Picture of author.

John Dickson Carr (1906–1977)

Author of Three Coffins

231+ Works 19,020 Members 406 Reviews 38 Favorited

About the Author

John Dickson Carr, the master of locked room mysteries, was born in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, in 1906. He was educated at Haverford College and the Sorbonne in Paris. Carr is a prolific writer with more than 80 novels and collections of short stories to his credit. He began his writing career at the show more age of 26 with his first published novel, It Walks At Night. Some of his most popular works are The Three Coffins (1935), The Burning Coat (1937), and The Bride of Newgate (1951). Carr also collaborated with Adrian Doyle, the son of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle in The Exploits of Sherlock Holmes (1954). Carr met his wife in 1932 and settled in England in 1933. He was drafted by the United States military in World War II, and was ordered to remain in England and work with the BBC. He lived in many cities throughout the world until 1967, when he permanently moved to Greenville, South Carolina. John Dickson Carr also wrote mystery novels under the name Carter Dickson. He died in Greenville in 1977. (Bowker Author Biography) show less

Series

Works by John Dickson Carr

Three Coffins (1935) 984 copies, 41 reviews
The Exploits of Sherlock Holmes (1954) 894 copies, 17 reviews
Hag's Nook (1955) 433 copies, 12 reviews
The Mad Hatter Mystery (1933) 433 copies, 11 reviews
The White Priory Murders (1934) 423 copies, 7 reviews
The Case of the Constant Suicides (1941) 419 copies, 14 reviews
The Crooked Hinge (1938) 419 copies, 17 reviews
He Who Whispers (1946) 409 copies, 9 reviews
The Problem of the Green Capsule (1939) 409 copies, 16 reviews
The Burning Court (1937) 377 copies, 10 reviews
The Emperor's Snuff-Box (1942) 368 copies, 8 reviews
It Walks By Night (1930) 362 copies, 6 reviews
The Corpse in the Waxworks (1932) 346 copies, 4 reviews
Till Death Do Us Part (1944) 342 copies, 11 reviews
The Judas Window (1938) — Author — 336 copies, 9 reviews
Death Watch (1935) 334 copies, 10 reviews
The Blind Barber (1934) 332 copies, 7 reviews
Castle Skull (1931) 309 copies, 5 reviews
The Red Widow Murders (1935) 281 copies, 6 reviews
The Plague Court Murders (1934) 281 copies, 12 reviews
The Devil in Velvet (1951) 274 copies, 8 reviews
To Wake the Dead (1938) 272 copies, 7 reviews
Fire, Burn! (1957) 269 copies, 2 reviews
The Lost Gallows (1931) 268 copies, 5 reviews
The Seat of the Scornful (1941) 265 copies, 5 reviews
The Life of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (1975) 262 copies, 5 reviews
The Problem of the Wire Cage (1939) 261 copies, 5 reviews
The Man Who Could Not Shudder (1940) 257 copies, 3 reviews
The Eight of Swords (1934) 256 copies, 7 reviews
Lord of the Sorcerers (1945) 245 copies, 2 reviews
Below Suspicion (1949) 239 copies, 1 review
The Arabian Nights Murder (1936) 238 copies, 3 reviews
The Peacock Feather Murders (1937) 234 copies, 7 reviews
