The Court of the Air

I was thinking about giving this book 4 stars but really I said, "Man this book is awesome" way too many times to not give it 5 stars. It's really about action and ideas and a fully realized world. The action is almost constant and it's fun. The characters are badasses (not right away but at some point). People also die so it doesn't feel like a Disney fantasy where everything works out perfect. It's brutal and gritty and political.

All I have to say is voodoo practicing steam men and insane insect gods feeding off the still warm hearts of 1000's of humans, airships dropping dirtgas on protesting socialists and a king with no arms. I think you get.

I actually read the 2nd book in this series first The Kingdom Beyond the Waves but it show more didn't make much of a difference. It's not the same characters just the same world. I actually like this one more. show less

Thinly-veiled anti-socialist diatribes aside, the thing that really tweaked me was the evident fascination with horrible things.

How can I show how really horrible these (socialist) people are? By making everybody "equalized" a la Kurt Vonnegut's "Harrison Bergeron" but in a much creepier way, by turning them into machines, or having them cut off body parts.

How can I show how awful the ancient society was? They weren't just doing human sacrifice -- they were making an enormous killing machine out of the blood of their beloved family members, AND turning other people into meat plants so they could be cannibal farmers.

How can I demonstrate the awfulness of people with anti-monarchical sentiments? By embedding ritual humiliation, show more amputation, and torture into their treatment of the royal family.

It was honestly just sort of disturbing, how the author's inventive capacity were most turned toward inventing horrors.

On top of all that, the shallow political analysis (see S. M. Stirling, for example) is hardly even noticeable. The heroic rich adventurers, the monarchs and royalists who aren't as bad as the socialists, the idealist who although not evil is still completely delusional, and so forth. That all just kind of faded into the background of being repeatedly hit over the head with really horrible gross abuses of the imagination.

But I did notice how the attempts to make the book trendily gender balanced failed rather miserably. The boy and girl protagonists were figured as the "defense" and the "offense" by some "watcher" species. But the girl's "offensive" capabilities turned out to be being really good at withstanding torture, and then merging with some mechanical god to supernaturally show up at the last minute and do not much. The "defensive" boy turned out to merge with some kind of warrior spirit who sent him wicking around swords and having a sort of grim bloodthirstiness. Channeling Elric of Melniboné, I guess, because there was a kind of soul-sucking quality to the weapons. Anyway I guess that failed because there wasn't a lot of character development. We were supposed to want to like the characters, but they mostly just were cyphers for the plot as well as for the operators in their own world. So the author ended up falling back on gender stereotypes.

Anyway, I won't be picking up more of these. If you like a lot of horror mixed in with your steampunk, dystopia, adventuring, and capital-L Libertarian-style politics, give these a shot. show less

I don't know if I'm disappointed or not by this book. Basically it's a steampunk fantasy set in a world that is recognisably a quasi-Victorian England in conflict with a neighbour which is recognisably a cross between Revolutionary France and Marxist USSR. Throw in some quasi-Aztec evil gods, voodoo steammen and fae magick and you get - well, a hell of a mess really. Some people applaud the wealth of ideas crammed into this novel, but for me there were just too many of them, too scantily developed, and in the end they threaten to bury the story entirely. Add to that a relentlessly fast pace and I ended up feeling like I'd fallen into a raging torrent and was just being carried along blindly by it.

The characters were poorly developed show more and one never really got to care for them or what happened to them. Although Hunt does occasionally lapse into passages of fluid and poetic prose, the dialogue is often cringeworthy. Yes, It's supposed to sound quaint and archaic, I suppose, but it just sounded creaky and artificial to me.

I wanted to like this book and had high expectations since it came so highly praised to me. And I did appreciate some of the imaginative concepts and rip-roaring action scenes. But ultimately it's over-ambitious. rambling and over-long, the result of a first-time author's tendency to cram in everything including the kitchen sink going unchecked by a firm editorial hand. I might try another of his books later on, just to see if he's learned to rein in the ideas enough to let a story shine through. show less

Like being pelted by spare brass cogs in triple-waltz time. Familiar Steampunk tropes abound, the characterization never takes hold, and there's just too damn much going on. Underground lands? Check. Orphans? Check. Sentient robots? Check. Quasi-Victorian social structure? Check. Imaginative gun-weapons? Check.

