Charl08 vs library's reservation shelf #2
This is a continuation of the topic Charl08 reads .
This topic was continued by Charl08 dreaming of beach reading #3.
Talk 75 Books Challenge for 2015
Join LibraryThing to post.
This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.
1charl08
“What we remember is probably fiction anyway.” —Beryl Bainbridge http://t.co/PgB7IVUq8f
— Quoted by The Paris Review (@parisreview)
(L) Lighthouse, Mull. (R) Gerard Manley Hopkins quote, part of a wall of Scottish poetry on the Scottish Parliament building, Edinburgh.
"What would the world be, once bereft of wet and wildness?
Let them be left, O let them be left, wildness and wet,
Long live the weeds and the wilderness yet."
2charl08
Read in 2015 73
January (25)
Mercy Department Q (Denmark M)
One Man, One Murder by Jakob Arjouni (Turkish-German M)
The Absent One by Jussi Adler-Olsen (Denmark M)
An Unnecessary Woman by Rabih Alameddine thanks to LizzieD (Lebanon M)
Truth Peter Temple - Foreign Bodies (SA / Australia M)
Tomorrow there will be Apricots (US F)
Bad Boy Brawly Brown -Foreign Bodies (US M A/A)
Five Children on the Western Front -Costa (UK F)
White Butterfly (US M A/A)
As the Crow Flies- African Women Writers (Cote D'Ivoire - self declared 'Pan-African' F)
Stone Mattress (Canada F)
Lila (US F)
Entanglement -Foreign Bodies (Poland M)
Always Outnumbered, Always Outgunned (US M A/A)
Academy Street - Costa awards (Irish F)
The Miniaturist (UK F)
The Map of Love - African Women Writers (Egypt F)
Memoirs of a Woman Doctor (Egypt F)
The Thin Man (US M)
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (UK F)
Distant view of a minaret - African Women Writers (Egyptian F)
A Red Death (US M A/A)
How to Be Both (UK F) (but alternative category? Scottish, w/c LGBT)
The Children Act (UK M)
The Toughest Indian in the World (US M N/A)
February (24)
The Holy Thief (Ireland, M)
A Little Yellow Dog (US M A/A)
Outline (UK F)
Elizabeth is Missing - Costa (UK F)
I was Jack Mortimer (Austria M)
July's People - African Women Writers (SA, F)
Blonde Faith (US M A/A)
How to Build a Girl (UK F)
Our sister Killjoy- African Women Writers (Ghana, F)
Dept of Speculation (US F)
A Man Called Ove recommended by VancouverDeb (Sweden, M)
Can't we talk about something more pleasant (US, F)
The Serpent Papers (UK, F)
The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher (UK, F)
The Zig Zag Girl (UK, F)
A Thread of Grace (US F)
A Land More Kind Than Home (US M)
Kindness Goes Unpunished (US M)
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian(US M N/A)
The Spectre of Alexander Wolf (Russia, M)
The Corpse on the Dike (Netherlands, M)
Harraga (Algeria, M)
Fun Home (US, F)
Rose Gold (US M A/A)
March (24)
Country Girl (Ireland, F) -- Gift
Chop Chop Costa Awards (UK, M) -- Library reservation
Your Madness not Mine - African Women Writers (Cameroon, F) -- Digital
The Broken Word (UK, M) -- Library reservation
Flight (US M N/A) -- Library reservation
The Dry Grass of August (US, F) -- Library reservation (ILL)
The Sleepwalker's Guide to Dancing (US, F) -- Library reservation
Bad Blood (UK, F) -- Library reservation
Hedy's Folly (US M) -- Library reservation
A Monstrous Regiment of Women (US, F) --Digital
Before I forget (South Africa, M) -- Library reservation
Funny Girl (UK, M) -- Charity shop buy
Aya of Yop City (Cote D'Ivoire, F)-- Library reservation (ILL)
All Our Names (Ethiopia, M) -- Library reservation
History of the Rain (Ireland, M) -- Library reservation
Dark Roots (Australia, F) -- Library reservation
Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter (South Africa, F) -- Library reservation
Blankets (US, M) -- Library reservation
Are you my Mother? (US, F) -- Library reservation
Bedsit Disco Queen (UK, F) -- Library reservation
Just so happens (Japan, F) -- Library reservation
Gone to Ground: One Woman's Extraordinary Account (Germany, F) -- Digital
Sights Unseen (US, F) -- Oxfam March Buy
Narrow Road to the Deep North (Australia, M) --Library
Currently reading
Carnival (Lebanon, M)--- Oxfam Feb Buy
Malcolm X: A life of reinvention (US, M A/A) -- News from Nowhere buy
In these times: living in Britain between the Napoleonic Wars (UK, F) -- Library
Aren't We Sisters? (US, F) --Library reservation
Ghettoside (US, F) --Library reservation
So long a letter (Senegal, F) - Library reservation
Stats on reading representation (at March 21st)
M: 35 F: 38
Europe: 29 US/ Canada 27 Rest of World: 17
January (25)
Mercy Department Q (Denmark M)
One Man, One Murder by Jakob Arjouni (Turkish-German M)
The Absent One by Jussi Adler-Olsen (Denmark M)
An Unnecessary Woman by Rabih Alameddine thanks to LizzieD (Lebanon M)
Truth Peter Temple - Foreign Bodies (SA / Australia M)
Tomorrow there will be Apricots (US F)
Bad Boy Brawly Brown -Foreign Bodies (US M A/A)
Five Children on the Western Front -Costa (UK F)
White Butterfly (US M A/A)
As the Crow Flies- African Women Writers (Cote D'Ivoire - self declared 'Pan-African' F)
Stone Mattress (Canada F)
Lila (US F)
Entanglement -Foreign Bodies (Poland M)
Always Outnumbered, Always Outgunned (US M A/A)
Academy Street - Costa awards (Irish F)
The Miniaturist (UK F)
The Map of Love - African Women Writers (Egypt F)
Memoirs of a Woman Doctor (Egypt F)
The Thin Man (US M)
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (UK F)
Distant view of a minaret - African Women Writers (Egyptian F)
A Red Death (US M A/A)
How to Be Both (UK F) (but alternative category? Scottish, w/c LGBT)
The Children Act (UK M)
The Toughest Indian in the World (US M N/A)
February (24)
The Holy Thief (Ireland, M)
A Little Yellow Dog (US M A/A)
Outline (UK F)
Elizabeth is Missing - Costa (UK F)
I was Jack Mortimer (Austria M)
July's People - African Women Writers (SA, F)
Blonde Faith (US M A/A)
How to Build a Girl (UK F)
Our sister Killjoy- African Women Writers (Ghana, F)
Dept of Speculation (US F)
A Man Called Ove recommended by VancouverDeb (Sweden, M)
Can't we talk about something more pleasant (US, F)
The Serpent Papers (UK, F)
The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher (UK, F)
The Zig Zag Girl (UK, F)
A Thread of Grace (US F)
A Land More Kind Than Home (US M)
Kindness Goes Unpunished (US M)
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian(US M N/A)
The Spectre of Alexander Wolf (Russia, M)
The Corpse on the Dike (Netherlands, M)
Harraga (Algeria, M)
Fun Home (US, F)
Rose Gold (US M A/A)
March (24)
Country Girl (Ireland, F) -- Gift
Chop Chop Costa Awards (UK, M) -- Library reservation
Your Madness not Mine - African Women Writers (Cameroon, F) -- Digital
The Broken Word (UK, M) -- Library reservation
Flight (US M N/A) -- Library reservation
The Dry Grass of August (US, F) -- Library reservation (ILL)
The Sleepwalker's Guide to Dancing (US, F) -- Library reservation
Bad Blood (UK, F) -- Library reservation
Hedy's Folly (US M) -- Library reservation
A Monstrous Regiment of Women (US, F) --Digital
Before I forget (South Africa, M) -- Library reservation
Funny Girl (UK, M) -- Charity shop buy
Aya of Yop City (Cote D'Ivoire, F)-- Library reservation (ILL)
All Our Names (Ethiopia, M) -- Library reservation
History of the Rain (Ireland, M) -- Library reservation
Dark Roots (Australia, F) -- Library reservation
Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter (South Africa, F) -- Library reservation
Blankets (US, M) -- Library reservation
Are you my Mother? (US, F) -- Library reservation
Bedsit Disco Queen (UK, F) -- Library reservation
Just so happens (Japan, F) -- Library reservation
Gone to Ground: One Woman's Extraordinary Account (Germany, F) -- Digital
Sights Unseen (US, F) -- Oxfam March Buy
Narrow Road to the Deep North (Australia, M) --Library
Currently reading
Carnival (Lebanon, M)--- Oxfam Feb Buy
Malcolm X: A life of reinvention (US, M A/A) -- News from Nowhere buy
In these times: living in Britain between the Napoleonic Wars (UK, F) -- Library
Aren't We Sisters? (US, F) --Library reservation
Ghettoside (US, F) --Library reservation
So long a letter (Senegal, F) - Library reservation
Stats on reading representation (at March 21st)
M: 35 F: 38
Europe: 29 US/ Canada 27 Rest of World: 17
3charl08
To read in 2015
Foreign Bodies 'challenge' - 3 read so far
To reread in 2015
Remains of the day (thanks to Sandykaypax's post)
Reading my bookshelves in 2015
Gateway for Africa / Bookshy's list of 50 Books by African women everyone should read / 6 Read so far in 2015!
1. The Translator - Leila Aboulela (Sudan) READ b4 challenge
2. The Aya Series Aya of Yop City- Marguerite Abouet (Cote D'Ivoire / France) READ
3. Half A Yellow Sun - Chimamanda Adichie (Nigeria) READ b4 challenge
4. Americanah READ b4 challenge
5. Changes: A Love Story - Ama Ata Aidoo (Ghana)
6. Our Sister Killjoy - READ
7. African Love Stories: An Anthology READ b4 challenge
8. Our Wife and Other Stories - Karen King-Aribisala (Nigeria)
9. Everything Good Will Come - Sefi Atta (Nigeria)
10. So Long a Letter - Mariama Ba (Senegal)
11. Tropical Fish: Stories out of Entebbe - Doreen Baingana (Uganda)
12. Patchwork - Ellen Banda-Aaku (UK/ Zambia / Ghana)
13. The Shining Girls - Lauren Beukes (South Africa) READ b4
14. We need new names - No Violet Bulawayo (Zimbabwe)
15. Daughters of Africa - Margaret Busby (Ghana / UK)
16. Nervous Conditions - Tsitsi Dangarembga (Zimbabwe) READ b4
17. Woman at Point Zero - Nawal El Saadawi (Egypt)
18. The Joys of Motherhood - Buchi Emecheta (Nigeria)
19. The Memory of Love - Aminatta Forna (Scotland / Sierra Leone) READ b4 challenge
20. July’s People - Nadine Gordimer (South Africa) READ
21. The Collector of Treasures - Bessie Head (South Africa)
22. In Dependence - Sarah Ladipo (Nigeria/ UK)
23. Secret Son - Laila Lalami (Morocco)
24. Sundowners - Lesley Lokko (Ghana/Scotland)
25. Black Mamba Boy - Nadifa Mohamed (UK / Somaliland)
26. Your Madness, Not Mine - Juliana Makuchi (Short Stories, Cameroon) READ
27. Neighbours: The Story of a Murder - Lilia Momplé (Mozambique)
28. Ripples in the Pool- Rebeka Njau (Kenya)
29. Efuru- Flora Nwapa (Nigeria)
30. I Do Not Come To You By Chance- Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani (Nigeria)
31. The Promised Land - Grace Ogot (Kenya)
32. Bitter Leaf - Chioma Okereke (Nigeria / England)
33. Zahrah the Windseeker - Nnedi Okorafor (US / Nigeria)
34. The Spider King’s Daughter - Chibundu Onuzo (Nigeria)
35. Dust - Yvonne Adhiambor Owuor (Kenya)
36. The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives (Nigeria) Lola Shoneyin READ b4
37. The Map of Love - Ahdaf Soueif (Egypt) READ
38. This September Sun - Bryony Rheam (Zimbabwe)
39. Distant View of a Minaret and Other Stories -Alifa Rifaat (Egypt) READ
40. As the Crow Flies - Véronique Tadjo (Côte d'Ivoire). READ
41. The Blind Kingdom (also by Véronique Tadjo)
42. On Black Sisters Street - Chika Unigwe (Nigeria / Netherlands) READ b4
43. Looking for Transwonderland: Travels in Nigeria - Noo Saro-Wiwa (Nigeria / England)
44. Butterfly Burning - Yvonne Vera (Zimbabwe).
45. Nehanda (also by Yvonne Vera)
46. Teaching my Mother How to Give Birth - Warsan Shire (Kenya / Somalia)
47. The Ghost Le Revenant in French) - Aminata Sow Fall (Senegal)
48. Men of the South - Zukiswa Wanner (South Africa)
49. David’s Story - Zoe Wicomb (South Africa)
Costa Shortlist novels & category winners
The Lives of Others
House of Ashes
How to Be Both READ
Nora Webster READ
• First novel
A Song for Issy Bradley
Academy Street READ
Elizabeth is Missing READ
Chop Chop READ
• BiographyThe Iceberg: A Memoir ABANDONED (TOO GRIM)
• Children’s book - Five Children on the Western Front READ
Non-fiction
Still thinking about this, but tempted by Verso books' feminist publishing list for 2015, which is on the list of 'things I think I should read more about'
Foreign Bodies 'challenge' - 3 read so far
- Nigeria The XIth Hour CM Okonkwo
- Australia Truth Peter Temple READ
- US Walter Mosely Bad boy brawly Brown READ
- Poland Zygmunt Miloszewski's Entanglement READ
- Thanks to drneutron I can add The Land of Dreams to the wish list
To reread in 2015
Remains of the day (thanks to Sandykaypax's post)
Reading my bookshelves in 2015
- Middlemarch
- The Broken Road By Patrick Leigh Fermor
- The Story of a Non-marrying Man
- The Periodic Table
- In a Free State
- Season of Migration to the North
- The Wake
- Three Letter Plague
Gateway for Africa / Bookshy's list of 50 Books by African women everyone should read / 6 Read so far in 2015!
1. The Translator - Leila Aboulela (Sudan) READ b4 challenge
2. The Aya Series Aya of Yop City- Marguerite Abouet (Cote D'Ivoire / France) READ
3. Half A Yellow Sun - Chimamanda Adichie (Nigeria) READ b4 challenge
4. Americanah READ b4 challenge
5. Changes: A Love Story - Ama Ata Aidoo (Ghana)
6. Our Sister Killjoy - READ
7. African Love Stories: An Anthology READ b4 challenge
8. Our Wife and Other Stories - Karen King-Aribisala (Nigeria)
9. Everything Good Will Come - Sefi Atta (Nigeria)
10. So Long a Letter - Mariama Ba (Senegal)
11. Tropical Fish: Stories out of Entebbe - Doreen Baingana (Uganda)
12. Patchwork - Ellen Banda-Aaku (UK/ Zambia / Ghana)
13. The Shining Girls - Lauren Beukes (South Africa) READ b4
14. We need new names - No Violet Bulawayo (Zimbabwe)
15. Daughters of Africa - Margaret Busby (Ghana / UK)
16. Nervous Conditions - Tsitsi Dangarembga (Zimbabwe) READ b4
17. Woman at Point Zero - Nawal El Saadawi (Egypt)
18. The Joys of Motherhood - Buchi Emecheta (Nigeria)
19. The Memory of Love - Aminatta Forna (Scotland / Sierra Leone) READ b4 challenge
20. July’s People - Nadine Gordimer (South Africa) READ
21. The Collector of Treasures - Bessie Head (South Africa)
22. In Dependence - Sarah Ladipo (Nigeria/ UK)
23. Secret Son - Laila Lalami (Morocco)
24. Sundowners - Lesley Lokko (Ghana/Scotland)
25. Black Mamba Boy - Nadifa Mohamed (UK / Somaliland)
26. Your Madness, Not Mine - Juliana Makuchi (Short Stories, Cameroon) READ
27. Neighbours: The Story of a Murder - Lilia Momplé (Mozambique)
28. Ripples in the Pool- Rebeka Njau (Kenya)
29. Efuru- Flora Nwapa (Nigeria)
30. I Do Not Come To You By Chance- Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani (Nigeria)
31. The Promised Land - Grace Ogot (Kenya)
32. Bitter Leaf - Chioma Okereke (Nigeria / England)
33. Zahrah the Windseeker - Nnedi Okorafor (US / Nigeria)
34. The Spider King’s Daughter - Chibundu Onuzo (Nigeria)
35. Dust - Yvonne Adhiambor Owuor (Kenya)
36. The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives (Nigeria) Lola Shoneyin READ b4
37. The Map of Love - Ahdaf Soueif (Egypt) READ
38. This September Sun - Bryony Rheam (Zimbabwe)
39. Distant View of a Minaret and Other Stories -Alifa Rifaat (Egypt) READ
40. As the Crow Flies - Véronique Tadjo (Côte d'Ivoire). READ
41. The Blind Kingdom (also by Véronique Tadjo)
42. On Black Sisters Street - Chika Unigwe (Nigeria / Netherlands) READ b4
43. Looking for Transwonderland: Travels in Nigeria - Noo Saro-Wiwa (Nigeria / England)
44. Butterfly Burning - Yvonne Vera (Zimbabwe).
45. Nehanda (also by Yvonne Vera)
46. Teaching my Mother How to Give Birth - Warsan Shire (Kenya / Somalia)
47. The Ghost Le Revenant in French) - Aminata Sow Fall (Senegal)
48. Men of the South - Zukiswa Wanner (South Africa)
49. David’s Story - Zoe Wicomb (South Africa)
Costa Shortlist novels & category winners
The Lives of Others
House of Ashes
How to Be Both READ
Nora Webster READ
• First novel
A Song for Issy Bradley
Academy Street READ
Elizabeth is Missing READ
Chop Chop READ
• Biography
• Children’s book - Five Children on the Western Front READ
Non-fiction
Still thinking about this, but tempted by Verso books' feminist publishing list for 2015, which is on the list of 'things I think I should read more about'
- Michèle Barrett and Mary McIntosh The Anti-Social Family
- Lynne Segal Straight Sex: Rethinking the Politics of Pleasure
- Sheila Rowbotham Woman’s Consciousness, Man’s World
- Juliet Mitchell Woman’s Estate
- Shulamith Firestone The Dialectic of Sex: The Case for Feminist Revolution
- Christine Delphy Dominating Others: Feminism and Racism after the War on Terror.
6msf59
Happy New thread, Charlotte! I love that best of list. I was also crazy about Lila and the Chast memoir. I liked Dept. of Speculation but did not love it.
8charl08
>5 Ameise1: That was quick!
---------
Finished Harraga. I've already written about it on the previous thread, so will try not to repeat myself. I thought that Sansal did an impressive thing in telling a story that talks about the experiences of migrants leaving Algeria, but also acknowledges what (and who) is left behind, and the consequences of losing large numbers of young people. It's made clear that this is a loss both as migrants who don't plan to return and those who can't because they don't survive trafficking.
It is scorching in critique of corruption throughout Algeria, from the police to the civil service, health professionals and even the head of state. It is also (bravely) unflinching in criticising Islamist (as opposed to Islamic) influenced politics. From Lamia's attempt to find out what has happened to her brother, Sofiane, who has left to try and make it to Europe:
---------
Finished Harraga. I've already written about it on the previous thread, so will try not to repeat myself. I thought that Sansal did an impressive thing in telling a story that talks about the experiences of migrants leaving Algeria, but also acknowledges what (and who) is left behind, and the consequences of losing large numbers of young people. It's made clear that this is a loss both as migrants who don't plan to return and those who can't because they don't survive trafficking.
It is scorching in critique of corruption throughout Algeria, from the police to the civil service, health professionals and even the head of state. It is also (bravely) unflinching in criticising Islamist (as opposed to Islamic) influenced politics. From Lamia's attempt to find out what has happened to her brother, Sofiane, who has left to try and make it to Europe:
Maybe I should have told her that the only way to truly extricate this country from hell itself would be to toss the government into the sea, and the wagging tail of the civil service in with it. Then young people wouldn't dream of taking to sea any more for fear of meeting them bobbing on the waves.The attempts by men to limit women in the name of religion is mocked throughout. In places it reads like a polemic but given the author's agenda and bravery in stating his politics in the face of intimidation I'm not inclined to judge him for using his writing in this way.
For every single person on this planet, there is a book that speaks directly to them, that is a revelation, that tells them everything they need to know. To read that book - your book- without being forever changed is impossible.I'll be looking out for his other books which have been translated into English.
10Crazymamie
Happy new thread, Charlotte! Very fine book review, and the quotes that you chose from it make me want to read it.
11charl08
>6 msf59: I don't think it's a coincidence, the three that you mention were LT recommended, I wouldn't have found them otherwise :-)
>7 scaifea: *waves*
>9 Ameise1: They're having unanticipated consequences. I hadn't looked at Mull photos for ages, and now I want to be in Scotland *right now*. Talk about itchy feet. Think I'm going to have to find a good Scottish travel book to compensate for lack of er, travel.
>10 Crazymamie: I do love a quote about reading. I was spoiled for choice for snarky quotes about useless politicians in Harraga.
>7 scaifea: *waves*
>9 Ameise1: They're having unanticipated consequences. I hadn't looked at Mull photos for ages, and now I want to be in Scotland *right now*. Talk about itchy feet. Think I'm going to have to find a good Scottish travel book to compensate for lack of er, travel.
>10 Crazymamie: I do love a quote about reading. I was spoiled for choice for snarky quotes about useless politicians in Harraga.
12BLBera
Hi Charlotte - I love to see new threads. It's fun to look at what you've been reading and also to feel caught up, at least momentarily. I love your list of 50 African writers - I've only read five or six on the list, so I'll keep that in mind.
13rosylibrarian
Happy New Thread and also, happy Friday!
14charl08
>12 BLBera: >13 rosylibrarian: Hello! Thanks for visiting!

I picked up Fun Home from the library, bought a coffee and before I knew it I'd finished it. A graphic novel that explores the author's childhood, her parents' crumbling marriage and her father's death. Tragic but also very funny in places. I liked the way she linked her family's story to books - The Great Gatsby, Ulysses - and even Winnie the Pooh.

Ironically, I have been relieved of (some of the) reservation shelf pressure: the library has lost three of the books that their computer system claims have been delivered to my branch...
Next up more Easy Rawlins with Rose Gold.
I picked up Fun Home from the library, bought a coffee and before I knew it I'd finished it. A graphic novel that explores the author's childhood, her parents' crumbling marriage and her father's death. Tragic but also very funny in places. I liked the way she linked her family's story to books - The Great Gatsby, Ulysses - and even Winnie the Pooh.