The Four False Weapons (1937) 230 copies, 4 reviews
The Skeleton in the Clock (1948) 213 copies, 4 reviews
Poison in Jest (1932) 212 copies, 2 reviews
Death in Five Boxes (1938) 211 copies, 4 reviews
The Sleeping Sphinx (1947) 207 copies, 6 reviews
The Dead Man's Knock (1958) 204 copies, 4 reviews
She Died a Lady (1943) 200 copies, 5 reviews
And So to Murder (1940) 191 copies, 3 reviews
A Graveyard to Let (1950) — Author — 187 copies, 2 reviews
The Bride of Newgate (1950) 184 copies, 2 reviews
The Witch of the Low Tide (1961) 183 copies, 2 reviews
The Demoniacs (1962) 181 copies, 2 reviews
Patrick Butler for the Defense (1956) 179 copies, 3 reviews
The Nine Wrong Answers (1952) 178 copies, 2 reviews
Night at the Mocking Widow (1952) 175 copies, 3 reviews
In Spite of Thunder (1960) 175 copies, 1 review
Dark of the Moon (1967) 167 copies, 2 reviews
The House at Satan's Elbow (1965) 164 copies, 2 reviews
The Unicorn Murders (1935) 163 copies, 1 review
The Reader is Warned (1939) 159 copies, 4 reviews
He Wouldn't Kill Patience (1944) 157 copies, 4 reviews
Nine - and Death Makes Ten (1940) 155 copies, 3 reviews
Captain Cut-Throat (1955) 154 copies
The Cavalier's Cup (1953) 147 copies, 4 reviews
My Late Wives (1946) 146 copies, 4 reviews
Scandal at High Chimneys (1959) 142 copies, 4 reviews
Panic in Box C (1966) 136 copies, 1 review
Behind the Crimson Blind (1952) 136 copies, 3 reviews
Seeing is Believing (1941) 134 copies, 2 reviews
The Magic Lantern Murders (1937) 129 copies, 1 review
The Gilded Man (1942) 128 copies, 2 reviews
The Bowstring Murders (1933) 126 copies, 3 reviews
Papa Là-Bas (1969) 110 copies, 2 reviews
Deadly Hall (1971) 100 copies, 1 review
Most Secret (1934) 97 copies
The Ghosts' High Noon (1969) 87 copies
The Murder of Sir Edmund Godfrey (1975) 80 copies, 1 review
Fatal Descent (1939) 70 copies, 1 review
The Door to Doom (1980) 68 copies, 1 review
The Third Bullet (1937) 64 copies, 3 reviews
The Department of Queer Complaints (1940) 58 copies, 1 review
The Third Bullet and Other Stories (1954) 49 copies, 1 review
The Hungry Goblin (1972) 42 copies
Fear Is the Same (1959) 41 copies, 3 reviews
Merrivale, March and Murder (1991) 34 copies
Fell and Foul Play (1991) 32 copies
Speak of the Devil (1994) 24 copies
13 to the Gallows (2008) 19 copies
Maiden Murders (1952) — Introduction — 13 copies
The Kindling Spark (2022) 7 copies
Blind Man's Hood (2018) 5 copies
A Dr Fell Omnibus (1959) 4 copies
Il lago d'oro 2 copies
Repouso mortal (1993) 2 copies
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Great Stories — Editor — 2 copies
Oscura sospecha 2 copies
Secret Radio 2 copies
The Shadow Of The Goat (1926) 2 copies
MEURTRE APRES LA PLUIE 1 copy, 1 review
Svart sabbat 1 copy
La muerta acude al teatro (1976) 1 copy, 1 review
The Ends Of Justice (1927) 1 copy
Gideon Fell 1 copy
Grand Guignol (1929) 1 copy
The Fourth Suspect (1927) 1 copy
The Haverfordian, Vol. 46: June, 1926 (2017) — Editor — 1 copy
Rösten 1 copy
Saper morire 1 copy