Oh, look, here comes the airship. I thought one would be along sooner or later.

I also thought the political undercurrents were crudely managed. Those bad, bad commies! I finished the book, but won't be continuing with the series.

Oh, this book. Much like Jonathan Strange, Court of the Air is one that I love to bits but I haven’t read it time after time. It’s one of the first steampunk books that I got into, and it’s definitely a good one.

The world-building’s fantastic. I like that there’s no implication that this is supposed to be our Earth x-number of years or even that it’s an alternate universe, but rather, it’s own Earth with specific races and cultures. There are equivalents with the different countries that you can draw on the references, but even still, Hunt makes this world his own. What’s also important to note is the sheer political detail that gets covered in this, which I think definitely adds to the world-building. While a large show more amount of the book is action and mystery, there’s a healthy amount of political intrigue that adds to the story. Again, there’s many real world parallels, but for the story’s sake, it does illustrate the larger ideologies at play here (and in future volumes). I also like the fact that none of the politics are painted as “This is the absolute one thing we (and by extension, you, the reader) should follow in governance.” Even the main political infrastructure of Jackals has its darker side. It’s sort of interesting to find a book that deals with the warts and all of political ideology. Also, the population of this Earth fascinates me. It’s not just humans and sorcerers and fae, although they all play a major role in the series. We’ve got a race of crustacean people living in steampunk quasi-London. There’s doglike people who pop up (although they have a bigger role in the second book). My personal favorite, and the one I sell the series on, are the Steammen: sentinent steampunk robots who practice voudoun. There were no words for me to describe that awesome aside from “squee!”

And while this all comes off as rather gimmicky, Hunt manages to pull off a finely crafted story that supports and fits this world he’s created. There’s so much complexity in this that I’m not surprised that there’s more to the series than just the one book. And I love the history that we get in here, and that there’s so much more to explore to it.

That all said, there is a LOT going on in this. It’s already bad enough following two narratives that could both support a single book, add in the sheer amount of world-building and backstory and it does feel like you need a list of names to figure out what’s going on. And a lot of the characters don’t appear for more than a few pages to boot. That said though, I think it’s one of the positive aspects of the book, and adds to the world. As for our two main characters, I rather like Molly and Oliver. They start off as kind of boring protagonists—both stuck in boring lives, have super-special abilities, get dragged into adventure, atypical orphans saving the world plot. What I like about them is that they’re very much their own characters. Oliver’s known that he’s got the potential for his special abilities, they’ve just never come to light, and he’s much more focused on trying to stop his powers from manifesting. I also love that there’s this fantastic set-up of him becoming a swashbuckling hero in-universe. (More hood o’the marsh in the next books!) Molly is fantastic—I love that because she reads so many penny dreadfuls, when she learns that someone’s trying to kill, Molly immediately launches into a scenario from one of her books. (And the villain pretty much goes “lol no.”) And while her own special abilities aren’t really alluded to in the beginning, I like that she slowly learns about them and uses them to her advantage. I really want to see more of her as the series goes on. And both Molly and Oliver don’t sit around and let things just happen to them. Oliver definitely isn’t afraid to ask questions that need to be asked, and Molly does her best with trying to piece her past together. They’re presented as these stock characters, but they definitely become more than just stereotypes. Not to mention, while their individual plotlines feel like two random events, everything dovetails neatly together.

I also love the supporting cast. Not so much Oliver’s quasi-guardian, Harry Stave, if only because his motives feel a little too unclear. Molly’s friends and allies, though, are fantastic. I love the steammen who come to help her out; her friends at the workhouse; Professor Amelia Harsh, who unfortunately disappears after two pages (but is the main character in the sequel!)—again, I loved that we get these fleshed-out characters, even if they don’t play a huge part in the narrative. And Prince Alpheus—you can’t help but feel sorry for the poor kid, especially when it’s mentioned early on that members of the royal family are mutilated and subject to public humiliation for past sins. (And this is for the country we’re supposed to like.) My heartstings, all of them. I like that while the main villains are fairly black and white in their motives, the way they’re presented until the reveal is definitely muddled and present different options.