Ironically, I have been relieved of (some of the) reservation shelf pressure: the library has lost three of the books that their computer system claims have been delivered to my branch...
Next up more Easy Rawlins with Rose Gold.
15susanj67
My library says that even if things show up on the website as "available for collection" we have to wait for the email as that's when things are *actually* available. So now you're down to five things? I have ten reserved after a moment of weakness earlier. Only one actually published so far, though.
17BLBera
I tend to over reserve, too. And the odd thing is no matter where I am on the list, THEY ALL COME IN AT THE SAME TIME?! I don't know how that happens, but it's like it's a library law. I have 10 on reserve now, and only three have been published.
I also loved Fun House. Have you read Are You My Mother?? I think I may have liked that one even more.
I also loved Fun House. Have you read Are You My Mother?? I think I may have liked that one even more.
18charl08
>17 BLBera: Just had a quick look at the reviews for Are you my mother- looks good, thank you. I'm only just starting out with graphic novels, so any and all recommendations gratefully received.
But the big question: do I dare put it on the reserve list?!
But the big question: do I dare put it on the reserve list?!
19cushlareads
Hi Charlotte - nice new thread!
I enjoyed your review of Harraga and will definitely look out for it. I've read An Unfinished Business (also published as The German Mujahid) and gave it 4 1/2 stars.
Good luck getting through those library books.
I enjoyed your review of Harraga and will definitely look out for it. I've read An Unfinished Business (also published as The German Mujahid) and gave it 4 1/2 stars.
Good luck getting through those library books.
20charl08
>19 cushlareads: Thank you! I was wondering why the same book had two different titles... Sounds like you really rated it.
I finished Rose Gold last night. Walter Mosley continues to keep me interested in Easy Rawlins, despite now being the sixth book in the series I've enjoyed (completists, look away now: all out of order). In this book, set in the 60s, Rawlins is commissioned to investigate the apparent kidnapping of an arms dealer's daughter. I think one of the reasons I'm still interested is that he has a back story, a complex life beyond investigation. Although the sexual politics can be dubious (as per the period), unlike say Entanglement women are more than male evaluation as sex objects. Having said that I wish his partner in this book was a bit tougher, a bit less forgiving. The recipes are also mouth-watering (fried fish in this one).
Of course, the perfect detective has a love of books:
I finished Rose Gold last night. Walter Mosley continues to keep me interested in Easy Rawlins, despite now being the sixth book in the series I've enjoyed (completists, look away now: all out of order). In this book, set in the 60s, Rawlins is commissioned to investigate the apparent kidnapping of an arms dealer's daughter. I think one of the reasons I'm still interested is that he has a back story, a complex life beyond investigation. Although the sexual politics can be dubious (as per the period), unlike say Entanglement women are more than male evaluation as sex objects. Having said that I wish his partner in this book was a bit tougher, a bit less forgiving. The recipes are also mouth-watering (fried fish in this one).
Of course, the perfect detective has a love of books:
... I plunked down on the packed sand and started rereading, for the sixth or seventh time,The Grapes of Wrath.
"Readin' good books is like meeting' a girl you wanna get to know bettah," Jackson Blue once told me. "You don't just have one talk and think you know her. If that was true there wouldn't be no need to get to know more; it wouldn't be worth it. Naw, man, you wanna talk to that girl again and again. You remember her phone number and every time you talk you find out something' else. Same thing with a good book. You got to read that suckah again and again and still you finding' out sumpin' new ever time."
I liked the way Steinbeck understood the plight of a man displaced by nature and society...
21PaulCranswick
Impressive debut thread in the 75ers and the second is shaping up nicely too, Charlotte. Have a lovely weekend,
22charl08
>21 PaulCranswick: Thanks for visiting. I've got RL fun (which has mysteriously become 'things to do' in my head) planned for today Paul, and all I want to do is read. Le Sigh.
Guardian Reviews 28th Feb











Dancing in the Dark: My Struggle 4
"My Struggle, which recounts the growth of the author’s mind, the childhood that shaped him, the obstacles, misadventures and breakthroughs, the agony and ecstasy of being Karl Ove. How he succeeds in making this so compelling over the course of 3,600 pages is a puzzle that critics and scholars find difficult to crack." (ha: backhanded compliment!)
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/26/dancing-in-the-dark-fourth-volume-m...
The Fish Ladder
"...she describes the uncanny day she found herself on Crosby Beach looking at the human sculptures by Anthony Gormley whose collective name is, appropriately, Another Place. The sands and their surroundings feel strangely familiar to her and, sure enough, she soon stumbles on a convent. Amazingly – miraculously – it turns out to have been the place she was born.... The connection between water and life, the reader now grasps, is for Norbury a visceral and impossibly complicated thing."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/15/fish-ladder-journey-upstream-review...
Pinkoes and Traitors: The BBC and the nation

"There is no point in romanticising a BBC golden age. The corporation was always an establishment institution, deeply embedded in the security state and subject to direct government control in an emergency. The sexism at the BBC, as Seaton recounts, was appalling, as in many other workplaces, and ethnic diversity non-existent...those who failed the “political reliability” test, often for the mildest of radical connections, were blacklisted....But in the 1960s and 70s, a new generation of programme-makers had begun to carve out a more independent and less deferential BBC. That was the institution Thatcher and her political hatchet-men were determined to bring to heel."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/seumas-milne-on-pinkoes-and-traitor...
The Anchoress
'Essentially, don’t read this for the plot; Robyn Cadwallader is not Sarah Dunant. The Anchoress, like its heroine, renounces excitement, though there are other pleasures, of a subtle and delicate kind'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/the-anchoress-robyn-cadwallader-rev...
One of Us: The Story of Anders Breivik
"What is striking is how much Breivik’s profile – the social and sexual failures, the sense of isolation, the conversion, often through the internet, to a grand and empowering cause – matches that of jihadi killers. Indeed, Breivik told his police interrogators that he was actually inspired by the fighting spirit of al-Qaida. But he is also like the murderers at Columbine high school, in Colorado, or the Boston bombers – the same lethal mixture of violent fantasy and feelings of worthlessness."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/26/one-of-us-the-story-of-anders-breiv...
None of the Above Rick Edwards
"Rick Edwards, the host of BBC3’s debate programme Free Speech, has a simple answer: young people need to vote. Every chapter of his book None of the Above ends with a simple entreaty to turn up at a polling station on 7 May."
Wasted Georgia Gould
"her book offers a useful corrective to the myth that youngsters are all feckless, internet-addled layabouts who need to have the joints and tequila shots snatched from their hands and be sent on national service. The teenage murder rate has fallen sharply since 2007; teen pregnancy is also on a downward trajectory. At the same time, the old rites of passage – getting a job, buying a home and having a family – now happen later, and financial stability is harder to attain. In keeping with current Labour orthodoxy, Gould identifies the problem as a lack of community spirit..."
(reviewed together at: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/none-of-the-above-by-rick-edwards-w...
Birth of a Theorem
"“Appreciating a theorem in mathematics is like watching an episode of Columbo: the line of reasoning by which the detective solves the mystery is more important than the identity of the murderer.” Villani should know. He is widely regarded as one of the most talented mathematicians of his generation. His work has won him almost every prize going: the Fermat prize (a big deal) the Poincaré prize (a very big deal) and even the Fields medal (off-the-chart big deal)."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/birth-of-a-theorem-mathematical-adv...
Get in Trouble
"One distinctive aspect of Link’s stories is that although fantastical events do occur, they occur in a world like ours where people consume fantasy culture."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/get-in-trouble-kelly-link-review-sh...
The Faithful Couple R D Miller
"Though the novel is never less than lucid and engaging when articulating the queasy, exculpatory mindsets of both protagonists, the chronologically choppy structure, coupled with Miller’s over-expository third-person narration, can make The Faithful Couple a removed, even static reading experience."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/the-faithful-couple-ad-miller-revie...
We are Pirates
"...beneath the slapstick lurks the painful reality of a father’s marital ennui and a daughter’s teenage turmoil. The dark, unhappy story that proceeds to unfurl continues to send out brilliant comic sparks, but is soon yelling “disaster ahoy” at the top of its lungs."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/we-are-pirates-review-lemony-snicke...
Guardian Reviews 28th Feb











Dancing in the Dark: My Struggle 4
"My Struggle, which recounts the growth of the author’s mind, the childhood that shaped him, the obstacles, misadventures and breakthroughs, the agony and ecstasy of being Karl Ove. How he succeeds in making this so compelling over the course of 3,600 pages is a puzzle that critics and scholars find difficult to crack." (ha: backhanded compliment!)
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/26/dancing-in-the-dark-fourth-volume-m...
The Fish Ladder
"...she describes the uncanny day she found herself on Crosby Beach looking at the human sculptures by Anthony Gormley whose collective name is, appropriately, Another Place. The sands and their surroundings feel strangely familiar to her and, sure enough, she soon stumbles on a convent. Amazingly – miraculously – it turns out to have been the place she was born.... The connection between water and life, the reader now grasps, is for Norbury a visceral and impossibly complicated thing."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/15/fish-ladder-journey-upstream-review...
Pinkoes and Traitors: The BBC and the nation

"There is no point in romanticising a BBC golden age. The corporation was always an establishment institution, deeply embedded in the security state and subject to direct government control in an emergency. The sexism at the BBC, as Seaton recounts, was appalling, as in many other workplaces, and ethnic diversity non-existent...those who failed the “political reliability” test, often for the mildest of radical connections, were blacklisted....But in the 1960s and 70s, a new generation of programme-makers had begun to carve out a more independent and less deferential BBC. That was the institution Thatcher and her political hatchet-men were determined to bring to heel."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/seumas-milne-on-pinkoes-and-traitor...
The Anchoress
'Essentially, don’t read this for the plot; Robyn Cadwallader is not Sarah Dunant. The Anchoress, like its heroine, renounces excitement, though there are other pleasures, of a subtle and delicate kind'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/the-anchoress-robyn-cadwallader-rev...
One of Us: The Story of Anders Breivik
"What is striking is how much Breivik’s profile – the social and sexual failures, the sense of isolation, the conversion, often through the internet, to a grand and empowering cause – matches that of jihadi killers. Indeed, Breivik told his police interrogators that he was actually inspired by the fighting spirit of al-Qaida. But he is also like the murderers at Columbine high school, in Colorado, or the Boston bombers – the same lethal mixture of violent fantasy and feelings of worthlessness."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/26/one-of-us-the-story-of-anders-breiv...
None of the Above Rick Edwards
"Rick Edwards, the host of BBC3’s debate programme Free Speech, has a simple answer: young people need to vote. Every chapter of his book None of the Above ends with a simple entreaty to turn up at a polling station on 7 May."
Wasted Georgia Gould
"her book offers a useful corrective to the myth that youngsters are all feckless, internet-addled layabouts who need to have the joints and tequila shots snatched from their hands and be sent on national service. The teenage murder rate has fallen sharply since 2007; teen pregnancy is also on a downward trajectory. At the same time, the old rites of passage – getting a job, buying a home and having a family – now happen later, and financial stability is harder to attain. In keeping with current Labour orthodoxy, Gould identifies the problem as a lack of community spirit..."
(reviewed together at: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/none-of-the-above-by-rick-edwards-w...
Birth of a Theorem
"“Appreciating a theorem in mathematics is like watching an episode of Columbo: the line of reasoning by which the detective solves the mystery is more important than the identity of the murderer.” Villani should know. He is widely regarded as one of the most talented mathematicians of his generation. His work has won him almost every prize going: the Fermat prize (a big deal) the Poincaré prize (a very big deal) and even the Fields medal (off-the-chart big deal)."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/birth-of-a-theorem-mathematical-adv...
Get in Trouble
"One distinctive aspect of Link’s stories is that although fantastical events do occur, they occur in a world like ours where people consume fantasy culture."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/get-in-trouble-kelly-link-review-sh...
The Faithful Couple R D Miller
"Though the novel is never less than lucid and engaging when articulating the queasy, exculpatory mindsets of both protagonists, the chronologically choppy structure, coupled with Miller’s over-expository third-person narration, can make The Faithful Couple a removed, even static reading experience."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/the-faithful-couple-ad-miller-revie...
We are Pirates
"...beneath the slapstick lurks the painful reality of a father’s marital ennui and a daughter’s teenage turmoil. The dark, unhappy story that proceeds to unfurl continues to send out brilliant comic sparks, but is soon yelling “disaster ahoy” at the top of its lungs."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/27/we-are-pirates-review-lemony-snicke...
23msf59
Happy Saturday, Charlotte. You are on a very nice book roll. Fun Home remains one of my favorite GNs. I am currently reading Get in Trouble and I LOVE it.
24RidgewayGirl
Oh, I hadn't known that Asne Seierstad had a new book out. I really enjoyed (if enjoyed is the right word) her other two books about Afghanistan and Chechnya.
25elkiedee
>25 elkiedee:: She has also written books about Baghdad and Serbia.
26mdoris
Hi Charlotte, I got a little carried away with researching Alison Bechdel when I read her books. There is a wonderful New Yorker article about her Drawn from Life, April 23, 2012 and lots to read about concerning her movie critic approach, the Bechdel Test from her comic strip leading you to content by Hollywood actresses about the" scene" there. I found it all very interesting and well let's face it, disturbing.
27charl08
>24 RidgewayGirl: >25 elkiedee: This one seems to be getting a lot of attention. Sensation value?
> 26 Thanks for this. I had no idea she was the same Bechdel. (They discuss it a lot on a film podcast I listen to. It's amazing how many films fail such a simple thing as 'two women have a conversation about something other than a man'.)
Possibly coincidentally to the above, I went to my local(ish) radical bookstore and bought Well behaved women seldom make history, the autobio for the Malcolm X group read, and because I hate relying on one source Manning Marable's bio of him. Lovely lovely Penguin paperbacks. :-)
> 26 Thanks for this. I had no idea she was the same Bechdel. (They discuss it a lot on a film podcast I listen to. It's amazing how many films fail such a simple thing as 'two women have a conversation about something other than a man'.)
Possibly coincidentally to the above, I went to my local(ish) radical bookstore and bought Well behaved women seldom make history, the autobio for the Malcolm X group read, and because I hate relying on one source Manning Marable's bio of him. Lovely lovely Penguin paperbacks. :-)
28mdoris
Hello, I 've been having a peek at your books and very interested in the gender studies one, (well many of the other ones too). I am a mother of 4 daughters (who have flown the coop) and have always been interested in that direction but would love a recommendation as to which book I should start with. Have you been in a program, studying? #27 Yes, I was really fascinated too about the Bechdel Test and thought maybe the bar could be a wee bit higher!!!!
29elkiedee
>27 charl08: Probably because that case touches on such hot issues right now. I don't know. I've read The Bookseller of Kabul and really want to read the other 3 I own, but I can't see myself buying or borrowing this one any time soon.
30charl08
>28 mdoris: I added a whole pile of gender / feminism books from a discussion over at the feminism group
https://www.librarything.com/groups/feministtheory
There is so much out there - and plenty being published at the moment. I tend to read books about gender and history (and feminism as a part of that history) rather than the contemporary politics side of things, which is why I listed the Verso books at the bottom of >3 charl08: - think I should be reading more. From the books I have read that deal with contemporary politics Feminism: Issues and Arguments was accessible, and had plenty of recommendations for further reading. A friend of mine from uni co-wrote Reclaiming the F Word, so I feel honour-bound to mention that too :-)
https://www.librarything.com/groups/feministtheory
There is so much out there - and plenty being published at the moment. I tend to read books about gender and history (and feminism as a part of that history) rather than the contemporary politics side of things, which is why I listed the Verso books at the bottom of >3 charl08: - think I should be reading more. From the books I have read that deal with contemporary politics Feminism: Issues and Arguments was accessible, and had plenty of recommendations for further reading. A friend of mine from uni co-wrote Reclaiming the F Word, so I feel honour-bound to mention that too :-)
31charl08
>29 elkiedee: Had something floating around my head about Åsne Seierstad - she was sued by the Afhgan family for misrepresentation by her Afghan book (but the case was thrown out on appeal http://www.newsinenglish.no/2012/03/12/author-wins-over-afghan-subject/)
Interesting point re cross-cultural writing:
"What, when writing about foreign cultures, is true, and what can be considered accurate? Here, the idea of accuracy must mean something more than an adherence to the mere facts. It must mean giving, as far as possible, an accurate reflection of the conditions under which the facts appear. Seierstad's book is not the story of Afghanistan, but the story of one family. Rais's chief complaint was that Seierstad revealed things that were private to the family that she did not have permission to write about - in essence that she was free to experience them, but not free to write about them. Seierstad views it differently. She has argued that she was there explicitly as a journalist and that her intentions were clear to the family."
http://www.thenational.ae/arts-culture/the-ruling-against-bookseller-of-kabul-au...
Interesting point re cross-cultural writing:
"What, when writing about foreign cultures, is true, and what can be considered accurate? Here, the idea of accuracy must mean something more than an adherence to the mere facts. It must mean giving, as far as possible, an accurate reflection of the conditions under which the facts appear. Seierstad's book is not the story of Afghanistan, but the story of one family. Rais's chief complaint was that Seierstad revealed things that were private to the family that she did not have permission to write about - in essence that she was free to experience them, but not free to write about them. Seierstad views it differently. She has argued that she was there explicitly as a journalist and that her intentions were clear to the family."
http://www.thenational.ae/arts-culture/the-ruling-against-bookseller-of-kabul-au...
32charl08

Finished Edna O'Brien's memoir Country Girl, which in the last few chapters takes us into the 21st Century, with a view of the end of the Troubles and the collapse of the Celtic Tiger. The relentless name-dropping continues, including a cringe-inducing account of a meal in New York with Al Pacino and his 'beautiful' girlfriend. She says 'Adonis' Jude Law kissed her in Pinter's garden (not a euphemism) and she was glad nothing else came of it, the 'relief' of old age. I'm not sure I believe her. She decides to return to Ireland, building a property on contested land, and the local community 'encourage' her to leave. One chapter details her plans to commit suicide, but she never really explains why, just that she changes her mind when her son makes plans for her to meet a friend, and she leaves the pills where they were.
The overall impression (to me) is of someone seeking to defend the choices she made in her life, tilting at windmills to argue for her own significance. Lovely pieces of prose though, a possible favourite the Connemara nightwatchman, who she meets when arriving at a castle another famous friend has arranged for her. He is reciting (first Hamlet, then Margaret of Anjou, Jefferson)
Soliloquies that he has memorised kept him company, as he mopped floors, cleaned teapots, polished shoes and prepared the breakfast trays. He had, as he put it, his own little theatre to while away the worst of the night.
Later we stood at the open door to look at the night. A navy-blue sky spanned the snowy fields and the mountain peaks gleamed with a heavenly, and other-world, splendour.
33charl08
>23 msf59: Argh, missed your message when I checked the thread on the phone. It looks really good, I'm not usually a big fan of short stories unless I'm already a fan of the author, but enjoying Your Madness Not Mine so much I might change my mind and try and read more.
34charl08
Reading Chop Chop - the narrator is a pretentious English lit grad, so some nice reading jokes in amongst the cooking and 4 letters (think Gordon Ramsey on a Very Bad Day).
'Dibden and I. A classic duo. Morecambe and Wise. Laurel and Hardy. Mice and Men.'
'I read that,' said Dibden entering, still very much haunted. 'About the big bloke with the hamster.'
'Think about what you're saying, Knobber' said Ramilov. 'The clue's in the title. It's not called Of Blokes and Hamsters is it?'
(the cover for this is so grim I am not putting it on my nice new thread).
'Dibden and I. A classic duo. Morecambe and Wise. Laurel and Hardy. Mice and Men.'
'I read that,' said Dibden entering, still very much haunted. 'About the big bloke with the hamster.'
'Think about what you're saying, Knobber' said Ramilov. 'The clue's in the title. It's not called Of Blokes and Hamsters is it?'
(the cover for this is so grim I am not putting it on my nice new thread).
36charl08
Reserve report -
To be picked up Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary, History of the rain, The sleepwalker's guide to dancing
Still to read
The people in the trees, Praying mantis, A bit of difference, Bonita Avenue, Before I forget, Star of the morning, Canada, Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter, The broken word
Reading Bad blood : a memoir
All our names (started this on the train, realised it was not the book I thought it was. V. relieved)
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815 (love her writing style, not sure I'm committed enough to read the whole book though)
Reading (ish) So long a letter (this is so short, I keep thinking I'll get to it - eventually)
Returning unread Poison, shadow and farewell like an idiot, I reserved this without checking that it is volume III, and whilst I don't usually care, in this case I do as it is like a brick.
To be picked up Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary, History of the rain, The sleepwalker's guide to dancing
Still to read
The people in the trees, Praying mantis, A bit of difference, Bonita Avenue, Before I forget, Star of the morning, Canada, Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter, The broken word
Reading Bad blood : a memoir
All our names (started this on the train, realised it was not the book I thought it was. V. relieved)
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815 (love her writing style, not sure I'm committed enough to read the whole book though)
Reading (ish) So long a letter (this is so short, I keep thinking I'll get to it - eventually)
Returning unread Poison, shadow and farewell like an idiot, I reserved this without checking that it is volume III, and whilst I don't usually care, in this case I do as it is like a brick.
37charl08
Your Madness Not Mine

Part of my challenge this year to read more books published by women writers from/ linked to Africa.
I'm reading this now because I got a free trial of Scribd digital books - and this was on it!
I'm not a big reader of short stories, although memorable collections I've enjoyed include books by Lorrie Moore and Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and most recently by Margaret Atwood. That said, I really enjoyed this collection of stories set in the English-speaking part of Cameroon. The introduction provides context for the stories, explaining that Cameroon is the only African country to have two European languages as lingua franca, but because of the French postcolonial role, French takes a predominant role despite an official policy of equality between the two languages. So this is one of the topics of the stories - relationships between people who see speaking English or French as a marker of community identity, in the context of limited resources. So in one story, in the midst of a car accident, everyone is arguing in a mix of English, pidgin and French, and Their arguments betrayed linguistic cultural and political assumptions whose validity they no longer particularly cherished...
Although there are stories set in a rural village as well as in the city, both contexts are dealing with change. Juliana Makuchi's stories address AIDS, environmental exploitation, migration, domestic abuse and political corruption but the key focus is personal, and as the reader it is impossible to forget the individuals who are at the heart of this collection. Whilst the issues dealt with may make this seem overly serious (and it is tragic too: her description of someone in the last days of AIDS is heartbreaking), it is also humorous; from the observations of the customers at the village's only bar, to the grandma carefully negotiating the benefits of political support in an election year. We switch between pidgen, French and English in the text.
Highly recommended.

Part of my challenge this year to read more books published by women writers from/ linked to Africa.
I'm reading this now because I got a free trial of Scribd digital books - and this was on it!
I'm not a big reader of short stories, although memorable collections I've enjoyed include books by Lorrie Moore and Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, and most recently by Margaret Atwood. That said, I really enjoyed this collection of stories set in the English-speaking part of Cameroon. The introduction provides context for the stories, explaining that Cameroon is the only African country to have two European languages as lingua franca, but because of the French postcolonial role, French takes a predominant role despite an official policy of equality between the two languages. So this is one of the topics of the stories - relationships between people who see speaking English or French as a marker of community identity, in the context of limited resources. So in one story, in the midst of a car accident, everyone is arguing in a mix of English, pidgin and French, and Their arguments betrayed linguistic cultural and political assumptions whose validity they no longer particularly cherished...
Although there are stories set in a rural village as well as in the city, both contexts are dealing with change. Juliana Makuchi's stories address AIDS, environmental exploitation, migration, domestic abuse and political corruption but the key focus is personal, and as the reader it is impossible to forget the individuals who are at the heart of this collection. Whilst the issues dealt with may make this seem overly serious (and it is tragic too: her description of someone in the last days of AIDS is heartbreaking), it is also humorous; from the observations of the customers at the village's only bar, to the grandma carefully negotiating the benefits of political support in an election year. We switch between pidgen, French and English in the text.
Highly recommended.
38Bond_Girl
Happy new thread :)! Dept. of Speculation seems very, very interesting - (and a short read which is always a win with me), I'm very tempted to add it to my reading wishlist.
39charl08
>38 Bond_Girl: I'm a big fan of Dept of Speculation - hope you enjoy it!
40charl08
Just picked up The Sleepwalker's Guide to Dancing along with another two that were waiting at the library, Had a sneaky read in the coffee shop and was hooked. I'm not sure who recommended this (sorry!) but can tell I am going to enjoy it :-)
41elkiedee
>40 charl08:: Claire (sakerfalcon) from the VMC group mentioned that one, I don't know whether anyone else did.
42Copperskye
Hi!
You've been reading some interesting books! I had Fun Home checked out from the library a while ago but never got to it. Thanks for the reminder!
You've been reading some interesting books! I had Fun Home checked out from the library a while ago but never got to it. Thanks for the reminder!
43charl08
>41 elkiedee: Found the reference (I forgot you can check this on talk. D'oh!) on Beth's thread
>42 Copperskye: Right back at you - I'd forgotten to order her other books, as the book that was supposed to be sitting on the shelf wasn't there. The librarian blames it on the cost of the books - they walk out of the library apparently and don't come back. Some people seem to have missed the point of the institution... Thank goodness for an online catalogue to order when the mood strikes.
>42 Copperskye: Right back at you - I'd forgotten to order her other books, as the book that was supposed to be sitting on the shelf wasn't there. The librarian blames it on the cost of the books - they walk out of the library apparently and don't come back. Some people seem to have missed the point of the institution... Thank goodness for an online catalogue to order when the mood strikes.
44charl08
I'm a slow reader (or I always feel myself to be a slow reader) of non-fiction, but despite not having got very far at all with In These Times: Living in Britain Through Napoleon's Wars felt the need to share one of the examples she gives - book full of individuals, the kind of history I enjoy.
I can see why one of the blurbers describes Uglow as 'the perfect historian'. Cheers to SusanJ whose thread led me to reserve this book.
Debt-ridden students also fled to the army, including Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who signed up secretly as a private in the 15th Light Dragoons... He couldn't ride well,had rusty equipment, found himself nursing a man with smallpox and after three months of misery was extricated by his brothers, discharged as 'insane'.
I can see why one of the blurbers describes Uglow as 'the perfect historian'. Cheers to SusanJ whose thread led me to reserve this book.
45charl08
Well Behaved Women Seldom Make History was part of my book haul at News from Nowhere at the weekend. Historian Ulrich opens her book describing how a quote from an article on women in Puritan funeral sermons became a bumper sticker (and beyond). I'm still in the introduction and the book bullets are flying, not least for Ulrich's other book about an early modern midwife:
Ballard made history by performing a methodical and seemingly ordinary act - writing a few words in her diary every day. Through the diary we know her as a pious herbalist whose curiosity about the human body led her to observe and record autopsies as well as nurse the sick, whose integrity allowed her to testify in a sensational rape trial... and whose sense of duty took her out of bed at night not only to deliver babies but to care for the bodies of a wife and children murdered but heir own husband and father.
46susanj67
>44 charl08: Charlotte, I'm so glad you're enjoying it!
47charl08
Having had a cheery morning with Ulrich, Uglow and Jacob, decided to spend a short time in the company of Adam Foulds rave-reviewed verse narrative about a young man in the Kenyan home guard during 'Mau Mau'.

Powerful despite being short, less than 60 pages.
Beautifully expressed version of the foul colonial underbelly. Rachel Seiffert has also written about the long term impact of the memory of participating in this particular colonial war. Here we are given the immediate contrast between the detention camp the character policed as a volunteer and his university studies, and left to imagine what will happen in the years that follow Tom graduating, how he will process his participation, his guilt at what was done and not done.