Associated Works

The Lost World (1912) — Preface, some editions — 5,563 copies, 121 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Historical Whodunits (1993) — Contributor — 617 copies, 4 reviews
Masterpieces of Terror and the Supernatural (1985) — Contributor — 601 copies, 3 reviews
English Country House Murders (1989) — Contributor — 541 copies, 13 reviews
Murder for Christmas (1982) — Contributor — 500 copies, 7 reviews
The Oxford Book of English Detective Stories (1990) — Contributor — 435 copies, 5 reviews
Alfred Hitchcock Presents: Stories Not for the Nervous (1966) — Contributor — 349 copies, 3 reviews
A Treasury of Great Mysteries, Volumes 1-2 (1957) — Contributor — 288 copies, 3 reviews
The Maracot Deep (1929) — Introduction, some editions — 259 copies, 6 reviews
The Christmas Card Crime and Other Stories (2018) — Contributor — 252 copies, 17 reviews
Crime Stories From the 'Strand' (1991) — Contributor — 249 copies, 2 reviews
A Treasury of Great Mysteries, Volume 1 (1957) — Contributor — 245 copies
A Treasury of Great Mysteries, Volume 2 (1957) — Contributor — 224 copies, 2 reviews
Masterpieces of Mystery and Suspense (1988) — Contributor — 218 copies, 2 reviews
The Game Is Afoot: Parodies, Pastiches, and Ponderings of Sherlock Holmes (1994) — Contributor — 216 copies, 2 reviews
The Oxford Book of American Detective Stories (1996) — Contributor — 200 copies, 2 reviews
London After Midnight : A Tour of Its Criminal Haunts (1996) — Contributor; Contributor — 157 copies
Daring Detectives (1969) — Author, some editions — 153 copies, 4 reviews
A Surprise for Christmas and Other Seasonal Mysteries (2020) — Contributor — 150 copies, 7 reviews
Alfred Hitchcock Presents : A Month of Mystery (1969) — Contributor — 137 copies, 2 reviews
The Mammoth Book of Locked-Room Mysteries and Impossible Crimes (2000) — Contributor — 135 copies, 1 review
Alfred Hitchcock Presents : My Favorites in Suspense (1959) — Contributor — 130 copies
Locked Room Puzzles (1986) — Contributor — 127 copies, 1 review
Murder on Christmas Eve (2017) — Contributor — 123 copies, 4 reviews
Masterpieces of Mystery : The Supersleuths (1976) — Contributor — 118 copies, 1 review
Great Modern Reading (1943) — Contributor — 115 copies, 3 reviews
101 Years' Entertainment: The Great Detective Stories 1841-1941 (1941) — Contributor — 111 copies, 1 review
Murder for Christmas, Volume 2 (1982) — Contributor — 97 copies
Great Short Tales of Mystery and Terror (1982) — Contributor — 94 copies
The Misadventures of Sherlock Holmes (1989) — Contributor — 94 copies, 2 reviews
Great American Mystery Stories of the 20th Century (1989) — Contributor — 91 copies
Stories Not for the Nervous, Part 1 (1968) 90 copies, 4 reviews
14 of My Favorites in Suspense (1959) — Contributor — 85 copies, 2 reviews
Masterpieces of Mystery : The Grand Masters (1976) — Contributor — 84 copies, 1 review
Death Locked In (1987) — Contributor — 81 copies, 1 review
Fifty Best Mysteries (1991) — Contributor — 78 copies, 2 reviews
Who Killed Father Christmas? and Other Seasonal Mysteries (2023) — Contributor — 76 copies, 2 reviews
Ghosts from the Library: Lost Tales of Terror and the Supernatural (2023) — Contributor — 75 copies, 1 review
Crimes of Cymru: Classic Mystery Tales of Wales (2023) — Contributor — 74 copies
The Twelve Crimes of Christmas (1981) — Contributor — 68 copies, 2 reviews
Great Tales of Mystery & Suspense (1981) — Contributor — 67 copies, 1 review
Bodies from the Library 3 (2020) — Contributor — 66 copies
The Television Late Night Horror Omnibus (1993) — Contributor; Contributor — 66 copies
Murderous Schemes (1996) — Contributor — 65 copies, 2 reviews
14 Great Detective Stories (1949) — Contributor — 64 copies, 1 review
Murder British Style (1993) — Contributor — 62 copies, 1 review
A Century of British Mystery and Suspense (2000) — Contributor — 61 copies
Three Times Three: A Mystery Omnibus (1964) — Contributor — 60 copies, 2 reviews
The Penguin Classic Crime Omnibus (1984) — Contributor — 58 copies
The Arbor House Treasury of Mystery and Suspense (1981) — Contributor — 57 copies
Murder in Midsummer (2019) — Contributor — 57 copies
Crime on the Coast [and] No Flowers by Request (1953) — Contributor — 56 copies, 2 reviews
Realms of Darkness (1985) — Contributor — 49 copies, 1 review
Murder Takes a Holiday (2020) — Contributor — 45 copies, 1 review
Great Tales of Crime and Detection (1992) — Contributor — 43 copies
Suddenly at the Priory (1957) — Foreword, some editions — 41 copies
