George Crile (1) (1945–2006)

the movie was a fun romp, the book is darker and more ambivalent. philip seymour hoffman was great, but in the book gust avrakotos is more clearly a horrendous asshole. charlie wilson is still charming, but the backdoor porkbarrel deals and an egregious hit-and-run make him less sympathetic.

remember when the mujahideen were freedom fighters? remember rambo 3? several times the book talks about muj fighters raping, mutilating, and executing captured russian soldiers, to the extent that the show more idea of russians troops surrendering or defecting to mujahideen was considered ludicrous.

and of course over it all hangs the shadow of 9/11. I've often thought star trek needs to get past the prime directive, or have iain m. banks's culture series supplant it. explicit interventionism, horse trading, trolley problems, unintended consequences, imagine charlie wilson's war IN SPACE. show less

Why read fiction when you can read books like this one? You just can't make this stuff up.

But taking a few steps back. The British and the Americans have had interests in Middle East since the 1800s, often finding themselves in the middle of local/tribal conflicts. Someone took it upon themselves to draw some lines on a map to create countries. When oil was found, the interests ramped up. However, when locals wanted a fair share of the spoils, they found themselves with puppet and often show more corrupt and cruel governments. And the story continues to evolve. Take for example, Iran. Talks of nationalising by Mosaddegh the oil in the 1950s was met with the imposition of the Shah. With the Soviets on the outer, and the Cold War in full swing, they sought to exploit whatever they could. After the Shah was sent packing by a Khomeini, and eventually ended up in USA, the American influence in Iran all but disappeared, helped along by some students taking the American embassy hostage.
In the meantime, the Soviets moved into neighbouring Afghanistan. The Cold War had a new theatre of operations; but most of the world did not know. Covert CIA-led operations, using Pakistan as a proxy, provided every increasing support to a guerrilla war against the Soviets. This book tells that story. It's an unbelievable story of the dirty world of global politics.
When the Soviets finally moved out, they found the USSR falling to pieces as well, and for the most part the Cold War was over. The Afghans devolved into new, or rather old conflicts. This is where the book finishes.
However, we know that the story continued, and even though the US and their allies have now (in 2021) decided to withdraw after a further 20 years on the ground in Afghanistan I doubt anyone thinks that this is the end of the story.
P.S. I have not seen the film. I do not think I want to - there is no way to capture this incredible story in a short film. show less

Slow and steady, says the old adage, wins the race. Half the battle, others say, is showing up. Whatever cliché you choose, none will explain how Texas Representative Charlie Wilson, an unknown Democrat Congressman in a Democratic-controlled House of Representatives spear-headed the exponential increase in secret appropriations to support Afghan fighters against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.

Simply saying "truth is stranger than fiction" still does not adequately explain the bizarre true show more story told by veteran "60 Minutes" producer George Crile in "Charlie Wilson's War." Undergirded by years of research, including what certainly must have been extensive interviews with several of the principle actors in the story, Crile carefully unravels the story of the clandestine American involvement with the Afghans, with its secret operations, money laundering, arms trafficking, and unofficial foreign relations negotiations.

At the heart of this tale are the incorrigible Wilson and free-thinking CIA agent Gust Avrakotos. Each has a mixed reputation among his colleagues. Wilson is seen as an overt womanizer, who becomes a cocktail party joke when he becomes part of a public drug investigation. Avrakotos, who became disgruntled when passed over for a station chief assignment, is a loose cannon who speaks his mind.

Neither should be in a position to control any major operation. Their outsider status, however, allows them to work without much oversight; their experience in how to get things done in Congress and the CIA means they can use their relative freedom to pursue their own goals. Beyond that, though, they also negotiate with other foreign governments in order to facilitate their plans.

The story of their amazing success -- in that the Soviet Union retreated from Afghanistan in 1989 -- is an amazing tale. There is the sense, though, that the haphazard American involvement may have led to foreign policy problems in the years since the 9/11 terrorist attacks. So for the giddiness of the story -- which is frequently filled with humor -- there's also a nagging sense of loss by the books end.

In any event, Crile tells his fascinating story with a no-nonsense style, well aware of the irony and absurdity of many of the twists and turns. It is an enlightening, entertaining read. show less

The book opens a fascinating window on US involvement in the Soviet war in Afghanistan and how the Congress operates. Charlie Wilson is an American archetype - the boozing, loud-mouthed, brash Texan with the trophy woman on his arm. (The cocaine snorting maybe is not quite so much a part of the stereotype.) Wilson managed to stay barely a half step ahead of the law as he indulged his reckless self-destructive behavior.

At the same time, he took full advantage of the arcane rules of the US show more House of Representatives to wield an out-sized influence in the US Afghanistan policy supporting the Afhgani resistance and pushing to provide them with high-tech weaponry. An entertaining character! And if he had confined himself to pork barrel projects for his East Texas district, you could say 'no harm, no foul'. Unfortunately, he appears to have had a sizeable amount of influence over policy. The Soviets left, the US lost interest and control of Afghanistan fell to the Islamist fundamentalists who now had modern military equipment to sell on the black market. In the end the Taliban ended up in power with the attendant dire consequences. show less