Powerful despite being short, less than 60 pages.
Beautifully expressed version of the foul colonial underbelly. Rachel Seiffert has also written about the long term impact of the memory of participating in this particular colonial war. Here we are given the immediate contrast between the detention camp the character policed as a volunteer and his university studies, and left to imagine what will happen in the years that follow Tom graduating, how he will process his participation, his guilt at what was done and not done.
Tom walked between the lines
of coffee for half a mile
knocking fragments
of water onto his sleeves -
little bubble lenses
that amplified the weave
then broke, darkening in.
The large, composed silence of the library
with its little human lapses: coughs
rustled paper, the bump of books.
Thrumming a card index, the corners
of popular titles soft as seed heads
where the glue had worn away
the fibres coming loose.
48elkiedee
Please feel free to ignore this completely, but do you know about the monthly "Take it or Leave It" challenge a lot of 75ers participate in? You don't need to change your reading plans to do it, you can, or you can just fit the reads into the monthly challenges, it's rare that a book can't be matched to one of the monthly challenges posted.
http://www.librarything.com/topic/188331
http://www.librarything.com/topic/188331
49charl08
>48 elkiedee: Thanks for mentioning it, I'll go take a look.
50RidgewayGirl
Thanks for posting that poem segment. I'll look for The Broken Word. I've read far too few books by African authors.
51souloftherose
>44 charl08: In These Times is high up on my library list thanks to Susan and others :-)
52charl08
>50 RidgewayGirl: Just to clarify, as my comments didn't say, Foulds is British, not Kenyan. Would be interesting to read this alongside Dreams in a Time of War (for example) as NwT experienced the state of emergency first hand.
53charl08
>51 souloftherose: I've been looking for Uglow's other books, which I have mostly missed. For when the reserve pile goes down!
54charl08
My Sherman Alexie binge continues with Flight a touching story about a young man in foster care. "Zits" has a series of time-travelling experiences after he goes to a bank with a gun.
(I have something in my eye again).
(I have something in my eye again).
55charl08
Finished The Dry Grass of August, after it turned out it was 'hidden' on a shelf the other librarians hadn't known about when I asked previously (!) Another LT recommended winner, keeping me turning the pages to find out what would happen to Jubie and her family.
56Chatterbox
You scored a book bullet with Harraga. I think I knew it was coming out, but somehow had overlooked it? In any event, it now resides comfortably on my Kindle... I loved (if that's the right word) The German Mujahid. It was published here by Europa, which is one of my favorite presses.
I've got Uglow's book on my UK Kindle already, and have been meaning to delve into it; the size of all her works is daunting. I think someone else is reading it this month for the "take it or leave it" (TIOLI) challenges.
I may keep my eyes open for The Anchoress and the A.D. Miller novel, in search of bargain pricing; I liked the latter's first novel better than did many here (which, I fear, isn't saying all that much...) Perhaps it's because I'm very interested in post-Communist Russia?
I've got Uglow's book on my UK Kindle already, and have been meaning to delve into it; the size of all her works is daunting. I think someone else is reading it this month for the "take it or leave it" (TIOLI) challenges.
I may keep my eyes open for The Anchoress and the A.D. Miller novel, in search of bargain pricing; I liked the latter's first novel better than did many here (which, I fear, isn't saying all that much...) Perhaps it's because I'm very interested in post-Communist Russia?
57BLBera
I love your thread, Charlotte. You have so much great reading going on. I'm happy that you are loving The Sleepwalker's Guide. Alexie is one of my favorites. I will look for the O'Brien memoir, too.
58charl08
>56 Chatterbox: I was underwhelmed by Snowdrops so don't think I'll be looking for the latest (especially after the review above, which was not v. pro). I don't have a lot of patience for books about well off men complaining about their lives. The Anchoress on the other hand has gone on the reservation list. I'll be interested to see what you think of Harraga having read his other work.
>57 BLBera: Yes, somewhat frustrated that I can't just keep on reading The Sleepwalker's Guide today! Hope to finish this evening, because The Narrow Road to the Deep North has finally appeared on the reservation shelf.
>57 BLBera: Yes, somewhat frustrated that I can't just keep on reading The Sleepwalker's Guide today! Hope to finish this evening, because The Narrow Road to the Deep North has finally appeared on the reservation shelf.
59susanj67
>55 charl08: A secret shelf that even the librarians don't know about?! There's a novel in that somewhere. Or at least a picture book :-)
I had to look up The Dry Grass of August, and my library had it as an ebook available to borrow! "Had" being the operative word there. Ahem.
I had to look up The Dry Grass of August, and my library had it as an ebook available to borrow! "Had" being the operative word there. Ahem.
60charl08
I'm in Hamner, darkest Wales (a 'village of the damned' to misquote somebody) this lunch hour,finding out about the vicar's secret diary with his granddaughter, Lorna Sage.
Has anyone else felt like they are breaking the code that says you don't read a diary without permission of the author, reading Bad Blood? (Even if it's clear that the guy in question didn't have an ethical leg to stand on!)
(Wonders what an unethical leg looks like...)
This is another aspect of rural life that's lost now the middle-class diaspora has populated the countryside with property owning vagrants: the peculiar hell of having to live with such substantial ghosts from your past.
Has anyone else felt like they are breaking the code that says you don't read a diary without permission of the author, reading Bad Blood? (Even if it's clear that the guy in question didn't have an ethical leg to stand on!)
(Wonders what an unethical leg looks like...)
61charl08
>59 susanj67: At the moment, the novel would be "The bookish frustrations of C". Argh! I've been asking for that book for about a month. I just found Scribd has the Mary Russell series on it -including A Monstrous Regiment of Women which seems to be as rare as hen's teeth in the library system. Hurrah!
(although not sure when I'm going to get the time read this before the trial runs out!)
(although not sure when I'm going to get the time read this before the trial runs out!)
62susanj67
>61 charl08: Charlotte, you'll just have to bookhorn it in somehow! I was planning a lunch hour having The Affair with Jack Reacher, but it turned into writing a note on legal professional privilege, which isn't quite the same. Maybe I could work a gun into it somehow...
63charl08
Reading the introduction to Hamlet's dreams: The Robben Island Shakespeare: both fascinating and frustrating.

The author discusses how what remains of the copies of Shakespeare that were read by prisoners in Robben island can be analysed, along with interviews, to talk about the significance of Shakespeare to these men who were imprisoned for many years by the apartheid state. I'm not likely to get to the rest of the book, as it was too much academic analysis instead of what I wanted, which was pictures of the marginalia, and transcripts of interviews with the former prisoners. I did particularly like the excerpted section from an interview (long after release) with three former prisoners, now esteemed political figures, who all complained extensively that they had not been properly briefed and that the idea of remembering one section was not particularly relevant to them.

The author discusses how what remains of the copies of Shakespeare that were read by prisoners in Robben island can be analysed, along with interviews, to talk about the significance of Shakespeare to these men who were imprisoned for many years by the apartheid state. I'm not likely to get to the rest of the book, as it was too much academic analysis instead of what I wanted, which was pictures of the marginalia, and transcripts of interviews with the former prisoners. I did particularly like the excerpted section from an interview (long after release) with three former prisoners, now esteemed political figures, who all complained extensively that they had not been properly briefed and that the idea of remembering one section was not particularly relevant to them.
Ahmed Kathrada:Years and years ago, I went through very hurriedly the Complete Works when I had nothing else to do, but there were passages that made an impact, which I can't off-hand remember. Some of them of course I do... Off-hand I remember, because I quoted it at the memorial service of Walter Sisulu, a former Robben Islander. I quoted that, 'His life was gentle; and the elements; So mixed in him, that Nature might stand up, And say to all the world, THIS WAS A MAN!'However also interesting to me re the comments by the writer of the continuing political significance of the memories of those who were on the island (not all interviews are accessible to researchers).
64charl08
>62 susanj67: Hope you managed to get Reacher in there somewhere. That note does not sound like it would go well with food.
65Chatterbox
The Anchoress is better priced for UK Kindle than for US Kindle -- Kindle arbitrage!! (And yes, it's lovely to be able to exploit these differentials...)
I just find so many books, in one way or another, revolve around male privilege, that this one didn't surprise me. It also felt in line with the plot, given that Miller was writing about a society in which men have lives their own way and complain about them endlessly (Russia from the late 1990s onward to today). I'm not sure about this new one, but I might keep my eyes open for it. I liked his ability to blend convincing background details with a plot and make it relevant.
How do you like Scribd? I almost signed up for Oyster earlier this week. I caught myself in time. There won't be enough books that I really desperately want to read that I need to do that. I think. At least Oyster does have some of the big 5. The first one that lands Penguin as a partner, I'll consider.
I just find so many books, in one way or another, revolve around male privilege, that this one didn't surprise me. It also felt in line with the plot, given that Miller was writing about a society in which men have lives their own way and complain about them endlessly (Russia from the late 1990s onward to today). I'm not sure about this new one, but I might keep my eyes open for it. I liked his ability to blend convincing background details with a plot and make it relevant.
How do you like Scribd? I almost signed up for Oyster earlier this week. I caught myself in time. There won't be enough books that I really desperately want to read that I need to do that. I think. At least Oyster does have some of the big 5. The first one that lands Penguin as a partner, I'll consider.
66charl08
Money's a key thing for me - I found a code that gave me three months free on Scribd, and I like that price!
I was surprised by the availability of the Mary Russells because several of the other books I wanted to read (e.g. Dust) are shown as not available for UK subscribers. This would put me off paying as it stands. I also like my paperwhite, and I don't much like reading on a normal screen (although I will if there isn't an alternative) so that also puts me off.
I'd not come across Oyster - just looked at it now and the appearance is almost identical to Scribd, which surprised me.
Do love the 'books for bibliophiles' section. Several there I like!
I was surprised by the availability of the Mary Russells because several of the other books I wanted to read (e.g. Dust) are shown as not available for UK subscribers. This would put me off paying as it stands. I also like my paperwhite, and I don't much like reading on a normal screen (although I will if there isn't an alternative) so that also puts me off.
I'd not come across Oyster - just looked at it now and the appearance is almost identical to Scribd, which surprised me.
Do love the 'books for bibliophiles' section. Several there I like!
67charl08
Finished The Sleepwalker's Guide to Dancing. Such a lovely novel. My copy came from the library, but I will be looking out for one to keep, as I want to read it again, and loan it to friends.
68susanj67
>67 charl08: Ooh, my library branch has that one on the shelf right now, according to the catalogue. I've made a bargain with myself that if I can finish a couple of things over the weekend I'll look for it on Monday :-)
69charl08
I'm back in Bad Blood's Hamner, Laura's grandfather is revealed by further awfulness, and his grandmother's strategy to make him pay alongside it. My copy from the library is just about falling apart, and it wish I had my own to underline and post-it. Just completely absorbing, the kind of book that is a gift to a lunch hour full of distraction.
I knew how to hide in books. If need be I could build a kind of nest out of any old scraps of print I found around. The taste for words Grandpa had given me was thoroughly promiscuous. I read everything in no particular order.…
70charl08
Couldn't not begin A Monstrous Regiment of Women which for some (unknown) reason is difficult to get hands on here.
I love this series of covers. (Mine is small text on the phone, but still!). I love how Laurie King writes, love the set-up (a post-suffragette women's movement) and the anti-feminist historical quotes to get the blood going at the start of each chapter.
I love this series of covers. (Mine is small text on the phone, but still!). I love how Laurie King writes, love the set-up (a post-suffragette women's movement) and the anti-feminist historical quotes to get the blood going at the start of each chapter.
71elkiedee
The Bookpeople has the first 3 Mary Russell books on offer for £4.99, including Monstrous Regiment, plus postage, or you can just buy more books - they sometimes send out offers for free postage over £10. Other offers include a few VMC sets, Edna O'Brien's Country Girls trilogy at £4.99 for three books, and 6 Anne Tyler novels for £4. Or Weird Things Customers Say in Bookshops and More Weird Things.... for £3.99
73Matke
My first visit to your thread, Charlotte, but assuredly not my last. Interesting, informative, and quirky. One could hardly ask for more!
74charl08
Welcome!
Owing to coming down with a case of 'Chaptigue'
I've only made it as far as the third part of Bad Blood and am retiring defeated.
Lorna has gone to grammar school, discovering the politics of the school bus (secondary modern at the back, grammar at the front), failing to learn to ride a bike and loving Latin. Her descriptions of her mother's lack of interest (and skills) at housework made me laugh. The house is never clean or tidy, so :Women neighbours were never allowed in, nor were their daughters, who were suspected of being fifth columnists, housework spies who'd run home and tell their mothers we didn't clean behind the sofa. She describes her father's (failed) attempts to turn the rest of the family into obedient 'other ranks', following orders, after a successful wartime career. At the end of the section she is on the cusp of rebelling as a teenager, listening to rock & roll despite being tone deaf.
Owing to coming down with a case of 'Chaptigue'
I've only made it as far as the third part of Bad Blood and am retiring defeated.
Lorna has gone to grammar school, discovering the politics of the school bus (secondary modern at the back, grammar at the front), failing to learn to ride a bike and loving Latin. Her descriptions of her mother's lack of interest (and skills) at housework made me laugh. The house is never clean or tidy, so :Women neighbours were never allowed in, nor were their daughters, who were suspected of being fifth columnists, housework spies who'd run home and tell their mothers we didn't clean behind the sofa. She describes her father's (failed) attempts to turn the rest of the family into obedient 'other ranks', following orders, after a successful wartime career. At the end of the section she is on the cusp of rebelling as a teenager, listening to rock & roll despite being tone deaf.
75kidzdoc
Hi, Charlotte! Thanks for your excellent review of Harraga. I enjoyed his subsequent novel The German Mujahid, so I'll definitely buy and read Harraga.
Ha! I had just written a message on my thread to Benita about The Broken Word, as I told her that I loved that book. I'm glad that you did, too.
Ha! I had just written a message on my thread to Benita about The Broken Word, as I told her that I loved that book. I'm glad that you did, too.
76charl08
>75 kidzdoc: Thanks for dropping in, I'm looking forward to finding out more about Saramago (the library even had one of the books you recommended for order, so I'll get it soon).
Finished Bad Blood. Waaah! I didn't want it to end. Particulaly the last bit about her teachers and the toothache of the Durham Cathedral bells.
Finished Bad Blood. Waaah! I didn't want it to end. Particulaly the last bit about her teachers and the toothache of the Durham Cathedral bells.
77charl08
My social media accounts are flooded with small children in fancy dress, from Angelina Ballerina to Thing 1 and Thing 2, but this story made my jaw drop:
A boy who dressed as a character from Fifty Shades of Grey was excluded from his school's World Book Day celebrations, according to his mother.
Liam Scholes, 11, went to Sale High School as Christian Grey from the explicit novel, wearing a grey suit and carrying cable ties and an eye mask.
His mother Nicola Scholes, a teacher, said the Greater Manchester school ruled the costume was "inappropriate" and excluded her son from photographs.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-31760713
A boy who dressed as a character from Fifty Shades of Grey was excluded from his school's World Book Day celebrations, according to his mother.
Liam Scholes, 11, went to Sale High School as Christian Grey from the explicit novel, wearing a grey suit and carrying cable ties and an eye mask.
His mother Nicola Scholes, a teacher, said the Greater Manchester school ruled the costume was "inappropriate" and excluded her son from photographs.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-31760713
78charl08
Reading Hedy's Folly as I was unable to decide between various novels. Wishing it was her memoir not a biography though.
As you do...
Since she made two or three movies a year, each one taking about a month to shoot, she had spare time to fill. She didn't drink and she didn't like to party, so she took up inventing.
As you do...
79charl08
Library progress record:
Much remains to be read (and I am not sure how much will be)-
Books I've had the longest and are beginning to enter the 'pile of shame' section (returned unread)
The people in the trees
All our names
A bit of difference
Praying mantis
Bonita Avenue
Before I forget
Star of the morning
Audio book for challenge read
Canada
LT recommended
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
History of the rain
Africa reads
So long a letter
Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
Possible women in rock read
Bedsit disco queen : how I grew up and tried to be a pop star
Random feminist read
Hedy's folly : the life and breakthrough inventions of Hedy Lamarr
Prize winner read (Booker)
The narrow road to the deep north
Much remains to be read (and I am not sure how much will be)-
Books I've had the longest and are beginning to enter the 'pile of shame' section (returned unread)
The people in the trees
All our names
A bit of difference
Praying mantis
Bonita Avenue
Before I forget
Star of the morning
Audio book for challenge read
Canada
LT recommended
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
History of the rain
Africa reads
So long a letter
Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
Possible women in rock read
Bedsit disco queen : how I grew up and tried to be a pop star
Random feminist read
Hedy's folly : the life and breakthrough inventions of Hedy Lamarr
Prize winner read (Booker)
The narrow road to the deep north
80Chatterbox
The Flanagan novel is superb, but brutally difficult to read, and very depressing.
The more I learn about Hedy Lamarr, the more awed I am by her...
The more I learn about Hedy Lamarr, the more awed I am by her...
81PaulCranswick
What an interesting lady Hedy Lamarr. Gorgeous and talented. Born in Austria near the outset of the First World War and hugely controversial with her pioneering love-making scenes in the early days of the movies (Ecstasy, 1933).
Apart from soluble tablets a type of which she discovered, she co-invented a number of inventions vital to the military in WW2 for amongst other torpedo control.. On top of that she was renowned as the most beautiful woman of her age. Quite some lady.

I will look for that book too, Charlotte.
Have a lovely weekend
Apart from soluble tablets a type of which she discovered, she co-invented a number of inventions vital to the military in WW2 for amongst other torpedo control.. On top of that she was renowned as the most beautiful woman of her age. Quite some lady.

I will look for that book too, Charlotte.
Have a lovely weekend
82EBT1002
Hi Charlotte. It's my first time visiting your thread. Thanks for posting the "Bookshy list of 50 books by African women that everyone should read." I will go look at the article (?) but it's a list I'm interested in tackling. I've only read three of them so far: Half of a Yellow Sun, Americanah, and We Need New Names. I have The Map of Love, The Memory of Love, July's People, and a few others in my TBR library. Now I am more motivated to get to them this year!
83alcottacre
Checking in on the new thread, Charlotte!
85charl08
>80 Chatterbox: Yes. I'm a bit afraid of it, truth be told. Although at least it is fiction. Since the film version the bookshop has had The Railway Man on display, but I've not quite worked up the courage.
>81 PaulCranswick: She is. I'm not sure this is the best book about her though, Paul. Comments to follow.
>82 EBT1002: Thanks for visiting! Bookshy is a blogger, and the post is part of two that she and a colleague from the Royal African Society put together to encourage reading as much as anything else - the first 25 can be found here http://www.gatewayforafrica.org/blog/50-books-african-women-everyone-should-read
"The more recent novels by Adichie, and Bulawayo, can’t help but press themselves against the imagination – but there are also older titles which deserve to be read, and read again. There are some omissions because wherever possible we’ve avoided more than one entry from an author, especially where neither of us has read their complete ouvre. While this is predominantly a list of novels, there are some non-fiction, and poetry titles which just had to be on the list because of their contemporary or lasting impact.
Now, it’s not definitive, exhaustive or even representative – but we hope you enjoy reading these titles"
>83 alcottacre: Thanks for visiting!
>84 Ameise1: Ooh, flowers :-)
>81 PaulCranswick: She is. I'm not sure this is the best book about her though, Paul. Comments to follow.
>82 EBT1002: Thanks for visiting! Bookshy is a blogger, and the post is part of two that she and a colleague from the Royal African Society put together to encourage reading as much as anything else - the first 25 can be found here http://www.gatewayforafrica.org/blog/50-books-african-women-everyone-should-read
"The more recent novels by Adichie, and Bulawayo, can’t help but press themselves against the imagination – but there are also older titles which deserve to be read, and read again. There are some omissions because wherever possible we’ve avoided more than one entry from an author, especially where neither of us has read their complete ouvre. While this is predominantly a list of novels, there are some non-fiction, and poetry titles which just had to be on the list because of their contemporary or lasting impact.
Now, it’s not definitive, exhaustive or even representative – but we hope you enjoy reading these titles"
>83 alcottacre: Thanks for visiting!
>84 Ameise1: Ooh, flowers :-)
86susanj67
>79 charl08: Charlotte, I clicked on The People in the Trees which looks intriguing, and the library has it as an ebook. I remembered the wishlist function for the elibrary, so I clicked on it...and then realised I'd saved about 20 things onto it already. Aaaaargh. I saved a few more.
87charl08
>86 susanj67: This is reminding me that I really need a way to record who recommends what - I know I got that from LT, but not sure who from...
88charl08
Hedy's Folly

I had my tongue firmly in cheek when I labelled this book 'random feminist' above - a couple of pages in, and there had already been too many references to her physical attributes for this to be described in any conscience as feminist (even in the minimalist interpretation as 'being judged as a human being rather than a sex object').
I think my main criticism is that he hasn't decided about Hedy's role, and uses the lack of explicit extant source material as a kind of cover for his failure to construct an argument. So he describes her first marriage to an Austrian arms dealer with the kind of connections across fascist Europe that a spy would dream of, but is never very clear about the level of understanding she had about the armaments industry. I don't know much about US intelligence, but to me this would have made her a valuable source if she had known a lot about her ex's business (and there would be -now declassified- records about her conversations with government). He has the letters of a multi-talented composer, Antheil, who worked with her to turn the invention into a patentable innovation, and quotes from them extensively. However he reads them as a straight source a lot of the time, despite evidence in the letters themselves, and in the accounts of his widow, that he was (at the least) prone to exaggeration, and more than happy to take money for years from a wealthy sponsor, despite her lack of interest in his music. Where he does question them (as in the case of Antheil's description of her as illiterate) it's so meekly done that it raises more questions than it answers (He suggests if you're multilingual, maybe you develop different ways of taking notes? Yes, you probably do - but you also have children who could tell the historian how this worked...?!). He also uses showbiz sources which clearly had their own agenda again, and need more careful handling than they are given here - and a gender sensitive one at that (how Hedy dealt with being treated as a sex object all the time, for example. Or how the US patent office dealt with women inventing. Or how women celebrities were used as part of the war effort. Or....). At points his reliance on Antheil's analysis makes my blood boil as Hedy comes off as a cliched hysterical woman. He accuses her in a letter of seeing spies everywhere in the 1940s. At this point I lost all respect for Antheil (Hedy was Jewish, grew up in Vienna and was an intelligent woman in touch with family overseas who had emigrated to escape the Nazis. I'm reaching for a way to say this that isn't DO THE MATHS ANTHEIL AND RHODES).
In that light, and particularly given that there is a story here, I think a feminist historian like Jill Lepore or Caroline Steedman would do amazing things with it. Richard Rhodes is a historian of warfare, of nuclear policy in particular, and this book suggests his social history skills just aren't up to the job of the subject. Again and again I was thinking 'why didn't he interview'**, why didn't he think about his sources more, why didn't he analyse his approach? Add this to the tendency to divert into history-for-beginners speak on the post-WW1 German economy and 1920s Paris, and the repetition of various quotes / comments about Hedy's film career re the most beautiful woman in the world, how easy it is to be beautiful...
And just when it's getting really annoying, he diverts into several pages of description about the technology behind naval weaponry, and how useless the American torpedo system was (which presumably he knows something about) and the book goes off in (yet another) direction. So it turns out that 60% of American torpedoes didn't work (in the paragraph that introduces this fact he quotes 'a historian' saying that 'US submariners began to realise that there was something wrong with their torpedoes' (italics mine). What do you think was the first clue?!!
I have enjoyed popular science books in the past Simon Singh comes to mind, but this book emphasises how good a writer you have to be to tell a compelling historical science story without giving the impression of lurching all over the place. I wondered if he had seen this project as a nice little earner without requiring much additional research. Chatterbox's thread has been discussing the death of the editor. I think a really good one here would have seen past the sales value of a glam 1940s film star on the cover and done some heavy pruning and redirecting.
I guess it's fair to say this book wasn't my bag. If I could write I would be plotting out a novel: Hedy Lamarr and her amazing inventing career.
{Rant over}
Edited to add: **The acknowledgements note he did interview.