Murder by the Seaside (2022) — Contributor — 41 copies
Murder Impossible (1990) — Contributor — 36 copies
Manhattan Mysteries (1987) — Contributor — 35 copies
Rogues' Gallery: The Great Criminals of Modern Fiction (1945) — Contributor — 29 copies
Ellery Queen's The Golden 13 (1972) — Contributor — 28 copies
The Black Lizard Big Book of Locked-Room Mysteries (2019) — Contributor — 26 copies, 2 reviews
A Century of Detective Stories (1935) — Contributor — 23 copies
Great detective stories (1998) — Contributor — 23 copies
Ellery Queen's Mystery Mix (1963) — Contributor — 21 copies, 1 review
Fifty Famous Detectives of Fiction (1948) — Contributor — 21 copies
Murder by Candlelight (2024) — Contributor — 21 copies
Ellery Queen's Twentieth Century Detective Stories (1964) — Contributor — 20 copies
Ellery Queen's Lethal Black Book (1965) — Contributor — 20 copies
Four and Twenty Bloodhounds (1950) — Contributor — 19 copies
Twelve American Crime Stories (1998) — Contributor — 18 copies
The Queen's Awards : Fifth Series (1950) — Contributor — 18 copies
Classic Crime Stories (2014) — Contributor — 16 copies
Noch mehr Morde (1972) — Contributor — 16 copies
Best Detective Stories (1959) — Contributor — 15 copies
Cream of the Crime (1962) — Contributor — 15 copies, 2 reviews
Crime on the Coast (1984) — Contributor — 13 copies
The Second Century of Detective Stories (1938) — Contributor — 13 copies
Rejser i tid og rum : en bog om science fiction (1973) — Author, some editions — 12 copies, 1 review
Ellery Queen's 12 (1964) — Contributor — 12 copies
Classic stories of crime and detection (1976) — Contributor; Contributor — 11 copies
Dangerous Crossing [1953 film] (1953) — Writer — 11 copies
He Who Whispers | The Unsuspected | Crows Can't Count (1946) — Contributor — 10 copies
The Deadly Arts: A Collection of Artful Suspense (1985) — Contributor — 9 copies
Detective Omnibus — Contributor; Contributor — 9 copies, 2 reviews
Redselen i Deptford og andre studier i Sherlock Holmes (1980) — Contributor — 9 copies
De lever af gys : Poe-klubben skriver (1973) — Author, some editions — 8 copies, 2 reviews
Mord als schöne Kunst betrachtet. (1999) — Contributor — 8 copies
Detection Medley (1939) — Contributor; Contributor — 8 copies
20 Great Tales of Murder (1951) — Contributor — 8 copies
The Queen's Awards : 1947 (1947) — Contributor — 8 copies
Verhalen omnibus (1967) — Contributor — 7 copies
Verdens største detektiver II (1995) — Contributor; Contributor — 7 copies
Crime Without Murder (1970) — Contributor — 7 copies
Nieuwe verhalen die Hitchcock koos — Contributor — 6 copies
Alfred Hitchcock's Fireside Book of Suspense (1947) — Contributor — 6 copies
Best Detective Stories 2 (1964) — Contributor — 5 copies
The Fly and Other Stories (1994) — Contributor — 5 copies, 1 review
Giant Mystery Reader (1951) — Author — 5 copies
I delitti della camera chiusa (1974) — Contributor; Contributor — 5 copies
Verdens største detektiver I (1995) — Contributor — 4 copies
London After Midnight: A Conducted Tour, Part 1 (1996) — Contributor — 4 copies
Avon Mystery Story Teller (1946) — Contributor; Contributor — 4 copies
London After Midnight: A Conducted Tour, Part 2 (1996) — Contributor — 3 copies
Great Stories of Detection (1960) — Contributor — 3 copies
Nye kriminalhistorier (1969) — Author, some editions; Author, some editions — 3 copies, 2 reviews
Mørkets gjerninger : 21 hårreisende kriminalhistorier (2001) — Contributor — 3 copies
Best Stories from Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine (1944) — Contributor — 3 copies
Detektivhistorier fra Sherlock Holmes til Hercule Poirot — Contributor — 3 copies, 2 reviews
Detective-verhalen — Contributor — 3 copies
Murder Mixture (1963) — Contributor — 2 copies
A Magnum of Mysteries (1963) — Contributor — 2 copies
The Fourth Book of Crime-Craft (1959) — Introduction — 2 copies
150 anni in Giallo (1989) — Contributor — 2 copies
Ellery Queen's 1966 Anthology (1966) — Contributor — 2 copies
10 moderne spionhistorier — Author, some editions — 2 copies, 1 review
Catch a Spy (1965) — Contributor — 2 copies
Verdens beste kriminalhistorier (1960) — Contributor — 1 copy
Conferencia sobre la habitación cerrada (1982) — Introduction — 1 copy
De bedste kriminalhistorier fra hele verden (1966) — Contributor — 1 copy, 1 review
Huset i Goblin Wood og andre mysterier (1993) — Contributor — 1 copy
Murder By Experts (1947) — Contributor; Contributor — 1 copy
Det ligner mord : 10 moderne detektivhistorier — Author, some editions — 1 copy, 1 review