This is a fantastic read, and definitely for someone looking for good steampunk novels. I don’t know if I’d necessarily recommend it for those starting out in the genre, but it does bring many new ideas to the subject, along with some fantastic world-building and just incredibly enjoyable storytelling. Despite the overreaching story arcs and build-up, at the heart of Hunt’s world is a grand adventure tale, which has been continuing throughout the series thus far. It’s an excellent read, and comes highly recommended. show less

Two young orphans find themselves at the center of vast conspiracy; their world on the brink of apocalypse. Molly, a street punk with strange skills for repairing the race of mechanical steam men, is hunted by both a fearsome assassin and the underground revolutionary communityists, who want to overthrow the current system of government in favor of apocalypse-bringing dark gods. Oliver, who as a child was exposed to the dangerous fey mists, has supernatural powers yet is not cursed with the physical deformities most other fey-children experience. He is set up for the murder of his last surviving relative, and is being pursued by both the oppressive-to-fey government and the secret Court of the Air, a supra-military, supra-government show more body in charge of being in charge of, well, everything.

Sounds complicated? It is. And there is much, much more.

Hunt packs in so much detail to the historical and geographic setting, I was totally overwhelmed. There are so many plot lines, so many side stories, I had a hard time getting a handle on the actual world. Instead of world building, it was more like world-dumping. Never boring the way info-dumping can be, but completely burying the characters and plot.

The story obviously parallels a Victorian-esque England and yet, instead of being fresh and new, I found it derivative and superficial. The parallels were too obvious. Communityists? Communisits. And just like our world, the once social ideal of its writer, Ben Carl (Marx) has turned into Stalin’s Russia, complete with population-killing pogroms against first the elite, then the wealthy, then the middle class, and finally, almost everyone.

Those dark gods, with names like its-a-coatyl, that-a-dopotchli and this-a-zayloc, demanding bloody human sacrifice and a return to the old ways of total enslavement? I kept thinking of alien Mayans, but in an Ice Age, instead of the Yucatan.

At some key moments Oliver or Molly figure out secret motives or unconver conspiracies and I felt totally bewildered— not because it was a great plot twist that I deliciously anticipated, no— because I had no idea in the hundreds of pages past that a clue had come and gone. I found the characters rather flat compared to all of the historical and geographic description; as I read, I did not assign them unknown or deep complexities. When these complexities were revealed, it was rather like having Sherlock Holmes jump out from behind the curtain, screaming “the butler did it! And here are twenty reasons why that you never guessed!”

The book was hard to get through and almost boring, which is strange because the story itself is action-packed. By the end, it becomes a flat out race to the end, and I was fairly hooked. I might have given it three stars, except that until those last 100 pages or so, reading it was kind of a chore rather than a pleasure. show less

An interesting work of steampunk fantasy, but as other reviewers have noted, Hunt tends to throw in too much to manage. In fact there is so much thrown at the reader at the beginning that the book makes little sense and requires a deal of effort to really grasp what is going on.

In addition, for fantasy, a setting is as critical as the characters and can make or break a story. Hunt's setting is a too bizarre for my liking. It is wonderful that fantasy authors are starting to move away from the sword and sorcery and middle age settings to explore other periods from a fantasy perspective; Hunt's setting, however, seems to diverge too much for my tastes for me to be able to connect with anything in the story.

Added to this is the lack of show more sympathetic characters. I found the two protagonists to be rather dull and carboard figures. And, the supporting cast was even less sympathetic. The Court of the Air, a secretive organization that I presumed would play a critical role in the story given that it is the title of the book, seemed rather pointless and peripheral.

In the end, I think others have done a better job of exploring alternate time periods from a fantastic perspective.

I should note, however, that I do not mean to imply that Court of the Air is a poorly written work or badly wrought setting; rather, I think the nature of the setting is not for everyone. show less