I had my tongue firmly in cheek when I labelled this book 'random feminist' above - a couple of pages in, and there had already been too many references to her physical attributes for this to be described in any conscience as feminist (even in the minimalist interpretation as 'being judged as a human being rather than a sex object').
I think my main criticism is that he hasn't decided about Hedy's role, and uses the lack of explicit extant source material as a kind of cover for his failure to construct an argument. So he describes her first marriage to an Austrian arms dealer with the kind of connections across fascist Europe that a spy would dream of, but is never very clear about the level of understanding she had about the armaments industry. I don't know much about US intelligence, but to me this would have made her a valuable source if she had known a lot about her ex's business (and there would be -now declassified- records about her conversations with government). He has the letters of a multi-talented composer, Antheil, who worked with her to turn the invention into a patentable innovation, and quotes from them extensively. However he reads them as a straight source a lot of the time, despite evidence in the letters themselves, and in the accounts of his widow, that he was (at the least) prone to exaggeration, and more than happy to take money for years from a wealthy sponsor, despite her lack of interest in his music. Where he does question them (as in the case of Antheil's description of her as illiterate) it's so meekly done that it raises more questions than it answers (He suggests if you're multilingual, maybe you develop different ways of taking notes? Yes, you probably do - but you also have children who could tell the historian how this worked...?!). He also uses showbiz sources which clearly had their own agenda again, and need more careful handling than they are given here - and a gender sensitive one at that (how Hedy dealt with being treated as a sex object all the time, for example. Or how the US patent office dealt with women inventing. Or how women celebrities were used as part of the war effort. Or....). At points his reliance on Antheil's analysis makes my blood boil as Hedy comes off as a cliched hysterical woman. He accuses her in a letter of seeing spies everywhere in the 1940s. At this point I lost all respect for Antheil (Hedy was Jewish, grew up in Vienna and was an intelligent woman in touch with family overseas who had emigrated to escape the Nazis. I'm reaching for a way to say this that isn't DO THE MATHS ANTHEIL AND RHODES).
In that light, and particularly given that there is a story here, I think a feminist historian like Jill Lepore or Caroline Steedman would do amazing things with it. Richard Rhodes is a historian of warfare, of nuclear policy in particular, and this book suggests his social history skills just aren't up to the job of the subject. Again and again I was thinking 'why didn't he interview'**, why didn't he think about his sources more, why didn't he analyse his approach? Add this to the tendency to divert into history-for-beginners speak on the post-WW1 German economy and 1920s Paris, and the repetition of various quotes / comments about Hedy's film career re the most beautiful woman in the world, how easy it is to be beautiful...
And just when it's getting really annoying, he diverts into several pages of description about the technology behind naval weaponry, and how useless the American torpedo system was (which presumably he knows something about) and the book goes off in (yet another) direction. So it turns out that 60% of American torpedoes didn't work (in the paragraph that introduces this fact he quotes 'a historian' saying that 'US submariners began to realise that there was something wrong with their torpedoes' (italics mine). What do you think was the first clue?!!
I have enjoyed popular science books in the past Simon Singh comes to mind, but this book emphasises how good a writer you have to be to tell a compelling historical science story without giving the impression of lurching all over the place. I wondered if he had seen this project as a nice little earner without requiring much additional research. Chatterbox's thread has been discussing the death of the editor. I think a really good one here would have seen past the sales value of a glam 1940s film star on the cover and done some heavy pruning and redirecting.
I guess it's fair to say this book wasn't my bag. If I could write I would be plotting out a novel: Hedy Lamarr and her amazing inventing career.
{Rant over}
Edited to add: **The acknowledgements note he did interview.
89PaulCranswick
>88 charl08: Mmm Charlotte looks like a great chance to write a good biography came and went. There is nothing wrong of course with admiring someone's beauty and Hedy Lamarr was certainly a beautiful woman but it is something that doesn't really need to be told is it? Her life story was so fascinating it is a shame that it doesn't seem to have been done justice to.
90charl08
Exactly Paul. I couldn't believe it but he actually got *funded* to do the 'research' to write this book. Argh.
92Chatterbox
Wow, what a waste of an opportunity! There's nothing wrong with writing a critical biography, but by the sound of this one, it looks as if he really didn't want to be writing it at all -- he didn't want to be giving her credit for much of anything, didn't like the whole idea that a sex symbol/Hollywood star could have this whole other identity, and instead of finding it a fascinating idea to explore, pushed back against it all the way.
Have we been discussing the death of editors? It's certainly a constant lament of mine. But part of it, too, is that few editors are able to coax a pedestrian writer to think out of the box or take a new approach. I was pondering that recently, working with a friend on a mundane editing task, which really is closer to rewriting. I'm farming out the work to him, and I should just be re-reading what he sends me before sending it back to the client. The stuff I edit myself takes about 3 hours, sometimes a bit more, to get done. When I get a piece back from him, it still takes me an hour to go through it, because he doesn't have a good, instinctive flair for doing this. I can't tell him, hey remember this and that, but if it's not instinctive, it doesn't matter. I've seen it in young journalists I've worked with, too. Some, you have to kind of nudge, like sheepdogs -- pointing them at story ideas and waiting to see if they can spot the nose on their face and will figure out how to put the pieces together. Others get it immediately and zoom, off they go. So, an editor can make one of the latter even better, by imposing focus and order on what they produce (and ensuring there aren't bloopers). But an editor can't do much with the former: the people who really seem themselves as writers, but who don't quite possess that X factor.
I'm curious enough to see what else has been written about Hedy Lamarr. You're right; there is room for a novel.
Have we been discussing the death of editors? It's certainly a constant lament of mine. But part of it, too, is that few editors are able to coax a pedestrian writer to think out of the box or take a new approach. I was pondering that recently, working with a friend on a mundane editing task, which really is closer to rewriting. I'm farming out the work to him, and I should just be re-reading what he sends me before sending it back to the client. The stuff I edit myself takes about 3 hours, sometimes a bit more, to get done. When I get a piece back from him, it still takes me an hour to go through it, because he doesn't have a good, instinctive flair for doing this. I can't tell him, hey remember this and that, but if it's not instinctive, it doesn't matter. I've seen it in young journalists I've worked with, too. Some, you have to kind of nudge, like sheepdogs -- pointing them at story ideas and waiting to see if they can spot the nose on their face and will figure out how to put the pieces together. Others get it immediately and zoom, off they go. So, an editor can make one of the latter even better, by imposing focus and order on what they produce (and ensuring there aren't bloopers). But an editor can't do much with the former: the people who really seem themselves as writers, but who don't quite possess that X factor.
I'm curious enough to see what else has been written about Hedy Lamarr. You're right; there is room for a novel.
93charl08
>91 kidzdoc: Thanks. I wish it was a better book though.
>92 Chatterbox: I really like how you describe editing. Makes it sound so helpful. I enjoyed reading other people's work and commenting as part of postgrad / teaching life, especially when something I know a little about. Recently a friend published something I had read in an early stage, and so cool to look at the journal headings and think i read that years ago, and maybe helped a tiny bit. But obvs not the kind of professional editing you're talking about: I read Ghosting a couple of years ago, and was (naively) shocked by the shenanigans in publishing. Think I had an image that was unwittingly more Little Women, Jo slaving over her MS with Good Intentions.
Happily I'm now reading far from books that need editing - Jenny Uglow in In these Times: Living in Britain Through the Napoleonic Wars describing the Galton family making a fortune from guns in the late 18thC, and getting chucked out of Quaker membership as a result. '...but he and Lucy went to Meeting, as they had always done, to the end of their lives.' She's good on bringing in the empire too - this chapter manages to point to the key role of the Royal African Co & East India Co in gun production (and so the connection between these Brummie workshops and slavery).
RAC coins
>92 Chatterbox: I really like how you describe editing. Makes it sound so helpful. I enjoyed reading other people's work and commenting as part of postgrad / teaching life, especially when something I know a little about. Recently a friend published something I had read in an early stage, and so cool to look at the journal headings and think i read that years ago, and maybe helped a tiny bit. But obvs not the kind of professional editing you're talking about: I read Ghosting a couple of years ago, and was (naively) shocked by the shenanigans in publishing. Think I had an image that was unwittingly more Little Women, Jo slaving over her MS with Good Intentions.
Happily I'm now reading far from books that need editing - Jenny Uglow in In these Times: Living in Britain Through the Napoleonic Wars describing the Galton family making a fortune from guns in the late 18thC, and getting chucked out of Quaker membership as a result. '...but he and Lucy went to Meeting, as they had always done, to the end of their lives.' She's good on bringing in the empire too - this chapter manages to point to the key role of the Royal African Co & East India Co in gun production (and so the connection between these Brummie workshops and slavery).
RAC coins
94Chatterbox
Oh, I need to make time for that Uglow book... I will have a big gap in my non-fiction reading next month, though, I think.
95cushlareads
Hi Charlotte - I'm lurking and really enjoying reading your reviews. The Hedy Lamarr book grabbed my attention because 20+ years ago, the girlfriend of a friend of mine at grad school was a research assistant on Richard Rhodes' book The Making of the Atomic Bomb. I hadn't realised it's now the first of a series - I haven't even got round to reading that one!
I will definitely be avoiding Hedy's Folly - thanks. I'm struggling through another book that needs a good editor at the moment - The Bletchley Girls by Tessa Dunlop. Ellusive with 2 l's... and a bit much gushiness.
I will definitely be avoiding Hedy's Folly - thanks. I'm struggling through another book that needs a good editor at the moment - The Bletchley Girls by Tessa Dunlop. Ellusive with 2 l's... and a bit much gushiness.
96charl08
>94 Chatterbox: It's wonderful. I want my own copy!
>95 cushlareads: Thanks for visiting. His other books are prize winning, so I'd guess they're better than this?!
>95 cushlareads: Thanks for visiting. His other books are prize winning, so I'd guess they're better than this?!
97charl08
Guardian Reviews 7th March (kindle version - paper may differ!)













The Buried Giant
"Literary fiction and dragons rarely go together. This, though, has evidently not deterred Kazuo Ishiguro."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/the-buried-giant-review-kazuo-ishig...
Perfect Wives in Ideal Homes
'Do a princess and a factory worker – or, for that matter, a middle-class, university-educated housewife, longing for a career – really have more in common with each other, as women, than they do with the men of their own class? It’s one of the interesting political questions that this book raises, by assembling together all these life stories, and then doesn’t quite satisfactorily answer.'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/perfect-wives-in-ideal-homes-review...
So You've Been Publicly Shamed
"Ronson has to date struck a wily balance between championing and ridiculing outsiders, while presenting himself as basically an outsider too. The only question is how long he can keep this up..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/so-youve-been-publicly-shamed-jon-r...
The End of Apartheid: Diary of a revolution
"He shows himself as a hyperactive diplomat, never out of the limelight. He has contacts everywhere, in the cabinet, the press, the Afrikaner establishment, the radical opposition, even the banned ANC. With apartheid crumbling and power shifting uneasily from group to group, Renwick, like Pinocchio’s conscience, admonishes all and sundry to be good. How significant this was to the course of events is unclear."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/the-end-of-apartheid-diary-of-revol...
Gone to Ground
"a heartening book, about how ordinary German men and women could and did behave imaginatively and generously, often at great danger to themselves. It belongs with Hans Fallada’s novels, and Victor Klemperer’s diaries, as a portrait of a German city during the Nazi years, many of its inhabitants neither good nor bad, but simply intent on survival, and willing to take risks as a reminder that they were, at heart, human beings, with sympathy for those in trouble."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/gone-to-ground-marie-jalowicz-simon...
Aquarium
"as in Vann’s previous novels Goat Mountain and Caribou Island, the sudden encroachment of violence causes a split in the narrative, the creation of a “before” and “after” that moves it into darker territory."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/aquarium-david-vann-review-family-d...
The Ship
"Honeywell’s debut is ambitious and well written and provides endless possibilities for debate'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/the-ship-antonia-honeywell-review-d...
Karate Chop
"Karate Chop’s compact stories leave the reader wishing paradoxically for this sort of thing at greater length, but without diluting the effect."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/karate-chop-minna-needs-rehearsal-s...
She Will Build Him a City
"These are lives played out against an urban landscape morphing so rapidly its human inhabitants cannot count on the solid ground beneath their feet; one character, dispossessed by development, goes on hunger strike and is reincarnated as a giant cockroach that lives at the bottom of a country club swimming pool."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/she-will-build-him-a-city-raj-kamal...
The Girl in the Red Coat
"Hamer’s novel aims to be more than a thriller, and the real heart of the book is not its suspense, but its explorations of grief and how we weather it. It’s no accident that the title calls to mind Little Red Riding Hood, the ultimate story of a young girl captured by a predator."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/the-girl-in-the-red-coat-kate-hamer...
White Hunger
"The skill of this novella lies in the way it portrays hunger without becoming monotonous."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/03/white-hunger-aki-ollikainen-review-...
The African Equation
"the hostage drama simply provides the context for a long disquisition on Africa, which is treated as a single mythic entity with the kind of stereotyping we might have hoped was long gone."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/african-equation-yasmina-khadra-rev...
Shakespeare in London Arden Shakespeare
"this fascinating study argues that although Shakespeare rarely wrote about London – none of his plays is set in the city of his own day – it played a central role in shaping his imagination"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/shakespeare-london-hannah-crawforth...
Quite fancy White Hunger and Gone to Ground (especially given the cover art!).













The Buried Giant
"Literary fiction and dragons rarely go together. This, though, has evidently not deterred Kazuo Ishiguro."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/the-buried-giant-review-kazuo-ishig...
Perfect Wives in Ideal Homes
'Do a princess and a factory worker – or, for that matter, a middle-class, university-educated housewife, longing for a career – really have more in common with each other, as women, than they do with the men of their own class? It’s one of the interesting political questions that this book raises, by assembling together all these life stories, and then doesn’t quite satisfactorily answer.'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/perfect-wives-in-ideal-homes-review...
So You've Been Publicly Shamed
"Ronson has to date struck a wily balance between championing and ridiculing outsiders, while presenting himself as basically an outsider too. The only question is how long he can keep this up..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/so-youve-been-publicly-shamed-jon-r...
The End of Apartheid: Diary of a revolution
"He shows himself as a hyperactive diplomat, never out of the limelight. He has contacts everywhere, in the cabinet, the press, the Afrikaner establishment, the radical opposition, even the banned ANC. With apartheid crumbling and power shifting uneasily from group to group, Renwick, like Pinocchio’s conscience, admonishes all and sundry to be good. How significant this was to the course of events is unclear."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/the-end-of-apartheid-diary-of-revol...
Gone to Ground
"a heartening book, about how ordinary German men and women could and did behave imaginatively and generously, often at great danger to themselves. It belongs with Hans Fallada’s novels, and Victor Klemperer’s diaries, as a portrait of a German city during the Nazi years, many of its inhabitants neither good nor bad, but simply intent on survival, and willing to take risks as a reminder that they were, at heart, human beings, with sympathy for those in trouble."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/gone-to-ground-marie-jalowicz-simon...
Aquarium
"as in Vann’s previous novels Goat Mountain and Caribou Island, the sudden encroachment of violence causes a split in the narrative, the creation of a “before” and “after” that moves it into darker territory."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/05/aquarium-david-vann-review-family-d...
The Ship
"Honeywell’s debut is ambitious and well written and provides endless possibilities for debate'
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/the-ship-antonia-honeywell-review-d...
Karate Chop
"Karate Chop’s compact stories leave the reader wishing paradoxically for this sort of thing at greater length, but without diluting the effect."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/04/karate-chop-minna-needs-rehearsal-s...
She Will Build Him a City
"These are lives played out against an urban landscape morphing so rapidly its human inhabitants cannot count on the solid ground beneath their feet; one character, dispossessed by development, goes on hunger strike and is reincarnated as a giant cockroach that lives at the bottom of a country club swimming pool."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/07/she-will-build-him-a-city-raj-kamal...
The Girl in the Red Coat
"Hamer’s novel aims to be more than a thriller, and the real heart of the book is not its suspense, but its explorations of grief and how we weather it. It’s no accident that the title calls to mind Little Red Riding Hood, the ultimate story of a young girl captured by a predator."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/the-girl-in-the-red-coat-kate-hamer...
White Hunger
"The skill of this novella lies in the way it portrays hunger without becoming monotonous."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/03/white-hunger-aki-ollikainen-review-...
The African Equation
"the hostage drama simply provides the context for a long disquisition on Africa, which is treated as a single mythic entity with the kind of stereotyping we might have hoped was long gone."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/african-equation-yasmina-khadra-rev...
Shakespeare in London Arden Shakespeare
"this fascinating study argues that although Shakespeare rarely wrote about London – none of his plays is set in the city of his own day – it played a central role in shaping his imagination"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/06/shakespeare-london-hannah-crawforth...
Quite fancy White Hunger and Gone to Ground (especially given the cover art!).
98Chatterbox
Book bullet with Gone to Ground. Anything that compares something to Fallada...
99EBT1002
I already had the new Ishiguro on my radar and now I want to read Gone to Ground. Putting it on hold at the library.....
100RidgewayGirl
I've made note of Gone to Ground. Being compared to Alone in Berlin is quite a recommendation. I've just ordered the new Jon Ronson book.
101charl08
>98 Chatterbox: The reviewer was clearly impressed.
>99 EBT1002: I've filled out the 'pretty please order a copy of this' form myself.
>100 RidgewayGirl: I read the excerpt in the Guardian magazine last week and ias an article was certainly a compelling look at how the net deals with (apparent) transgressions.
>99 EBT1002: I've filled out the 'pretty please order a copy of this' form myself.
>100 RidgewayGirl: I read the excerpt in the Guardian magazine last week and ias an article was certainly a compelling look at how the net deals with (apparent) transgressions.
102susanj67
>101 charl08: Charlotte, I also read an excerpt from the Ronson book (about a US woman who posed for an unfortunate photo at Arlington cemetery, I think) and reserved it after that. I'm constantly struck by all the online outrage these days (or maybe faux outrage) - it's like people are just looking for reasons to be offended. But then I don't understand why anyone goes on Twitter and encourages them. I have Perfect Wives in Ideal Homes reserved too. I discovered a feature on Amazon which lists the books being published in the next 60 or 90 days - fatal!
103BLBera
Hi Charlotte - Thanks again for posting. Gone to Ground also caught my eye.
104charl08
>102 susanj67: Think I better avoid that feature!
>103 BLBera: I have my fingers crossed the library tells me they can get it, otherwise I'm going to head to the bookshop I think. I really liked the way the review described the process of her remembering her life, recording it all on tape. And of course, Anthea Bell as translator is a good sign.
>103 BLBera: I have my fingers crossed the library tells me they can get it, otherwise I'm going to head to the bookshop I think. I really liked the way the review described the process of her remembering her life, recording it all on tape. And of course, Anthea Bell as translator is a good sign.
105charl08
Finished A Monstrous Regiment of Women - found it slow going at the beginning, not least because there's a lot of theological discussion here (not my bag). The background (London in the 1920s) she does very well, but perhaps could have done with less of it, and more plot.
106charl08
Enjoying the humour in The History of the Rain: description of the 'kidnapping' of the doll being used to sit in for Jesus in the manger display.
Mr Cuddy called in every student for questioning - Have you seen Jesus? - and eventually announced that if Jesus did not return there would be no Christmas Mass.
....
(the doll is still not found)
....
By this stage the whole school was on the side of the kidnappers, and false sightings were announced hourly. Jesus was in the Chemistry lab. He was in the Girls' changing room before games. He was taking French Oral with sub Miss Trigot.
That lad is everywhere, Thomas Halvey said.
107charl08
I seem to have at least one memoir going at any time this year.
Currently it's Bedsit Disco Queen, Tracey Thorn's account of being in Everything but the Girl. First gig at 'Dave's house' - 'it went off ok until some gatecrashers barged in, a fight broke out and Dave's dad got beaten up and the police were called. Apart from that it was a lovely evening.'
I wasn't expecting book references, but intrigued by her mention of Lucy O'Brien's She Bop.

Currently it's Bedsit Disco Queen, Tracey Thorn's account of being in Everything but the Girl. First gig at 'Dave's house' - 'it went off ok until some gatecrashers barged in, a fight broke out and Dave's dad got beaten up and the police were called. Apart from that it was a lovely evening.'
I wasn't expecting book references, but intrigued by her mention of Lucy O'Brien's She Bop.

108RidgewayGirl
I listened to the Radio 4 presentation of Bedsit Disco Queen and I enjoyed it quite a bit.
I'm glad you're enjoying History of the Rain. I like that book to an unreasonable degree - I'm regretting having checked it out of the library, and am looking around for a good hardcover copy.
I'm glad you're enjoying History of the Rain. I like that book to an unreasonable degree - I'm regretting having checked it out of the library, and am looking around for a good hardcover copy.
109charl08
>108 RidgewayGirl: I could see how the narrative would be good on audio - she includes the lyrics of her songs which reference her personal life in the book - so would work well if played at the end of chapters. She's kept so much memorabilia from her early days that are included in the book too, which radio wouldn't be able to reproduce - home made posters, ticket stubs and pictures of C90s with early demos.
110Chatterbox
The Ronson book is very good -- I read an ARC of that. It's a little more reflective than just being about people who do dumb things after deliberately courting an audience of millions; rather, it's about the fact that the dumb stuff you do will haunt you, even for years. There's some thoughtful stuff about what we choose to shame people for, as well.
111markon
Resolutely looking away from the reviews in the Guardian . . . There are several that look interesting but I have too many in the pile already.
The first three Mary Russell books are my favorites in the series, though I continue to read them as they come out.
The first three Mary Russell books are my favorites in the series, though I continue to read them as they come out.
112lkernagh
Stopping by with hellos and noting that Lila is one of your best books of 2015 so far. Bechdel's Fun House is on of those great GN memoirs that struck a cord with me when it comes to family dynamics.
I love the Guardian reviews posts! I try to quickly skim them with hopes that they won't do serious damage to my future reading lists. So far you have caught my eye with Gone to Ground and sorry to see the Hedy Lemarr book was probably written by the wrong biographer. *shakes head and sighs*
I love the Guardian reviews posts! I try to quickly skim them with hopes that they won't do serious damage to my future reading lists. So far you have caught my eye with Gone to Ground and sorry to see the Hedy Lemarr book was probably written by the wrong biographer. *shakes head and sighs*
113charl08
>110 Chatterbox: Perhaps I would feel differently if given a free copy (by which I mean I usually read a free book, not anything nasty), but the Robson didn't appeal. As a r4 and this American life listener and Guardian reader, you get a lot of him and I don't always find his persona comfortable. As the reviewer above says in the full review, he presents himself as an Everyman, when he clearly isn't (now). I feel the same way about Louis Theroux's docs: the outcomes may be startling, but the methods make me uncomfortable.
Currently reading Andre Brink's Before I forget which is perhaps why I have focussed on the discomfort I feel at Ronson's writing style . Brink is doing something similar here, and reminding me that I like his historical novels more than those closer to the author's own persona.
The narrator is facing the death of a lover who has been in a coma. He revisits the loves of his life, or perhaps that should be lovers: the emotional connection, apart from sexual desire, is not explicit. The description of his younger self attempting to shame a partner into consent was grim reading and reminded me of some of the horrors of Disgrace.
But then again there is a description of three people: a couple and the narrator, listening to Don Giovanni,and just as I am thinking that this is all too pretentious for me, he drops in the connection between the music and the theme of the book: the characters discuss why Don Giovanni made hundreds of conquests? And whether these reasonschange over time?
"In his youth I'd say it is the urge to make a statement: I am here. The need for affirmation. But as he approaches middle age, who knows, it may simply be the need to be reassured. about his waning powers. About himself.'
'Isn't it pure arrogance? George challenges me....
-----
George shakes his head. He is still smiling, but his eyes are deadly serious. 'I don't think Don Giovanni is about love at all. It's about freedom...
And so the book that begins apparently about an elderly man recalling his conquests, becomes about the experience of violence as part of apartheid: his first encounter with a young cousin tinged with her memory of her mother's overreaction to another child's spying (because he is 'coloured'), and an infatuation with the young secretary at work acted on by them both in anger at the town's compulsory attendance at the choreographed white celebration of Dutch invasion. And further complicated by his father's affair with the same woman, and her 'coloured' status, and subsequent disappearance.
And then if as readers we were congratulating ourselves on the end of those times, our narrator is pushing us a along with his grief and his insomnia to witness the parallels with the (then) present, Iraq invasion:
I never liked the narrator: he is not supposed to be likeable. I did appreciate what Brink did with the idea of a man running from himself, as well as from woman to woman, in years of political conflict, exile, intimidation and ultimately democracy. As the characters discuss, do you feel sorry for Don Giovanni? And what does it mean if you do?
Edited to correct impression of first sentence, which when I reread it gave a different impression than the one I meant!
Currently reading Andre Brink's Before I forget which is perhaps why I have focussed on the discomfort I feel at Ronson's writing style . Brink is doing something similar here, and reminding me that I like his historical novels more than those closer to the author's own persona.
The narrator is facing the death of a lover who has been in a coma. He revisits the loves of his life, or perhaps that should be lovers: the emotional connection, apart from sexual desire, is not explicit. The description of his younger self attempting to shame a partner into consent was grim reading and reminded me of some of the horrors of Disgrace.
But then again there is a description of three people: a couple and the narrator, listening to Don Giovanni,and just as I am thinking that this is all too pretentious for me, he drops in the connection between the music and the theme of the book: the characters discuss why Don Giovanni made hundreds of conquests? And whether these reasonschange over time?
"In his youth I'd say it is the urge to make a statement: I am here. The need for affirmation. But as he approaches middle age, who knows, it may simply be the need to be reassured. about his waning powers. About himself.'
'Isn't it pure arrogance? George challenges me....
-----
George shakes his head. He is still smiling, but his eyes are deadly serious. 'I don't think Don Giovanni is about love at all. It's about freedom...
And so the book that begins apparently about an elderly man recalling his conquests, becomes about the experience of violence as part of apartheid: his first encounter with a young cousin tinged with her memory of her mother's overreaction to another child's spying (because he is 'coloured'), and an infatuation with the young secretary at work acted on by them both in anger at the town's compulsory attendance at the choreographed white celebration of Dutch invasion. And further complicated by his father's affair with the same woman, and her 'coloured' status, and subsequent disappearance.
And then if as readers we were congratulating ourselves on the end of those times, our narrator is pushing us a along with his grief and his insomnia to witness the parallels with the (then) present, Iraq invasion:
A day or two ago (I find it difficult to keep up with atrocities) fifteen Iraqi civilians were blown up in a Baghdad residential street... Pressed about civilian deaths, Big Chief Rumsfeld comments, 'Stuff happens.' Years ago our Minister of Justice, Jimmy Kruger, responded to the news of Steve Biko's death in detention, 'It leaves me cold.' Today that is all he is remembered for.
I never liked the narrator: he is not supposed to be likeable. I did appreciate what Brink did with the idea of a man running from himself, as well as from woman to woman, in years of political conflict, exile, intimidation and ultimately democracy. As the characters discuss, do you feel sorry for Don Giovanni? And what does it mean if you do?
Edited to correct impression of first sentence, which when I reread it gave a different impression than the one I meant!
114charl08
>111 markon: Thanks for dropping in. I think my favourite is the pirate one. Title escapes me, and phone keyboard not helping...
>112 lkernagh: Hi. Thanks for visiting. Glad they're useful. Sort of! Think I'm going to have to buy Gone to Ground as a public service, to make sure it's as good as the review said (that's my excuse, anyway!).
>112 lkernagh: Hi. Thanks for visiting. Glad they're useful. Sort of! Think I'm going to have to buy Gone to Ground as a public service, to make sure it's as good as the review said (that's my excuse, anyway!).
115charl08
Longest of Baileys prize (formerly Orange prize) is out:
Rachel Cusk: Outline
Lissa Evans: Crooked Heart
Patricia Ferguson: Aren’t We Sisters?
Xiaolu Guo: I Am China
Samantha Harvey: Dear Thief
Emma Healey: Elizabeth is Missing
Emily St. John Mandel: Station Eleven
Grace McCleen: The Offering
Sandra Newman: The Country of Ice Cream Star
Heather O’Neil: The Girl Who Was Saturday Night
Laline Paull: The Bees
Marie Phillips: The Table of Less Valued Knights
Rachel Seiffert: The Walk Home
Kamila Shamsie: A God in Every Stone
Ali Smith: How to be Both
Sara Taylor: The Shore
Anne Tyler: A Spool of Blue Thread
Sarah Waters: The Paying Guests
Jemma Wayne: After Before
PP Wong: The Life of a Banana
I enjoyed Outline and How to be Both, couldn't finish The Paying Guests and was a bit mixed about Elizabeth is Missing. Hoping that The Walk Home gets into the shortlist - loved this book - moving account of dealing with sectarianism (and not dealing with it) in Glasgow.
Rachel Cusk: Outline
Lissa Evans: Crooked Heart
Patricia Ferguson: Aren’t We Sisters?
Xiaolu Guo: I Am China
Samantha Harvey: Dear Thief
Emma Healey: Elizabeth is Missing
Emily St. John Mandel: Station Eleven
Grace McCleen: The Offering
Sandra Newman: The Country of Ice Cream Star
Heather O’Neil: The Girl Who Was Saturday Night
Laline Paull: The Bees
Marie Phillips: The Table of Less Valued Knights
Rachel Seiffert: The Walk Home
Kamila Shamsie: A God in Every Stone
Ali Smith: How to be Both
Sara Taylor: The Shore
Anne Tyler: A Spool of Blue Thread
Sarah Waters: The Paying Guests
Jemma Wayne: After Before
PP Wong: The Life of a Banana
I enjoyed Outline and How to be Both, couldn't finish The Paying Guests and was a bit mixed about Elizabeth is Missing. Hoping that The Walk Home gets into the shortlist - loved this book - moving account of dealing with sectarianism (and not dealing with it) in Glasgow.
116charl08
I've had a bit of a poke around the Bailey's list, and putting together the ones I don't want to read (as well as the ones that I do).
I'm not keen on dystopia, so I'm probably going to avoid Station Eleven (yes, despite all the LT love for it) and The Country of Ice Cream Star. I've seen reviews of The Bees and from this I know that it's set in a bee colony / hive. I'm not sure about that either!
I've already got A Spool of Blue Thread on order at the library (and I won't bore everyone *again* with how many people are ahead of me in the queue...), and I've added The Girl who was Saturday Night partly because of the amazing cover (judge away). Having read the description of Marie Phillips book, including the 'locum of the lake' I'm hoping it's going to be as funny as the library blurb makes it sound, as I'm a fan of Spamalot :-), but ordering The Table of Less Valued Knights will have to wait until my reserve list comes down a bit.