Tagged

20th century (350) American (231) American literature (113) British (177) Carr (101) crime (568) crime and mystery (235) crime fiction (420) detective (344) detective fiction (166) ebook (122) England (175) fiction (1,613) Gideon Fell (453) Golden Age (330) impossible crime (190) John Dickson Carr (177) locked room (141) locked room mystery (213) mystery (4,012) novel (428) paperback (246) PB (133) read (130) series (131) Sherlock Holmes (147) short stories (119) Sir Henry Merrivale (268) to-read (609) unread (128)

Common Knowledge

Members

Discussions

Found: Murder mystery book in Name that Book (February 2025)
Exploits of Sherlock Holmes in Combiners! (February 2023)

Reviews

451 reviews
Probably the most famous of Carr's Dr. Gideon Fell mysteries, and a frequent occupant of "all-time best mysteries" lists. It's famous, among other things, for its Chapter 17, in which Dr. Fell delivers a lecture on the various types of locked-room mysteries.

In this one, Carr gives us two apparently impossible murders. Two men are in a locked office, and a gunshot is heard. In the few seconds it takes to burst through the door, the killer has disappeared. There is a window through which he show more could have jumped, but the newly-fallen snow in the yard below is undisturbed. The second killing takes place in the middle of a short dead-end street. There are witnesses at both ends of the street who see a man fall after a gunshot is heard. The police determine that he's been shot at close range, but no gunman was seen, and again, the victim is surrounded by snow with no footprints but his own.

The solution to the mysteries is indeed clever, and all of the clues are neatly laid out, many of them scattered into Fell's locked-room lecture. But getting to that solution is a bit of a slog, I'm afraid. Carr's prose is stodgy and dense; plowing through to the final chapters is rather like wading through molasses. (And I say that as someone who enjoys mysteries of this era.)

As for the famous lecture? It's thorough and informative, but it's a great clump of "and now I shall pontificate" that brings the actual story to a screeching halt for a dozen pages. The most interesting thing about it is the moment in which Fell obliterates the fourth wall, saying

"...we're in a detective story, and we don't fool the reader by pretending we're not. Let's not invent elaborate excuses to drag in a discussion of detective stories. Let's candidly glory in the noblest pursuit possible to characters in a book."

Happy to have read this for its historical importance, but I think Carr's prose will keep me from going back for more, despite the cleverness of his solutions.
show less
A Drunken Farce, without a Locked Room
Review of The Murder Room eBook (November 19, 2012) of the Harper and Brothers hardcover original (October 1, 1934)

Uninsured jewels belonging to ?!£&/! viscounts were stolen while murdering thieves posed as Harley Street doctors at his table. Blood-stained blankets and razors mysteriously appeared in the cabins; women vanished but did not vanish; the nephews of eminent American administrators first went mad and gibbered of bears and geography then ran
show more
amok with bug-powder guns, tried to poison him and finally threatened him with razors. Indeed, an unprejudiced listener would have decided that the situation aboard the Queen Victoria was past hope. - the ship's captain summarizes the mayhem of events on board his ship.


The Blind Barber is a particularly weak entry for the Dr. Gideon Fell series and hopefully a one-off with its reliance on drunken comic antics. Dr. Fell is approached at home by his friend, the writer Henry (Hank) Morgan who was a passenger on the Queen Victoria cruise liner due to dock at Southampton after its journey from New York City. Morgan has managed to get ashore ahead of time via a smaller crew vessel as the larger ship awaits a docking berth.

Morgan relates a tale of how he and a group of friends had got themselves mixed-up in the middle of a jewelry heist and then found a body apparently murdered by a cutthroat razor (the single brief tie-in to the title) but when bringing it to the attention of the ship's authorities they found that the body had disappeared. Enormous amounts of alcohol are consumed throughout, adding to the befuddlement of the characters. There were various other irritations such as having 3 characters deliver their dialogue in fake accented dialogue: a Norwegian, a Scot and an Italian.

