I liked is the narrator, a child, is not the typical precocious child wise bound her years, instead her account reads like that of a child forced to grow up by her circumstances. It is a more adult like voice, but I think this only adds to her lose of innocence and her childhood. This is a beautifully written and heartbreaking account of the ugliness we humans can inflict on one another. show less

If we think about communism in Asia, as Americans we tend to focus on China or Korea or Vietnam. Very few people probably include Cambodia in that list and an even smaller handful of people are likely to have any knowledge of the Cambodian revolution and civil war in the 1970s, Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge, the atrocities they perpetuated, and the genocide that followed their takeover of this South East Asian neighbor to Vietnam. Vaddey Ratner's lyrical and heartbreaking tale of a seven year old girl's view of the revolution, based loosely on her own terrible experiences living through that desperate time, brings the reality of the time to vivid life.

Raami is a young princess in the Cambodian royal family. Despite her leg brace, needed show more after suffering polio as a baby, she lives a privileged life with her graceful mother, sensitive and poetic father, and beautiful baby sister. But her educated and wealthy family is not blind or indifferent to the poverty and want that seems to be growing daily outside their door. And as loved as the royal family is in some quarters, when the revolution comes, they too are swept up in the exodus from the city, hiding their origins in order to survive and struggling to stay together. The situation escalates as they move from place to place, feeling the pinch of hunger and forced into meaningless backbreaking labor. And they are not spared the suffering, separation, and the deaths of those they love that people all across the country endure at the brutal hands of the Khmer Rouge.

Because Raami is merely a child, the narration captures the horrific alongside her innocence and lack of understanding of the bigger, more menacing reality. She is sustained by the memory of her father's lyrical poetry and the fanciful stories she's internalized. And she has the striking ability to notice the landscape and the beauty of nature all around her even in the midst of horrors. This perspective helps to temper the graphic and terrible experiences, muting them some for the reader as well. As Raami recounts the starvation and the inhumanity of the labor camps, the deaths, and the brutality, she also finds instances of good and kindness around her, counterbalancing the inhumanity of man.

The novel is beautifully written although it still remains difficult to read about the worst of the atrocities, even with the gentler perspective of a child. And it is hard to believe that all of this horror was packed into only four years because there's so much sorrow and pain. Ratner's first hand experience shines through the text and her ability to find the beauty in the Cambodia she left so long ago and which decimated her beloved family is astounding. She has written a novel that doesn't shy away from documenting the worst of humanity but also celebrates survival, the resilience of the human heart, and the enduring bonds of family and of love. You won't soon forget this one. show less