I'm not keen on dystopia, so I'm probably going to avoid Station Eleven (yes, despite all the LT love for it) and The Country of Ice Cream Star. I've seen reviews of The Bees and from this I know that it's set in a bee colony / hive. I'm not sure about that either!
I've already got A Spool of Blue Thread on order at the library (and I won't bore everyone *again* with how many people are ahead of me in the queue...), and I've added The Girl who was Saturday Night partly because of the amazing cover (judge away). Having read the description of Marie Phillips book, including the 'locum of the lake' I'm hoping it's going to be as funny as the library blurb makes it sound, as I'm a fan of Spamalot :-), but ordering The Table of Less Valued Knights will have to wait until my reserve list comes down a bit.

117elkiedee
I have an ARC of the Heather O'Neill from my favourite secondhand bookshop - I really liked her first novel Lullabies for Little Criminals
118charl08
>117 elkiedee: I'd not come across that one.
Happy to report The life of the Banana and After Before (touchstone not working, argh!) by Jemma Wayne are both on Scribd, so as long as I can squeeze them in to read before the trial runs out (!), I'm golden.
Happy to report The life of the Banana and After Before (touchstone not working, argh!) by Jemma Wayne are both on Scribd, so as long as I can squeeze them in to read before the trial runs out (!), I'm golden.
119vancouverdeb
I've read Elizabeth is Missing from the list , and I'd like to get in the library line- up for Blue Spool among others. I enjoyed Lullabies for Little Criminals by {Heather O'Neill but when I took out The Girl Who Was Saturday Night I did not actually read it, feeling it was more of the same of her first book. Like you, I'm not a fan of dystopian lit, so I might well miss Station Eleven. Just for fun and because it looked kind of interesting, I ordered Aren't We Sisters? from amazon ca today. I'll see if that was good choice in a few days! I'm sure I'll read more from the list, but first I'll need to know more about some of the books.
120charl08
>119 vancouverdeb: Look forward to hearing what you think about Aren't We Sisters. Really good to see the way the prize long list is promoting new fiction on LT!
I have cracked and downloaded Gone to Ground. It doesn't pull its punches: in the intro she's been 'sold' by a pimp for 15 marks (all she gets is a roof over her head). Her photo is heartbreaking: so young to be facing so much.
I have cracked and downloaded Gone to Ground. It doesn't pull its punches: in the intro she's been 'sold' by a pimp for 15 marks (all she gets is a roof over her head). Her photo is heartbreaking: so young to be facing so much.
121vancouverdeb
Woot ! Gone to Ground sound very interesting - I'll look forward to your comments! Yes, I am always keen to try out new books from Literary lists, especially the Orange/ Bailey's list. Really, all of the lists interest me.
123charl08
Gone to Ground: One Woman's extraordinary account proving grim reading (as you would expect, of course, from a memoir of a Jewish survivor of Nazi Germany). It doesn't 'flow' like a literary memoir, but in places seems more authentic for this lack of sophistication in expression.
At this point a lady made her energetic way towards us. ‘I’m sorry you’re having such trouble here,’ she said to me. ‘Let me introduce myself: my name is Rödelsheimer.’ I found out later that she was a musicologist.....‘Well, Fräulein Jalowicz, you made a mistake,’ she explained to me. ‘You acted like a normal human being.’
124charl08
>122 elkiedee: Did you have comments? Do you have a link? Sorry if it's obvious - I had a poke around using search function, but not much luck. This one sounds really good.
125elkiedee
>124 charl08:: Not yet, which is ridiculous and embarrassing - I still owe a review. Aren't We Sisters is set in the 1930s and features 3 women whose lives become connected - one has come to a small town in Cornwall to run a women's clinic, providing advice including contraception.
130charl08
I tried not to look smug at the counter (£2! for an immaculate hardback that only came out at the tail end of last year! Whoooo!).
131elkiedee
I can just browse in a bookshop selling new books, but I feel really disappointed not to find something in a charity shop - I love the element of surprise, and the thrill of finding something special. I read really popular stuff too, but so many of the books I want aren't even available in most new bookshops. Waterstones is really rubbish at stocking Virago Modern Classics.
132charl08
It's the sense of a bargain for me in a charity shop, definitely.
Funny Girl was just what I needed this afternoon - laugh out loud funny, absorbing story (young woman from Blackpool in the 1960s goes to London to work in TV) and characters that I cared about. As in Fever Pitch and About a Boy Nick Hornby does men who are a bit hopeless at relationships well, and does so again here.
Funny Girl was just what I needed this afternoon - laugh out loud funny, absorbing story (young woman from Blackpool in the 1960s goes to London to work in TV) and characters that I cared about. As in Fever Pitch and About a Boy Nick Hornby does men who are a bit hopeless at relationships well, and does so again here.
133brenzi
Hi Charlotte. I've read Station Eleven and Elizabeth is Missing from the longlist and enjoyed both of them; look forward to reading a few more before the shortlist is announced, including the Tyler.
134charl08
There's been a lot of love for Station Eleven around here, and I did have a look at it in the library but dystopia just doesn't do it for me, I'm afraid. Going to add another plug for The Walk Home which I loved (but it's not exactly light reading either!).
135charl08
Not much progress on the library books:
Still to read:
A bit of difference
Praying mantis
Star of the morning
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter
So long a letter
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
The narrow road to the deep north
The people in the trees
Dark roots
In the wolf's mouth
Reading:
Bedsit disco queen : how I grew up and tried to be a pop star
All our names
History of the rain
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
Probably going back unread
Bonita Avenue
Canada
However, enjoying the (non-library)
Gone to Ground and Malcolm X: A life of reinvention which has totally won my historical heart with a lengthy discussion of the difficulty of accessing the Nation of Islam records, overcome with years of negotiation.
Still to read:
A bit of difference
Praying mantis
Star of the morning
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
Divided lives : dreams of a mother and a daughter
So long a letter
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
The narrow road to the deep north
The people in the trees
Dark roots
In the wolf's mouth
Reading:
Bedsit disco queen : how I grew up and tried to be a pop star
All our names
History of the rain
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
Probably going back unread
Bonita Avenue
Canada
However, enjoying the (non-library)
Gone to Ground and Malcolm X: A life of reinvention which has totally won my historical heart with a lengthy discussion of the difficulty of accessing the Nation of Islam records, overcome with years of negotiation.
136charl08
Book blogs - does anyone read them? This is because I found a site called 'shiny new books' that I quite liked, but I suspect there are better!
137CDVicarage
>136 charl08: Some of the contributors to Shiny New Books are on LT.
I've bookmarked or follow on Twitter etc several book blogs but rarely get round to reading them - I read LT much more!
I've bookmarked or follow on Twitter etc several book blogs but rarely get round to reading them - I read LT much more!
138charl08
>137 CDVicarage: I'd expect nothing less from people with good book taste to be LT members :-)
139sibylline
I've been having a marvelous time browsing through this thread! Many many books I haven't read and many thoughtful and entertaining reviews (the Hedy Lamarr, in particular). Let's hope this bad bio will inspire a better one.
140elkiedee
I love Shiny New Books. A couple of other good ones: www.thebookbag.co.uk and www.curiousbookfans.co.uk - I used to review for one and occasionally submit reviews to the other, though the CBF site owner still seems to be taking some time out. I hope he'll feel able to run it again or I might have to post my reviews on my own blog - which is really just a bit of messing about at the moment. I like group review sites better than single person blogs, generally.
141msf59
Congrats on landing Funny Girl. I had pre-ordered a copy but when Hornby had to cancel his author event, I cancelled the order. I am going to see if I can track it down on audio. It's been getting solid reviews.
I pick The Narrow Road! I pick The Narrow Road!
I pick The Narrow Road! I pick The Narrow Road!
142charl08
>139 sibylline: Hello! Thanks for visiting. I'm trying to think of a better title. Hedy's Hobbies? (bit patronizing). I do think part of the problem is sources: you would need better ones to write a better book.
>140 elkiedee: Thanks. Plenty here to keep me busy for a while. Lots of interesting interviews on the curious book fans one.
>141 msf59: I'd offer to mail it on but RL book buddy has already nabbed it for her reading group!
>140 elkiedee: Thanks. Plenty here to keep me busy for a while. Lots of interesting interviews on the curious book fans one.
>141 msf59: I'd offer to mail it on but RL book buddy has already nabbed it for her reading group!
143charl08
Uh oh. Further Harper Lee news:
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/harper-lee-elder-abuse-investigatio...
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/harper-lee-elder-abuse-investigatio...
144msf59
So, you would pick a RL pal over an LT one? The nerve!
Just teasing! It is no problem, Charlotte.
Just teasing! It is no problem, Charlotte.
145rosylibrarian
>143 charl08: I'm kind of glad some type of authority is checking up on Harper Lee. It was kind of an odd situation...
146charl08
>144 msf59: :-)
>145 rosylibrarian: Yes, weirder and weirder it seems as more people claiming to have her best interests at heart pile in to give their expert opinion. Hopefully the state will determine a way to ensure her rights are being observed?
And in second hand book buying news, discovered the memoir/ biography section of the Liverpool Oxfam bookshop, and came away with:
Livingstone's Tribe, In Their Own Voices: African Women Writers Talk (too old to cover most of the writers I am reading this year, but still interesting) and Sights Unseen, a Virago book with an intriguing Edward Hopper print on the cover.
Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention is proving fascinating - I'm only up to the second chapter, and already the young Malcolm has experienced incredible hardship: his father dying as the result of a racist attack, his mother institutionalised after a breakdown, and living with a highly erratic half sister who was repeatedly arrested for shoplifting and violence, after the family home all but disappeared following his mother's collapse. Beautifully written, well referenced and with the kind of context (a discussion of Garveyite support in early 20C, for example) that helps to place his family, as well as him as an individual life. Whether I'll like the political stuff that is still to come, remains to be seen.
>145 rosylibrarian: Yes, weirder and weirder it seems as more people claiming to have her best interests at heart pile in to give their expert opinion. Hopefully the state will determine a way to ensure her rights are being observed?
And in second hand book buying news, discovered the memoir/ biography section of the Liverpool Oxfam bookshop, and came away with:
Livingstone's Tribe, In Their Own Voices: African Women Writers Talk (too old to cover most of the writers I am reading this year, but still interesting) and Sights Unseen, a Virago book with an intriguing Edward Hopper print on the cover.
Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention is proving fascinating - I'm only up to the second chapter, and already the young Malcolm has experienced incredible hardship: his father dying as the result of a racist attack, his mother institutionalised after a breakdown, and living with a highly erratic half sister who was repeatedly arrested for shoplifting and violence, after the family home all but disappeared following his mother's collapse. Beautifully written, well referenced and with the kind of context (a discussion of Garveyite support in early 20C, for example) that helps to place his family, as well as him as an individual life. Whether I'll like the political stuff that is still to come, remains to be seen.
147charl08
More Harper Lee news:
In a statement issued on Friday, Andrew Nurnberg, who has been Lee’s foreign-rights agent for two years, said he was “surprised to hear that someone had, anonymously, approached the authorities in Alabama to suggest that Harper Lee was being subjected to ‘elder abuse’”.
“Nelle could not be better cared for in the residential home where she lives. To suggest otherwise, anonymously and without any supportive evidence, is as shameful as it is sad,” said Nurnberg. “We should rather celebrate the fortuitous discovery of this long-lost novel and share the author’s joy at its imminent appearance.”
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/harper-lee-elder-abuse-investigatio...
In a statement issued on Friday, Andrew Nurnberg, who has been Lee’s foreign-rights agent for two years, said he was “surprised to hear that someone had, anonymously, approached the authorities in Alabama to suggest that Harper Lee was being subjected to ‘elder abuse’”.
“Nelle could not be better cared for in the residential home where she lives. To suggest otherwise, anonymously and without any supportive evidence, is as shameful as it is sad,” said Nurnberg. “We should rather celebrate the fortuitous discovery of this long-lost novel and share the author’s joy at its imminent appearance.”
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/harper-lee-elder-abuse-investigatio...
148charl08
Argh. 4 books have come in to the library, but I have 20 out already. Oh dear. Panic! One of them is Aya of Yop City, a GN I have been wanting to read since Jan 1st.
149rosylibrarian
>147 charl08: Well.... he would say that, wouldn't he? Does she have any living family members?
151charl08
The graphic novel Aya of Yop City arrived at the library (finally, thanks to an interlibrary loan, after the copy the system is supposed to own 'walked' - I only found this out after a conversation with a librarian, as the digital catalogue doesn't seem to be able to report 'lost' status for requested books).
I have been looking forward to reading this, but it turns out I got a bit confused - Aya of Yop City is one of a series about Aya - and not the first book. So I was thrown in the deep end a bit with this, but it was still a lot of fun. The books are set in 1970s Cote D'Ivoire which (at the time) was a successful state, with relative (comparative) affluence and stability. Marguerite Abouet bases this series on her own youth, and the book reflects her enthusiasm for her home. There are wonderful full page illustrations of busy market scenes, as well as humour around everyday life. This is not the grim, famine and corruption-filled "Africa" you get on the news or the charity ads. Some scenes will be familiar to those who've travelled in West Africa, such as Aya's friend's experience in the shared taxi:

That's not to say she doesn't deal with some tricky issues - infidelity key amongst them in this book. I'm adding them to my wishlist to buy and will think about (!) buying the series in the original French, as the illustrations are such fun that it would make the work translating interesting.
Recommended!

I have been looking forward to reading this, but it turns out I got a bit confused - Aya of Yop City is one of a series about Aya - and not the first book. So I was thrown in the deep end a bit with this, but it was still a lot of fun. The books are set in 1970s Cote D'Ivoire which (at the time) was a successful state, with relative (comparative) affluence and stability. Marguerite Abouet bases this series on her own youth, and the book reflects her enthusiasm for her home. There are wonderful full page illustrations of busy market scenes, as well as humour around everyday life. This is not the grim, famine and corruption-filled "Africa" you get on the news or the charity ads. Some scenes will be familiar to those who've travelled in West Africa, such as Aya's friend's experience in the shared taxi:

That's not to say she doesn't deal with some tricky issues - infidelity key amongst them in this book. I'm adding them to my wishlist to buy and will think about (!) buying the series in the original French, as the illustrations are such fun that it would make the work translating interesting.
Recommended!
152susanj67
>148 charl08: So many reserves! But at least you've finished one of them already :-) I have four still on their way somehow - maybe via somewhere far away.
153charl08
I can tell from the typos in the previous message that I should probably give up and stop reading (and reading about things to read).
CTPress' thread had a lovely review of A Month in the Country which just sounds wonderful and so has quietly slipped onto my wishlist.
And the Paris Review roundup of staff reads included this which makes me want to get my hands on it, like, now...
Sentimentality sometimes seems like a given in coming-of-age stories; fortunately, Karim Dimechkie’s debut, Lifted by the Great Nothing, avoids it at every turn. The novel centers on Max, a teen who lives with his father, Rasheed, in a New Jersey suburb; the pair emigrated from Beirut under mysterious circumstances when Max was a baby. As Rasheed tells it, the rest of the family was murdered; he doesn’t elaborate further, and his son doesn’t ask. “When we are in America,” Rasheed says, “we are Americans.” A rendering of a family torn apart not only by a civil war, but by a stubborn unwillingness to concede to the differences within itself, Lifted by the Great Nothing is awkward, challenging, and funny. It’s sharp and frank—and, like any good family, it stays with you. —Andrew Jimenez
http://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2015/03/13/staff-picks-padded-panels-pushcart...
>152 susanj67: The other 3 are calling my name!
CTPress' thread had a lovely review of A Month in the Country which just sounds wonderful and so has quietly slipped onto my wishlist.
And the Paris Review roundup of staff reads included this which makes me want to get my hands on it, like, now...
Sentimentality sometimes seems like a given in coming-of-age stories; fortunately, Karim Dimechkie’s debut, Lifted by the Great Nothing, avoids it at every turn. The novel centers on Max, a teen who lives with his father, Rasheed, in a New Jersey suburb; the pair emigrated from Beirut under mysterious circumstances when Max was a baby. As Rasheed tells it, the rest of the family was murdered; he doesn’t elaborate further, and his son doesn’t ask. “When we are in America,” Rasheed says, “we are Americans.” A rendering of a family torn apart not only by a civil war, but by a stubborn unwillingness to concede to the differences within itself, Lifted by the Great Nothing is awkward, challenging, and funny. It’s sharp and frank—and, like any good family, it stays with you. —Andrew Jimenez
http://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2015/03/13/staff-picks-padded-panels-pushcart...
>152 susanj67: The other 3 are calling my name!
154vancouverdeb
Carsten finds a lot of fab books, doesn't he! Glad to hear from elkiedee >122 elkiedee: that she enjoyed Aren't We Sisters because my copy arrived from amazon today. Not reading it yet, as I can only manage one book at time, unlike you!
155EBT1002
You hit me with another book bullet: Aya of Yop City.
And, for me, A Month in the Country was a wonderful read!
And, for me, A Month in the Country was a wonderful read!
156charl08
>154 vancouverdeb: I'm intrigued to find out what you think of this one as I wait for it to arrive at the library. Ideally I'll read all before the shortlist is announced but realistically that's unlikely!
>155 EBT1002: I think the first one is just Aya if that helps track it down. I'm having such a good year with graphic novels, hoping that blanket turns up at the library soon!
>155 EBT1002: I think the first one is just Aya if that helps track it down. I'm having such a good year with graphic novels, hoping that blanket turns up at the library soon!
157charl08
It might seem a bit flippant, and in no way is meant to undermine the extremity of what she faced as a hunted woman, but I was struck last night reading Gone to Ground how similar her experiences are to a book about travelling, the stress on the eccentric and the odd characters she meets along the way. She survived by moving from person to person, supported by wealthier or protected friends (e.g. a man married to an 'Aryan' woman), but rarely staying longer than a few nights in most cases. So she's describing how many people despite their heroism were far from perfect: the woman who was obsessive about the floor in her dining room, to the point of giving herself a heart attack:
That was what the Hellers were like: on the one hand heroically ready to risk their lives for others, on the other thinking as much of their polished floor as of resistance to the Nazis.Her descriptions of what I would term sexual harassment are awful, in some ways made worse by how taken for granted and blunt she is about dealing with it, even from those who opposed Nazism. Opposition comes in small ways, from ignoring regulations against Jews where she can, to more personal opposition:
When I saw a name that I didn’t like on a door, because it had a Nazi ring to it, I squatted down and did my business. I left some newspaper there too. What would the people in that apartment think next morning when they found what I had left on their doormat?
158charl08
Guardian Reviews 14th March (paper copy=happy neoluddite)













John Aubrey: My Own Life by Ruth Scurr reviewed by Alexandra Harris (BOOK OF THE WEEK)
"Though he had many grand projects on the go – an account of all the Roman camps in Britain, historical surveys of Wiltshire and Surrey – he was always quicker to help with others’ inquiries than to get on with his own. A natural collaborator, he wanted his research to be part of a conversation. Meetings of the newly formed Royal Society were highlights of his calendar: five fellows were to plant wheat and compare the results; or Francis Potter was to demonstrate the movement of blood between chickens; or Aubrey was to present his findings about spring water, the only good thing to come out of the time he spent waiting for Joan Sumner to marry him. (She didn’t. She sued him instead.) Night after night Aubrey sat up late in the coffee houses on Exchange Alley with the society’s “curator of experiments” Robert Hooke, gossiping, remembering, questioning the world, bringing about an intellectual revolution."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/john-aubrey-my-own-life-ruth-scurr-...
Boundless by Kathleen Winter, reviewed by Kathryn Hughes
"The late millennial success of work by Roger Deakin and W G Sebald paved the way (or perhaps led a trail of bread-crumbs) for the huge commercial and critical success of Robert Mcfarlane's landscape trilogy.... You don't realise how tricky this is to pull off until you read a book that tries to do the same sort of thing and fails...Boundless is such a book"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/boundless-tracing-land-and-dream-in...
Hitler's First Victims: And One Man's Race for Justice by Timothy Ryback review by Richard J Evans
"Ryback tells a good story. But his book is not without problems. He presents Harbinger as a lone campaigner for justice, a man who risked his life by standing up to Nazi violence. But he was in fact only one of many prosecutors who began proceedings against Nazi thugs..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/hitlers-first-victims-and-one-mans-...
Honourable Friends? Parliament and the fight for Change by Caroline Lucas reviewed by Andrew Simms
"...opens the door on a political past we are condemned to live with and sniffs the stale air of an institution to where we outsource our democracy. Stepping back, it is not Lucas who looks all alone in Westminster but Westminster that looks odd and out of place in the world"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/honourable-friends-parliament-fight...
Ray Davies: A Complicated Life by Johnny Rogan reviewed by Ian Penman
"In the absence of any obvious psychological acuity, Rogan interviews an apparently endless supply f people who testify to what a horror show it was dealing (separately with Ray or Dave, or with Dave and Ray together.... If the book's testimony is to be believed, it seems that no one who ever worked with Ray has a good word to say about him."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/ray-davies-a-complicated-life-johnn...
To Explain the World: The Discovery of Modern Science by Steven Weinberg reviewed by Tim Radford
"This is the Whig version of history with a vengeance: an unabashed vision of them in terms of now, rather than then as the world must have seemed then. It is also science history without the science; more precisely, a series of tentative and piecemeal questions about the cosmos that ends with the arrival of something that a modern physicist would recognise as science. In those terms it is a history not of science, but of the questions from which modern science emerged."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/to-explain-the-world-discovery-of-m...
Half Life: The Divided Life of Bruno Pontecorvo, Physicist or Spy by Frank Close reviewed by Graham Farmelo
"Of all the people who have been accused of being nuclear spies, Pontecorvo was perhaps the most accomplished and imaginative physicist.... Close's coup is to have found archival evidence that it was almost certainly Kim Philby who tipped off the Soviets that the FBI was on Pontecorvo's trail."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/half-life-divided-life-bruno-pontec...
Satin Island by Tom McCarthy reviewed by James Lasdun
"McCarthy dispenses with all but the most austerely diagrammatic renderings of setting, character and action, leaving us with little more than the thought-flow of his narrator as he contemplates the ... totality of modern existence."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/satin-island-tom-mccarthy-review-co...
Mainlander by Will Smith reviewed by Gerard Woodward
"This is a novel that is never quite as dark as its author wants it to be, and that can't quite decide if it's a crime thriller or a social comedy of sexual mores. In an interview, Smith has suggested he was trying to meld Middlemarch with John le Carre, though at times it felt more like The Wicker Man meets Fargo. Which isn't a bad thing."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/mainlander-will-smith-wicker-man-fa...
Nobody is Ever Missing by Catherine Lacey reviewed by Justine Jordan
"We are in the company of a mind relentlessly interrogating itself, in the tradition of Beckett and now Eimear McBride but with its own singular flavour."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/nobody-is-ever-missing-catherine-la...
Making Nice by Matt Summell reviewed by Sandra Newman (author of a Bailey's Prize long listed novel!)
"The protagonist is a thirtyish loser who drinks too much and stumbles comically in his attempts to pick up women... One might wonder if we need another book exploring a landscape so thickly covered in footprints. But Making Nice has an anarchic humour and a goofy, ingenuous humanity that makes every page feel new."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/making-nice-matt-sumell-review-sand...
The Chimes by Anna Smaill reviewed by Catherine Taylor
"... a bold, engrossing piece of dystopian writing which, despite a fiendishly complicated structure and the many distinguished antecedents in the genre, comes across as fresh and original. Small's musical training as a violinist is the bedrock of her ambitious story-telling. The setting his an alternative London, where written words and memory have been banned..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/the-chimes-anna-smaill-review
The Fishermen by Chigozie Obioma reviewed by (bookish swoon!) Helon Habila
It "mixes the traditional English novel form with the oral storytelling tradition, dramatising the conflict between the traditional and the modern. But The Fishermen is also grounded in the Aristotelian concept of tragedy..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/the-fishermen-chigozie-obioma-revie...
Rebel Footprints: A Guide to Uncovering London's Radical History by David Rosenberg reviewed by Nicholas Lezard
"Would anyone actually go on such a walk?"
(me! me!)
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/10/rebel-footprints-guide-to-uncoverin...
Argh! I think I want all of them except for Satin Island, the Ray Davies bio and Boundless (although the Observer was much kinder in their review, I feel honour-bound to point out!)