“You get somet’ing to gag him wit’ till he cool down, or he call de chief mate and den maybe we iss all in de brig." “do you t’ank we are right, or iss dere a mistake? Dat wass no yoke, what dey tell us. If dey say dere is nobody missing, den ay don’t see how dere is somebody missing. Maybe we talk about a murder and dere is no murder.”

"'Auld Ayr, wham ne'er a town surpasses,'" announced Dr. Kyle, with a gesture that indicated him to be a local boy and proud of it, "'for honest men and bonnie lasses'! Aye! A statement ye ken, Mr. Morgan, frae the wairks o' the great Scottish poet, Rabbie Burrrns. Sit down Mr. Morgan. And perhaps yell tak a drap o' whusky, eh? 'The souter tauld his queerest stories__.'"

“So! So! You have trieda to de-ceive me, eh? You have a trieda toa deceive Signor Benito Furioso Camposozzi, eh? Sangua della madonne, I feex you! You tella me he eesa all-right, eh? Haah! What you call all-aright, eh? I tell you, signorina, to youra face, he eesa DRUNK!”


What might be funny in small doses becomes insufferable when used several dozen times.

There are also extended fake French language passages, usually involving ranting about the alcohol intake.
“Eh, bien, eh bien! Encore tu bois! Toujours tu bois! Ah, zut, alors!” She became cutting. “Tu m’a donné votre parole d’honneur, comme un soldat de la France! Et qu’est-ce que je trouve? Un soldat de la France, hein! Non!” She drew back witheringly. “Je te vois en buvant le GIN!”



The front cover of the original 1934 Harper and Brothers hardcover. Image sourced from Goodreads.

To top it off, there are artefacts which demonstrate that a sloppy proofread / copy edit of the text scan was done to produce the eBook edition. Various scan typos were not fixed, even some that should have been caught by spellcheck such as the word: "endorsemHnt" (sic).

Dr. Fell is able to explain it all of course and even to cable a message to the authorities to have the culprit arrested upon docking. Overall, there was too little deduction, even though Fell lists 16 clues which point to the villain during the course of the story-telling. Disappointingly, I thought the bad 'un was apparent fairly early on, unlike most John Dickson Carr books which usually involve confusing puzzles in the so-called "locked room" sub-genre.

Avoid this one, even if you are a Dr. Fell or John Dickson Carr completist.

Bonus Track
Even among the dregs and the dross, I thought this one passage describing inebriation 🥴😵 was rather good:
Each of his trio had consumed exactly one bottle of champagne; and, while he would have scorned the imputation that he could become the least sozzled on a quart of fizz, he could not in honesty deny certain insidious manifestations. For example, it seemed to him that he was entirely without legs, and that his torso must be moving through the air in a singularly ghostly fashion;


Trivia and Links
John Dickson Carr (1906-1977) is one of the 99 authors listed in The Book of Forgotten Authors>/i> (2017) by Christopher Fowler. He is No. 20 in the alphabetical listing which you can see towards the bottom of my review here.

John Dickson Carr took the inspiration for Dr. Gideon Fell's appearance from that of author G.K. Chesterton (1874-1936), writer of the Father Brown mysteries and other works.
See photograph at https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/75/Gilbert_Chesterton.jpg...
Photograph of G.K. Chesterton. Image sourced from Wikipedia.
The source of the name Dr. Fell is apparently from the apocryphal epigram:
I do not like thee, Doctor Fell,
The reason why – I cannot tell;
But this I know, and know full well,
I do not like thee, Doctor Fell.
show less
Clever locked room mystery. Carr's style when writing Dr. Fell is a bit didatic and may turn off some readers but I loved the (somewhat lengthy) exposition Fell gives about the various types of so-called "locked room" mysteries. As he says himself:

"    "When the cry of 'This-sort-of-thing-wouldn't-happen!' goes up, when you complain about half-faced fiends and hooded phantoms and blond hypnotic sirens, you are merely saying, 'I don't like this sort of story.' That's fair enough. If you do show more not like it, you are howlingly right to say so. But when you twist this matter of taste into a rule for judging the merit or even the probability of the story, you are merely saying, 'This series of events couldn't happen, because I shouldn't enjoy it if it did.'"

