2016 Hugo Eligible Novels

mathgirl40: Very well written. A fairy tale with unexpected twists. Definitely a Hugo contender.

GreenVelvet: One of the most original fantasy/reality merges I've ever read. Utterly unique. I can't stop thinking about it.

aulsmith: A tour-de-force of speculative fiction, but I suspect folks with no background in Plato or Socratics might be a bit lost.

mathgirl40: This book was a real page-turner, with an interesting premise and lovely writing.

mathgirl40: A nice retelling of the Beauty and the Beast story, with unexpected twists.

Awfki: I was really surprised he was able to wrap this up in a reasonable way. The book is typically Scalzi, fast paced, humorous (if you like snark and sarcasm) and generally a light read. My main complaint with this series is that the aliens don't feel at all alien. They speak with the same snark and sarcasm as the humans and that just feels off. It's still a fun read, just don't take it too seriously Also, I hesitate to call a popcorn read the "best" SF/F novel of the year. If a popcorn read is the best year had to offer it seems like it must have been a pretty off year.

tottman: Another great entry in the series. Well-written characters, thoughtful politics and plotting.

tottman: Creative plot and world building. Solid and interesting characters. Definitely worthy of Hugo consideration

Awfki: It feels very fresh and original. It's a blend of elements strung together in new and interesting ways and a well told story with likable characters and a dash of humor. Butcher is obviously the servant of several cats because knows exactly what is going on in their evil little heads. Also, this is a much, MUCH better selection for him than the puppy-slated Dresden novel of last year. The Dresden stuff is good but it got old for me after book four or five. This is a totally different feel and much better than than any of the Dresden novels.

andyl: Extended eligibility - UK edition 2014, US edition 2015

Settings: This is eligable? If so, it's my favorite so far.

andyl: UK published in 2014 but extended eligibility (publ. in USA 2015)

Lirleni: has an interesting base for 'mancy (magic). Basically, a 'mancer has become so obsessed with it, that they can use their obsession to change reality, with a price.

mathgirl40: Not my favourite of Wilson's books, but well-written with good character development and interesting ideas. More speculative fiction than science fiction.

jain: Extended eligibility: UK published 2014, US published 2015.

andyl : light entertainment not Hugo-worthy

Awfki : #8 in a series. Didn't think it was appropriate for the Dresden book last year, don't think it's appropriate for this. Also, the three (four?) Kate Daniels books that I read at my daughter's request were good, but they weren't award winning good.

Awfki : Read it, sort of enjoyed it, but it doesn't deserve a Hugo.

AnnieMod : Weaker than his previous novel - and not really Hugo worthy.

andyl : light entertainment not Hugo-worthy

Settings : This is a light popcorny novel. Recommended if you want something fun, but it doesn't have any qualities I think make it worthy of the Hugos.

AnnieMod : It is very light, not really Hugo worthy in my opinion but it is still readable (and eligible)

AnnieMod : Not really Hugo worthy on its own.

AnnieMod : Not really Hugo worthy on its own.

AnnieMod : Not really Hugo worthy on its own.