John Aubrey: My Own Life by Ruth Scurr reviewed by Alexandra Harris (BOOK OF THE WEEK)
"Though he had many grand projects on the go – an account of all the Roman camps in Britain, historical surveys of Wiltshire and Surrey – he was always quicker to help with others’ inquiries than to get on with his own. A natural collaborator, he wanted his research to be part of a conversation. Meetings of the newly formed Royal Society were highlights of his calendar: five fellows were to plant wheat and compare the results; or Francis Potter was to demonstrate the movement of blood between chickens; or Aubrey was to present his findings about spring water, the only good thing to come out of the time he spent waiting for Joan Sumner to marry him. (She didn’t. She sued him instead.) Night after night Aubrey sat up late in the coffee houses on Exchange Alley with the society’s “curator of experiments” Robert Hooke, gossiping, remembering, questioning the world, bringing about an intellectual revolution."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/john-aubrey-my-own-life-ruth-scurr-...
Boundless by Kathleen Winter, reviewed by Kathryn Hughes
"The late millennial success of work by Roger Deakin and W G Sebald paved the way (or perhaps led a trail of bread-crumbs) for the huge commercial and critical success of Robert Mcfarlane's landscape trilogy.... You don't realise how tricky this is to pull off until you read a book that tries to do the same sort of thing and fails...Boundless is such a book"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/boundless-tracing-land-and-dream-in...
Hitler's First Victims: And One Man's Race for Justice by Timothy Ryback review by Richard J Evans
"Ryback tells a good story. But his book is not without problems. He presents Harbinger as a lone campaigner for justice, a man who risked his life by standing up to Nazi violence. But he was in fact only one of many prosecutors who began proceedings against Nazi thugs..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/hitlers-first-victims-and-one-mans-...
Honourable Friends? Parliament and the fight for Change by Caroline Lucas reviewed by Andrew Simms
"...opens the door on a political past we are condemned to live with and sniffs the stale air of an institution to where we outsource our democracy. Stepping back, it is not Lucas who looks all alone in Westminster but Westminster that looks odd and out of place in the world"
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/honourable-friends-parliament-fight...
Ray Davies: A Complicated Life by Johnny Rogan reviewed by Ian Penman
"In the absence of any obvious psychological acuity, Rogan interviews an apparently endless supply f people who testify to what a horror show it was dealing (separately with Ray or Dave, or with Dave and Ray together.... If the book's testimony is to be believed, it seems that no one who ever worked with Ray has a good word to say about him."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/ray-davies-a-complicated-life-johnn...
To Explain the World: The Discovery of Modern Science by Steven Weinberg reviewed by Tim Radford
"This is the Whig version of history with a vengeance: an unabashed vision of them in terms of now, rather than then as the world must have seemed then. It is also science history without the science; more precisely, a series of tentative and piecemeal questions about the cosmos that ends with the arrival of something that a modern physicist would recognise as science. In those terms it is a history not of science, but of the questions from which modern science emerged."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/to-explain-the-world-discovery-of-m...
Half Life: The Divided Life of Bruno Pontecorvo, Physicist or Spy by Frank Close reviewed by Graham Farmelo
"Of all the people who have been accused of being nuclear spies, Pontecorvo was perhaps the most accomplished and imaginative physicist.... Close's coup is to have found archival evidence that it was almost certainly Kim Philby who tipped off the Soviets that the FBI was on Pontecorvo's trail."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/half-life-divided-life-bruno-pontec...
Satin Island by Tom McCarthy reviewed by James Lasdun
"McCarthy dispenses with all but the most austerely diagrammatic renderings of setting, character and action, leaving us with little more than the thought-flow of his narrator as he contemplates the ... totality of modern existence."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/satin-island-tom-mccarthy-review-co...
Mainlander by Will Smith reviewed by Gerard Woodward
"This is a novel that is never quite as dark as its author wants it to be, and that can't quite decide if it's a crime thriller or a social comedy of sexual mores. In an interview, Smith has suggested he was trying to meld Middlemarch with John le Carre, though at times it felt more like The Wicker Man meets Fargo. Which isn't a bad thing."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/12/mainlander-will-smith-wicker-man-fa...
Nobody is Ever Missing by Catherine Lacey reviewed by Justine Jordan
"We are in the company of a mind relentlessly interrogating itself, in the tradition of Beckett and now Eimear McBride but with its own singular flavour."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/nobody-is-ever-missing-catherine-la...
Making Nice by Matt Summell reviewed by Sandra Newman (author of a Bailey's Prize long listed novel!)
"The protagonist is a thirtyish loser who drinks too much and stumbles comically in his attempts to pick up women... One might wonder if we need another book exploring a landscape so thickly covered in footprints. But Making Nice has an anarchic humour and a goofy, ingenuous humanity that makes every page feel new."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/11/making-nice-matt-sumell-review-sand...
The Chimes by Anna Smaill reviewed by Catherine Taylor
"... a bold, engrossing piece of dystopian writing which, despite a fiendishly complicated structure and the many distinguished antecedents in the genre, comes across as fresh and original. Small's musical training as a violinist is the bedrock of her ambitious story-telling. The setting his an alternative London, where written words and memory have been banned..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/14/the-chimes-anna-smaill-review
The Fishermen by Chigozie Obioma reviewed by (bookish swoon!) Helon Habila
It "mixes the traditional English novel form with the oral storytelling tradition, dramatising the conflict between the traditional and the modern. But The Fishermen is also grounded in the Aristotelian concept of tragedy..."
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/13/the-fishermen-chigozie-obioma-revie...
Rebel Footprints: A Guide to Uncovering London's Radical History by David Rosenberg reviewed by Nicholas Lezard
"Would anyone actually go on such a walk?"
(me! me!)
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/10/rebel-footprints-guide-to-uncoverin...
Argh! I think I want all of them except for Satin Island, the Ray Davies bio and Boundless (although the Observer was much kinder in their review, I feel honour-bound to point out!)
159elkiedee
Several people said they hated Satin Island on the radio earlier. I'm quite curious about the Ray Davies bio, though I don't think I'll be buying it unless it's a Kindle Daily Deal.
Rebel Footprints sounds interesting - maybe if you're down in London some time we can try and arrange a walk and/or meetup. Though I'm shockingly lazy about walking these days - I have a real problem with finding shoes that fit.
Rebel Footprints sounds interesting - maybe if you're down in London some time we can try and arrange a walk and/or meetup. Though I'm shockingly lazy about walking these days - I have a real problem with finding shoes that fit.
160charl08
>159 elkiedee: A London walk sounds good (as does the book). I wonder if Nicholas Lezard ever leads walks? or the author of the book?
-------
Finally finished All Our Names which made a lot more sense once I'd worked out that the American half was also taking place in the 1970s (I don't quite know what I thought was happening for the first half - the Ethiopian - Ugandan had time travelled from Idi Amin's Uganda? I was reading a different book from the one the author wrote). In 1970s Mid-west, Helen is trying to work out how to have a relationship with 'Isaac' an exchange student she's been asked to help settle in her small town. In Kampala, Isaac and a friend are part of rising protest against a corrupt leader.
-------
Finally finished All Our Names which made a lot more sense once I'd worked out that the American half was also taking place in the 1970s (I don't quite know what I thought was happening for the first half - the Ethiopian - Ugandan had time travelled from Idi Amin's Uganda? I was reading a different book from the one the author wrote). In 1970s Mid-west, Helen is trying to work out how to have a relationship with 'Isaac' an exchange student she's been asked to help settle in her small town. In Kampala, Isaac and a friend are part of rising protest against a corrupt leader.
Of the half-dozen books I had owned, Isaac had managed to rescue only one from my room. The loss was negligible. I knew the lost books almost by heart, and the same was true for the one with me. I took my copy of Great Expectations into the courtyard and sat near the tree. I didn't read the book so much as I recited it; I could have gone minutes without looking down at the page and not lost a word, just as I knew my father and uncles must have done with the stories they told me and their own children. The stories were lifeless until they made something out of them, and that was what I did that morning. London was now Kampala; Pip, a poor African orphan wandering the streets of the capital.
161avatiakh
I thought I'd left a post on my last visit. Anyway I loved the Aya series of graphic novels and if you haven't yet I can suggest Maus and The Rabbi's Cat.
>158 charl08: I've started The Chimes and made very little progress so far because like you I have too many books vying for attention but it looks to be a promising read.
>136 charl08: Book blogs I try to follow though not that so much of late are Gaskella and Lisa's ANZ Lit Lovers
Lisa's reviews are especially good and indepth.
>158 charl08: I've started The Chimes and made very little progress so far because like you I have too many books vying for attention but it looks to be a promising read.
>136 charl08: Book blogs I try to follow though not that so much of late are Gaskella and Lisa's ANZ Lit Lovers
Lisa's reviews are especially good and indepth.
162charl08
>161 avatiakh: My brother has Maus and so far is ignoring all requests to post it to me. How inconsiderate (of me, tbh, to expect him to loan me his book!)
Unfortunately it seems that these books 'walk' at the libraries (and don't get reported as lost on the bit of the system members see, so my requests online just 'sit' until I remember to ask a librarian how come my #1 reservation position hasn't led to the book turning up. I'm a bit ambivalent about this to be honest. The librarian suggested it was because the books are expensive, hence the stealing. I kind of feel like if they know the books are going to be stolen (or more likely to be) they should take some measures (better security tagging?) to help those of us who want to read. But at the same time I don't want to stop anyone from picking up a book (of course!). It really frustrated me that Aya of Yop City for example, an amazing way for anyone to find out about a different place that isn't often published about in the UK, is still merrily sitting on the catalogue but isn't actually there to read. The same for other GNs. {rant over}
Re The Chimes - don't think I'll get to it soon, but it does sound good. After enjoying Funny Girl so much, I think I will probably hunt out Will Smith's book next, as a comic novel definitely appeals.
Thanks for the book blog tips - more to add to the WL this way I fear!
Unfortunately it seems that these books 'walk' at the libraries (and don't get reported as lost on the bit of the system members see, so my requests online just 'sit' until I remember to ask a librarian how come my #1 reservation position hasn't led to the book turning up. I'm a bit ambivalent about this to be honest. The librarian suggested it was because the books are expensive, hence the stealing. I kind of feel like if they know the books are going to be stolen (or more likely to be) they should take some measures (better security tagging?) to help those of us who want to read. But at the same time I don't want to stop anyone from picking up a book (of course!). It really frustrated me that Aya of Yop City for example, an amazing way for anyone to find out about a different place that isn't often published about in the UK, is still merrily sitting on the catalogue but isn't actually there to read. The same for other GNs. {rant over}
Re The Chimes - don't think I'll get to it soon, but it does sound good. After enjoying Funny Girl so much, I think I will probably hunt out Will Smith's book next, as a comic novel definitely appeals.
Thanks for the book blog tips - more to add to the WL this way I fear!
163SandDune
>158 charl08: I was just reading the Guardian review over breakfast (didn't get around to any of it yesterday) and the one that appeals to me is The Chimes.
164charl08
I sometimes save it for Sunday breakfast so that I get the benefit of reading it in paper format without the going out faff the same day. Somehow it goes well with morning coffee.
I've been trying to link to a photo from twitter of Terry Pratchett's t-shirt, but it's not working (not a .jpg file, but beyond that I'm lost).
Man's still making me smile several days after having passed on. RIP. https://twitter.com/jackschofield/status/576051787439980544/photo/1
I've been trying to link to a photo from twitter of Terry Pratchett's t-shirt, but it's not working (not a .jpg file, but beyond that I'm lost).
Man's still making me smile several days after having passed on. RIP. https://twitter.com/jackschofield/status/576051787439980544/photo/1
165charl08
I've not finished History of the Rain but there are so many lovely quotes about reading I felt the need to share this one:
Salar the Salmon a book so good that reading it you feel you're on a river.
Each journal is carefully kept, blue marbling inside and blackly leather-bound like a Lesser Bible. The first time i opened one I felt indecent. I love the feel of a book. I love the touch and smell and sound of the pages. I love the handling. A book is a sensual thing. You sit curled in a chair with it or like me you take it to bed and it's, well, enveloping. Weird I am. I know. What the Hell? as Bobby Bowe says to everything. You either get it or you don't.
When my father first took me to Ennis Library I went down among the shelves and felt company, not only the company of the writers, but the readers too, because they had lifted and opened and read these books. The books were worn in a way they can only get worn by hands and eyes and minds; these were the literal original Facebooks, the books where faces had been, and I just loved it, the whole strange sense of being aboard a readership.
166BLBera
Thanks, as always for the Guardian reviews, Charlotte. I also recommend A Month in the Country. Beautiful little book. History of the Rain and Gone to Ground both sound like books for the list.
167charl08
>167 charl08: No worries - except perhaps book wishlist ones about when I'm going to get the time to read everything I want to that the Guardian recommends! Pleased that the library has both the book and the dvd for A Month in the Country, so I may even get my Colin Firth fix at a later date :-)
I really want to finish A History of the Rain but am putting it down just now to make some bread and then will come back to it later.
I really want to finish A History of the Rain but am putting it down just now to make some bread and then will come back to it later.
168charl08
Finished History of the Rain which managed a wonderful balance of humour and tragedy to keep me reading. It even made me cry, although not at the ending I was expecting, which was even better (I do hate that sense of being manipulated into a predictable emotional response). I've quoted above about reading, and one of the things I loved about the book (which Niall Williams says took five years worth of writing) was the use of the library throughout - so the narrator is a teenager sick in bed (we're not sure what with at first) in rural Ireland (the gorgeous but very damp Co Clare), and she is reading her father's library, all helpfully numbered and fully referenced, as per a student essay (she was briefly an English lit student before her illness). We're given a tour of some odd 'classics' but also well loved favourites - Ruth riffs on Emily Dickinson's ideas of the 'feathers' of hope, while her father retells his sailing past with the help of Robert Louis Stevenson and Moby Dick.
So she tells the story of her family - how her grandfather arrived in Ireland after WW1, how her father left, how her mother met her father. More broadly it's also a community's response to the Irish economic collapse, both in terms of dramatic changes, such as the migration of young people to find work abroad but also those elements of community life that refuse to change: the owner of the post office who continues to sell stamps despite being officially closed down by the powers that be, the men who step in to rescue a home from a near flood, the high school teacher who regularly visits Ruth at home as she can no longer leave it, and offers editorial and comments on her progressing MS (which Ruth in turn shares with us).
Idiosyncratically done, and jumping from the present (her diagnosis, the village's reaction, the visits of her would-be boyfriend). In places it reminded me of The Fault in their Stars which also surprised me by how non-mawkish it managed to be. Some great gags, both in terms of Irish-English usage, the nicknames of villages (one character consistently referred to as if his first name is 'Jesus, Mary and Joseph', another 'Saddam'!) and it read beautifully in my head with wonderful accents (I imagine Niamh Cusack reading this on Radio 4, but I've got no idea if she did - just after Brooklyn it's her that is my idea of perfect Irish narration. People who know the difference between Irish regional accents may well be howling in derision right now - I apologise).
Nice connection between this and All Our Names - the power of reshaping the story, in particular those of Charles Dickens. Ruth even attributes Great Expectations to Dickens' stay in an eccentric hotel in Dublin - complete with stopped clocks, and a visit to the Blarney Stone (of course).
So she tells the story of her family - how her grandfather arrived in Ireland after WW1, how her father left, how her mother met her father. More broadly it's also a community's response to the Irish economic collapse, both in terms of dramatic changes, such as the migration of young people to find work abroad but also those elements of community life that refuse to change: the owner of the post office who continues to sell stamps despite being officially closed down by the powers that be, the men who step in to rescue a home from a near flood, the high school teacher who regularly visits Ruth at home as she can no longer leave it, and offers editorial and comments on her progressing MS (which Ruth in turn shares with us).
Idiosyncratically done, and jumping from the present (her diagnosis, the village's reaction, the visits of her would-be boyfriend). In places it reminded me of The Fault in their Stars which also surprised me by how non-mawkish it managed to be. Some great gags, both in terms of Irish-English usage, the nicknames of villages (one character consistently referred to as if his first name is 'Jesus, Mary and Joseph', another 'Saddam'!) and it read beautifully in my head with wonderful accents (I imagine Niamh Cusack reading this on Radio 4, but I've got no idea if she did - just after Brooklyn it's her that is my idea of perfect Irish narration. People who know the difference between Irish regional accents may well be howling in derision right now - I apologise).
Nice connection between this and All Our Names - the power of reshaping the story, in particular those of Charles Dickens. Ruth even attributes Great Expectations to Dickens' stay in an eccentric hotel in Dublin - complete with stopped clocks, and a visit to the Blarney Stone (of course).
169LovingLit
>127 charl08: my mum just found this one mega -cheap at an op shop too! I hope this is no comment on how it reads! I have never actually read any Nick Hornby, just seen his films ;)
>158 charl08: neo Luddite! Love it!!!
>158 charl08: neo Luddite! Love it!!!
170charl08
I have (finally!) started reading Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother & Daughter and hit with the coincidence of one of the settings. I know it fairly well having stayed there for a couple of months. Weird. It's full of pictures of her in her childhood, so I am looking at each picture thinking 'oh yes, that's round the corner from x' and 'I think that's near such and such a cafe now...'. I knew she was roughly from around there, but not so close.
What it looks like now:

Ed to add: Cape Town, South Africa (can't believe I left that out!)
What it looks like now:

Ed to add: Cape Town, South Africa (can't believe I left that out!)
171charl08
>169 LovingLit: Not for me. It was a lovely, funny book, the kind of thing you want to find to read after a bad day. At a guess, I would think that because it was released in hardback here before Xmas, lots of people will have got it for a present (and now they're being recycled by those who don't keep books!). Hope your mum likes it as much as I did.
172RidgewayGirl
History of the Rain is one of those books that sticks. I'm still thinking about it, the mud and the bed in the attic.
I'll jump on the A Month in the Country recommendation. That was a rare five star read for me. I thought that the movie was a little cheesy, but I have been soundly disagreed with, so you'll have to come to your own conclusions.
I'll jump on the A Month in the Country recommendation. That was a rare five star read for me. I thought that the movie was a little cheesy, but I have been soundly disagreed with, so you'll have to come to your own conclusions.
173charl08
>172 RidgewayGirl: It was compelling - a bit like An unnecessary woman for me - I found it hard to believe it was fiction, not a person narrating their experience, by the end.
I like a bit of cheese, so the film of A Month in the Country sounds like it might work - thanks :-)
And in other news, found Spring on my walk today
:
I like a bit of cheese, so the film of A Month in the Country sounds like it might work - thanks :-)
And in other news, found Spring on my walk today
:
174charl08
Finished Dark Roots a short collection of short stories by an Australian author Cate Kennedy that was reviewed over on Mamie's thread.
Nice and dark, twists and turns and unexpected humour. I think my favourite was the encounter between a rural child and a city woman who's just bought the house next door and thinks he's 'special'. Also a soft spot for the woman rethinking her relationship with the unpredictable partner, as they drive to start a hike:

Nice and dark, twists and turns and unexpected humour. I think my favourite was the encounter between a rural child and a city woman who's just bought the house next door and thinks he's 'special'. Also a soft spot for the woman rethinking her relationship with the unpredictable partner, as they drive to start a hike:
As they parked the car and got ready, she caught sight of some other people in the park lying under a tree on a blanket, lazing in the shade with their books. Lucky bastards.I think I may be a convert to short stories having had such luck with them recently. Am also enjoying Colleen Higgs' Johannesburg-set collection Looking for Trouble, based on her own experiences living in a unique suburb in the '80s, full of protestors, academics and other 'troublemakers'.

175Storeetllr
Thanks for visiting my thread, Charlotte! I finally managed to find yours ~ not sure what took me so long. Love your thread toppers, esp. the lighthouse image and the Bainbridge quote. You've sure been doing a lot of great reading! Even though most of them aren't the kind of book I usually read, you've got me interested in more than a few. Dark Roots, for example, though I am not usually a short-story fan, and Aya, because I am a GN fan, and I have been meaning to read Malcolm X forever, so thanks for the reminder, and, from your review, History of the Rain sounds like I really need to read it. Happy almost Spring!
176charl08
Thanks for visiting Mary.
I am keen to read the rest of the Aya series, and am thinking I might 'justify' a purchase on the basis that I can scan some images to use for 'educational use only' ppt presentations for work. Assuming I get hired again! Darryl is to blame for Malcolm X - I thought I would read a bio before the autobio group read starts.
I'm a relatively recent convert to GN's: another has just arrived at the library (Are you my mother?) :-) I'm hoping to persuade them to get March: Book One by John Lewis, and am waiting for Blankets, Just so happens and Psychiatric Tales to turn up on the reservation shelf....
I am keen to read the rest of the Aya series, and am thinking I might 'justify' a purchase on the basis that I can scan some images to use for 'educational use only' ppt presentations for work. Assuming I get hired again! Darryl is to blame for Malcolm X - I thought I would read a bio before the autobio group read starts.
I'm a relatively recent convert to GN's: another has just arrived at the library (Are you my mother?) :-) I'm hoping to persuade them to get March: Book One by John Lewis, and am waiting for Blankets, Just so happens and Psychiatric Tales to turn up on the reservation shelf....
177charl08
The reserve shelf is definitely winning at the moment, as it waits for me to come pick up:
Are you my mother?
Blankets : an illustrated novel
The stone raft
Lemon sherbet and Dolly Blue : the story of an accidental...
The table of less valued knights
Aren't we sisters?
(always, all at once!) I'm still 200 for The Girl on the Train though :-)
Are you my mother?
Blankets : an illustrated novel
The stone raft
Lemon sherbet and Dolly Blue : the story of an accidental...
The table of less valued knights
Aren't we sisters?
(always, all at once!) I'm still 200 for The Girl on the Train though :-)
178Storeetllr
Oh, fun! I enjoyed Blankets, but my favorite GNs so far are Maus I and II, Persepolis, and Dykes to Watch Out For. I'm always on the lookout for more great GNs, and just requested Psychiatric Tales from the interlibrary system. So, thanks!
179charl08
Thanks for the recommendations - I must add Dykes to Watch Out for to my list - love Persepolis, and Maus is on my radar.
Finished Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter - I've got Divided opinions on this, so may come back to it I think to comment.
Finished Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter - I've got Divided opinions on this, so may come back to it I think to comment.
180avatiakh
Ooh, I have Blankets out from the library at present, I've had it out before and failed to read it, it's a biggie. I can also recommend Rutu Modan's The Property and Epileptic by David B.
181charl08
ooh, duly adding The Property and The Epileptic to my list to reserve, thank you!
--
I promised (threatened?) further comments on Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter.