As I was starting this book, I realized that I had read a few other Gideon Fell mysteries before and that Fell wasn't as much fun as Gervase Fen. In other words, I do not much like Carr's mysteries or perhaps just not his writing style.

However, this seemingly insoluble, improbable locked-room mystery in which the murderer didn't even leave footprints in the snow was extremely clever. I thought I had suspected everyone in turn but not once did I come close to the true culprit! Carr plays fair with the reader -- there are no hidden facts brought out only during the solution. In fact, he tells you in the first chapter the names of certain witnesses whose testimony can be relied on to be truthful and complete!! Yet despite this broad hint and Fell uttering cryptic clues periodically, I only deciphered one small aspect of the crime.

In addition, Gideon Fell did make me chuckle several times with his pronouncements, such as when he gives rules about what ghosts should be like in English fiction (they should be seen in old abbeys or cemeteries, not lemonade stands). I also liked his mention of several other mystery novels and authors who excelled at certain types of mysteries during his discourse mentioned above.

Overall, I would recommend this as an excellent example of a certain style of mystery (the locked room) which is no longer fashionable.
show less
This is a gripping locked room mystery that keeps you barreling along through fast-paced scenes of action and puzzlement. There are very few slow sections, which makes it a compelling case for finishing in one sitting, or at least one day (which is what I did!).
At the heart of the story are whisperings about a femme fatale – Lesley, the lovely new fiancée of Dick Markham. Why should Dick care that he knows absolutely nothing about her prior to the last six months? What could possibly be show more of concern? But when a neighbor masquerading as a fortune teller at a fair confides in Dick that he recognizes Lesley as a serial but unproven husband-poisoner, Dick's world is shaken. Especially when the fortune teller is immediately shot in the back by Leslie firing a gun, ahem, accidentally. What is happening?
The rest of the novel is a masterful kaleidoscope that leads you to believe first one thing, then another, then back again, then on to something else, and so on and so forth until a breathless finale.
This was my first book by John Dickson Carr, and I was impressed. Although his sleuth, Dr. Gideon Fell, is somewhat Poirot-adjacent but less appealing, the mystery itself and the core cast of characters are very good! I look forward to checking out more titles from this Golden Age author.

Thanks to NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for this digital review copy!
show less

Lists

Awards

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Ellery Queen Introduction
David Alexander Contributor
August Derleth Contributor
Jerome Barry Contributor
Georges Simenon Contributor
Kenneth Millar Contributor
Ruth Wilson Contributor
Lawrence Treat Contributor
Stuart Palmer Contributor
Jerome Prince Contributor
Day Keene Contributor
Stanley Ellin Contributor
Harold Prince Contributor
Roland Lacourbe Préface, Preface
Reijo Kalvas Translator
Roger Roth Cover artist
Eero Ahmavaara Translator
Emanuel Schongut Cover artist & designer, Cover artist/desgner
Risto Raitio Translator
Arto Tuovinen Translator
Otto Penzler Introduction
Nils Nordberg Translator, Afterword
Laura Grimaldi Translator, Foreword
Ian Yeomans Cover photograph
Peter Noble Narrator
Martin Edwards Introduction
Pertti Koskela Translator
Im-Ho; Cover artist
Per Olaisen Preface
Erik Lindegren Translator
Iet Houwer Translator
Kaija Kauppi Translator
Bascove Cover artist
Arnaldo Sole Translator
Nicky Zann Cover artist
Ingalisa Munck Translator
Romek Marber Cover designer
Pasi Junila Translator
Michael Dirda Introduction
Stephen Sweny Cover artist
Leif Forsblom Translator
Pirkko Haljoki Translator
John Sewell Cover designer
Riku Riihimäki Translator
Fabrice Bonnard Translator
Eija Rytkö Translator
Tauno Peltola Translator
Risto Ratio Translator
Nils Brantzeg Translator
Gail Phillips Cover artist
Danièle Grivel Traduction
Donald Sinden Narrator
John Hartley Narrator
Eva Iribarne Translator
Leo Strøm Overs.
Full Cast Narrator
Fernando Santos Translator

Statistics

Works
231
Also by
151
Members
19,020
Popularity
#1,148
Rating
½ 3.6
Reviews
406
ISBNs
885
Languages
18
Favorited
38

Charts & Graphs