Gordon's book uses the relationship between her mother and herself, first in Cape Town and then as she travels to the US and the UK to tell a biographical story. She focuses, in a narrative that will be familiar to those who have read Karen Armstrong, on her mother's (awful) experiences being told that she can somehow personally 'control' her epilepsy through force of will. And that the seizures that result are perhaps the result of her own moral failure.
She is aware of the problems of apartheid, but this is not a book to read to find out about women's protest groups e.g. the Black Sash. For her family, emigration to Israel is the solution to complicity in apartheid, as visitors from Israel urge members of the South African population to migrate in the 1950s and 60s, running children's groups and hebrew classes, and even encouraging young people to give up their studies as their degrees will be of no use in the new state (fortunately, she records, South African members of the youth groups ignore this instruction). I said in an earlier post I had been to much of the coastline she describes. The black and white photos here don't do justice to a beautiful part of the world that she lovingly describes. Here she is talking in terms of her homesickness
Yet for me the most interesting section of this book is where she writes about herself: her own battle with postnatal depression (and homesickness) in New York, where she studied literature as her husband worked on scientific research. Her self-doubt at moving her daughter to Oxford when she was appointed to teach, following her thesis on T.S. Eliot. The responses to her work are not all positive, and reflect resistance from critics convinced by 'the death of the author':
--
I promised (threatened?) further comments on Divided Lives: Dreams of a Mother and Daughter.

Gordon's book uses the relationship between her mother and herself, first in Cape Town and then as she travels to the US and the UK to tell a biographical story. She focuses, in a narrative that will be familiar to those who have read Karen Armstrong, on her mother's (awful) experiences being told that she can somehow personally 'control' her epilepsy through force of will. And that the seizures that result are perhaps the result of her own moral failure.
She is aware of the problems of apartheid, but this is not a book to read to find out about women's protest groups e.g. the Black Sash. For her family, emigration to Israel is the solution to complicity in apartheid, as visitors from Israel urge members of the South African population to migrate in the 1950s and 60s, running children's groups and hebrew classes, and even encouraging young people to give up their studies as their degrees will be of no use in the new state (fortunately, she records, South African members of the youth groups ignore this instruction). I said in an earlier post I had been to much of the coastline she describes. The black and white photos here don't do justice to a beautiful part of the world that she lovingly describes. Here she is talking in terms of her homesickness
The alternative that isn't on offer is what I want, but can't voice: to return to the roar of the breakers on the rocks and the gulls overhead beating their wings against the wind.
Yet for me the most interesting section of this book is where she writes about herself: her own battle with postnatal depression (and homesickness) in New York, where she studied literature as her husband worked on scientific research. Her self-doubt at moving her daughter to Oxford when she was appointed to teach, following her thesis on T.S. Eliot. The responses to her work are not all positive, and reflect resistance from critics convinced by 'the death of the author':
Some reviewers are outraged though. These men own Eliot. Who is this female scurrying around, sifting papers? I try (though don't quite manage) to console myself with Virgina Woolf's comic portrait of the gentleman put out to find the housemaid turning over books in his library.She offers insight into the process of the biographer, her own ability to see a narrative in the lives of others such as Emily Dickinson, and connects this to her experiences as a child, reading with her mother, caring for her mother.
...the deep pursuit will be that question Woolf asked about what is obscured in our nature: the authenticity of unuttered thoughts, the pressure to communicate the incommunicable - to say directly, even awkwardly, what's in the mindI have a copy of Lives Like Loaded Guns on my shelf and reading this bio has made me want to go back to it again, to see the points of similarity with her descriptions of her mum's experience of epilepsy and isolated creativity. I don't think this bio works because she never addresses the key question at the heart of her mother's life (was she a good poet?), even though she is more than willing to expose other personal questions (her mother's affair) that you might expect from a family member writing a biography to hide or downplay. I wondered if this is because for her this question of literary worth *is* the most personal question, given her career as a literary scholar and writer. The book works though if read as a love letter to her mother, demonstrating her feelings through her investigations of connections, papers and experiences to find a woman who had aspired to the writing life Gordon successfully achieved: perhaps in some ways this is also an apology. Her mother's one bid to follow her work, taking a short trip to London where she joined the City Lit and was beginning to see her work published, was cut short for the sake of the children (Lyndall Gordon and her brother) back in Cape Town.
182charl08
And on a completely different note, I read Blankets this afternoon in the cafe. I really enjoyed this coming-of-age story, set in a snowy rural US. I especially liked the sections where the two brothers pretend their bed is a boat (and their teasing of each other).


183elkiedee
Thanks for the Lyndall Gordon review. Interestingly, I recently found another book by her in a charity shop, called Shared Lives which is about 3 of her friends and Lyndall Gordon herself growing up in Cape Town. I also have her Emily Dickinson bio to read. I've just reserved Divided Lives, I'm second in the queue for one copy, but that's fine. Actually, at the moment I've got so many interesting library books to contend with that I'm quite happy to just join the queue for others.
184charl08
I've also come across Shared Lives but not read it. She refers to it in this biography. I think Shared Lives might be the one to read first from her comments about it here (but may well be wrong!). I know what you mean about reservations - couple of books I'm keen to read but hoping the current reservers hold on to them until the full time is up!
185charl08
Weird how themes develop in (apparently unrelated) reading - reading Are you my mother which has a whole section on Virginia Woolf and her diary - as the Lyndall Gordon book I just finished includes a discussion of Woolf as important and influential in writing about women's lives.
186katiekrug
Hi Charlotte - I haven't visited your thread before but have seen you posting around on some of my favorite LTers' threads, so thought I should mosey on over and say hello. And then I saw that you read and liked A Map of Love, which is one of my favorite books, so that sealed it. I've dropped a star and look forward to following you (in a non-stalker kind of way)!
187LovingLit
>182 charl08: I loved this one too, I think it was my first graphic novel!!
188charl08
>186 katiekrug: Hi Katie, thanks for visiting. Your post reminds me I meant to check out the rest of Ahdaf Soueif's books.
>187 LovingLit: Wow Megan, what a great place to start. I read Persepolis first, and was completely shocked at this genre that I had been being so snobby about, being so amazing.
Crazy misty today, so I'll be walking not biking, which means I get to listen to Rabih Alameddine and Anne Tyler talking about their latest books on my way.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0536938
>187 LovingLit: Wow Megan, what a great place to start. I read Persepolis first, and was completely shocked at this genre that I had been being so snobby about, being so amazing.
Crazy misty today, so I'll be walking not biking, which means I get to listen to Rabih Alameddine and Anne Tyler talking about their latest books on my way.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0536938
189susanj67
Ooh, have you got the smog cloud from Paris? (darned foreign weather, coming over here...) London isn't getting it much, but further north it's supposed to be really bad. I don't understand how smog can get to the north without passing over London, but then I don't suppose it follows the Eurostar route...
190charl08
I'd not heard about this - as far as I know, this is 'British' fog - weather map makes it look like it's coming from the coast so it would be pretty weird to be French (not that I'd recognize the difference). Felt like Jane Eyre walking through the park this morning; slightly undermined by all the other walkers with their little dogs, but still.
191susanj67
The Telegraph is running a live blog (a smog blog, I suppose): http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/environment/11482122/Health-alert-as-smog-... Some places have a pollution warning of 9 (out of 10) but London is only about a 4.
192msf59
Sweet Thursday, Charlotte! Love all the GN chatter. You know I am a HUGE fan. I try to keep a small pile beside my favorite reading spot, at all times.
I also loved Blankets. I have March Book 2, waiting at hand and I am really enjoying Displacement.
I also loved Blankets. I have March Book 2, waiting at hand and I am really enjoying Displacement.
193charl08
Hey Mark - Friday is ahead, hurray! As if sensing your enthusiasm Just so happens has turned up on the library shelf for me. Lovely weekend of reading beckons...
194charl08
Interesting news story for readers of Arthur and George (and perhaps of Arthur Conan Doyle more widely) - evidence coming to auction that a police chief sent false evidence to ACD in a bid to discredit him. Sadly not surprising.
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/arthur-conan-doyle-set-up-by-police...
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/arthur-conan-doyle-set-up-by-police...
195charl08
And this that makes me want to read Dear Thief http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/booknews/11470185/Why-great-novels-dont...
196charl08
Finished Are you my Mother?. A lot of the psychoanalysis stuff went over my head, but I enjoyed the continued / overlapping memoir narrative from Fun Home. Looking forward to picking up Just so Happens for the weekend.
197avatiakh
>195 charl08: I also added Dear Thief to my library requests after reading that article last week. I read Arthur and George several years ago, will look forward to reading the article later this evening.
198charl08
The power of the literary reviewer. Especially since The Wilderness sits on my shelf unread.
I have this in my head today https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4sPkS8b62Q thanks to Bedsit Disco Queen
I have this in my head today https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q4sPkS8b62Q thanks to Bedsit Disco Queen
199charl08
I finished Bedsit Disco Queen which surely must be in the running for 'least rock and roll' rocknroll memoir ever. Particularly liked the stories near the end about her children recognizing her voice in public places 'mummy, you're singing in the shop' (this is from memory, so probably not exact), and George Michael causing swooning amongst mums when she's picking them up from school. Very unshowbizzy though.
200charl08
Finished Just so happens continuing my run of graphic novels. Lovely book - beautifully illustrated.
As is usual with any book about 'abroad' I finished the book wanting to visit the place shown: Japan here is beautiful, green field views from the train, quiet shrines, firework displays and mountain regions. Obata is also good at showing London (as in the illustration) as busy and diverse - a contrast to her quiet meetings with her parents.
As is usual with any book about 'abroad' I finished the book wanting to visit the place shown: Japan here is beautiful, green field views from the train, quiet shrines, firework displays and mountain regions. Obata is also good at showing London (as in the illustration) as busy and diverse - a contrast to her quiet meetings with her parents.
201msf59
Happy Friday, Charlotte! I enjoyed your thoughts on Just So Happens. It looks like another GN to add to the list.
203charl08
Gone to Ground: One woman's extraordinary account of survival in the heart of Nazi Germany
Marie Jalowicz-Simon's account of life as a 'U-Boat' (a Jewish person in hiding from the Nazi authorities) is difficult to describe, and oddly has similarities with Lyndall Gordon's memoir of her mother in that it is a life story that was published due to the efforts of a child, rather than from the initiative of the parent concerned. It's also similar (and perhaps all memoirs are) in terms of what is not said as much as what is focussed upon. In the fascinating afterword, her son describes the process by which he came to persuade his mother, long into her retirement years, to record her memories of living in Nazi Germany. This was despite her never mentioning her experiences to her students, barely mentioning it at home as anecdotes and when pushed to contribute to historical works, insisting on being an anonymous source (and keeping some information back). He opens his text recalling her response to a historian:
Marie's story is one of someone who was relentless in her desire to survive. At one point she is told that this is because she was young, and so was adaptable, but clearly it was more than this. She became a Professor of Philosophy and the book concludes with her own comments on the nature of survival being about luck - and clearly it was this too - but it is hard not to think that a big part of that luck was made by Marie herself in horrible conditions. She never loses sense of who she is, part of which is her Jewish identity, despite being forced to live apart from everyone she knew before the war:
Some of her survival is psychological too - she writes diaries, when this is not possible keeps a diary in her head (which must have contributed to the incredible recall she has of the period) and continues to read and to think for herself when she can.
I'm glad I read this - it is not literary in any sense (and in places the detailed descriptions of people become wearing) but because of that it seems more 'honest'. She has no solution to offer, no sense of divine rescue:
Marie Jalowicz-Simon's account of life as a 'U-Boat' (a Jewish person in hiding from the Nazi authorities) is difficult to describe, and oddly has similarities with Lyndall Gordon's memoir of her mother in that it is a life story that was published due to the efforts of a child, rather than from the initiative of the parent concerned. It's also similar (and perhaps all memoirs are) in terms of what is not said as much as what is focussed upon. In the fascinating afterword, her son describes the process by which he came to persuade his mother, long into her retirement years, to record her memories of living in Nazi Germany. This was despite her never mentioning her experiences to her students, barely mentioning it at home as anecdotes and when pushed to contribute to historical works, insisting on being an anonymous source (and keeping some information back). He opens his text recalling her response to a historian:
‘Do you seriously think I would not be intellectually capable of writing down the story of my life if I wanted to?’ My mother, then aged about seventy, shouted this question down the phoneI wonder if some of this was due to the negative attitudes taken to survivors of the Holocaust in the years immediately following WW2 (I've read about this fairly recently, but the name of the text completely escapes me) as much as the effect noted by oral historians that elderly people tend to be more willing to leave lengthy life narratives.
Marie's story is one of someone who was relentless in her desire to survive. At one point she is told that this is because she was young, and so was adaptable, but clearly it was more than this. She became a Professor of Philosophy and the book concludes with her own comments on the nature of survival being about luck - and clearly it was this too - but it is hard not to think that a big part of that luck was made by Marie herself in horrible conditions. She never loses sense of who she is, part of which is her Jewish identity, despite being forced to live apart from everyone she knew before the war:
Suddenly I heard a distant voice: Po Yerushalayim (This is Jerusalem). I knocked on the wall above the receiver and cried, ‘Chaverim (comrades), I’m shut up here with an impossible Dutchman in an apartment full of bugs belonging to a Nazi woman called Blase! But I want to live! I’m fighting, I’m doing my best to survive! Shalom, shalom!’She is unsparing in account - matter of fact about - her willingness to accept sexual harassment and rape in order to live. This makes it a very uncomfortable read but clearly there was no one for her to protest to, given that the police and authorities were Nazi, and many times those who were forcing her were theoretically protecting her at the same time. She lives with a man for two years who chooses to ignore that she is only with him because he can offer her accommodation. Sometimes she lies to those who are hosting her, or steals food or money, and walks away from hosts when it all becomes too much without looking back.
Some of her survival is psychological too - she writes diaries, when this is not possible keeps a diary in her head (which must have contributed to the incredible recall she has of the period) and continues to read and to think for herself when she can.
A film with Marika Rökk was showing, and at this time everyone wanted to see it. People longed for something to take their minds off reality, and long lines formed outside the cinemas. Even in great cold or driving rain, they were ready to queue for several hours with the prospect of such enjoyment ahead. I loved to see these kitschy films myself. I identified with the women stars, imagining myself in their wonderful dresses, dancing gracefully through ballrooms. Meanwhile a second part of my mind was closely analysing the political ideology of the films, which were designed to encourage the populace to see things through while also looking for such diversions, and I despised the sentimentality served up by the Nazis.At the end of the book the war is over and she is trying to accept that no one is 'good' or 'evil' because of where they come from - she decides not to emigrate and tracks down those of her friends and relatives who have survived. She writes to a friend:
Please don’t be surprised if I tell you that I feel I’ve emigrated already. I have emigrated from Hitler’s Germany to the Germany of Goethe and Johann Sebastian Bach, and I feel very comfortable thereHer son adds that she goes on to gain her doctorate and become a professor in East Germany, never failing to challenge the state despite her status as one of the early members of the Communist party (and so protected, he thinks, from some of the potential fall-out of her opinions).
I'm glad I read this - it is not literary in any sense (and in places the detailed descriptions of people become wearing) but because of that it seems more 'honest'. She has no solution to offer, no sense of divine rescue:
We have to come to terms with the fact that we cannot solve the riddle, we must content ourselves with admitting to our ignorance and grant it an asylum by using the word ‘chance’, and establishing that it is the deciding factor in all stories of survival.
205Storeetllr
Happy weekend, Charlotte! Just wanted to thank you for getting me back to GNs and that yesterday I picked up a few (eight, to be precise) from the library that you talked about, including Bechdel's Are You My Mother?
206charl08
>204 Ameise1: Thank you for the lovely colour on my thread
>205 Storeetllr: That's great - hope you enjoy them. I'm keen to read the rest of Alison Bechdel's books now.
>205 Storeetllr: That's great - hope you enjoy them. I'm keen to read the rest of Alison Bechdel's books now.
207Ameise1
>206 charl08: You're very welcome. :-)
208charl08
Guardian Reviews 21st March














The Purple Revolution by Nigel Farage reviewed by Will Self
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/purple-revolution-review-nigel-fara...
"most of all, Farage is extra-ordinary in failing to understand Britain’s unique history of colonialism and its aftermath. Even if we take him at his own devoid-of-prejudice estimation, only an extra-ordinary man could imagine for a second that contemporary Britain was now such a harmonious land that laws against racial discrimination were no longer necessary. But there are a lot of extra-ordinary men and women in good old Blighty (from the Urdu bilayati meaning “foreign”) – always have been – and come May they could well be tripping to the polls and putting an “X” beside a Kipper candidate..."
Cuckoo: cheating by nature by Nick Davies reviewed by Stephen Moss
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/cuckoo-cheating-by-nature-nick-davi...
"During the course of this book, Davies leads us on parallel journeys through the history of our knowledge of the cuckoo, its own natural history, and a series of ingenious experiments carried out by him and his colleagues to test their hypotheses. This is science of the highest order; but more importantly still, it has been rendered into clear, readable prose, which non-scientists such as myself can easily understand. Beautiful illustrations by the talented Norfolk artist James McCallum add to the book’s appeal."
A different kind of weather by William Waldegrave reviewed by Gaby Hinsliff
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/a-different-kind-of-weather-william...
"This is one of the most honest descriptions I’ve read of how it feels to be born to rule; of how precisely things worked, even in an era supposedly becoming more egalitarian, for a tiny golden circle in which everyone seemingly knew everyone. And although its author hasn’t been in parliament for almost two decades, it feels oddly relevant to our own era of anxiously class-based politics and rage against elites."
Grammar Wanker: Sleaford Mods 2007‑2014 by Jason Williamson reviewed by John Harris http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/grammar-wanker-sleaford-mods-2007-2...
"To call Sleaford Mods “rock” may seem misplaced: they do not use guitars, and their live performances are built around a solitary laptop. But their 40-something lyricist and ranter Jason Williamson is the product of a rock background, and their debt to punk, in particular, is obvious. What’s more, the bracingly sparse arrangements over which he spits out his words – programmed drums, bass and not much more, composed by his creative partner Andrew Fearn – sometimes sound like the basis of rock’s last stand: as if the only way it can possibly leave behind its mountain of baggage is by being stripped down to its merest essence."
The Birth of the Pill by Jonathan Eig reviewed by Christopher Turner
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/the-birth-of-the-pill-jonathan-eig-...
"Simmering below Eig’s readable, racy tale of heroic scientific discovery, and jarring with that narrative, is the less salubrious subject of eugenics."
Girl in the Dark by Anna Lyndsey reviewed by Alice O'Keefe
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/girl-in-the-dark-anna-lyndsey-revie...
"Within a year she was confined to her blacked-out bedroom, trussed up in light-proof clothing and completely isolated from the outside world. She became, quite literally, a creature of the shadows. And nearly nine years later, so she remains. Girl in the Dark is a memoir (written under a pen name) of those nine years."
Letters of T.S. Eliot: vol 5 reviewed by Lyndall Gordon
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/letters-ts-eliot-volume-5-1930-31-r...
"In the midst of business communications relating to Eliot’s journal the Criterion, accounts of his high-toned engagements with European intellectuals such as Ernst Robert Curtius in Germany, as well as factual reports to his mother- and brother-in-law about shares it is extraordinary to come upon an unguarded Eliot opening up to Paul Elmer More, a fellow American and Anglican, about how he went “in daily terror of eternity”. To More, he is not the “enigma” (as one correspondent complains), not the Pope of Russell Square (his address at Faber & Faber, where Eliot was a director); on the subject of pain, Eliot bares his soul."
A Curious Friendship: the story of a bluestocking and a bright young thing by Anna Thomasson reviewed by Lara Feigel
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/a-curious-friendship-anna-thomasson...
"It would be easy to dismiss them both as sublimating sexual desire: her for him, and him for the often overtly homosexual young men he gathered around him. Thomasson doesn’t forget the importance of sex for both of them, but she is also alert to the possibility of other kinds of intensity. In the process, she portrays an emotional climate subtler than our own; certainly one in which friendships were more intense than they commonly are now"
The Shore by Sara Taylor reviewed by Kate Clanchy
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/the-shore-sara-taylor-review-kate-c...
"...all the way through the book, as on TV, character trumps history: Medora has a delightful but surely unlikely sense of feminism for 1876; while Letty, in 1933, is well acquainted with therapy-speak: “You’re not ready to be a man. Fair enough, that’s your choice to make. But please, don’t question my choices.” None of these problems will make you stop reading, though, any more than they would make you turn off the telly: you want to know what happens next."
Wolf, Wolf by Eben Venter reviewed by Christopher Hope
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/wolf-wolf-eben-venter-review-christ...
"Matt Duiker happens to be gay in a culture that exalts machismo. His dilemma is at the heart of Wolf, Wolf: who are Afrikaners when they can’t be who they were? Wolf, Wolf draws a haunting portrait of Matt as an Afrikaner Jekyll and Hyde, a man sentenced to a double life."
Vanessa and her Sister by Priya Parmar reviewed by Suzi Feay
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/vanessa-and-her-sister-priya-parmar...
"Parmar seems to want to rescue the placid and heavy-set Vanessa, not widely seen as an artistic genius, from her thinner, more brilliant sister. Out of their “negative spaces” she has crafted an absorbing story, throbbing with the imagined rage and resentment strict biographers must leave out."
Acts of the Assassins by Richard Beard reviewed by Philip Hensher
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/act-of-the-assassins-richard-beard-...
"Acts of the Assassins takes place in a unique novelistic space, simultaneously in the remote past and the present day. More to the point, it embarks upon the gloriously futile project of telling the story of Jesus’s death and resurrection, and the subsequent martyrdom of all the disciples, one by one, in the manner of a police procedural, with a hapless gumshoe trying to track down the killer before he gets any further down the list of victims. This is, of course, extraordinarily funny. The way the investigating coppers talk about the disciples’ role is wonderfully inappropriate. “Thomas has privileged information about the health status of Jesus in the period after the crucifixion.” “According to John, a man died, was in a tomb for three days, and then on the Sunday he came back to life and walked away. A god is involved. ‘That figures.’ ‘He came back from the dead,’ John said. ‘Oh, fuck off.’”"
The Well by Catherine Chanter reviewed by Sarah Crown
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/the-well-catherine-chanter-review-n...
"...the difficulty in categorising the novel points to its wider ambiguities: Chanter has chosen to build her book on slippery terrain, where there are few footholds."
Dust by Yvonne Adhiambo Owuor reviewed by Abdulrazak Gurnah
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/dust-review-yvonne-adhiambo-owuor-k...
"At the core of Owuor’s novel, disguised by its intensely poeticised evocation of experience and its desire to avoid an easy emotionalism, is a moral concern to forgive past wrongs. This is not to grant her creations an easy salvation, but it is the only way forward for them – and for Kenya. Dust is a fine, compassionate novel that relishes the complexity of human relations. It is written in a language that is often beautifully observant, and is alert in its insight and sympathy."
More reviews: http://www.theguardian.com/books/books+tone/reviews














The Purple Revolution by Nigel Farage reviewed by Will Self
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/purple-revolution-review-nigel-fara...
"most of all, Farage is extra-ordinary in failing to understand Britain’s unique history of colonialism and its aftermath. Even if we take him at his own devoid-of-prejudice estimation, only an extra-ordinary man could imagine for a second that contemporary Britain was now such a harmonious land that laws against racial discrimination were no longer necessary. But there are a lot of extra-ordinary men and women in good old Blighty (from the Urdu bilayati meaning “foreign”) – always have been – and come May they could well be tripping to the polls and putting an “X” beside a Kipper candidate..."
Cuckoo: cheating by nature by Nick Davies reviewed by Stephen Moss
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/cuckoo-cheating-by-nature-nick-davi...
"During the course of this book, Davies leads us on parallel journeys through the history of our knowledge of the cuckoo, its own natural history, and a series of ingenious experiments carried out by him and his colleagues to test their hypotheses. This is science of the highest order; but more importantly still, it has been rendered into clear, readable prose, which non-scientists such as myself can easily understand. Beautiful illustrations by the talented Norfolk artist James McCallum add to the book’s appeal."
A different kind of weather by William Waldegrave reviewed by Gaby Hinsliff
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/a-different-kind-of-weather-william...
"This is one of the most honest descriptions I’ve read of how it feels to be born to rule; of how precisely things worked, even in an era supposedly becoming more egalitarian, for a tiny golden circle in which everyone seemingly knew everyone. And although its author hasn’t been in parliament for almost two decades, it feels oddly relevant to our own era of anxiously class-based politics and rage against elites."
Grammar Wanker: Sleaford Mods 2007‑2014 by Jason Williamson reviewed by John Harris http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/grammar-wanker-sleaford-mods-2007-2...
"To call Sleaford Mods “rock” may seem misplaced: they do not use guitars, and their live performances are built around a solitary laptop. But their 40-something lyricist and ranter Jason Williamson is the product of a rock background, and their debt to punk, in particular, is obvious. What’s more, the bracingly sparse arrangements over which he spits out his words – programmed drums, bass and not much more, composed by his creative partner Andrew Fearn – sometimes sound like the basis of rock’s last stand: as if the only way it can possibly leave behind its mountain of baggage is by being stripped down to its merest essence."
The Birth of the Pill by Jonathan Eig reviewed by Christopher Turner
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/the-birth-of-the-pill-jonathan-eig-...
"Simmering below Eig’s readable, racy tale of heroic scientific discovery, and jarring with that narrative, is the less salubrious subject of eugenics."
Girl in the Dark by Anna Lyndsey reviewed by Alice O'Keefe
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/girl-in-the-dark-anna-lyndsey-revie...
"Within a year she was confined to her blacked-out bedroom, trussed up in light-proof clothing and completely isolated from the outside world. She became, quite literally, a creature of the shadows. And nearly nine years later, so she remains. Girl in the Dark is a memoir (written under a pen name) of those nine years."
Letters of T.S. Eliot: vol 5 reviewed by Lyndall Gordon
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/letters-ts-eliot-volume-5-1930-31-r...
"In the midst of business communications relating to Eliot’s journal the Criterion, accounts of his high-toned engagements with European intellectuals such as Ernst Robert Curtius in Germany, as well as factual reports to his mother- and brother-in-law about shares it is extraordinary to come upon an unguarded Eliot opening up to Paul Elmer More, a fellow American and Anglican, about how he went “in daily terror of eternity”. To More, he is not the “enigma” (as one correspondent complains), not the Pope of Russell Square (his address at Faber & Faber, where Eliot was a director); on the subject of pain, Eliot bares his soul."
A Curious Friendship: the story of a bluestocking and a bright young thing by Anna Thomasson reviewed by Lara Feigel
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/a-curious-friendship-anna-thomasson...
"It would be easy to dismiss them both as sublimating sexual desire: her for him, and him for the often overtly homosexual young men he gathered around him. Thomasson doesn’t forget the importance of sex for both of them, but she is also alert to the possibility of other kinds of intensity. In the process, she portrays an emotional climate subtler than our own; certainly one in which friendships were more intense than they commonly are now"
The Shore by Sara Taylor reviewed by Kate Clanchy
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/the-shore-sara-taylor-review-kate-c...
"...all the way through the book, as on TV, character trumps history: Medora has a delightful but surely unlikely sense of feminism for 1876; while Letty, in 1933, is well acquainted with therapy-speak: “You’re not ready to be a man. Fair enough, that’s your choice to make. But please, don’t question my choices.” None of these problems will make you stop reading, though, any more than they would make you turn off the telly: you want to know what happens next."
Wolf, Wolf by Eben Venter reviewed by Christopher Hope
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/wolf-wolf-eben-venter-review-christ...
"Matt Duiker happens to be gay in a culture that exalts machismo. His dilemma is at the heart of Wolf, Wolf: who are Afrikaners when they can’t be who they were? Wolf, Wolf draws a haunting portrait of Matt as an Afrikaner Jekyll and Hyde, a man sentenced to a double life."
Vanessa and her Sister by Priya Parmar reviewed by Suzi Feay
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/21/vanessa-and-her-sister-priya-parmar...
"Parmar seems to want to rescue the placid and heavy-set Vanessa, not widely seen as an artistic genius, from her thinner, more brilliant sister. Out of their “negative spaces” she has crafted an absorbing story, throbbing with the imagined rage and resentment strict biographers must leave out."
Acts of the Assassins by Richard Beard reviewed by Philip Hensher
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/18/act-of-the-assassins-richard-beard-...
"Acts of the Assassins takes place in a unique novelistic space, simultaneously in the remote past and the present day. More to the point, it embarks upon the gloriously futile project of telling the story of Jesus’s death and resurrection, and the subsequent martyrdom of all the disciples, one by one, in the manner of a police procedural, with a hapless gumshoe trying to track down the killer before he gets any further down the list of victims. This is, of course, extraordinarily funny. The way the investigating coppers talk about the disciples’ role is wonderfully inappropriate. “Thomas has privileged information about the health status of Jesus in the period after the crucifixion.” “According to John, a man died, was in a tomb for three days, and then on the Sunday he came back to life and walked away. A god is involved. ‘That figures.’ ‘He came back from the dead,’ John said. ‘Oh, fuck off.’”"
The Well by Catherine Chanter reviewed by Sarah Crown
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/20/the-well-catherine-chanter-review-n...
"...the difficulty in categorising the novel points to its wider ambiguities: Chanter has chosen to build her book on slippery terrain, where there are few footholds."
Dust by Yvonne Adhiambo Owuor reviewed by Abdulrazak Gurnah
http://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/mar/19/dust-review-yvonne-adhiambo-owuor-k...
"At the core of Owuor’s novel, disguised by its intensely poeticised evocation of experience and its desire to avoid an easy emotionalism, is a moral concern to forgive past wrongs. This is not to grant her creations an easy salvation, but it is the only way forward for them – and for Kenya. Dust is a fine, compassionate novel that relishes the complexity of human relations. It is written in a language that is often beautifully observant, and is alert in its insight and sympathy."
More reviews: http://www.theguardian.com/books/books+tone/reviews
209elkiedee
I'll read the review but no way am I subjecting myself to The Purple Revolution (touchstones bring up Confessions of an English Opium Eater and Purple Rain by Prince and the Revolution!)
211lkernagh
Stopping by to get caught up with your reading and to get my weekly Guardian reviews fix. ;-)
I really like the cover for Divided Lives.... seems to be perfectly suited for the story, which is kind of a rarity these days. Great thoughts on that one, too.
I am bugged a little bit by the fact that The Birth of the Pill is a pink, almost chicklit styled cover. Seriously, they couldn't come up with something better than that?!
I hope you are having a wonderful weekend, Charlotte.
I really like the cover for Divided Lives.... seems to be perfectly suited for the story, which is kind of a rarity these days. Great thoughts on that one, too.
I am bugged a little bit by the fact that The Birth of the Pill is a pink, almost chicklit styled cover. Seriously, they couldn't come up with something better than that?!
I hope you are having a wonderful weekend, Charlotte.
212elkiedee
I have a book called Feminism by June Hannam, http://www.librarything.com/work/2295139/book/108330521 - the cover is the most inappropriate I've seen - those who like the cover might not want to read the book, and vice versa.
213charl08
>211 lkernagh: >212 elkiedee: What were they thinking?
214charl08
Sights Unseen

This proved to be a genius bargain purchase at Oxfam - short novel set in North Carolina, a daughter's account of her mother's manic depression and treatment. I'd not come across Kaye Gibbons before, but would like to read her other books now: the account of the family's reaction to illness is well done, observed through the eyes of a child. She also manages to encompass the tensions between the child's father and his father, who still owns the family farm (as the narrator says, which would once have been known as the 'plantation'). She's convincing on the child's eye view of illness, as the young girl and her brother Freddy try to understand what will happen to her mother as she is hospitalised - as the older brother keeps back his view inspired by Hammer horror for the sake of his young sister. Imagery lovely, as when the teenage boy is rustled up by his grandfather:
This proved to be a genius bargain purchase at Oxfam - short novel set in North Carolina, a daughter's account of her mother's manic depression and treatment. I'd not come across Kaye Gibbons before, but would like to read her other books now: the account of the family's reaction to illness is well done, observed through the eyes of a child. She also manages to encompass the tensions between the child's father and his father, who still owns the family farm (as the narrator says, which would once have been known as the 'plantation'). She's convincing on the child's eye view of illness, as the young girl and her brother Freddy try to understand what will happen to her mother as she is hospitalised - as the older brother keeps back his view inspired by Hammer horror for the sake of his young sister. Imagery lovely, as when the teenage boy is rustled up by his grandfather:
Freddy cracked the door and stuck his face out, as if he was an old woman who read the newspapers and was not so sure about this man who said that he had come to check her gas meter.
215charl08
Challenge / Library loans update:
Reading the 'Foreign Bodies' books:
I still have to read The XIth Hour by CM Okonkwo. Going to order this at the library, as the system doesn't have a copy (don't they listen to R4? Sacrilege)
Reading my bookshelves
Cough cough. Nothing to see here...
Gateway for Africa / Bookshy's list of 50 Books by African women everyone should read / 6 Read so far in 2015!
Still to read: Lots! But currently on the horizon:
So Long a Letter library
Tropical Fish: Stories out of Entebbe on the shelf
Patchwork Also on the shelf. Somewhere...
We need new names On the shelf. This one I know where it is though.
Woman at Point Zero Having read an early book by her Memoirs of a Woman Doctor, and found that the library DOES have a copy of this (in Urdu) have now asked for an English version. Fingers crossed.
The Joys of Motherhood On the shelf
Black Mamba Boy I started reading this on googlebooks and think I will buy it. It's partly set in the 1930s. I have no power to resist.
Men of the South Hoping that some birthday book delivery fairies will find this for me.
Costa Shortlist novels & category winners - 6 read
Still to read:
The Lives of Others
House of Ashes
Verso books' feminist publishing list for 2015
When I first looked into ordering these, most weren't published yet - going to have to check up on this!
Library loans -
Two books Ghettoside and Artemisia* are now waiting to be picked up
I'm currently reading:
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
The narrow road to the deep north
Aren't we sisters? (Bailey's Prize)
Still to read:
The anchoress
In the wolf's mouth
Traces remain : essays and explorations*
The journal of Antonio Montoya
The table of less valued knights (Bailey's Prize)
Star of the morning
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
A bit of difference
So long a letter
Praying mantis
The people in the trees
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
*(a book I found on the library catalogue when looking for something else entirely. Digital catalogues are dangerous!)
Reading the 'Foreign Bodies' books:
I still have to read The XIth Hour by CM Okonkwo. Going to order this at the library, as the system doesn't have a copy (don't they listen to R4? Sacrilege)
Reading my bookshelves
Cough cough. Nothing to see here...
Gateway for Africa / Bookshy's list of 50 Books by African women everyone should read / 6 Read so far in 2015!
Still to read: Lots! But currently on the horizon:
So Long a Letter library
Tropical Fish: Stories out of Entebbe on the shelf
Patchwork Also on the shelf. Somewhere...
We need new names On the shelf. This one I know where it is though.
Woman at Point Zero Having read an early book by her Memoirs of a Woman Doctor, and found that the library DOES have a copy of this (in Urdu) have now asked for an English version. Fingers crossed.
The Joys of Motherhood On the shelf
Black Mamba Boy I started reading this on googlebooks and think I will buy it. It's partly set in the 1930s. I have no power to resist.
Men of the South Hoping that some birthday book delivery fairies will find this for me.
Costa Shortlist novels & category winners - 6 read
Still to read:
The Lives of Others
House of Ashes
Verso books' feminist publishing list for 2015
When I first looked into ordering these, most weren't published yet - going to have to check up on this!
Library loans -
Two books Ghettoside and Artemisia* are now waiting to be picked up
I'm currently reading:
In these times : living in Britain through Napoleon's wars, 1793-1815
The narrow road to the deep north
Aren't we sisters? (Bailey's Prize)
Still to read:
The anchoress
In the wolf's mouth
Traces remain : essays and explorations*
The journal of Antonio Montoya
The table of less valued knights (Bailey's Prize)
Star of the morning
Living, loving and lying awake at night
Zenzele : a letter for my daughter
A bit of difference
So long a letter
Praying mantis
The people in the trees
The lost garden
Sophia : princess, suffragette, revolutionary
*(a book I found on the library catalogue when looking for something else entirely. Digital catalogues are dangerous!)
216katiekrug
Charlotte, thank you for The Guardian book review round-up. I've had my eye on The Shore for a little bit and heard bits and pieces about some of the others.
Re: the covers - maybe they are done ironically with all that pink?!?
Re: the covers - maybe they are done ironically with all that pink?!?
217Storeetllr
Good review of Sights Unseen, which is now on my wishlist!
>212 elkiedee: Blech. Looks like it was dropped in a bottle of Pepto Bismol.

>212 elkiedee: Blech. Looks like it was dropped in a bottle of Pepto Bismol.

218lkernagh
>212 elkiedee: - Wow, that cover is .... nope, I cannot describe how much that cover fails for me.
219Tara1Reads
>214 charl08: Nice review of Sights Unseen. Gibbons is known for Ellen Foster which I read years ago and liked even though now I don't remember anything about the book. I have Charms for the Easy Life and A Virtuous Woman waiting TBR.
220charl08
>216 katiekrug: >217 Storeetllr: >218 lkernagh: I think that's a conclusive vote "no" on a pink cover for a book about feminism.
>219 Tara1Reads: I envy you that TBR pile. I'm hoping my library will help me out a bit (once the reservations I've got go down a bit though).
Currently completely sucked into The Narrow Road to the Deep North. It even got me out of bed this morning, which is a vote of confidence.
>219 Tara1Reads: I envy you that TBR pile. I'm hoping my library will help me out a bit (once the reservations I've got go down a bit though).
Currently completely sucked into The Narrow Road to the Deep North. It even got me out of bed this morning, which is a vote of confidence.
221susanj67
>208 charl08: Thanks for the reviews, Charlotte :-) The cuckoo book, the pill one and the William Waldegrave memoir look good, so I've added them to my library wishlist. The Girl in the Dark cover reminded me of Gone Girl although I see they are quite different.
Nigel Farage must be laughing this morning, after the suspension of the Conservative candidate for Dudley North :-) Although actually, as I was typing that, he was asked about it on Sky News and didn't gloat, just saying it was a challenging time for all parties. That makes me wonder what UKIP is about to announce...
Nigel Farage must be laughing this morning, after the suspension of the Conservative candidate for Dudley North :-) Although actually, as I was typing that, he was asked about it on Sky News and didn't gloat, just saying it was a challenging time for all parties. That makes me wonder what UKIP is about to announce...
222RidgewayGirl
At least Farage isn't smiling on his cover. A smiling Farage is a Farage I unaccountably want to punch, and that's not an impulse I often have. Count me in as someone who will not be buying the book. Poor Will Self.
223charl08
>221 susanj67: Cuckoo does look wonderful, not least because of the illustrations. The pill book sounded like a pacey read, but I'm not sure how much (more) I can read about eugenics after the Nazi immersion that was Gone to Ground (I'm not sure why the link only goes to the German version of this). Maybe when it comes out in paperback I'll have regained some stamina for this kind of thing.
>222 RidgewayGirl: Will Self managed an entertaining review of a book I would never read - although his set up for the 'one word school of reviewing' made me wonder if he had pitched a one word review to the editor. I'm not sure the one word would be 'extra' -'ordinary' though.
>222 RidgewayGirl: Will Self managed an entertaining review of a book I would never read - although his set up for the 'one word school of reviewing' made me wonder if he had pitched a one word review to the editor. I'm not sure the one word would be 'extra' -'ordinary' though.
224vancouverdeb
I do enjoy your Guardian Reviews each week, Charlotte. Honestly, I think I might be interested in The Birth of The Pill . Though my reading pace has been slow , I'm really enjoying Aren't We Sisters? and while I am sure they are two totally different sorts of reads, contraceptives and how they changed women's lives and the resistance of contraceptives of any sort for women is an interesting topic. I enjoy My Globe and Mail and The Sun Saturday book reviews. They tend to focus on Canadian books.
225charl08
>224 vancouverdeb: I love review pages, when I am a millionaire (er, perhaps in the next life) I plan to subscribe to all of them. The London Review of Books, the NY Review of Books, the Mail and Guardian (South Africa) the Times Lit Supplement... And have the time to read them, of course.
I don't check the Globe but now you've pointed it out, I think I might be going back - I really like the sound of Higher ed: a novel given the focus on university life (and my fandom for Zadie Smith's On Beauty), and A Measure of Light sounds like a fascinating look at early US history. Both are authors I'd not come across before, even though McWatt teaches in the UK. Although not a good sign that amazon uk don't have either listed...
I'm liking Aren't we sisters but have had to break off to try and finish The Narrow Road to the Deep North because it's due back at the library this week, and it has taken me SO LONG to get it on the reservation system I feel like I don't want to risk forgetting everything I've read by the time it comes back to me again. Although it is so good I am tempted to buy a copy for myself. Must resist!
I don't check the Globe but now you've pointed it out, I think I might be going back - I really like the sound of Higher ed: a novel given the focus on university life (and my fandom for Zadie Smith's On Beauty), and A Measure of Light sounds like a fascinating look at early US history. Both are authors I'd not come across before, even though McWatt teaches in the UK. Although not a good sign that amazon uk don't have either listed...
I'm liking Aren't we sisters but have had to break off to try and finish The Narrow Road to the Deep North because it's due back at the library this week, and it has taken me SO LONG to get it on the reservation system I feel like I don't want to risk forgetting everything I've read by the time it comes back to me again. Although it is so good I am tempted to buy a copy for myself. Must resist!
226elkiedee
The paperback of Narrow Road is due out next week, and maybe the Kindle version will drop again (depending on which you prefer). I snaffled it for £1.99 during a day or two of mad bargains at the beginning of February.
227PaulCranswick
>208 charl08: As always Charlotte your Guardian Review slot caught my attention. I often enjoy reading books by those
whose political views are opposed to my own and would therefore not be as reluctant as Luci to read it - I am sure Nigel Farage's book is a laugh a minute. Still on second thoughts fantasy has never been a big favourite of mine.
I agree that the book on the pill boasts an annoyingly patronising cover.
Have a lovely Sunday.
whose political views are opposed to my own and would therefore not be as reluctant as Luci to read it - I am sure Nigel Farage's book is a laugh a minute. Still on second thoughts fantasy has never been a big favourite of mine.
I agree that the book on the pill boasts an annoyingly patronising cover.
Have a lovely Sunday.
228elkiedee
My objection would be to contributing to his funds, as much as to reading the book. But also, there are rather a lot of books I want to read more than that one.
229msf59
Happy Sunday, Charlotte! I recently read and loved the Narrow Road. I imagine you will too. I also have Ghettoside saved on audio. I want to bookhorn that one in.
230BLBera
Hi Charlotte - I look forward to see what the Guardian is reviewing every week, thanks to you. I have to get to The Narrow Road to the Deep North soon; I've heard so many good things about it.
I loved Ghettoside; it's certainly one of the best this year, so far. Thoughtful reflection on race in America wrapped into stories of victims.
I loved Ghettoside; it's certainly one of the best this year, so far. Thoughtful reflection on race in America wrapped into stories of victims.
231charl08
>226 elkiedee: I'll keep an eye out on those prices - thanks. I hadn't realised it was out in paperback so soon. Hopefully there will be some offers around :-)
>227 PaulCranswick: Self's review of Farage certainly made me snort into my coffee. Well worth reading in full (and I am reminded that I meant to pick up Shark and really want to do so at some point soon!).
>230 BLBera: Self also mentions the link between the publisher and UKIP.
>229 msf59: >230 BLBera: I am loving The Narrow Road to the Deep North - completely engrossing story. I thought it might be overhyped, but I agree with all the hyperbole so far. Also really looking forward to reading Ghettoside after it has been recommended by so many LT readers. After the events in the news over the past year, it seems important to read this as well as the civil rights history in the Malcolm X bio Malcolm X: a life of reinvention. I have been distracted from this by the library books, but *must* get back to this week.
>227 PaulCranswick: Self's review of Farage certainly made me snort into my coffee. Well worth reading in full (and I am reminded that I meant to pick up Shark and really want to do so at some point soon!).
>230 BLBera: Self also mentions the link between the publisher and UKIP.
>229 msf59: >230 BLBera: I am loving The Narrow Road to the Deep North - completely engrossing story. I thought it might be overhyped, but I agree with all the hyperbole so far. Also really looking forward to reading Ghettoside after it has been recommended by so many LT readers. After the events in the news over the past year, it seems important to read this as well as the civil rights history in the Malcolm X bio Malcolm X: a life of reinvention. I have been distracted from this by the library books, but *must* get back to this week.
232charl08
The Narrow Road to the Deep North

Though this is a novel that shows deep research into military history, is full of violence, and the text includes barely any women except as mother / love objects*, all qualities I don't appreciate in novels, it had me engrossed from the beginning to the last page. We're shown early on that this is a complex narrative, not a tale of an uncomplicated hero or nationalist folk story, as each section is introduced by a haiku (the source of the title of the novel) highlighting the beauty of Japanese culture, even as we are sunk deep in the mud, lice and gore of the prisoners' lives.
I was particularly impressed by the way the author used a shifting timeframe to mess around with conventional narrative arc of war stories. There's nothing here like a liberation moment, a fixed progress to an agreed end point - no Ice Cold in Alex celebratory lager at the bar, as everyone forgets what has gone before in the haze of 'being the victor'. Just individuals dealing with a horrible experience, one that is (now) well known, but is individually lived. I also thought the author did well to consider the way memorialisation changes over time - and what that means for survivors, as well as the different background of those who ran the camps. His skill in dealing with the experience of those the Japanese colonised in Korea in particular I thought impressive, as well as acknowledging early that the Australian POWs story is just one part of the horror of the 'line', and many other forced workers died in their thousands to build the railway. Our central narrator 'Dorrigo' Evans, is a fan of classical poetry, reciting and quoting at key moments in the narrative. At times Flanagan's text echoes with these histories, as he comments on the futility of what was undertaken as part of the Japanese Imperial project (and by implication imperial and globalising projects more broadly?):
Highly recommended, well deserving of the many awards it has achieved, and a new favourite read of the year.
*This book would not pass the Bechdel test.

Though this is a novel that shows deep research into military history, is full of violence, and the text includes barely any women except as mother / love objects*, all qualities I don't appreciate in novels, it had me engrossed from the beginning to the last page. We're shown early on that this is a complex narrative, not a tale of an uncomplicated hero or nationalist folk story, as each section is introduced by a haiku (the source of the title of the novel) highlighting the beauty of Japanese culture, even as we are sunk deep in the mud, lice and gore of the prisoners' lives.
For the Line was broken, as all lines finally are; it was all for nothing, and of it nothing remained. People kept on longing for meaning and hope, but the annals of the past are a muddy story of chaos only.
And of that colossal ruin, boundless and buried, the lone and level jungle stretched far away. Of imperial dreams and dead men, all that remained was long grass.
Highly recommended, well deserving of the many awards it has achieved, and a new favourite read of the year.
*This book would not pass the Bechdel test.
233EBT1002
>155 EBT1002: Thank you! I just put Aya on hold at the library. I'm first in the queue. :-)
I'm glad you enjoyed The Narrow Road to the Deep North. It would indeed fail the Bechdel test but I agree that it was a magnificent novel.
Acts of the Assassins looks like a hoot! I must track it down. It won't pass the Bechdel test either but it sounds hilarious!
I'm glad you enjoyed The Narrow Road to the Deep North. It would indeed fail the Bechdel test but I agree that it was a magnificent novel.
Acts of the Assassins looks like a hoot! I must track it down. It won't pass the Bechdel test either but it sounds hilarious!
234RidgewayGirl
I agree that The Narrow Road to the Deep North is impressive. I really enjoyed it.
235charl08
>233 EBT1002: Yes, I love the cover (although not sure if this is the US or UK version!)
>234 RidgewayGirl: I'm still hovering over buying it. One of those ones I want on my shelf as a 'good book memory', even if I don't reread it.
>234 RidgewayGirl: I'm still hovering over buying it. One of those ones I want on my shelf as a 'good book memory', even if I don't reread it.
236Storeetllr
Of imperial dreams and dead men, all that remained was long grass.
Love that line. I may have to check that book out!
Also, I love that you buy books you've already read and may never read again, just to have them on the "good book memory" shelf! I admit to having done that a time or three too.
Love that line. I may have to check that book out!
Also, I love that you buy books you've already read and may never read again, just to have them on the "good book memory" shelf! I admit to having done that a time or three too.
237RidgewayGirl
My perfect home library would be stocked with those books I have truly engaged with, and be a reflection of my reading over the years.
I'll admit to a certain frustration whenever I check a book out of the library that ends up being one I'd like to own. And the list of books to look for at book sales grows and grows.
I'll admit to a certain frustration whenever I check a book out of the library that ends up being one I'd like to own. And the list of books to look for at book sales grows and grows.
238elkiedee
I think there's a good argument, particularly if you have a good library, for buying the books you know you loved after you've read them, perhaps rather than buying ones that turn out to be a disappointment.
I have about 7 Amazon wishlists, 6 of which are for Kindle books (the other is for books that aren't available on Kindle or occasionally one which is best in dead tree format). One of those is for "library reads I'd like on Kindle", though I do end up getting some from charity shops - then they go on the "replacement" list for books I can give away if I get them on Kindle. I buy when they come up at under £2.
I have about 7 Amazon wishlists, 6 of which are for Kindle books (the other is for books that aren't available on Kindle or occasionally one which is best in dead tree format). One of those is for "library reads I'd like on Kindle", though I do end up getting some from charity shops - then they go on the "replacement" list for books I can give away if I get them on Kindle. I buy when they come up at under £2.
239charl08
>236 Storeetllr: Yeah, there's a lot of near poetry in the book - and the main character quotes all the time. I think if I was more classically knowledgeable would probably recognise more of the references. As it was, one year of Latin means I didn't get much further than Caecilia and Clemens going to the arena (ha! Found the course online - or the up-to-date version of it, which reminds me that half was history, which explains how I passed the course!) http://www.cambridgescp.com
>237 RidgewayGirl: I have a perfect home library in my head too. As well as all those much loved books it would look something like this I think:
.
>238 elkiedee: The multiple Amazon wishlist is a good plan: I've got a 'why doesn't this work on kindle' one, one for gifts for small people, one to direct family to, and the work in progress one - but could probably do with another couple for the 'loved but not owned' category. Thanks for the suggestion.
>237 RidgewayGirl: I have a perfect home library in my head too. As well as all those much loved books it would look something like this I think:
. >238 elkiedee: The multiple Amazon wishlist is a good plan: I've got a 'why doesn't this work on kindle' one, one for gifts for small people, one to direct family to, and the work in progress one - but could probably do with another couple for the 'loved but not owned' category. Thanks for the suggestion.
240vancouverdeb
Oh! I love your library! I have to tell you that on amazon ca there is a new sort of retro cover for The Birth of the Pill. There is a sort of retro looking woman on the front - a bit tongue in cheek looking, I think. I much prefer it to the cover shown on the Guardian.
242msf59
Morning Charlotte! Good review of the Narrow Road. I am so glad you enjoyed it. I would like to try some of Flanagan's other work.
This topic was continued by Charl08 dreaming of beach reading #3.











